Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say mash is overrated?

108 replies

AintNobodyHereButUsChickens · 20/10/2021 22:39

I'm just not keen on mashed potatoes! DH doesn't like flavour and just likes it mashed into oblivion with a dollop of his fake butter spread, or cheese (depending on the meal, we generally just have cheesy mash with sausages and beans).

The best mash I've ever had was the garlic one at Toby Carvery, it was SO good but sadly I've still not managed to recreate it at home. Recently I've started cooking new potatoes just for myself when everyone else is having mash. They're so much nicer and I can actually chew them, unlike mash...

However, whenever I see a post about roast dinners on Facebook, a LOT of people say that mash is the best part of a roast dinner. How?!

AIBU to say mash is overrated?

OP posts:
Snowballs1 · 21/10/2021 07:28

I don't like it either, it's the texture rather than taste, for me it's not even worth the effort of peeling the potatoes. I often eat jacket potatoes, no peeling to do, & eat the skin, which is healthier than discarding it!
It spoils fish pie as well, bland topping & soggy underneath, yuck, & makes shepherds pie & cottage pie bland, so not keen on them either.

WhatIsThisPlease · 21/10/2021 07:27

YANBU. Mash makes me gag.

You are being a bit unreasonable for putting it on a roast dinner though Grin

OtterAndDog · 21/10/2021 07:25

Mash is the best food on earth, yabu

Coulddowithanap · 21/10/2021 07:19

I love mash with real butter, splash of milk and seasoning. Not sure it has a place in a roast dinner though (but would give it a go!)

MushMonster · 21/10/2021 07:13

One vote for delicious mash!

I cannot believe there are so many people who do not like it.

RampantIvy · 21/10/2021 07:06

@Pedalpushers

Mash in a roast dinner? Madness. Roast potatoes surely?

Mash is nice as comfort food, with sausages and gravy.

IMO roast potatoes are over rated. I prefer mash (ducks and hides)
DappledThings · 21/10/2021 07:03

Mash is great in the right context. With sausages or in top of a fish or cottage pie. It has no place in a roast dinner.

PenguinWings · 21/10/2021 06:57

Mash is nice.
The people who disagree are probably all serial killers. Or not using butter

GiltEdges · 21/10/2021 06:54

Mash (and mushy food in general) is the work of the devil. Full stop. 🤢

TroysMammy · 21/10/2021 06:40

When my DP makes mashed potatoes it's like eating clouds.

ThisIsTheEndMyFriend · 21/10/2021 06:39

It’s not normal to eat mash when new potatoes are in season.
I suppose I regard mash as a regrettable necessity once plain boiled potatoes become dry and unappetising.
Apart from butter, milk and seasoning the trick is to really beat hell out of them. They go well with stew, but not a roast.

Rubyupbeat · 21/10/2021 06:19

Mash is divine, my last meal on the green mile, and has to be obliterated with my most favourite and trusty kitchen gadget, a masha, smoothest lump free mash ever!

To say mash is overrated?
MerryMarigold · 21/10/2021 04:57

I don't think I've ever had mash with roast. But mash with sausages and gravy is the best. Or beef stew. Any stew. I make it as above with kids if butter, salt and pepper and full fat milk. I also hate fake mash, it's like playdough.

I can't stand boiled potatoes unless they are new pots as they are so tasteless and would rather have mash or jackets or roast.

Cocogreen · 21/10/2021 04:44

I didn't like it until I started making it with cream instead of milk, and more butter.

torquewench · 21/10/2021 04:07

I only ever have frozen mash. Sorry not sorry. Don't have the time or inclination to peel, boil, mash when the ready made stuff tastes nicer, and I prefer the texture. Anyone suggesting otherwise is wrong 😉

SirenSays · 21/10/2021 04:04

I have a very scientific test for mash. During the seasoning process, if you taste it and mindlessly keep eating, it's done. If you can put the fork down, it's bad mash and needs more love.

ThirdElephant · 21/10/2021 04:01

I love mashed potato. It's the best way to eat potato.

Unfortunately, my DC and DH do not agree and I don't much see the point of making a separate thing for just me, so I rarely have it.

HappyDays40 · 21/10/2021 03:50

Im goung to have to disagree OP. I feel all triggered now. How can you say these things😉

FiveGs · 21/10/2021 03:07

I can only have a little bit as it massively bloats me for some reason.

Shame as I love it

WeasilyPleased · 21/10/2021 02:32

You're not making it properly if you hate it or it's claggy! Mustard mash is a firm favourite in this house.

Oh4Tunas · 21/10/2021 02:30

It needs either good gravy or plenty of flavourful food (meat, especially) to go with each mouthful.

DinosaurDuvet · 21/10/2021 01:48

Kerry pinks are so lovely, floury & dry they melt in your mouth, only a pinch of salt needed. None of the milk / butter / cream craic

Yellownotblue · 21/10/2021 01:42

I feel sad for all the mash haters.

Really good mash is a lot of work (not to mention calories), so I only do it a few times a year (mostly Christmas). Riced potatoes, loads of butter and salt, pepper, milk, spring onions, lardons and masses of Parmesan (or emmental in dire straits). It is divine.

The rest of the year I buy ready made mash for cottage pies.

Snugglybuggly · 21/10/2021 01:14

YANBU I hate mash!

PigletJohn · 21/10/2021 01:11

I'm very fond of mash. Usually make it with red potatoes and a little warmed milk and white pepper. And mash it three times as long as most people consider necessary.

Can't get on with a ricer.

Depending on the potato, it may benefit from being steamed longer to dry out, and butter instead of milk (usually try to minimise fats).