Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want to work?!

343 replies

Anonymouseperson · 20/10/2021 21:33

I’m a mum of two (aged 3 and 5). I worked part time freelance from when my kids were 6 months old. I’ve recently started a new job (35 hours a week) because I thought I should try and get my career back on track and wanted to take the financial pressure off my husband.

I used to be very career driven. I loved my job. I was proud of it. Now, I just don’t give a monkeys. I work so much, my house is a mess and I don’t get to do as much with the kids in the week as I’d like.

This is going to sound really horrible, which is why I’m posting anonymously, but sometimes I just wish I’d married someone richer who would just look after me and the kids without question. Someone who wouldn’t expect me to work, but also if I didn’t work wouldn’t quibble over what I was spending.

Part of my reason for wanting to earn more was my husband’s attitude to money. I am not a spendthrift. I don’t shop really, or do beauty treatments or anything. I bought a £12 lamp once for the front room from wilko and he went ballistic on the front step in front of all the neighbours when he saw the shopping bag, saying I should “make some f-ing money before you go spunking it away all the time!” (He later apologised for that).

My point is, I work because I can’t stand him getting all stressy with me about money, not because I want to.

AIBU: Is it anti feminist to just want to raise my kids and be looked after?!

I feel guilty even writing this because it’s not who I used to be. I was Ms Ambitious - but I’m not anymore. Also I know a lot of people have it worse and I don’t want to be ungrateful. I’m sorry if it comes over that way.

Maybe I’m just a bit depressed?!

OP posts:
EgSk · 21/10/2021 22:11

I don’t think you are being unreasonable in the slightest and I know how you feel. Right now I’m a SAHM and I hate not contributing to the family but even more so I hate not having my OWN money that I earned.

Bluntness100 · 21/10/2021 21:50

@Nataliefrances123

I totally get u. Your kids are little and u want to be with them. I gave up work to stay at home to look after them. At times it has been hard but I have loved not working, we have had to make sacrifices but totally worth it being able to be around for tge kids and not have the juggle of work and childcare. Mine are both at school now. I'm doing a course at home and hope to get some part time work soon but I still love being at home doing housework, pottering around the house I will miss it. Can u go part time? Or get some evening work?
Case in point.
Nataliefrances123 · 21/10/2021 21:34

I totally get u. Your kids are little and u want to be with them. I gave up work to stay at home to look after them. At times it has been hard but I have loved not working, we have had to make sacrifices but totally worth it being able to be around for tge kids and not have the juggle of work and childcare. Mine are both at school now. I'm doing a course at home and hope to get some part time work soon but I still love being at home doing housework, pottering around the house I will miss it. Can u go part time? Or get some evening work?

TractorAndHeadphones · 21/10/2021 21:15

@Bluntness100 exactly.
Discrimination against women, the mummy track etc all exist but it doesn't mean that the majority of women's careers end as soon as they give birth. For example - a woman earns 30K, upon going back to work she is promoted less quickly. But how does that automatically equate to her 'giving up work'?
Many, many women who can afford to make it work, but choose to stay home or go 'part-time'.
We have statistics showing that women earn less than men, surveys etc showing that women drop out due to the cost of childcare.
But we don't have any evidence showing that the majority of women who stay home (SN excepted ) are forced to. That they haven't explored every other avenue and concluded that having one parent at home is the only choice.

Many have strong feelings about wanting to raise their own children and that's fine, but own it. Don't pretend that it was a heroic sacrifice.

In many other countries women staying home doesn't even cross anybody's mind..

TractorAndHeadphones · 21/10/2021 21:04

@thelegohooverer

YANBU you’ve got quite a kicking here today. I’m a sahm with a dh who 100% appreciates my contribution to our lives. He certainly doesn’t want to stay home, and happily reaps the benefits of having his life facilitated. We have a ds with sn, so while staying home wasn’t my plan, we’re both thankful that when it came to it, we could do this for him.

Is he keeping me or am I keeping him? Maybe not directly financially, but he has never had to leave early to get to a creche, pick up a sick child from school, rush to a shop before closing. Pre-covid he could agree to fly across Europe to a meeting, or work late to get a tender out, knowing that his responsibilities as the co-creator of his own offspring were taken care of. And that translates into increased earnings. He has a great work life balance because he doesn’t have to help squeeze the running of the home and life admin into his evenings and weekends.

To maintain this lifestyle, if I went to work I’d need to be paying for childcare to manage therapy appointments and afterschool activities, a cleaner, a meal service or a housekeeper of some kind. Our standard of living would drop if I were doing paid work.

He wasn’t always making enough for this to be comfortable (and we’re only comfortable not rich. There’s no lunches and designer handbags here)- we had years in the beginning on a shoestring, not quite scraping by. I think marrying a rich man is a nice daydream, but finding a partner who sees and respects what you do is the key thing. And that works both ways. There have been nights I’ve put the dc to bed, and then pitched in on his business. I taught myself graphic design in order to have a skill he can call on.

The only person who would benefit from me working right now is me- for pension, future earning capabilities and personal satisfaction. We’ve done our best to take care of the first two. This isn’t the life I aspired to. But I work bloody hard, and I really resent the mumsnet attitude that I’m a fanny lodger or a drain on society. I’ve contributed a lot to my local community, and to the school community.

I really don’t see anything wrong in wishing for a partner who would respect the work of child rearing in the early years and want to support you in providing that.

You have a child with SN, your situation is not relevant to the majority of the population. Also mumsnet doesn't think that SAHM's are fanny lodgers - in fact there are lots of snide comments about the 'emotional damage' childcare has on young children, 'I didn't have them to have someone else raise them' etc etc.

There is a lot of concern for women for are SAHM and not married.

Bluntness100 · 21/10/2021 20:38

[quote Owwasme]@LoveGrooveDanceParty

Many (most?) men don’t manage to earn a salary that comfortably supports en entire family either, is the entire point I’m making.

But the majority of those that DO manage to ARE men, because of the reasons pointed out to you.

You're not very good at making points tbh.[/quote]
I think it’s you who is struggling, you’re so far up on your soap box you’re failing to see the obvious.

If women stopped wishing to be stay at home mums, who saw childcare as a joint parental role, a joint cost, and went into having children as equal parents then this shit would die out

Instead we see thread after thread on here with women giving it, “oh but you should stay home and support your family that way if it works for you” “oh your husband only progressed because uou stayed home” And “oh you if child care costs more than you earn,then stay home”, and “oh I don’t wish to outsource my child care I want to stay home and raise my own children” and “oh gosh I don’t want to work, we will just have to live frugally as I love being at home”

So pretending all women have no choice is nonsense, and we all know it. Plenty of women don’t have a choice, but plenty do. And they chose to opt out first chance they get.

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 21/10/2021 18:11

[quote Owwasme]@LoveGrooveDanceParty

Many (most?) men don’t manage to earn a salary that comfortably supports en entire family either, is the entire point I’m making.

But the majority of those that DO manage to ARE men, because of the reasons pointed out to you.

You're not very good at making points tbh.[/quote]
And the OP can continue to wish all she wants to have, and I quote, ‘married someone richer who would just look after her and the kids without question, who wouldn’t expect her to work, but also wouldn’t quibble over what she spends’ all she likes.

It doesn’t change the fact that clearly neither of them earn enough for either of them to give up work, spend what they want and not ‘quibble’ over it. He doesn’t. She doesn’t.

Again - I maintain - any man coming on here and saying this would have his arse handed to him on a plate. And he’d well and truly deserve it. But for some reason people are tip-toeing around the OP telling her she’s being entirely reasonable.

Teaandtoastedbiscuits · 21/10/2021 17:54

Well you are doing 2 separate jobs. The one that takes 35 hours a week and then being a mum to 2 small kids. I am doing the same and I also find it hard and not that fair. I don't care if that makes me sound anti feminist all I know is I am bloody knackered x

DrSbaitso · 21/10/2021 17:10

The problem is less that you can't be a SAHM and more that the two of you argue about money, which is a really toxic thing to argue about.

Most people wish they didn't have to work.

ThirdElephant · 21/10/2021 17:08

@IntermittentParps

Why do women get to be the ones who opt out? Earning a decent wage - enough to comfortably support an entire family - doesn’t just fall out of the sky. No, indeed it doesn't. It comes about because boys are more encouraged to speak up at school; men are paid more than women for doing the same work; women lose out because parental leave is still heavily weighted for women to take and men not to; and women also lose out on career progression because they have to drop their hours when returning, because of the above parental leave issue and the prohibitive costs of childcare. That's if they don't get made redundant or otherwise squeezed out of their job while on maternity leave, as has happened to more women I know than I can face counting.

And women wonder why men don’t respect us.
I would have a think about how much you respect other women, TBH.

This, in spades.
Owwasme · 21/10/2021 17:01

@LoveGrooveDanceParty

Many (most?) men don’t manage to earn a salary that comfortably supports en entire family either, is the entire point I’m making.

But the majority of those that DO manage to ARE men, because of the reasons pointed out to you.

You're not very good at making points tbh.

Jillydix · 21/10/2021 16:59

@thelegohooverer

YANBU you’ve got quite a kicking here today. I’m a sahm with a dh who 100% appreciates my contribution to our lives. He certainly doesn’t want to stay home, and happily reaps the benefits of having his life facilitated. We have a ds with sn, so while staying home wasn’t my plan, we’re both thankful that when it came to it, we could do this for him.

Is he keeping me or am I keeping him? Maybe not directly financially, but he has never had to leave early to get to a creche, pick up a sick child from school, rush to a shop before closing. Pre-covid he could agree to fly across Europe to a meeting, or work late to get a tender out, knowing that his responsibilities as the co-creator of his own offspring were taken care of. And that translates into increased earnings. He has a great work life balance because he doesn’t have to help squeeze the running of the home and life admin into his evenings and weekends.

To maintain this lifestyle, if I went to work I’d need to be paying for childcare to manage therapy appointments and afterschool activities, a cleaner, a meal service or a housekeeper of some kind. Our standard of living would drop if I were doing paid work.

He wasn’t always making enough for this to be comfortable (and we’re only comfortable not rich. There’s no lunches and designer handbags here)- we had years in the beginning on a shoestring, not quite scraping by. I think marrying a rich man is a nice daydream, but finding a partner who sees and respects what you do is the key thing. And that works both ways. There have been nights I’ve put the dc to bed, and then pitched in on his business. I taught myself graphic design in order to have a skill he can call on.

The only person who would benefit from me working right now is me- for pension, future earning capabilities and personal satisfaction. We’ve done our best to take care of the first two. This isn’t the life I aspired to. But I work bloody hard, and I really resent the mumsnet attitude that I’m a fanny lodger or a drain on society. I’ve contributed a lot to my local community, and to the school community.

I really don’t see anything wrong in wishing for a partner who would respect the work of child rearing in the early years and want to support you in providing that.

Well said!!
LoveGrooveDanceParty · 21/10/2021 16:53

@IntermittentParps

Why do women get to be the ones who opt out? Earning a decent wage - enough to comfortably support an entire family - doesn’t just fall out of the sky. No, indeed it doesn't. It comes about because boys are more encouraged to speak up at school; men are paid more than women for doing the same work; women lose out because parental leave is still heavily weighted for women to take and men not to; and women also lose out on career progression because they have to drop their hours when returning, because of the above parental leave issue and the prohibitive costs of childcare. That's if they don't get made redundant or otherwise squeezed out of their job while on maternity leave, as has happened to more women I know than I can face counting.

And women wonder why men don’t respect us.
I would have a think about how much you respect other women, TBH.

Many (most?) men don’t manage to earn a salary that comfortably supports en entire family either, is the entire point I’m making.
LoveGrooveDanceParty · 21/10/2021 16:45

I wouldn’t expect anyone - man or woman - to respect me, if I went around saying:

“Sometimes I just wish I’d married someone richer who would just look after me and the kids without question. Someone who wouldn’t expect me to work, but also if I didn’t work wouldn’t quibble over what I was spending.”

Confused
Owwasme · 21/10/2021 16:35

@IntermittentParps

Why do women get to be the ones who opt out? Earning a decent wage - enough to comfortably support an entire family - doesn’t just fall out of the sky. No, indeed it doesn't. It comes about because boys are more encouraged to speak up at school; men are paid more than women for doing the same work; women lose out because parental leave is still heavily weighted for women to take and men not to; and women also lose out on career progression because they have to drop their hours when returning, because of the above parental leave issue and the prohibitive costs of childcare. That's if they don't get made redundant or otherwise squeezed out of their job while on maternity leave, as has happened to more women I know than I can face counting.

And women wonder why men don’t respect us.
I would have a think about how much you respect other women, TBH.

👏👏👏
Owwasme · 21/10/2021 16:34

@LoveGrooveDanceParty

Why do women get to be the ones who opt out? Earning a decent wage - enough to comfortably support an entire family - doesn’t just fall out of the sky.

And women wonder why men don’t respect us.

Lol. Are you serious? Ever heard of the pay gap? Maternity discrimination? Good old sexism in the work place? Old Boys club?

But yeah, it's women's fault that men don't respect us. 😒

IntermittentParps · 21/10/2021 16:34

Why do women get to be the ones who opt out? Earning a decent wage - enough to comfortably support an entire family - doesn’t just fall out of the sky.
No, indeed it doesn't. It comes about because boys are more encouraged to speak up at school; men are paid more than women for doing the same work; women lose out because parental leave is still heavily weighted for women to take and men not to; and women also lose out on career progression because they have to drop their hours when returning, because of the above parental leave issue and the prohibitive costs of childcare. That's if they don't get made redundant or otherwise squeezed out of their job while on maternity leave, as has happened to more women I know than I can face counting.

And women wonder why men don’t respect us.
I would have a think about how much you respect other women, TBH.

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 21/10/2021 16:28

@Userg1234

I am so surprised at many of the comments here. The op brings up "once' when her DP lost it on her spending. She makes no mention of how much they earn. Or if there was a reason for his outburst...they could well have been in huge debts when she bought a lamp.

Imagine if a man came out and said he doesn't want to work. Oh wait there have been many treads and the man is always slated.

The reality of the 21st century is 99% of couples, both need to work.

Absolutely agree.

This…

sometimes I just wish I’d married someone richer who would just look after me and the kids without question. Someone who wouldn’t expect me to work, but also if I didn’t work wouldn’t quibble over what I was spending.

I mean, yeah, wouldn’t we all?! I’m sure most men would love that, too.

But we’re adults, right? With responsibilities.

Why do women get to be the ones who opt out? Earning a decent wage - enough to comfortably support an entire family - doesn’t just fall out of the sky.

And women wonder why men don’t respect us.

IntermittentParps · 21/10/2021 15:18

@hotmeatymilk

Because I am at home I am expected to provide a good quality lunch for DH, of the sort you would get in a cafe. A cheese sandwich is not acceptable. So I boil some fresh pasta and make a quick tomato sauce. We eat that. Some days I don't feel like making lunch, and that is met with great disappointment. This is very much a your specific DH problem and not a universal SAHM vs WOHM issue. He sounds like a cockend who’d get much less than a cheese sandwich from me, disappointed or not.
Seconded. To invoke the great Bernard Black, he can expect away. And he can be as disappointed as he likes; you don't have to do anything about it. If my DP behaved like that (he never would, because he's not a cunt) he'd get his cheese sandwich served up his arse.
Userg1234 · 21/10/2021 14:56

I am so surprised at many of the comments here. The op brings up "once' when her DP lost it on her spending. She makes no mention of how much they earn. Or if there was a reason for his outburst...they could well have been in huge debts when she bought a lamp.

Imagine if a man came out and said he doesn't want to work. Oh wait there have been many treads and the man is always slated.

The reality of the 21st century is 99% of couples, both need to work.

thelegohooverer · 21/10/2021 14:37

YANBU you’ve got quite a kicking here today. I’m a sahm with a dh who 100% appreciates my contribution to our lives. He certainly doesn’t want to stay home, and happily reaps the benefits of having his life facilitated. We have a ds with sn, so while staying home wasn’t my plan, we’re both thankful that when it came to it, we could do this for him.

Is he keeping me or am I keeping him? Maybe not directly financially, but he has never had to leave early to get to a creche, pick up a sick child from school, rush to a shop before closing. Pre-covid he could agree to fly across Europe to a meeting, or work late to get a tender out, knowing that his responsibilities as the co-creator of his own offspring were taken care of. And that translates into increased earnings. He has a great work life balance because he doesn’t have to help squeeze the running of the home and life admin into his evenings and weekends.

To maintain this lifestyle, if I went to work I’d need to be paying for childcare to manage therapy appointments and afterschool activities, a cleaner, a meal service or a housekeeper of some kind. Our standard of living would drop if I were doing paid work.

He wasn’t always making enough for this to be comfortable (and we’re only comfortable not rich. There’s no lunches and designer handbags here)- we had years in the beginning on a shoestring, not quite scraping by. I think marrying a rich man is a nice daydream, but finding a partner who sees and respects what you do is the key thing. And that works both ways. There have been nights I’ve put the dc to bed, and then pitched in on his business. I taught myself graphic design in order to have a skill he can call on.

The only person who would benefit from me working right now is me- for pension, future earning capabilities and personal satisfaction. We’ve done our best to take care of the first two. This isn’t the life I aspired to. But I work bloody hard, and I really resent the mumsnet attitude that I’m a fanny lodger or a drain on society. I’ve contributed a lot to my local community, and to the school community.

I really don’t see anything wrong in wishing for a partner who would respect the work of child rearing in the early years and want to support you in providing that.

IceandIndigo · 21/10/2021 14:34

YANBU to fantasise about a different life. Lots of people would prefer not to work if they had the choice.

But YABU to think a stay-at-home lifestyle is achievable with your current circumstances and partner. If your DH is kicking off about a £12 lamp I'm guessing he's feeling a certain amount of financial stress. So you have to work. But I think you may need to consider changing jobs to one where you can work part-time, or negotiate a more flexible option with your current employer.

Incidentally I know someone who has achieved your fantasy. Her husband has a very high income job (7 figures). When they met she had a professional job in the same field but gave it up to stay home and raise their DC. I envy her in some ways (beautiful house, expensive holidays, never has to worry about money), but not in others. So much of her identity is locked up in her children and I really wonder what she's going to do when the youngest leaves home.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 21/10/2021 14:06

I am not a spendthrift. I don’t shop really, or do beauty treatments or anything.

I see no reason to disbelieve the OP. She said the above and then described just one discretionary spend, on something for the house not even for herself, resulting in an outburst. Not a series of extravagances leading to an outburst.

BillMasen · 21/10/2021 13:47

[quote PleasantBirthday]@BillMasen, it's possible to have a reasonable point and behave in a totally unreasonable manner in making it.[/quote]
Agree, and snapping isn’t great

I have more sympathy if it’s the result of lots of repeated spending issues compared to a one off though. Women who eventually shout at spendthrift men aren’t called abusive on here though

PleasantBirthday · 21/10/2021 13:41

@BillMasen, it's possible to have a reasonable point and behave in a totally unreasonable manner in making it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread