Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Travelled by train last week for the first time in years - really wish I hadn't

130 replies

coffeerevelsrock · 21/10/2021 10:50

What a depressing eye-opener. I wanted to do the right thing and use the car less and also going to a few different parts of London is obviously easier by public transport.

I was taken aback by the lack of mask wearing on the trains. Despite posters everywhere saying please wear them, pretty much all staff wearing them and announcements encouraging their use, only a handful of people in packed trains had them on. Even on the tubes it was a minority who had them on. Last time I went in the summer (travelled by car that time but used tfl once there) it was compulsory and almost 100% take up. Now that seems to have fizzled out.

Then, on the way home, the train was cancelled and our connection was packed as three earlier trains had also been cancelled. On the packed train, I asked someone to move a bag off a seat so ds or I could sit down and the woman glared and huffed and puffed before doing so. Just so rude. In the seat across the aisle I then had to ask a young lad to move over so one of us could use the empty seat he was next to. He did without the rudeness but tbh I don't know why he didn't just move anyway - he could see how packed t was. Then a woman opposite had bags on the seat, headphones in and was looking fixedly at her book. She blatantly ignored me when I asked her to move for my other ds/someone else. WTF? You're sitting on a packed train with a bag on the seat and you pretend not to notice people are going to have to stand for 40 mins + so your bag can have a seat or so you don't have to sit next to someone??

The whole experience made me think people in this country are fucking selfish. This was on a Sunday evening - god knows what it's like commuting.

Is it always this bad and why do we have such an issue with masks here?

OP posts:
Davina69 · 21/10/2021 18:59

OP I have a simple solution if you are unhappy at the lack of mask wearing. Stay at home. Don't come to London. Clutch your pearls and read your daily fail whilst you listen to the shite spouted by mainstream media. That way there will be plenty of spare seats for those of us that have bigger worries than whether someone else is wearing a mask Wink

UsedUpUsername · 21/10/2021 18:53

@Clocktopus

Mask wearing doesn’t do anything

Even the briefest of Google searches will show you that this is rubbish, there are umpteen studies out there showing that masks do reduce transmission.

RCT studies show no effects or very weak effects. Observational and lab studies are junk. Sorry.
UsedUpUsername · 21/10/2021 18:53

[quote lescompagnonsdeloue]@UsedUpUsername I guess you don't think covid exists either... Or else you don't mind coming across as not all that bright...[/quote]
Going straight for the ad hominems, aren’t we?

Not a lot of great evidence masks work though, and has it actually worked to stop or slow any waves in any of the countries that mandated it?

At best, you’d need N95s and the public won’t tolerate it. It’s not worth it esp. when you have vaccines and boosters available.

But sure, believe some porous cloth works. It’s the duck and cover of our age. The feeling that ‘we’re doing something!!!?!!’

KT727 · 21/10/2021 18:52

@coffeerevelsrock

It seems odd that you spotted such an amount of seat-hogging in a small area of the train, which makes me think it was not as 'packed' as you think. Were the aisles full of standing people? Could you move easily between carriages? Did you check the whole carriage for empty double seats or check another carriage?

Yes, it was weird! There were only 2 or 3 carriages and I arrived at a point with 3 spare seats near each other all blocked by bags/bodies and I couldn't move either forwards or backwards. at that point. I succeeded in freeing 2 of the seats but ds1 and several other people had to stand for the duration. I couldn't have gone looking elsewhere as the carriage was rammed as far as I could see - not surprising as there were 4 trains' worth of people on it. I guess we were lucky there were any seats.

I used to travel by train regularly and would always place my bag next to me and keep it there with eyes down at every stop! However, if it reached a point where there were clearly more people than seats then I would move it without being asked because, well, I'm not a total arsehole!

Originally I voted YABU because I used to block the seat next to me with a bag when I took the train in the past due to my health condition BUT I should have voted YANBU as I absolutely agree about the mask situation.
Clocktopus · 21/10/2021 18:47

Mask wearing doesn’t do anything

Even the briefest of Google searches will show you that this is rubbish, there are umpteen studies out there showing that masks do reduce transmission.

DismantledKing · 21/10/2021 18:43

Mask wearing doesn’t do anything. But if it makes you feel better to complain about an endemic, seasonal virus

The gormless are starting to escape from the Covid boards.

DismantledKing · 21/10/2021 18:42

@ShirleyPhallus

All these stories and threads of people being selfish arseholes boils down to one thing:

The general public are awful, selfish arseholes

This is the answer to many many different threads

This ☝️
lescompagnonsdeloue · 21/10/2021 18:39

@UsedUpUsername I guess you don't think covid exists either... Or else you don't mind coming across as not all that bright...

Mumoblue · 21/10/2021 18:00

I do think we have a very self-centred society here in the UK.
Mask wearing is on and off from what I’ve seen on the trains here.

When I was 30+ weeks pregnant with my son I had to stand about an hour on a packed train to London, which I didn’t mind so much, but people kept trying to push past me to walk up and down the train- I couldn’t really move my belly out of the way enough. A woman did offer me her seat but by that point we were almost at the station.
I did have a nice moment on the tube though, same day, a woman I didn’t know got my attention as soon as I got on the train and said loudly “I can get you a seat!” - dunno if it was her confidence, but someone hopped up to let me sit down straight away. Grin

BatshitCrazyWoman · 21/10/2021 17:58

@Lockheart

There's an unspoken etiquette on my commuter train that you don't sit next to anyone, for social distancing purposes. If it's a table of four, you can have two sitting diagonally opposite. So I'm afraid to me it sounds like you were the one committing the faux pas in that case.

I fully agree about the masks, but if you're sensible about masks you should also be sensible about distancing!

My commuter train is too busy for there to be empty seats. And too crowded generally!
UsedUpUsername · 21/10/2021 17:58

@Guetzlibache

WTF is wrong with people.I am not in a vulnerable group,but I always wear a mask on public transport,shops etc.How many times does Britain have to repeat the same thing over and over again.do you dipsticks not realise,if the numbers of Covid go up,there will be more restrictions again.Forget about Boris Johnson,he will always be 2 month behind with his acttions.
😆

Mask wearing doesn’t do anything. But if it makes you feel better to complain about an endemic, seasonal virus …

Clocktopus · 21/10/2021 17:54

The US

They do have exemptions for people unable to wear a mask in the US.

Babybellblue · 21/10/2021 17:51

@catblanket how do you know countries are about to close their borders to the UK?

lescompagnonsdeloue · 21/10/2021 17:50

@Dojacatpaws

I love train travel, you had one bad trip, surely you've been stuck in traffic jams too, have you sworn off cars as well?
But never come across somebody actually stopping their car in the middle of the road just because they wanted to park. Or at least not doing that and then being pissed because they don't think they should be told to move.
DeepaBeesKit · 21/10/2021 17:35

I got a london commuter train yesterday and easily 90% of adults were wearing masks. Same on the tube train (bakerloo).

Anonymous48 · 21/10/2021 17:31

@Clocktopus

Oh, and this whole exempt thing? I have never heard of this or come across it where I live. I'm sure there are rare instances of people who genuinely can't wear a mask, and it must be very hard for them because they aren't allowed to go anywhere that face masks are required

Which country is this as the majority do have systems in place for people are exempt? The ones who don't tend to be those who aren't particularly inclusive of disabled people anyway.

The US
Dojacatpaws · 21/10/2021 17:29

I love train travel, you had one bad trip, surely you've been stuck in traffic jams too, have you sworn off cars as well?

Bleddyansum · 21/10/2021 16:55

I wonder how many people would wear a mask if trains were segregated into a couple of carriages being for non mask wearers and the rest for wearers?

Once the non maskers carriages were full, they have to wait for the next train or put one on!

Guetzlibache · 21/10/2021 16:53

WTF is wrong with people.I am not in a vulnerable group,but I always wear a mask on public transport,shops etc.How many times does Britain have to repeat the same thing over and over again.do you dipsticks not realise,if the numbers of Covid go up,there will be more restrictions again.Forget about Boris Johnson,he will always be 2 month behind with his acttions.

lescompagnonsdeloue · 21/10/2021 16:28

And it's not backwards, it just stops all those people not wearing them because they don't like it, (many of whom post on mumsnet, some this post) from getting away with it. If you are entitled to be exempt, you are exempt.

lescompagnonsdeloue · 21/10/2021 16:26

@Clocktopus

Oh, and this whole exempt thing? I have never heard of this or come across it where I live. I'm sure there are rare instances of people who genuinely can't wear a mask, and it must be very hard for them because they aren't allowed to go anywhere that face masks are required

Which country is this as the majority do have systems in place for people are exempt? The ones who don't tend to be those who aren't particularly inclusive of disabled people anyway.

I agree with the person you have quoted. The UK has a problem because people can say "I'm exempt because I don't want to wear one". In my country (France) you never hear this "please wear a face covering unless you are exempt". It's just "face coverings must be worn". Why? Because here, you can't self certify. So the odd person could be exempt, but they will have been to see their doctor to do so. Virtually nobody is exempt as virtually nobody needs to be exempt. So we have higher levels of mask wearing. And not just any mask. I never see people in home made ones.
Silverswirl · 21/10/2021 16:00

@Anonymous48

This thread is depressing. I don't live in the UK. Where I live face coverings are still mandatory on public transportation (as they should be). I knew they no longer were in England, but I assumed that most people - being decent people who care enough about others to do this simple thing - still wore them.

They are not mandatory in shops here, just recommended, and probably 75% of people still wear them.

Oh, and this whole exempt thing? I have never heard of this or come across it where I live. I'm sure there are rare instances of people who genuinely can't wear a mask, and it must be very hard for them because they aren't allowed to go anywhere that face masks are required. But it means that only people who genuinely can't wear a mask make that claim.

Horrifically backward for disabled people and their carers. MIL has mod- severe dementia. She would be pulling it off every 2 seconds as she wouldn’t remember why it’s there. She can’t be left alone and no family really feels comfortable with her 1-2-1. Is my FIL not meant to go anywhere at all then for months and months? Does MIL not deserve to be taken to a garden centre r local shop every once in a while? Disgusting attitude
Clocktopus · 21/10/2021 15:42

Oh, and this whole exempt thing? I have never heard of this or come across it where I live. I'm sure there are rare instances of people who genuinely can't wear a mask, and it must be very hard for them because they aren't allowed to go anywhere that face masks are required

Which country is this as the majority do have systems in place for people are exempt? The ones who don't tend to be those who aren't particularly inclusive of disabled people anyway.

doublemonkey · 21/10/2021 15:16

Am I the only one thinking all these recent threads about covid/lockdown/masks etc is Psy Ops?

Shumoo · 21/10/2021 15:10

I have noticed that more people are wearing masks on my early train into London than on the way home, but I agree, it's grim and people can be incredibly selfish.

I don't love wearing a mask but frankly I'd rather be part of the solution than the problem so I do.

One day last week on a particularly packed train I sat on my seat while a man stood next to me in the aisle, sniffing, sneezing and mouth breathing. Full on snotty. No mask. I couldn't even have moved if I'd wanted to it was that busy and to be honest he wasn't the only one - you could hear sneezing, sniffing and coughing throughout the train. It's a filthy environment we're stuck in every day those who commute. Properly grim.