Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD's Uni asked her to repeat a whole year without marking her work because she missed their emails asking her if she was going to meet a certain deadline. DS has been suicidal and is not talking

87 replies

sayitwithcolors · 20/10/2021 23:15

DD's Uni asked her to repeat a whole year without marking her work because she missed their emails asking her if she was going to meet a certain assignment submission deadline. She made a later deadline and they would not mark her work at all. The reason she missed the deadline was because DS has been suicidal and is not talking to her or me.
AIBU to be mad at DD's Uni. We appealed the first time and gave them this reason and they refused. Please could anyone advise on what constitutes a compelling argument to make them change their mind. DD is freaking out and is now very depressed. Help please as I'm at a loss of what to do.

OP posts:
iloveeverykindofcat · 21/10/2021 05:49

I worked as the school exams officer during my last lectureship. Its not a personal decision, they are following procedure. I don't think you're getting the whole story here but if someone missed multiple deadlines with zero communication they would have to repeat. We literally can't mark work after a certain point - it's unfair on the people who submitted on time.

Belledan1 · 21/10/2021 05:42

Has she been to a board already as they normally make them decisions there. She would have a support representative attend with her that the uni sorts. Perhaps she missed the emails inviting her for this as I am sure if she took some evidence of what happened they would give her an extension.

bullywee · 21/10/2021 05:39

Posted too soon. Meant to add...

However, if your daughter has not met the minimum requirements for the course (attendance) then there may be little that can be done other than allowing her to repeat the year as a first sit (rather than as a result student).

Many courses are subject to accreditation requirements which must be fulfilled.

bullywee · 21/10/2021 05:35

A lot of posters on this thread need to remember that different universities (and even different courses/departments/disciplines/schools/colleges) within universities have different rules and policies so statements such as resits being capped etc are not entirely helpful.

One would imagine that the late submission of coursework is not the issue but rather by not submitting coursework your daughter has failed to meet the learning outcomes for the course. This can come about several ways encompassing non engagement with course. This could include not attending (enough) compulsory teaching and not submitting coursework at all. Most if not all courses require that students submit X% of the assessments (my institution is 75%).

Universities do have extenuating circumstances committees to deal with these events but unless a student informs the university that there are issues that may have affected their performance there is little we can do.

I would suggest your daughter contacts the university student support/student counselling as soon as possible - i.e. this morning - to arrange an emergency appointment. The student services may be able to help her case.

Zippy1510 · 21/10/2021 05:24

If she made any approved deadline- including any authorised extension then it would have to be marked. It sounds more like she didn’t communicate with student support to get an extension put in place- so would be classed as a non submission.

ThatsNotMyReindeer · 21/10/2021 05:08

This doesn't make sense to me. Its October. Which year is she having to repeat? Last year? The academic year has already started so why has this only come up now? Or is it her current year? In which case why is she being written off so early on?

I also don't think you're getting the full story...

Fetarabbit · 21/10/2021 05:05

When you say refuse to mark her work, do you mean the pieces that weren't handed in before the deadlines? We had to always hand extenuating circumstance forms in before the work was late, this was probably what the emails were mentioning. Its absolutely understandable that she wasn't in the right mindset to prioritise university (I've been in the same position with a sibling); but the rules are pretty standard across the board. It sounds like they tried to reach out, were ignored, and if they make allowances for her they'd have to do it for everyone.

wombat1a · 21/10/2021 05:00

There is perhaps something else going on here, I work in this environment and in the past we have also not marked a students work that has been given in late because we know the mark we would have to give would not be a fair reflection on that students capabilities.

In these cases we ask the student to resit the entire year with the aim that the 'missing year' essentially becomes a year out. When they resit we take their work from the resit year not the 'lost year'. This gives the student a far better chance of getting a good degree at the end of it. it may take them 5 yrs to get the degree not 4 but the one they end up with is the one they more often than not deserve rather than a poorer one because of circumstances.

julieca · 21/10/2021 01:37

I too suspect you are not getting the full story.
If she missed the deadline, how could she get in her work for a later deadline? How did this second deadline materialise?
Normally with mental health issues, which this would have to be, they would expect evidence. For example a previous visit to the GP about depression or anxiety. Or having talked to a tutor about how she was struggling.

Kanaloa · 21/10/2021 01:29

I think it’s worth speaking to them but there’s no point her saying she ‘missed’ the emails. They would have sent out several across a fair time period. It won’t have been one quick email then nothing.

If nothing else it might not be a bad thing to repeat.

puddlebubble · 21/10/2021 01:17

Part of her course is probably continuous assessment and perhaps what she missed, not matter what happens now would stop her passing? She should have engaged somewhat, some courses, some universities would expect this, because they are as much about academic achievement as they are about individual responsibility and drive; but it is not the end of the world. Look at @me4real post above. She may benefit from it all in the end in knowing no matter what; there are some things you have to take care of and your parents are not as responsible anymore; people will help, but can't if they are unaware at the time. (Don't want to sound harsh and I hope your son is in a better place now0

AveryGoodlay · 21/10/2021 00:24

Extenuating circumstances almost always need to be requested before the deadline is missed. Some lecturers don't accept certain types of extenuating circumstances though. My "pastoral tutor" couldn't understand why a stillborn baby may affect my course, for instance.

BiLuminous · 21/10/2021 00:24

I'm at uni doing my second degree and I think she might not be telling you the whole truth, so YABU to be mad without the full picture. Not sure what you can do though if she won't tell you. I think you're going to have to somehow reassure her that you won't be angry/disappointed with her if she comes clean. She might feel bad telling you the truth because of the upset you've had with your DS.

me4real · 21/10/2021 00:19

I had mental health problems that made it harder to give a consistent performance. Also had a missed miscarriage in my final year/focussed too much on boyfriends which meant I was too far behind.

So I came back in on a 'good year' and got a 1st in the end.

me4real · 21/10/2021 00:17

I took a few more years to finish @sayitwithcolors . She could get a doctor to write her a note or something which might help get it marked, but at PP's said you might not be being told everything.

Maybe an actual year out will help?

Or if the years been full of that much upheaval, she might get better grades if she repeated it.

Better to take longer and get a decent grade than scrape through if she's capable of more, IMHO.

ImUninsultable · 21/10/2021 00:13

Did she sit her exams?

Is it just coursework she was late with, or did she also miss the exams?

Sleeplessem · 21/10/2021 00:12

Are we sure that’s the full story with DD? It doesn’t sound like it. I repeated a year at Uni for failing a mandatory module (just pissed about too much), that’s typically the type of thing they make you retake a year for. Other modules you could carry over to the next year but because I was a dickhead I failed the mandatory one. I didn’t incur a full tuition fee for that year though I don’t think, but it taught me a huge lesson, that maybe dd needs to learn. I went on to get a 1st class UG and a Phd and work for the University, so I promise, whilst a bit shit, it’s not the end of the world for her.

I’m sorry to her DS is struggling!

Summerfun54321 · 21/10/2021 00:10

It doesn’t sound like the reason is the problem, just that she didn’t get her extenuating circumstances sorted in time.

Summerfun54321 · 21/10/2021 00:08

It sounds like she’s missed the boat for extenuating circumstances, they can’t award it after a deadline has passed. Won’t they let her just resit as if she’s failed? In which case her mark will be capped at 50%. She should try talking to a student welfare officer on campus to start with and go from there.

MoreStuffingMatron · 21/10/2021 00:03

If she has appealed to the University and was turned down you have the right to complain to the HE ombudsman
www.oiahe.org.uk/about-us/reviewing-complaints/what-happens-when-a-student-complains-to-us/

Your case won’t succeed unless you have evidence the University materially breached its own procedures or you can present new evidence that wasn’t available to the University for good reason when it took the
contested decision.

Good luck OP

Wildmum54 · 20/10/2021 23:56

Something similar happened with my sister but she was suffering with depression and attempted to take her life a few times - she was able to have the work marked eventually.

Go to your doctor and get DD to say how’s she’s been feeling regarding the situation with her brother- be honest if she has been feeling depressed or anxious. They may be able to give you a note to support a claim for ‘special circumstances’ with the university.
If the work is done and it’s just a matter of she missed a deadline with what’s been going on she should be able to appeal but you need to have something to support that.

If worse comes to worse it’s repeating a year.
Is she first year uni?
The first year doesn’t go towards your final mark but if it’s a second or third year honestly with what you’ve described I’d consider re-taking the year so your DD can start fresh with less stress.

sayitwithcolors · 20/10/2021 23:54

Thanks everyone, for the advice and kindness. Appreciated.

OP posts:
ImUninsultable · 20/10/2021 23:47

She had her deadlines for a long time. She missed them and didnt communicate with her anyone. She didnt even have to email every professor. One email to her advisor would have taken care of it.

If you miss deadlines and don't communicate then its academic suspension.

amusedbush · 20/10/2021 23:44

Students are given their deadlines at the start of each semester, so September and January. The main exam diet is in April/May. The exam board meets in June to discuss the progress of each student. If someone is failing or hasn't communicated, they are given resits in August. The exam board meets again in August and those still failing are put into academic suspension, where they must repeat a year before they can progress.

Your DD would have had a lot of opportunities to submit extenuating circumstances or discuss this with her personal tutor. If she has been asked to repeat, it means she failed to communicate with the university with regard to any of her modules - twice. I don't think you'll get very far with an appeal because it sounds like she will simply have too much to make up.

Where I work a student is permitted to carry over one 20 credit module into the next year but any more than that and they go into suspension.

Stompythedinosaur · 20/10/2021 23:43

She is an adult, and I think she'll have to live with her mistake.

Extenuating circumstances almost always need to be requested before the deadline is missed.

I'm sorry about your ds, but I'm not sure that situation will convince the uni she couldn't have followed the required procedure.