Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emma Watson Wedding Dresses

185 replies

YearsSinceISawYou · 21/10/2021 15:32

All those at the Earth shot Awards were asked to wear outfits that considered the environment-I suppose this means second hand or worn before. At any rate, that's what they did.

Along comes Emma Watson with her Harris Reed designed dress, made from 10 upcycled wedding dresses from Oxfam.

AIBU to think that if Emma really cared about this sort of stuff-as she often says she does-she would have left the 10 wedding dresses in Oxfam, so that 10 people would have been able to recycle 10 dresses-with the added bonus that they would have been affordable for those people.

Instead, she takes all ten of them and chops them up, thus showing herself to be an over-privileged hypocrite, who cares more about making a headline than 'saving the planet' or thinking about the women who could have made real use of those dresses.

Surely she had something else in her wardrobe that she could have used.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Wanttoconnectwithmorepeople · 21/09/2022 17:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MushMonster · 24/10/2021 19:04

Upcycling is a huge part of being environmentally friendly. Many times it takes more than one old piece to make a new fasionable one.
Wearing something that you have in your wardrobe is another option indeed.
There is nothing wrong at all with any of the options.
All within the spirit of the event, I think.

TSSDNCOP · 24/10/2021 18:19

"Charity" shops are, you may be surprised to discover, are run along the same lines as commercial businesses. Their main motivation is to raise money for the charity of choice; many donators chose a particular shop because they support that charity.

Yes, the prices attract people on low incomes, it's great to help a person that needs a fancy wedding outfit, or a funeral suit, an interview outfit or kids clothes/toys etc we all know how useful that is.

The shops also have to make rent in whichever location they are in. They also have strict guidelines on stuff like electricals and DVD's etc. They have to pay to have crap they cannot sell taken away.

Charity shops need to be able to price effectively; there are guidelines on this.
They need to make £'s because they have targets. Yes, serving the local community is also an objective, but it's really not the prevailing objective.

They also need to be laid out in ways that adhere to H&S. Volunteers need to be managed. Managers are paid and, the same as commercial managers need to be business minded to create seasonal display, rotate stock etc.

Donators also donate to a particular shop because they can stop outside and effectively do a fly tip. Donators also donate because they've got great stuff that is used but sellable, and someone may benefit. Donators also donate because who wouldn't want their used pants/socks and kids clothes still with ketchup and pasta stuck to them?

PackedintheUK · 24/10/2021 14:46

I thought it was a very strange thing to do, but tbh I thought the whole event was a bit weird.

It wasn't very nice either and I bet there were plenty of new bits in it.

Disabrie22 · 24/10/2021 14:44

I’ve just seen it - it’s awful - I genuinely believe I could have made something better myself!

Pandaly · 24/10/2021 14:38

The "Charity" bit in Charity shop is because the money raised goes to charity not because it sells 2nd hand clothes as a charitable act.

KingsleyShacklebolt · 24/10/2021 13:37

Not just someone, @ChristmasFluff. A "poor person".

ChristmasFluff · 24/10/2021 13:33

So according to you, OP, I shouldn't buy a coat from Oxfam, and cut it up to make a jacket and shorts, because I'm depriving someone of a coat?

And as for the Great British Sewing Bee.....

Whataday198 · 24/10/2021 13:10

I'm pretty certain Oxfam second hand wedding dresses aren't such a rare and sought after item that EW is denying someone else. OP sounds like she's desperately reaching for something to complain about.

NickiWap · 24/10/2021 12:50

Tbh Op you come across as someone that hates Emma Watson and you're just looking for any old reason to put the boot in.

Smashingspinster · 24/10/2021 12:43

AIGINAF

Grin
BalladOfBarryAndFreda · 24/10/2021 12:35

@Glitterybug

Have you had a look at the wedding dresses available on oxfam?

onlineshop.oxfam.org.uk/bridal/category/bridal?N=4131982658&Ns=product.creationDate|1&Nr=AND(product.active:1,NOT(sku.listPrice:0.000000))&No=0

1980s monstrosities and fast fashion high street wedding dresses from places like wed2be and asos.

Best thing for them to be cut up and reused.

Get over yourself, there are plenty of good quality dress designers on the first page alone.

FWIW, I really like the champagne raw silk 80’s number Grin

ThinWomansBrain · 24/10/2021 12:33

Some of us had no choice to but to go to Oxfam for a wedding dress

there is a choice for everyone whether or not to acquire an outfit that thye plan to wear only once.

HesterShaw1 · 24/10/2021 12:30

@KingsleyShacklebolt

Insightful comment there, Blueuggboots. Hmm
She's not wrong though.
KingsleyShacklebolt · 24/10/2021 12:27

[quote ShinyHappyPoster]@KingsleyShacklebolt I've read the research which covered over 600 charity shops. You obviously haven't.[/quote]
Doesn't matter what research you've read. You still can't pretend to know the motives of everyone donating. Because all will have their own reasons for donating, and choosing that particular shop. I might not have read research covering 600 shops but I have spoken to many more than 600 customers in the 6.5 years I have been a charity shop volunteer.

Quite possibly some people are donating to a shop in the hope "poor people" will get a bargain, but their gesture in that case is misplaced. Because by and large, that's not what charity shops are about.

Oftenithinkaboutit · 24/10/2021 12:24

@KingsleyShacklebolt

Insightful comment there, Blueuggboots. Hmm
It’s mumsnet. If you want insightful debate, perhaps don’t jump on a thread on AIBU on mumsnet about a celeb and a wedding dress? Hmm
ShinyHappyPoster · 24/10/2021 12:20

@KingsleyShacklebolt I've read the research which covered over 600 charity shops. You obviously haven't.

KingsleyShacklebolt · 24/10/2021 12:10

Insightful comment there, Blueuggboots. Hmm

Blueuggboots · 24/10/2021 12:07

It looks shit.

KingsleyShacklebolt · 24/10/2021 12:04

You can't possibly know the motives of everyone who donates to charity shops, whatever the area and its demographics. Some people will donate because it's a cause close to their heart, others because that particular charity shop has easy parking and they can't be bothered taking bags to another one further down the road.

If people are taking stuff to a RSPCA or Cancer Research shop in a lower income area hoping to help poor people get cheap stuff rather than helping the animals or funding cancer studies, they are misguided. Because those shops do not have an aim of providing cheap stuff. You could argue (and I would argue) that if you want to donate your stuff directly to the needy then you would be better donating it straight to a refugee project, or a homeless shelter, women's refuge type place.

According to one stat I found with a very quick Google, only 4% of wedding dresses worn are second hand. And that will include people who have worn their mother's/granny's dress. There is quite clearly a glut of worn-once dresses. So by repurposing them or upcycling them, all this designer is showing is that there is no need to buy a new dress, when you can cobble together a "new" one from fabric taken from old ones.

ShinyHappyPoster · 24/10/2021 11:36

It's interesting that so many posters utterly refuse to believe that people in lower income areas go to charity shops because that is all they can afford.
I can only assume those posters are working in charity shops in affluent areas.
People donate to charity shops in lower income areas because they want people to have access to cheap items.
There are also different types of charity shops with different ethos. But reframing charity shops as purely capitalist endeavours is contrary to the most recent research on charity retail where social, community and environmental impacts came above economics.

LizzieMacQueen · 22/10/2021 09:23

I think this when the Sewing Bee do their upcycle week. The amount of decent 2nd hand stuff that gets hacked up for a TV show ! Gets on my nerves. But then, TV shows were never environmentally friendly. Best we can all do, is do our best.

2Two · 22/10/2021 09:17

I think they just sell any unwanted clothing to textile recycling companies. Probably make more for the charity that way than selling through the shops.

No, they don't. At the charity shop I know, they get £5 per bag - and we're talking large binbag sizes. A lot of what goes in there is the sort of tat that people dump on charity shops that would never sell anyway, but they also put stuff in there that has been out in the shop but hasn't sold. Obviously you only need to sell six things at a pound each to be doing better than that. So Emma Watson buying ten wedding dresses of which at best only one would have sold normally was doing this charity a major favour.

LavenderAskew · 22/10/2021 09:03

There's Oxfam's that sell wedding dresses specifically - so the price tag is more than 10 or something along that, it's 100s - but the dresses are often donated designer ones or come directly from designers' old stock with an original price tag of 1,000s. (As shown in a post above.) They certainly aren't all meringues or 80s horrors.

Not clear on whether Emma's dress came from 10 dresses or if the designer had 10 dresses and made several from them. What Emma is wearing doesn't look like the martierla of 10 at all.

But whatever you think about the horror of someone with money buying from a charity shop (directly or indirectly) or the horror of a wedding dress being can we all agree the result isn't great looking - those black trousers just make it a weird outfit. Sack the designer!! Grin

(I like the boots though)

MajorCarolDanvers · 22/10/2021 07:55

Crikey OP you don't like Emma Watson at all do you?