Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD's Uni asked her to repeat a whole year without marking her work because she missed their emails asking her if she was going to meet a certain deadline. DS has been suicidal and is not talking

87 replies

sayitwithcolors · 20/10/2021 23:15

DD's Uni asked her to repeat a whole year without marking her work because she missed their emails asking her if she was going to meet a certain assignment submission deadline. She made a later deadline and they would not mark her work at all. The reason she missed the deadline was because DS has been suicidal and is not talking to her or me.
AIBU to be mad at DD's Uni. We appealed the first time and gave them this reason and they refused. Please could anyone advise on what constitutes a compelling argument to make them change their mind. DD is freaking out and is now very depressed. Help please as I'm at a loss of what to do.

OP posts:
iloveeverykindofcat · 21/10/2021 07:53

@GnomeDePlume Glad she got the support she needs! Sometimes I get a little taste of what GPs must feel right now - bit much to be painted as uncaring when I think about the efforts most of us have gone to over for our students over the past 2 years, usually unpaid and overtime! And OP - would repeating the year be such a bad thing? People do it all the time. Surely she'll get more out of her degree and her university experience this way.

ejhhhhh · 21/10/2021 07:53

I would suspect that this has got to be about more than just a few missed emails. Given the financial implications of a repeat year, I would have thought there are quite strict rules about enforcing a repeat year, and universities can't just insist on it willy nilly (at least I hope not). Extenuating circumstances based on her mental health rather than her brothers may work, however if there's been no engagement at all from her, I can see how it might have come to to point where a repeat of the year is necessary.

lateSeptember1964 · 21/10/2021 07:52

I have been in a similar situation with my son. You can use the appeals process. However the university will decide if the university is unreasonable which doesn’t leave you much options. My son went to two appeals. 8 individuals from the university and between them not one had any additional training in mental health. We asked the question at the start of the panels. Fair to say they had limited insight.

Gazelda · 21/10/2021 07:47

@AliceinBorderland

Sounds as if the whole family is running rings around DS and even DDs life has suffered and no one noticed she was struggling at uni. Nice.
That's an unkind thing to say. Don't you think OP has enough to worry about, and has come here for advice. Your snippy comment served no purpose except to make you feel superior.
TumtumTree · 21/10/2021 07:43

To be honest OP, it sounds like repeating the year is the right outcome for DD. It's clear that (for understandable reasons Flowers ) her mind hasn't really been on her uni work, so she will probably struggle to progress to the next year if she doesn't repeat.

AliceinBorderland · 21/10/2021 07:42

Sounds as if the whole family is running rings around DS and even DDs life has suffered and no one noticed she was struggling at uni. Nice.

oscarcat99 · 21/10/2021 07:41

I won't repeat what others have said other than it's likely this isn't the full story. I work in student wellbeing in a uni dept and have over 1000 students in my remit - as much as I'd love to reach out more, I have my hands full with those who contact me themselves.
There will be a wellbeing dept at her uni - find the email and sit over her while she contacts them, they will be able to give clear advice about her options as well as advice on MH support.

AliceinBorderland · 21/10/2021 07:41

It doesn't sound as if she should be at uni if her brother is so influential on her life. Why is that the case. It isn't her issue to sort and sounds very burdensome for a young adult.

She has missed the deadline for every piece of work set by the sound of it and she has to deal with that.

amazeandastonish · 21/10/2021 07:39

The time to ask for the university's support is before, not after.

Warmduscher · 21/10/2021 07:39

@Disfordarkchocolate

As someone who has ongoing mental health issues. Don't worry about repeating a year, focus on the fact your daughter is suicidal.

She needs to focus on getting well, not appeals.

It’s not the DD who is suicidal, it’s her brother (see OP).
NichyNoo · 21/10/2021 07:38

Sorry for the situation with your DS. But in the kindest possible way, it literally takes 5 minutes to look at an email and reply. I can understand why the uni isn’t happy. I assume she’s been checking her phone and email for other things during this time?

Disfordarkchocolate · 21/10/2021 07:36

As someone who has ongoing mental health issues. Don't worry about repeating a year, focus on the fact your daughter is suicidal.

She needs to focus on getting well, not appeals.

CovidCorvid · 21/10/2021 07:35

Dd was in a similar boat where she had a bit of a nervous break down when covid started, didn’t do anything uni related, including not replying to emails. I didn’t know until June, she’d missed assignment deadlines, not applied for extensions, etc.

She didn’t have to repeat the whole year but did have to drop back a year and do the module she’d missed, so started in March. We had to fight for this a bit and put in evidence about her mental health….that was seen as extenuating circumstances for not communicating with the uni. She did by then have a formal diagnosis of ptsd which probably helped with the uni being sympathetic towards her. Dd got help and support from the student well being centre, they helped her respond to emails, deal with tutors, etc.

CandidaAlbicans2 · 21/10/2021 07:31

As others have said, I suspect there's more to this than your DD has said. When I was at uni a couple of years ago it was made clear what support there was (and there was a lot!), and lecturers bent over backwards to help when needed. We even had mandatory 1-2-1 tutorials to prevent things like stress-related disengagement, and a clear mitigating circumstances procedure (which I actually had to use due to bereavements).

Bear in mind that the uni will be so used to students messing up because they couldn't be arsed, then panicking and claiming XYZ, that they have to have clear rules and boundaries, and proof of the cause of difficulties should you go down the mit cirs route.

Realistically I can't see how she could "miss" deadlines and multiple uni emails unless she wasn't engaging, and the bottom line is, if she didn't engage with the uni then this is the consequence. Regardless of the reasons, it's not the uni's fault unless they broke their own guidelines. Consider it a useful life lesson. If it's any consolation, I messed up my first attempt at uni but went back and ended up with a 2:1 in a hard science. Even if she has to stay an extra year, it really isn't the end of the world, even if it feels that way at the moment.

I hope she get's things sorted and that your DS gets well Flowers

GnomeDePlume · 21/10/2021 07:20

I don't think the way universities treat students is appalling at all.

We drummed into our DC that they have to be proactive if they need support. Uni isn't school, if a student disappears off the radar the uni won't come looking for them.

DD2 is about to restart her 3rd year with the full support of the uni. She is getting the support because she sought it and they were more than happy to give it.

@iloveeverykindofcat I totally agree. Also DD2 is very grateful for the support she has had from her uni. Her course leader knows the full reason for DD2's need for support and has been discretion personified in making sure that DD can have the support she needs without everyone getting to know the details.

Motnight · 21/10/2021 07:19

Sounds like an awful time for you all, Op.

My dd went through something similar and I have the following thoughts for you. One - she didn't tell me the whole story. Turns out that her one missing of an email was in fact a whole series of emails with really important information that she willfully ignored. Two - she appealed against the decision. She was successful but it took months to go through the University process. She ended up having to take a year out from university whilst this happened.

For my dd, although it was awful at the time, it taught her that she can't simply assume that she can just break or ignore the rules with no consequence. She got loads of support from the student union, had to provide medical evidence (which she did have as part of her appeal was around her health and she had had an operation and then a hospital readmission). Go online and look at the appeals process for your dd's University and help her through it.

Good luck.

Simonjt · 21/10/2021 07:17

Universities are not mind readers, your daughter chose not to contact the university regarding her situation.

Also work is handed in online (unless a physical item is produced), so if she had an extended deadline (which she also missed), this means she asked for the deadline to be extended.

Her deadlines will not only be emailed to her, they will also be available on the portal where she was handing in her work, if she for some reason couldn’t find any of those why didn’t she ask rather than handing things in at random times, or asking her course mates?

The new university year has now started, so what has she been doing for the last two weeks?

I became very unwell in my first year of university, I kept my tutor in the loop and I was able to ‘step off’ for six months before returning (module flexibility meant I just sat my exams in August rather than May). If I had decided not to hand in work of course I would be expected to resit the year.

theremustonlybeone · 21/10/2021 07:11

i dont think that argument is going to wash I am afraid. If your DD was suicidal i would have thought her flat mates would have been contacting the university direct and raising concerns or you as a worried parent would have been doing so. They have support in place for this.

I doubt she was sat in her whilst not talking to you. If she was like my son who claimed low mood, stopped talking to me as i stopped giving him extra money, he was out getting hammered with mates. He had to resit a year because he missed deadlines, ignored emails and sat the wrong resit. Lesson learned I am afraid.

WaltzingBetty · 21/10/2021 07:07

Universities can only apply extenuating circumstances if they are aware of those circumstances.

Your DD would be aware of the assignment deadline from timetabling/course handbook

It sounds like she hasn't communicated with them or asked for special circumstances to be applied, missed the deadline then ignored the emails to her - is that right?

As it's now October, when did this happen? They can't be expecting her to repeat a year in October - so are you talking about last year? In which case she should have started the repeat already?

If it was last year and she's only just starting to address the issues now there will be nothing they can do. The academic cycle has entirely restarted

iloveeverykindofcat · 21/10/2021 06:52

I think the way universities treat students is appalling.

I find that really hurtful. Most university staff are not upper management and have no say over general policies. The vast majority of us lecturers, researchers and supervisors have been work incredibly hard to support our students, far over and above our contracted hours. What we can't do is award degrees or marks that students have not earned, whether the student has been too sick to do the work, been in a personal crisis, or simply hasn't bothered.

TillyTopper · 21/10/2021 06:50

Whilst Unis can be very understanding and flexible you really need to engage with them and keep them informed - that is key. If your DD hasn't engaged, hasn't kept an eye on emails then things won't go well. I appreciate you have both been very stressed but she must talk to them first and foremost.

TheUndeadLovelinessOfDemons · 21/10/2021 06:45

My XH had to drop out of uni because he was a victim of DA. Nobody listened. I think the way universities treat students is appalling.

diamondpony80 · 21/10/2021 06:38

I don't think there's any excuse for missing emails. Doesn't everyone have a phone with email and notifications on them these days?

As someone who was liable to bury their head in the sand when I was stressed or depressed I can understand how this happened though. I hope you manage to get it sorted and that your son is okay.

SarahBellam · 21/10/2021 06:17

I’m not sure you have the whole story. Nowadays work is usually uploaded to the online system (e.g. Moodle) by a deadline. If you haven’t handed in by then the link disappears from the module page so you can’t hand it in. We mark everything that has been submitted.

Are you sure your DD handed in work? Students need to have passed 120 credits at each level to progress to the next year (though they can proceed with fewer and do the resits). However, they do need a minimum number of credits to proceed and it sounds like your DD has not achieved that. If she hasn’t achieved that it would not be in her best interests to proceed as she almost certainly would be unable to handle the higher level work.

Her university will not talk to you as she is an adult so she needs to talk to them herself. Does she have evidence of work being completed by the deadline? Has she applied for Extenuating Circumstances (her Uni will have a Student Hub/Services/One Stop Shop where she will be able to seek advice and support) or spoken to her course tutor? She will also have known of this outcome for months. Progression boards, even for resits, are done and dusted by early September.

GCAcademic · 21/10/2021 05:57

Either the OP is being deliberately vague or she is not getting the full story here. Given that it is now October, I suspect the DD has missed the cut-off for either submitting the work or mitigating circumstances evidence in time for the exam board. Once past this date, marking the work is not an option. Normally, departments bend over backwards to get students through the exam board and will mark work at the eleventh hour.