Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD's Uni asked her to repeat a whole year without marking her work because she missed their emails asking her if she was going to meet a certain deadline. DS has been suicidal and is not talking

87 replies

sayitwithcolors · 20/10/2021 23:15

DD's Uni asked her to repeat a whole year without marking her work because she missed their emails asking her if she was going to meet a certain assignment submission deadline. She made a later deadline and they would not mark her work at all. The reason she missed the deadline was because DS has been suicidal and is not talking to her or me.
AIBU to be mad at DD's Uni. We appealed the first time and gave them this reason and they refused. Please could anyone advise on what constitutes a compelling argument to make them change their mind. DD is freaking out and is now very depressed. Help please as I'm at a loss of what to do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
me4real · 22/10/2021 21:52

@sayitwithcolors Get medical evidence, it'll make a real difference. She could see a doctor and explain the circumstances- even if she sees them now about past events it'll be helpful to her appeal. It'd probably do her good to discuss things with a doctor, anyway.

But if this is about this academic year (you still haven't really said) a break will probably do her good, and she would do better if she retook it.

me4real · 22/10/2021 21:47

So sorry to hear that @CSIblonde Sad Well done for complaining.
God willing, most of them are better than that, especially now. Mine were pretty decent with me and that was in about 2000.

CSIblonde · 22/10/2021 21:05

The two deadlines thing , as in she made the 2nd deadline is confusing. Are you sure you're getting the full story? Was it an extension, in which case it should be marked. If it wasn't I think yes, appeal, but she needs to communicate her circumstances effectively , not do a head in the sand tactic. I have to say, age 19, I asked for an extension when my Dad had been given 3 months terminal brain tumour diagnosis. The tutor was so rude & reluctant ("well my aunt lasted 10 years with cancer, how long is this going on for?")that I complained..

me4real · 22/10/2021 20:11

Best wishes to you all @sayitwithcolors Flowers

I don't know if this is relevant to you but student loans will automatically cover one extra year, in case someone has to repeat.

sayitwithcolors · 21/10/2021 21:05

Thanks everyone, DD is telling the truth. She has just handed in her appeal. Hope she succeeds, if no,t I will encourage her to repeat the year.

OP posts:
sayitwithcolors · 21/10/2021 21:02

@Me4real, very sorry about the miscarriage. Thanks for the advice.

OP posts:
burninglikefire · 21/10/2021 09:57

I work in a university and suggest that your DD should contact the Student Union. They will have people working for them who understand the regulations for her university. They will be able to recognise if your DD has grounds for an academic appeal and to work out if she has exhausted the appeals process within her university.

However, if she has not been able to progress to the next level of study by this stage of the academic year (approx 4 weeks in for my institution), then it really does seem inevitable that she will be delayed by a year.

It sounds as if there was one piece of work that your DD failed to submit? If this is the case then she should be able to look for paid employment and submit the assignment in a few months time. She does need to be absolutely certain about what she is required to do and the deadline. Discussing the situation with one of her personal tutor, lecturer or Director of Studies and then sending an email to get confirmation of what was said would be an excellent idea.

Wishing you all the best.

FatBettyintheCoop · 21/10/2021 09:36

It’s a shock but you need to take a step back and both of you carefully consider what your DD has been advised.

I think the University are bending over backwards to do her a favour here. Presumably, what she has managed to submit probably isn’t of a high quality and she knows she could produce better work?

It sounds like a sensible plan for her to stay home with support from you to re-take the year. She’ll be able to focus on her studies and submit new assignments, and they’ll be marked as if they’re a first attempt.

Normally, if a student repeats parts of the course, the repeat units are capped at 40% and added together, that could leave her with a Pass degree or a Third class Honours.

By totally disregarding this years work, the Uni is effectively allowing all her repeat assigments to be classed as a first attempt and therefore, not capped at 40%.

Another student on my course had a bereavement close to the end of the final year exams and was allowed to re-sit the year as a first attempt and she ended up with a First.

If you force them to mark her current work then the course rules wont allow them to ignore those marks. External examiners from other Universities will attend her exam boards to ensure that the rules are properly adhered to.

Motnight · 21/10/2021 09:34

Op just to add that if your dd has to repeat the year as others have said it really isn't too bad.

My dd ended up not repeating the year but having to take a year out and sit additional exams and left uni with a 2:1 which is perfectly respectable.

It probably seems awful to you both at the moment but in a few years it really won't matter.

ErickBroch · 21/10/2021 09:04

Thinking of you OP, an awful time. I know a handful of people who had family trauma's in their first year and were advised to resit and carry on. They did, and they graduated with good grades and have done the same as everyone else! Their is no shame, and it is much more common than you'd expect.

My best friend lost her mum in her first year, she ended up applying to a much better Uni, being accepted, and restarting there the following year.

mumwon · 21/10/2021 09:00

Op by offering her an extra year the uni is trying to help her because otherwise she would fail
let her read some of the positive reassurance from people who have gone through the same thing & gone onto to succeed
My thoughts are with you & I hope you hear some good news re your son soon
& ignore the critical pp who is an ignorant idiot

ArcticLemming · 21/10/2021 08:52

Assuming this work is for this academic year (and not an extension from last year) it seems a bit strange that they have already said she needs to repeat as she will presumably not have been required to submit many assignments yet. I obviously can't speak for all Unis but normally there would be a chance to apply for special considerations before the exam board at the end of the semester, which may give her the option of doing the assignment in the supplementary period (usually August /early Sept) if she has submitted enough other assignments. I think you need to read the university regulations carefully with her, and she needs to seek support from her personal academic tutor (or the senior tutor) plus any other support agencies the university offers her students - which, again in my experience and those of friends working at other Unis are many and of good quality. I would also she collects some sort of evidence of her mental distress - counselling sessions etc.
In my experience universities are extremely supportive to students these days and will bend over backwards to support students going through a tough time but they do need to engage otherwise there is very little we can do.

itsraininghere · 21/10/2021 08:46

Sorry, that was long!

itsraininghere · 21/10/2021 08:45

I'm sorry things have been so tough for you and your family, OP.

I would suggest supporting your DD to see the repeat year as an opportunity to do her best work, in a better place than she obviously was last year.

It does actually sound like they've accepted her circumstances were difficult and therefore allowed the repeat year - my department does not allow repeat years and would require her to leave if she hasn't met the requirements to progress (unless there are mitigating circumstances).

As pp have said, we can't mark work that's handed in very late as it's unfair to everyone else, particularly when feedback has already been given out so there is a chance that this could be incorporated into late submission.

We also can't allow students to progress to the next year when they haven't met the required learning outcomes, as they are not academically prepared for that next year. This is true even when mitigating circumstances are advised early and everyone is aware, we don't just wave people through to the next year without evidence that they're ready for it. It would be unfair to the student themselves to do this, as one bad year could then destroy their chances of a good degree classification.

Your DD does need to engage with the university throughout, there will have been many deadline reminders and emails from lecturers or tutors that have been ignored for it to get to this point.

The university process will require evidence of your DD difficulties - from her GP, counsellor or similar, rather than just emphasising the information about your DS - while these may be the cause of the problems it's difficult for the university to decide how to mitigate without evidence of the effect it's all having on your DD.

Busybee5000 · 21/10/2021 08:32

So her to speak with the equivalent of the student advice centre at her uni. She can speak to an advisor who can help her get to the bottom of it. No point sitting around worrying and being miserable, take some action and do what needs doing, Even if it doesn’t go the way you want, it will feel slightly better knowing the clear path ahead. Also are you clear you have the whole and correct story. One assignment missed doesn’t usually equate to a repeat of the whole year, there are usually resit opportunities.

Nayday · 21/10/2021 08:20

You won't necessarily get quality advice re mental health on mumsnet OP. If you're on Facebook take a look at the "Parenting Mental Health" group. There's good support and signposting on there.

theremustonlybeone · 21/10/2021 08:15

Hadjab Grin

to be fair I mis read the OP too and thought it was her DD who was suicidal...need more coffee

AutumnLeafy · 21/10/2021 08:15

It might be best for her to repeat the year to be honest, now she's had a bit of time to adjust to the situation with her brother?

tigerinyourtank · 21/10/2021 08:12

I understand your concern but she is an adult and this is between her and the university. She needs to take responsibility for her own issues not get her Mum to try and fix them.

theremustonlybeone · 21/10/2021 08:12

I have just realised it isnt your DD that is suicidal, who is the DS? Is it your DS and her brother? I am confused as your suggesting appealing on the basis of someone else in the family not talking to them and being suicidal.

My DS tried to use his fathers terminal diagnosis as an excuse for missing work etc and they refused as he hadnt bothered to engage with them at any point, was hardly going to lectures and wasnt new behaviour. So i think your DD is going to have to accept she is repeating.

Hadjab · 21/10/2021 08:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

AutumnLeafy · 21/10/2021 08:07

She made a later deadline and they would not mark her work at all was this for the same assignment? Or a different one and they didn't mark it because she missed submitting the first one.

Had she explained the situation to anyone and asked for an extension?

AliceinBorderland · 21/10/2021 08:02

That's an unkind thing to say. Don't you think OP has enough to worry about, and has come here for advice. Your snippy comment served no purpose except to make you feel superior.

Lol. My sister had an eating disorder, sectioned etc when I was a teen.

I was sick and tired of my mother calling me at my university hall to discuss. If my mother, a grown adult with almost 2 decades of parenting experience under her belt, couldn't handle it , how could I an 18 year old??

It's appalling how a young woman has been left to it and her life has suffered because of her parents other child.

That was the purpose of my comment no superiority about it.

SarahBellam · 21/10/2021 07:59

@TheUndeadLovelinessOfDemons

My XH had to drop out of uni because he was a victim of DA. Nobody listened. I think the way universities treat students is appalling.
Universities bend over backwards to help students - they really do. The last they they want is for students to drop out - it impacts on them in lots of negative ways. There are whole departments focused on helping students get the very best outcome. It is quite difficult to slip through the safety net unless you just don’t engage at all. I am very sorry for your DH and I hope he has recovered well.
KingsleyShacklebolt · 21/10/2021 07:56

@TillyTopper

Whilst Unis can be very understanding and flexible you really need to engage with them and keep them informed - that is key. If your DD hasn't engaged, hasn't kept an eye on emails then things won't go well. I appreciate you have both been very stressed but she must talk to them first and foremost.
This is so true. Things have changed dramatically in Higher Education over the last 20 or 30 years since I did an undergrad degree. It's all online for submissions, students are more like "customers" and universities are way more flexible with making arrangements for students who have additional needs or needs support with some circumstances.

BUT the student has to let the Uni know. They can't just ignore emails and not tell tutors and staff what's going on.