Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say mash is overrated?

108 replies

AintNobodyHereButUsChickens · 20/10/2021 22:39

I'm just not keen on mashed potatoes! DH doesn't like flavour and just likes it mashed into oblivion with a dollop of his fake butter spread, or cheese (depending on the meal, we generally just have cheesy mash with sausages and beans).

The best mash I've ever had was the garlic one at Toby Carvery, it was SO good but sadly I've still not managed to recreate it at home. Recently I've started cooking new potatoes just for myself when everyone else is having mash. They're so much nicer and I can actually chew them, unlike mash...

However, whenever I see a post about roast dinners on Facebook, a LOT of people say that mash is the best part of a roast dinner. How?!

AIBU to say mash is overrated?

OP posts:
puddlebubble · 21/10/2021 01:02

Mash dislike can be a texture issue too though. So use rooster potatoes, boil them up, add real butter (christ fake butter is not going to help) salt pepper and forgo the milk. Crush them rather than mash to a creamy pulp that a baby could eat. Leave them a little rough, you may like it better that way. In restaurants, sometimes for some unknown reason, creme fraiche or sour cream is added and it actually makes spuds taste like an old sock.

Monkeytennis97 · 21/10/2021 00:29

Roast potatoes with roast dinner though not mash.

RRts · 21/10/2021 00:28

Oh it's you...never mind.

Monkeytennis97 · 21/10/2021 00:28

Love mash.

Weirdly DH had lots of mash growing up- doesn't really like it.

I had lots of pasta and rice growing up. Not big fan of either but crave lovely mash made with butter and whole milk- yum!

Itsnotover · 21/10/2021 00:22

My mums mash is amazing.

I'll never forget the Boxing Day that my ex decided to make Smash. What fresh hell was that?? I can honestly say I'd never eaten it before and never will again !

ImFree2doasiwant · 21/10/2021 00:21

I like mashed potato but it has no place on a roast dinner. Heathens.

Scarby9 · 21/10/2021 00:17

Michelin star mash.
Equal quantities of potato and butter.
noseychef.com/2017/10/09/michelin-star-mash/

UmbilicusProfundus · 21/10/2021 00:16

I was being a bit tongue in cheek @Legitimatesalvage…

I also do both, and rely on my mandolin for my dauphinoise slices. However I usually can’t be arsed - even if it is quickish in reality, it seems to take forever.

HalfCakeHalfBiscuit · 21/10/2021 00:14

Mash done properly is great. Equal quantities by weight of butter and potatoes. Food of the gods

Pieceofpurplesky · 21/10/2021 00:12

Riced not mashed, butter, salt, pepper and a sprinkle of freshly grated nutmeg ... perfection

doyouwantachuffedybadge · 20/10/2021 23:49

the only thing better than mash, is mash topped with pot noodle

hangrylady · 20/10/2021 23:44

YANBU. Worst potato going

Legitimatesalvage · 20/10/2021 23:42

@UmbilicusProfundus

To make roast potatoe you peel and cut up potatoes, par boiled them, chuck them in the oven.
To make parmentier potatoes, you peel and cut up potatoes a little bit smaller, bar boil then chuck them in the oven.
Not really sure what part of that is something to boast about?

Dauphinoise. Peel and slice potatoes, put in a pot with cream and some garlic, bring to boil then shove it all in the oven.

Neither of them take more than 10 minutes of any actual work.

Wanky names, which I didnt choose. Very, very simple recipes with a couple of stages which takes 10 minutes of work.

Megan2018 · 20/10/2021 23:41

I’m indifferent about mash. I don’t mind a decent one with loads of butter occasionally. I like it most on fish pie.
I have never had mash on a roast, just not the done thing in my family (or DH’s).
I do like leftover mash fried up though. Yum.

larkstar · 20/10/2021 23:40

Get the right sort of potatoes for mashing - I've grown my own on my allotment and originally I wasn't going to bother with potatoes but it surprised me just how much better tasting own grown potatoes are and how different the many varieties are in terms of their suitability for either boiling, baking or mashing. I found the Kestrel potatoes really excellent for mash - although you'll usually look up and see other varieties mentioned - Maris Piper, Desiree (red) and Marabel - which are often in the shops - Vivalidi I've never grown or had. If your paying 2p/kg for cheap spuds and they are the wrong sort - guess what - they taste rubbish when mashed.

SickAndTiredAgain · 20/10/2021 23:37

I’m not sure if this is some kind of stealth boast. Who the fuck could be bothered making parmentiers or daphinoise all the time, or do you just pick something ready made from Tesco? Anyway I wouldn’t pander to such posh pickiness.

I agree about the pickiness but I’m not sure parmentiers would qualify as a stealth boast. It’s a fancy sounding name but they’re pretty simple.

amusedbush · 20/10/2021 23:35

I detest mashed potato. It feels like someone has already eaten it. No matter how it's prepared, I feel sick and just can't choke it down.

I will caveat this by pointing out that I'm autistic and I'm really weird about textures. I also hate mince, scrambled eggs, mushy peas (bleughhh), anything with beans or lentils in it, anything mashed up or paste-like.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 20/10/2021 23:34

Garlic mash is pretty easy. Toss some garlic cloves in the water while you boil the spuds and mash them in. If you don’t want to do that add garlic powder when mixing in the cream.

My favorite are Brie mashed potatoes. I use less cream and add Brie while mixing.

Plain mashed potatoes are pretty boring but I do like them on occasion.

The other thing is to leave the skin on and not to fully blend, best of all worlds if you ask me.

CheapFoodShits · 20/10/2021 23:31

Can't stand mash. Almost as much as I can't stand every bugger who says "Oh, but you haven't tried MY mash!"

Mummylovesmonkeys · 20/10/2021 23:29

I must be a badger, because 'Everybody knows badgers love mashed potatoes: bodger and badger, bodger and badger'

I LOVE mashed potatoes!

ducksalive · 20/10/2021 23:29

DH and I aren't fussed about mash, which is actually quite a lot of work to make properly.
Dc love it.
I secretly buy packets of dried mash for them, I live in the USA currently and there are a lot of choices in the dried mash aisle.
It is terrible mothering but everyone is happy.

RealHousewifeOfEastLondon · 20/10/2021 23:27

Mash is lovely. But it does not belong with a roast dinner.

LoveFall · 20/10/2021 23:24

I grew up in a mash-loving family. My Father was definitely a mash guy.

But since I met DH it has been roast all the way, except with shepherd's pie and sausages and mash. I confess I miss the mash at Thanksgiving and Christmas.

I'm guessing my Dad's side of my family, mostly of Scottish and English descent, were mash eaters.

DH, born and raised in London, makes awesome roast potatoes.

BurbageBrook · 20/10/2021 23:24

Garlic mash is easy. Chuck a whole garlic bulb in the oven, roast it, then squeeze out the garlic from the cloves into your potatoes. Mash together with salt and lots of butter et voila.

But, yes, YABU. Mash is awesome.

WellJuhnelle · 20/10/2021 23:23

I went for dinner at Galvin at Windows once and had a side of mash. Turns out Michelin star mash is probably about 80% butter to 20% potato but it was one of the nicest things I have ever eaten in my life.

I try to recreate it at home but can’t bring myself to put that much butter in.

Anyway OP, YABU mash (when made properly with real butter and full fat milk) is delicious.