Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emma Watson Wedding Dresses

185 replies

YearsSinceISawYou · 21/10/2021 15:32

All those at the Earth shot Awards were asked to wear outfits that considered the environment-I suppose this means second hand or worn before. At any rate, that's what they did.

Along comes Emma Watson with her Harris Reed designed dress, made from 10 upcycled wedding dresses from Oxfam.

AIBU to think that if Emma really cared about this sort of stuff-as she often says she does-she would have left the 10 wedding dresses in Oxfam, so that 10 people would have been able to recycle 10 dresses-with the added bonus that they would have been affordable for those people.

Instead, she takes all ten of them and chops them up, thus showing herself to be an over-privileged hypocrite, who cares more about making a headline than 'saving the planet' or thinking about the women who could have made real use of those dresses.

Surely she had something else in her wardrobe that she could have used.

OP posts:
TSSDNCOP · 21/10/2021 18:20

And there is a real issue with people thinking they can swoop in and buy up the best items.

Fucking bastards!

derxa · 21/10/2021 18:19

Jesus Christ… what happened to women supporting women? Whatever they do?

TSSDNCOP · 21/10/2021 18:18

I once unwrapped about 30 sheets of newspaper to find one of those cardboard baskets you put strawberries in at PYO. Used.

Off topic admittedly.

ShinyHappyPoster · 21/10/2021 18:17

@ConstanceGracy

Jesus Christ… what happened to women supporting women? She upcycled charity shop clothes, that’s a good thing.
Your sex doesn't mean you can avoid scrutiny. I'd rather support women living in poverty than a multi-millionaire. But I have lived and worked in low income areas where people do shop for clothes and items from charity shops by necessity not because they're into vintage as PPs have implied. And my cousin managed an Oxfam shop. Oxfam is known for having designer and good quality wedding dresses. They have brand new wedding dresses donated by designers and stores. And there is a real issue with people thinking they can swoop in and buy up the best items.
FrippEnos · 21/10/2021 18:16

ConstanceGracy
Jesus Christ… what happened to women supporting women?

Why would anyone want to support a hypocrite that throw another woman under the bus?

KingsleyShacklebolt · 21/10/2021 18:15

All this it's disrespectful, those poor women who donated their 80s meringues and they were (gasp) cut up!!! What bollocks.

Fashion comes and goes and nobody wants a very dated dress in their wedding day. As other volunteers have said, they hang on the rails unsold. Until some creative comes in and decides to buy the lot, dye them pink and turn them into cushion covers or whatever, if we sold 10 wedding dresses at once we'd be hanging out the bunting and celebrating a huge sale.

When you donate to a charity shop you are relinquishing control. Your things are no lingers yours. You are donating them to us to make the most money possible for the cause. If that means selling them to an art student to cut up, or fit someone to hack at with scissors and splatter with blood as a Halloween outfit that's what we'll do.

This idea that we should be interviewing customers to find out their financial status and intentions for their purchase is ... interesting.

TSSDNCOP · 21/10/2021 18:12

I have worked in an Oxfam shop. The basement of that one shop was absolutely stuffed with wedding dresses. In the two years I was there the only people that bought them were going to fancy dress, putting on a production or dressing up a stag.

At the very least Emma demonstrated how they could be used more creatively.

Bringham · 21/10/2021 17:54

@natwebb79

Why didn't you just call this thread 'I don't like Emma Watson because she's a trans ally so I'm going to slag off her dress' and be done with it? This website is a fucking joke nowadays...
This 100%
Cornettoninja · 21/10/2021 17:50

@slashlover

I work in a charity shop, the actual wedding dress boutique part was closed due to lack of interest. We have a wedding dress rail where they are priced between £5 and £25. They don't sell, nobody wants to buy them so selling 10 in one go would be brilliant for us. I couldn't care less what the person did with them afterwards.
You could make a window display of ‘vampire bride’, ‘corpse bride’ and ‘bride of Frankenstein’.

My friend did that one year (she specifically asked for a wedding dress to make into a costume with blood etc) and it looked amazing. She got a few years wear out of that one.

ConstanceGracy · 21/10/2021 17:49

Jesus Christ… what happened to women supporting women?
She upcycled charity shop clothes, that’s a good thing.

ShinyHappyPoster · 21/10/2021 17:46

I agree with you OP and think YANBU.
Cutting up wedding dresses from a charity shop shows an underlying privilege and a lack of imagination.
It's as though they couldn't imagine that someone would actually buy a wedding dress from a charity shop for their wedding day; they also couldn't imagine that people donate their wedding dresses to charity shops because they want lower income brides to be able to buy a wedding dress.
It gives off Marie Antionette vibes. 'Let me parade in dresses that would have been the most expensive clothing purchases for many people, that I have used like rags and in doing so have stopped others from being able to purchase for their big days.'

It may have fit the rules of the event at a stretch but it's as though focusing on recycling, they couldn't manage to think about poverty and privilege at the same time Hmm

CockalierMum · 21/10/2021 17:44

YABU

HouseOfFire · 21/10/2021 17:42

but how many more people are aware that you can get wedding dresses from Oxfam

@YearsSinceISawYou
Maybe she had the brass neck-wouldn't be shocked-to ask for them for nothing, as she would be advertising Oxfam's wedding dresses.

what is wrong with you?

Bimblybomeyelash · 21/10/2021 17:31

Oh come on! She didn’t do a Monica, and prise a dress from some poor bride to be hands. She took ten dresses, that probably wouldn’t sell, and made something new. In doing so she has promoted Oxfam and recycling/remaking clothing.

GardenNinja · 21/10/2021 17:25

Imagine if she had have just worn something from her wardrobe, we'd all be here going " it's all right for her with her back catalogue of beautiful designer dresses that perfectly fit her same size figure."

In 2021 after two kids, a desk job and a lot of pies I'm not going to fit into my 1998 velvet Dress from Richards and justify buying something new!

AutumnLeafy · 21/10/2021 17:23

I'm really sad that you feel this way OP. There are plenty of 2nd hand dresses for people to buy if they want.

slashlover · 21/10/2021 17:23

Yes to this! When I rule the world everyone will have to do 6 months volunteering in a charity shop before they are allowed to donate to or shop in one.

We get people who we know are buying clothes to sell on eBay, don't care. As long as they pay the price we're asking (people who try to haggle should have the price they pay doubled) then if they want to spend their free time photographing the items and listing them online then it's nothing to do with us.

They may spend 20 minutes making up a listing to possibly earn £10, in that time we can go through several bags of donations, tag them, hang them and put them out for sale to earn more than £10.

AutumnLeafy · 21/10/2021 17:21

I imagined she paid for them all. Maybe she went for ones that hadn't been sold for ages. Maybe not. Either way I'm sure Oxfam didn't mind. It's raised awareness.

2Two · 21/10/2021 17:20

@GingerScallop

I agree op. Surely the first step is to consume less. I have noted that this point is missed by many. As long as they do or buy recycle(d) or buy sustainable or bamboo products many feel they done it. We need to consume less. No need to covert 10 dresses into one. Wear and rewear one dress
But what difference does it make if she converts one dress or ten? She is still recycling and isn't funding the manufacture of new stuff. Plenty of people who know what they are talking about have come on here and confirmed that charity shops have great difficulty selling used wedding dresses. If EW hadn't bought these dresses it is virtually inevitable that they would have ended up being thrown away.
2Two · 21/10/2021 17:18

I can't see anything in the least hypocritical about this. She recycled, she gave money to charity. Can I ask how much you have done of either?

What difference would it have made realistically if she'd just bought one dress? Oxfam has no shortage of wedding dresses, nor do other charity shops, so she certainly wasn't depriving desperate brides of anything. The reality is that these things don't sell and get shoved into a bag of unsaleable fabrics and sold off for £5 per large bag. She did Oxfam a massive favour.

ItWorriesMeThisKindofThing · 21/10/2021 17:16

@Wroxie

I am SO sick of this misconception about charity shops.

They don't exist to provide clothing for the poor. They exist to provide money for the charity.

If you are living on very little money, and you need pyjamas or work trousers, it is cheaper and easier to go to Primark or to the clothes section of your nearby large supermarket, where you will find new, clean, and fashionable clothes in your size.

Charity shops are where you go if you have a special interest in vintage or sustainable clothes, or you enjoy the serendipity of finding a perfect silk whatever in exactly your size that you didn't know you needed, or if you want something for fancy dress. If you specifically need a white shirt for your new catering job, you don't go to the local Oxfam.

My dearest friend is a regional manager (or something like that, not sure of the exact title) for all of the charity shops in our geographical area for a certain well-known charity and she doesn't give a flying rat's banana if you're buying her stock to wear or to sell on ebay or to tear apart and make into curtains for your dog's house. If she waited for "the poor" to come along and only buy what they needed she'd never sell anything.

Yes to this! When I rule the world everyone will have to do 6 months volunteering in a charity shop before they are allowed to donate to or shop in one.
knittingaddict · 21/10/2021 17:13

Oh please op.

Most of the wedding dresses in charity shops are out of date and very few people would want to wear one. I love the creativity of making something new out of the old and unwearable. She's not robbing anyone.

I've got a 1980's wedding dress in the loft if anyone wants it. Seriously doubt they will though.

slashlover · 21/10/2021 17:12

I work in a charity shop, the actual wedding dress boutique part was closed due to lack of interest. We have a wedding dress rail where they are priced between £5 and £25. They don't sell, nobody wants to buy them so selling 10 in one go would be brilliant for us. I couldn't care less what the person did with them afterwards.

mustlovegin · 21/10/2021 17:09

Most people are fed up with the constant celebrity hypocritical virtue signalling. The penny should have dropped by now. I don't understand why they continue to do it.

FrippEnos · 21/10/2021 17:09

I find it amusing that people defend EW as a strong famous woman whilst ignoring that she fucked over JKR.

Swipe left for the next trending thread