Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Travelled by train last week for the first time in years - really wish I hadn't

130 replies

coffeerevelsrock · 21/10/2021 10:50

What a depressing eye-opener. I wanted to do the right thing and use the car less and also going to a few different parts of London is obviously easier by public transport.

I was taken aback by the lack of mask wearing on the trains. Despite posters everywhere saying please wear them, pretty much all staff wearing them and announcements encouraging their use, only a handful of people in packed trains had them on. Even on the tubes it was a minority who had them on. Last time I went in the summer (travelled by car that time but used tfl once there) it was compulsory and almost 100% take up. Now that seems to have fizzled out.

Then, on the way home, the train was cancelled and our connection was packed as three earlier trains had also been cancelled. On the packed train, I asked someone to move a bag off a seat so ds or I could sit down and the woman glared and huffed and puffed before doing so. Just so rude. In the seat across the aisle I then had to ask a young lad to move over so one of us could use the empty seat he was next to. He did without the rudeness but tbh I don't know why he didn't just move anyway - he could see how packed t was. Then a woman opposite had bags on the seat, headphones in and was looking fixedly at her book. She blatantly ignored me when I asked her to move for my other ds/someone else. WTF? You're sitting on a packed train with a bag on the seat and you pretend not to notice people are going to have to stand for 40 mins + so your bag can have a seat or so you don't have to sit next to someone??

The whole experience made me think people in this country are fucking selfish. This was on a Sunday evening - god knows what it's like commuting.

Is it always this bad and why do we have such an issue with masks here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Arbitan · 22/10/2021 21:48

It’s fantasy land to believe that you can socially distance on the underground. I was in London a couple of weekends ago and the tube was packed, standing and sitting, and mask wearing, at best, was roughly 50-60%.

I’m not saying it particularly bothered me, just an observation.

BatshitCrazyWoman · 22/10/2021 21:38

@FateHasRedesignedMost

Aren’t we supposed to social distance on trains now? So it’s rude to ask a stranger to move their bag so you can sit right next to them? Masks or not, if either of you had covid it’s likely you’d catch it from each other if sitting hip to hip.

Why not wait for a less busy train? Or stand and give people space?

Agree people should be wearing masks, but they’re not a foolproof way of avoiding covid and other viruses. Social distancing and good ventilation is more effective, especially as people tend to take masks off to eat/drink/blow their noses/talk on the phone.

It's not possible on my rush hour commuter train into London to not have someone sitting next to you, and/or standing near you. Many people are back working in the office and doing their normal hours.
VickyEadieofThigh · 22/10/2021 17:14

@5128gap

Where I commute, large city, not London, few people where masks. However, an etiquette has developed around seats, with it being accepted that you generally do not sit right next to anyone else. Occasionally on very busy trains people may do, but they always ask the existing occupant of the double seat if its OK. Knowing this, people do use the seat next to them for their bag. Pre covid bags on seats used to infuriate me, but its expected now on my train.
I got the train to London last week, returning the next day. Not many mask wearers on the way down, even fewer on return and that was a much busier train.

I booked my seat both ways and wore a mask - I could only get a table of 4 on return (sitting by the window) as all the 2 seats had gone - and then was obliged to sit, the only masked person of the 4, with 3 people, two of whom were in their late 60s or early 70s so should have known better, in my opinion.

On the tube, mask wearing was around 75-80* (despite it being compulsory) and the transgressors I saw were all under 40s.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 22/10/2021 17:05

Aren’t we supposed to social distance on trains now? So it’s rude to ask a stranger to move their bag so you can sit right next to them? Masks or not, if either of you had covid it’s likely you’d catch it from each other if sitting hip to hip.

Why not wait for a less busy train? Or stand and give people space?

Agree people should be wearing masks, but they’re not a foolproof way of avoiding covid and other viruses. Social distancing and good ventilation is more effective, especially as people tend to take masks off to eat/drink/blow their noses/talk on the phone.

Anonymous48 · 22/10/2021 16:21

@catblanket

To whoever quoted me and told me that England was doing lots more testing than the rest of the world, you have got to be KIDDING?

My app records all the PCRs I have had done since Covid started, and these are all administered by a nurse by the way, and I have had scores of them - at least 60. I was tested at least once a week until recently (it's reduced since our vaccination rates got into the 90s).

I have also been to Greece and France this summer, and they are also making tests easily available to everyone. Why does everyone in England think that they are just getting more tests done than other countries? The tests in England are pretty crap anyway, being self administered. I have friends and family in England who have never even been tested! Baffling.

Furthermore, to get away with not wearing a mask where I live, you'd have to actually have a certificate signed by a doctor and attested. I honestly don't think I've seen anyone not wearing one.

The UK vaccination rates are relatively low now - it's at around 67% which is way lower than most other western countries (and many of those were administered more than 6 months ago, so immunity is waning). So the UK can NOT afford to relax measures.

This thread has made me realise that there are thankfully some sensible and community-minded people left in England, but my god some of the replies have me utterly exasperated at the levels of denial about what a total shit-show it is in England.

Surely, unless you're in a job that requires it, most people only get tested if they suspect they might have covid, or if they need the test for something like traveling. I wouldn't think it was that unusual or strange for someone never to have been tested. I've only been tested once and that was because I had symptoms and it turned out that I did have covid. (I'm not in the UK, btw.)
KrispyKale · 22/10/2021 11:34

I know a lot of people do LFT and don't report them.

Volhhg · 22/10/2021 11:32

@catblanket

To whoever quoted me and told me that England was doing lots more testing than the rest of the world, you have got to be KIDDING?

My app records all the PCRs I have had done since Covid started, and these are all administered by a nurse by the way, and I have had scores of them - at least 60. I was tested at least once a week until recently (it's reduced since our vaccination rates got into the 90s).

I have also been to Greece and France this summer, and they are also making tests easily available to everyone. Why does everyone in England think that they are just getting more tests done than other countries? The tests in England are pretty crap anyway, being self administered. I have friends and family in England who have never even been tested! Baffling.

Furthermore, to get away with not wearing a mask where I live, you'd have to actually have a certificate signed by a doctor and attested. I honestly don't think I've seen anyone not wearing one.

The UK vaccination rates are relatively low now - it's at around 67% which is way lower than most other western countries (and many of those were administered more than 6 months ago, so immunity is waning). So the UK can NOT afford to relax measures.

This thread has made me realise that there are thankfully some sensible and community-minded people left in England, but my god some of the replies have me utterly exasperated at the levels of denial about what a total shit-show it is in England.

In answer to your question about why people think the UK is doing more testing just have a look online. Look it up on our world in data and you can see a table of how many tests are being carried out in each country. Only PCR tests and antigen tests are used in the data. The majority of UK self administered tests wont be included since most people don't report the results online and if positive go on to have another PCR test.
KatherineJaneway · 22/10/2021 06:44

@Lockheart

There's an unspoken etiquette on my commuter train that you don't sit next to anyone, for social distancing purposes. If it's a table of four, you can have two sitting diagonally opposite. So I'm afraid to me it sounds like you were the one committing the faux pas in that case.

I fully agree about the masks, but if you're sensible about masks you should also be sensible about distancing!

This was the case when few were travelling earlier in the year or the train is very quiet but not acceptable anymore when the train is busy and people want to sit down in rush hour.
catblanket · 21/10/2021 22:03

By the way, I suspect mask compliance is higher on the tube and train in London because Londoners were already well aware what a germ-fest the Tube can be. Also, black bogies anyone?!

catblanket · 21/10/2021 21:59

To whoever quoted me and told me that England was doing lots more testing than the rest of the world, you have got to be KIDDING?

My app records all the PCRs I have had done since Covid started, and these are all administered by a nurse by the way, and I have had scores of them - at least 60. I was tested at least once a week until recently (it's reduced since our vaccination rates got into the 90s).

I have also been to Greece and France this summer, and they are also making tests easily available to everyone. Why does everyone in England think that they are just getting more tests done than other countries? The tests in England are pretty crap anyway, being self administered. I have friends and family in England who have never even been tested! Baffling.

Furthermore, to get away with not wearing a mask where I live, you'd have to actually have a certificate signed by a doctor and attested. I honestly don't think I've seen anyone not wearing one.

The UK vaccination rates are relatively low now - it's at around 67% which is way lower than most other western countries (and many of those were administered more than 6 months ago, so immunity is waning). So the UK can NOT afford to relax measures.

This thread has made me realise that there are thankfully some sensible and community-minded people left in England, but my god some of the replies have me utterly exasperated at the levels of denial about what a total shit-show it is in England.

omfgimgettingmarried · 21/10/2021 21:36

Yup. It fucks me right off. I tell myself that they're just ill informed because the reality that they are selfish arseholes makes me too angry.

UsedUpUsername · 21/10/2021 21:33

@DismantledKing

Going straight for the ad hominems, aren’t we?

Yeah, like it’s worth engaging with people like you in good faith. You ignore the scientific consensus because you’ve seen something on Facebook or YouTube (sorry, ‘doing your own research’).
Ridicule is the only appropriate response to Covid denialism. You’re just Climate Change ‘sceptics’ and 9/11 truthers rebadged.

Yet here you are.

And it’s not the consensus. Science is not handed down on high from public health authorities. There’s plenty of healthy debate among the experts on COVID. See Great Barrington Declaration, which will ultimately be the way out of COVID (because the vaccines sure as hell haven’t done the job despite very high vaxx rates)

KeepPortlandWeird · 21/10/2021 21:17

We went by train yesterday into central London and noticed that most people actually were wearing masks on the underground staff and customers alike, in shops, and even outside. So I don’t understand how one experience is so vastly different to another??

This was at all times of day too - we travelled from early morning, throughout the day on tube and a bus, and tube during rush hour.

Oswina · 21/10/2021 21:02

Tbf, a lot of the time I would rather stand then sit next to someone on a train. It feels very intimate in a way that the tube doesn't - probably because of the dear layout being in threes or couples, as opposed to straight lines down the sides. Hate buses and coaches for this reason too.

Lightswitch123 · 21/10/2021 20:58

SAGE / The government / The press over egged the pudding with their fear mongering far, far too many times.

Those chickens have now come home to roost.

4thtimethecharm · 21/10/2021 20:50

I take the train for my work commute. There is very little mask-wearing (including none by the staff I have encountered). On my train yesterday, of the 6 people seated around me, none was wearing one. Last week there was someone close to me with such an obvious continuous cough (and no mask), that I stepped out and stood in the hallway for an hour, just because I did not feel safe.

I am newly pregnant and have lost every previous pregnancy thus far, so am not keen to throw the complicating factor of Covid into the mix. I don't love wearing a mask (who would?), but appreciate it as a key tool in combatting Covid, and happily put up with it for that purpose. I do appreciate some people are exempt, but surely not 75% of folks in my train carriage.

I wish they would start masked and non-masked compartments, like a PP also suggested, so there is an actual option for those of us who want to keep safe by masking, but rely on public transport for our livelihoods.

Arbitan · 21/10/2021 20:02

If you expect the train to be rammed and can get it for a reasonable price, it’s always worth going first class if it’s available. More room, bigger seat, generally quieter, and usually some food / drink thrown in. I wouldn’t do it every day but on the odd occasion I travel by train I usually splash out, especially for a long journey.

Essen · 21/10/2021 19:58

Central London has had some of the lowest case numbers in the country for the last 5 months. It is clearly a bit more complicated than how many are wearing a mask on the tube. Mask wearing seems to be a bit better during the week than at weekends.

Davina69 · 21/10/2021 19:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

DismantledKing · 21/10/2021 19:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Davina69 · 21/10/2021 19:27

@DismantledKing

Going straight for the ad hominems, aren’t we?

Yeah, like it’s worth engaging with people like you in good faith. You ignore the scientific consensus because you’ve seen something on Facebook or YouTube (sorry, ‘doing your own research’).
Ridicule is the only appropriate response to Covid denialism. You’re just Climate Change ‘sceptics’ and 9/11 truthers rebadged.

Just because I have a different opinion to you does not make me a nutter. It's called living in a democracy love
User135644 · 21/10/2021 19:22

@JollyAndBright

Pre covid I used trains regularly. I would never put bags on seats and saw it as incredibly annoying even on quiet train.

I have been using the train occasionally post covid,
I’m a mask wearer and have been pleasantly surprise by how many people have continued to wear masks, although it definitely depends on the area.

However, I will not sit next to a stranger, I have been intentionally putting my bag on the seat next to me to ensure nobody chooses to sit there and avoiding travelling at busy times so that it’s not an issue.

I’ve even moved seats if someone has decided to sit in the seats in front or behind me on a quiet train.

If the train was so busy there were no spare seats (well I wouldn’t have gotten on it to begin with, and I would probably choose to get off the train if it became that busy mid journey) but I would prefer to stand rather that have a stranger sit next to me.

Our bus route still have signs up telling people not to sit with people not in their household and that masks are mandatory, so the busses aren’t an issue.

Yeah, I take the train when I know it'll be quiet.

At the weekend I got the train and had a carriage to myself on a journey. A woman with two coughing and noisy kids then proceeds to plonk herself down in the table directly next to me (there was plenty empty behind and in front). Bloody ridiculous, so I moved to the back of the carriage.

When i've been in busy carriages mask wearing has been pretty good, but I avoid them if I can.

Dojacatpaws · 21/10/2021 19:22

Lescompagnon, what, so you've never been stuck on a motorway for hours, or moving at a snails pace in a city or the country side?

DismantledKing · 21/10/2021 19:13

Going straight for the ad hominems, aren’t we?

Yeah, like it’s worth engaging with people like you in good faith. You ignore the scientific consensus because you’ve seen something on Facebook or YouTube (sorry, ‘doing your own research’).
Ridicule is the only appropriate response to Covid denialism. You’re just Climate Change ‘sceptics’ and 9/11 truthers rebadged.

DismantledKing · 21/10/2021 19:01

@Davina69

OP I have a simple solution if you are unhappy at the lack of mask wearing. Stay at home. Don't come to London. Clutch your pearls and read your daily fail whilst you listen to the shite spouted by mainstream media. That way there will be plenty of spare seats for those of us that have bigger worries than whether someone else is wearing a mask Wink
And another nutter.