Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being a mean old grinch?

41 replies

Newwifeatnumber10 · 21/10/2021 09:48

I have four nieces aged from 9 to 16. Every year I buy each of them a Christmas gift worth about £35 each and a birthday gift of similar value. Each year I become increasingly pissed off to never get so much as a thank you or a merry Christmas text from them or their parents (all my brother’s children).

I don’t have children so DB and SIL don’t buy anything. I rarely get a birthday card.

In years past I’ve carefully shopped and bought thoughtful gifts and nice cards.

AIBU to put £10 in a card for them this year?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AnneLovesGilbert · 21/10/2021 19:22

Or an Oxfam goat.

Hillarious · 21/10/2021 14:53

A family board game is the way to go!

Triffid1 · 21/10/2021 14:45

I think you are totally justified. I am not one for big elaborate thank you cards etc but would expect an acknowledgement, from the parents when kids are smaller, and then in time in a quick message from the child once they have their own phone.

If MIL sends presents, the kids don't write her a card but I'll send her an email and DH will get them to talk to her briefly to say thank you when they next speak on Skype.

1forAll74 · 21/10/2021 14:44

Its not nice to be in this position, and I would limit the price on gifts, if I decided to buy anything for children. Its always a problem to buy things for children now,, as they have a tendency to have too much already.

It was always a stipulation, that I had to write a little note to family members,who gave me gifts in the oldie days, and I made sure that my two children did the same, when they were young.

Time40 · 21/10/2021 14:30

AIBU to put £10 in a card for them this year?

You would be VVU to do that. If they don't say thank you, they don't deserve anything at all.

Aria2015 · 21/10/2021 14:23

I think it's really important to teach children to be thankful for any gifts they receive. Mine are still little but my 6 year old writes his own thank you cards now and I've told him that if he doesn't thank people, they won't want to buy him a gift in the future! I've also told him that sometimes you get gifts you don't like that much but that it's still important to say thank you because they were given in kindness with the best intentions.

I must say it irks me that my db's children never do thank yous. They are youngish too so I guess it's really on my db and sil but neither of them do thank yous for their own birthdays so I shouldn't be surprised!

AnneLovesGilbert · 21/10/2021 14:13

Indeed. All I’ve ever done with them is try to make an effort to include them and get to know them. I’m a step child and a step mum and we all just muddle along as family. They’ve never accepted invitations to stay, declined to come to our wedding, never acknowledged my step kids or the birth of my daughter.

So I’m done. Feels good!

RuggerHug · 21/10/2021 13:56

@AnneLovesGilbert

YABVU to send them anything more than a card. And who gives a toss if anyone complains.

No one has a right to your money or effort. It’s a massive ball ache trying to come up with ideas for people you don’t see often, especially fickle kids.

I stopped buying for my step niece and nephew in their late teens as they never acknowledged them. The year after I got a thank you card from one of them “for all the presents you’ve sent me for lots of years” and a suggestion from his mum (he was by now 18) that as I’d been thanked I might start giving them stuff again Hmm

Yeah, no. That ship had sailed long since.

The gall!!!Shock
Hullbilly · 21/10/2021 13:55

It's the not knowing if your gift arrived I get fed up with.

Liverbird77 · 21/10/2021 13:49

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

AnneLovesGilbert · 21/10/2021 13:48

YABVU to send them anything more than a card. And who gives a toss if anyone complains.

No one has a right to your money or effort. It’s a massive ball ache trying to come up with ideas for people you don’t see often, especially fickle kids.

I stopped buying for my step niece and nephew in their late teens as they never acknowledged them. The year after I got a thank you card from one of them “for all the presents you’ve sent me for lots of years” and a suggestion from his mum (he was by now 18) that as I’d been thanked I might start giving them stuff again Hmm

Yeah, no. That ship had sailed long since.

ChargingBuck · 21/10/2021 13:42

@DingDongDenny

I also don't think we should have to ask them to say thank you - it's a bit meaningless if it doesn't come from them without persuasion
It has plenty of meaning.

It's about teaching kids life skills like good manners & gratitude.
DB is failing them by not showing them how to respond properly.

LittleDandelionClock · 21/10/2021 13:26

I don't think anyone has to write a 'thank you' letter, that's crazy when they can just text/whatsapp the person, or send them a facebook or twitter message. OR the old fashioned way, just tell them in person.

However @Newwifeatnumber10 I would probably drop it to maybe £20 each for this Christmas. Then tell everyone you are stopping, as it's a bit much now, as it's costing too much. If anyone carries on probing, just say 'my gifts were never acknowledged, and it's costing money I can ill afford, so I have made the decision to stop.'

They will be a bit miffed/feel slighted, but they'll get over it. It's not LAW that you have to buy nieces and nephews gifts or give them money! It's not law that we have to give anything to anyone actually!

Owlink · 21/10/2021 13:11

I got sick of that too. Just told the nephew & niece in person how rude & hurtful it is not to acknowledge gifts, told them we always had to write thank you letters when we were children, so much easier now you can just text etc etc (so I must have put up with it when they were younger, I realise). Niece always says thank you now AND sends me birthday & Xmas cards. Nephew does nowt & gets nowt from me any more.

Icebreaker99 · 21/10/2021 12:36

If they aren't bothered about Auntie, then Auntie shouldn't bother about them, they are all old enough to be able to call you or send a text. £10 in a card if you wish, or a family board game as a family present.

Catflapkitkat · 21/10/2021 12:33

Sorry messed up - I saw you didn't have children and pressed post too soon.

Catflapkitkat · 21/10/2021 12:31

It's so rude not to even acknowledge your gifts. How hard is it for a 16 year to send a thank you text - they are glued to their phones at that age. Do you ever ask if they received it? Do you ask your parents if they liked the presents, as you've not heard anything?'.

I would go one step further and say 'in an effort scale back, from now on we are only buying gifts for the immediate family. Would be great to meet up etc. What is the worse that can happen, they don't send your kids anything, your nieces don't contact you ......

Iwonder08 · 21/10/2021 11:51

I would buy a card for the family and won't buy presents or send money.

Fernhilde · 21/10/2021 11:40

I would stop buying them anything

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 21/10/2021 11:38

I know it's not relevant to OPs dilemma but I grew up on stories of my parents getting an orange & bar of chocolate for Xmas . And sometimes a cardigan that's been knitted. . And in my Dads large family he fondly recalls that one of his brothers or sisters in the family got a (second hand) bike each year and they all looked forward to it being their year for "a bike" or nearly as much a treat the hand me down bike from older sibling that could happen if they got a bike.

My parents grew up in large families and very poor. We're no longer poor but generally only the parents spend £££ on their own children and aunts and uncles send a card or text if that or occasionally a small £5 gift to godchildren niece/nephews . We're all extremely close so you'll get fed snd an icecream when you go round . But wouldn't be able to afford £££ on multiple children each Xmas and birthdays and we don't even try.

I cannot imagine spending £35 each on 3+ nieces or nephews for Xmas and birthdays in one family and not once getting an acknowledgement or Thankyou text. It's so rude and ungrateful

I guess we all have different attitudes to present giving . My friends and I only buy for each other for big birthdays or if we happen to see something they'd love that's funny or cute

MesChiensSontBeaux · 21/10/2021 11:34

I agree you should get a thank you text from your brother or possibly the nieces that are old enough. My kids are teens and they either text or phone their aunts/uncles to say thanks. If it’s from friends of ours they don’t know so well then we say thank you for them. A text takes seconds.

I’d definitely reduce the amount you spend.... they don’t even acknowledge you in any way over Christmas! Fuck that.

Rexthesnail · 21/10/2021 11:23

Just send cards

MysteriousMonkey · 21/10/2021 11:20

I'd make it £5 and put all the other money aside for something lovely for myself that I would usually think was too much.

Brollywasntneededafterall · 21/10/2021 11:06

I voted yabu...
Unless the tenner is between them...

WhereIsMumHiding3 · 21/10/2021 11:05

I was trying to say that £35 is almost as much as I'd spend on my parents together and also on my (only) sister

My DCs only got £5-10 from my sis and £25-50 from my parents as they're the only DGC (& will always be the only DGC as my Sis couldn't have DCs and is no longer with us)

My sister loved the bones of my DCs. The amount of money spent didn't matter and they always thanked her and rang her if she wasn't with us for their birthdays or Xmas (she usually was)
If they hadn't said thank-you , she'd have put them right straight away that she wouldn't bother if they didn't.

My aunts and uncles only sent their godchildren gifts at Xmas and birthdays and when we did get gifts it was usually £5 or a bottle of hair mousse or chocolates except for my 18th when I got gold locket necklace.

So I see no reason for you not to start sending money or voucher in a card and cutting the spend down as you have no idea if they've appreciated any of your gifts or if you've been wasting your money.