Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emma Watson Wedding Dresses

185 replies

YearsSinceISawYou · 21/10/2021 15:32

All those at the Earth shot Awards were asked to wear outfits that considered the environment-I suppose this means second hand or worn before. At any rate, that's what they did.

Along comes Emma Watson with her Harris Reed designed dress, made from 10 upcycled wedding dresses from Oxfam.

AIBU to think that if Emma really cared about this sort of stuff-as she often says she does-she would have left the 10 wedding dresses in Oxfam, so that 10 people would have been able to recycle 10 dresses-with the added bonus that they would have been affordable for those people.

Instead, she takes all ten of them and chops them up, thus showing herself to be an over-privileged hypocrite, who cares more about making a headline than 'saving the planet' or thinking about the women who could have made real use of those dresses.

Surely she had something else in her wardrobe that she could have used.

OP posts:
Glitterybug · 22/10/2021 07:32

Obviously it would be more eco-friendly and less wasteful if people were happy to just throw on a dated dress and wear it but I don't know how you'd make people happy to do this.

Exactly. Nobody in 2021 wants to wear an 80s puffy meringue. With a few alterations the fabric could be used to make something different - such as in this case.

But Mumsnet hates Emma because she once said trans rights are human rights so she does get a very hard time on here. If Queen JK Rowling has turned up wearing that it would have been "oh wow what a great idea to use up unwanted wedding dresses, better than throwing it away."

By the way ... Emma didn't actually do anything to the dresses herself. The designer did that.

MoreAloneTime · 22/10/2021 07:28

Obviously it would be more eco-friendly and less wasteful if people were happy to just throw on a dated dress and wear it but I don't know how you'd make people happy to do this. It's very unlikely that there were 10 perfectly good wedding dresses that 10 brides would have been happy to wear.

Glitterybug · 22/10/2021 07:24

So if a dress isn't brand new and designer it should be cut up? Blimey.

Another one who can't fucking read. What's happened to mumsnet these days?

SmellyOldOwls · 22/10/2021 00:28

[quote FirewomanSam]@SmellyOldOwls the charity shops do sell things to textile recyclers, but those companies sometimes send things overseas to be sold in poorer countries. I only did a quick Google so there are probably better sources but this article gives a good overview: www.rd.com/article/what-happens-used-clothing-donations/[/quote]
Interesting thanks - I thought everything went to be recycled. Bit crap when even the recycling companies are pushing rubbish onto other people.

Nancydrawn · 21/10/2021 22:25

You're not only being unreasonable but also ridiculous.

FirewomanSam · 21/10/2021 21:59

@SmellyOldOwls the charity shops do sell things to textile recyclers, but those companies sometimes send things overseas to be sold in poorer countries. I only did a quick Google so there are probably better sources but this article gives a good overview: www.rd.com/article/what-happens-used-clothing-donations/

SmellyOldOwls · 21/10/2021 21:41

@FirewomanSam

It’s of course difficult to say without seeing the wedding dresses hers was made from but I’d wager there are probably more second-hand wedding dresses out there than there are women currently in the market for a second-hand wedding dress.

So much of what gets donated to charity shops ends up a huge burden for the charities, who have to find storage for it all and have to make arrangements to get rid of things that don’t sell. I’ve heard that unsold clothing (though hopefully not wedding dresses!) often ends up getting shipped to poorer countries, who then end up with piles of rejected poor-quality crap clothing that they in turn have to deal with. So I think giving old charity-shop clothing a new lease of life and turning it into something new and exciting sounds like a wonderful idea.

I think they just sell any unwanted clothing to textile recycling companies. Probably make more for the charity that way than selling through the shops.

SmellyOldOwls · 21/10/2021 21:38

@Glitterybug

Have you had a look at the wedding dresses available on oxfam?

onlineshop.oxfam.org.uk/bridal/category/bridal?N=4131982658&Ns=product.creationDate|1&Nr=AND(product.active:1,NOT(sku.listPrice:0.000000))&No=0

1980s monstrosities and fast fashion high street wedding dresses from places like wed2be and asos.

Best thing for them to be cut up and reused.

So if a dress isn't brand new and designer it should be cut up? Blimey.

NotMeekNotObedient · 21/10/2021 21:36

I got my wedding dress from Oxfam, it was a sample of a well known brand. The tag said £2600, I paid £250.

Definitely not all old dresses no one would want.

There were dresses of all styles and priced appropriately.

Some were really old fashioned and I imagine they would have ended up in the rag bag eventually.

As long as she paid for them who cares what she did with them. They charity got the money and publicity.

StormyCornishSeas · 21/10/2021 20:42

I like the idea! But not that keen on the black trousers.

I love that other dress she's worn this week though, I normally don't go for chintzy sofa print but that outfit is lush

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 21/10/2021 19:43

Charities spend a lot on advertising to get donations. Emma Watson got very good publicity for them. It also publicised the idea of upscaling and recycling older clothes in an interesting and fashionable way - encouraging other people not to dismiss the clothes in Oxfam's Collection but to go and buy some and reinvent them.

Can't see what is wrong with that.

KingsleyShacklebolt · 21/10/2021 19:34

But if a juxtaposition for a charity which is meant to provide affordable second hand items.

More bollocks.

The only thing a charity is "meant" to do is maximise funds for its cause Oxfam's cause is poverty in the developing world, not providing affordable second hand items. Just as cancer research's aim is funding science, RSPCA is looking after animals and so on.

It's a total myth that charity shops are there to provide cheap stuff, and that those of us who volunteer in them should be policing or vetting the customers to ensure they are worthy enough. Or poor enough. Or make them sign a promise not to cut up a pair of old curtains or a dress.

Ghoulette · 21/10/2021 19:12

I get that she donated a lot of stuff, but aren't oxfam just going to sell it for hundreds anyway? But if a juxtaposition for a charity which is meant to provide affordable second hand items.

Oxfam are awful for over pricing anyway.

TSSDNCOP · 21/10/2021 18:50

I wonder how many extra hits and visits Oxfam gets as a result of a cut up dress.

They're going to need to find a lot more goats.

Lookingatthings · 21/10/2021 18:42

@ShinyHappyPoster

I agree with you OP and think YANBU. Cutting up wedding dresses from a charity shop shows an underlying privilege and a lack of imagination. It's as though they couldn't imagine that someone would actually buy a wedding dress from a charity shop for their wedding day; they also couldn't imagine that people donate their wedding dresses to charity shops because they want lower income brides to be able to buy a wedding dress. It gives off Marie Antionette vibes. 'Let me parade in dresses that would have been the most expensive clothing purchases for many people, that I have used like rags and in doing so have stopped others from being able to purchase for their big days.' It may have fit the rules of the event at a stretch but it's as though focusing on recycling, they couldn't manage to think about poverty and privilege at the same time Hmm
Except this isn't what happened. The designer if the dress has a 10 piece collection that reuses 10 wedding dresses. 1 of which EW wore to an event.
HomeSliceKnowsBest · 21/10/2021 18:35

There are some gorgeous dresses via that Oxfam link.

yourestandingonmyneck · 21/10/2021 18:33

Yes, I see your point OP

TSSDNCOP · 21/10/2021 18:27

No. It's happy days all round for the charity that's flogging them. Oxfam definitely don't ask punters for their council tax bill when they're trying to sell.

There is also a system in place where the really fancy pieces (we were trained to spot them) are centralised to shops in areas where shoppers with £ or vintage shoppers are more prevalent.

BiscuitLover09876 · 21/10/2021 18:26

Also anyone I know who is struggling gets them off ebay anyway.

BiscuitLover09876 · 21/10/2021 18:26

It was a one off. The amount she donates and gives to people will make it all back. She probably got them all from a wealthy area anyway. Wink

MoreAloneTime · 21/10/2021 18:25

Wedding dresses date badly. Unless it's a Halloween costume or you're appearing in a period piece set in the 80s no one is going to want to wear an non-modified dated wedding dress.

In the days before fast fashion it was very normal to take old clothes and remodel them into something more up to date.

KingsleyShacklebolt · 21/10/2021 18:24

No, shiny happy poster. You are wrong. Charity shops are there to make money. Not provide cheap stuff for "poor people".

BiscuitLover09876 · 21/10/2021 18:24

So she can never buy multiple things from a charity shop? Maybe she should go naked. Hmm Give her a break.

ShinyHappyPoster · 21/10/2021 18:23

@TSSDNCOP

And there is a real issue with people thinking they can swoop in and buy up the best items.

Fucking bastards!

I get that it's hilarious that people come in from out of area and buy up all the best items so the people who actually live in the lower-income areas can't buy them. Poverty is so funny for certain posters on MN Hmm
TSSDNCOP · 21/10/2021 18:21

As it happens I think EW has done some very questionable things. I just don't think, with the exception of those monstrous shoes she also wore, this is one of them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread