Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want to work?!

343 replies

Anonymouseperson · 20/10/2021 21:33

I’m a mum of two (aged 3 and 5). I worked part time freelance from when my kids were 6 months old. I’ve recently started a new job (35 hours a week) because I thought I should try and get my career back on track and wanted to take the financial pressure off my husband.

I used to be very career driven. I loved my job. I was proud of it. Now, I just don’t give a monkeys. I work so much, my house is a mess and I don’t get to do as much with the kids in the week as I’d like.

This is going to sound really horrible, which is why I’m posting anonymously, but sometimes I just wish I’d married someone richer who would just look after me and the kids without question. Someone who wouldn’t expect me to work, but also if I didn’t work wouldn’t quibble over what I was spending.

Part of my reason for wanting to earn more was my husband’s attitude to money. I am not a spendthrift. I don’t shop really, or do beauty treatments or anything. I bought a £12 lamp once for the front room from wilko and he went ballistic on the front step in front of all the neighbours when he saw the shopping bag, saying I should “make some f-ing money before you go spunking it away all the time!” (He later apologised for that).

My point is, I work because I can’t stand him getting all stressy with me about money, not because I want to.

AIBU: Is it anti feminist to just want to raise my kids and be looked after?!

I feel guilty even writing this because it’s not who I used to be. I was Ms Ambitious - but I’m not anymore. Also I know a lot of people have it worse and I don’t want to be ungrateful. I’m sorry if it comes over that way.

Maybe I’m just a bit depressed?!

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 23/10/2021 15:55

@MarshmallowSwede

If you’re a woman who thinks the only reason a woman is worthy of a man’s respect is to basically emulate men and work and do everything men do.. you’re a misogynist.

Women have always been the primary caregiver of children and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that. It baffles me this certain mindset of certain “feminists” who look down upon and hold motherhood and home making with such disdain.

There is nothing wrong with being a woman who loves to homemake. There is nothing with not wanting to have a career. If we are going tk say women have choices then we need to also say that it’s perfectly ok for women to opt out of careers and focus on being at home and home making.

There's nothing wrong with wanting to be a homemaker - given that your spouse agrees. And that the choice is open to either sex. By talking about 'women always being the primary caregiver' you're implying that it's a woman's right to stay home with her children and have her spouse support her regardless of what he wants. And with a slight extrapolation it's natural for the woman rather than the man to give up her career which is the very thing feminists are fighting against.

Finally - there are A LOT of things wrong with not wanting to have a career. The main thing being a reliance on someone else. How many posts have we seen on MN with SAHM stuck, reliant on a less than ideal husband?

The days of men handing over their salary to wives to manage (like my grandparents) are gone, but the attitude that women should continue to place themselves at his mercy has stayed.

DrSbaitso · 23/10/2021 14:01

If you’re a woman who thinks the only reason a woman is worthy of a man’s respect is to basically emulate men and work and do everything men do.. you’re a misogynist.

This works only if paid employment is inherently something that men do and somehow not fully compatible with being a woman.

MarshmallowSwede · 23/10/2021 12:18

If you’re a woman who thinks the only reason a woman is worthy of a man’s respect is to basically emulate men and work and do everything men do.. you’re a misogynist.

Women have always been the primary caregiver of children and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that. It baffles me this certain mindset of certain “feminists” who look down upon and hold motherhood and home making with such disdain.

There is nothing wrong with being a woman who loves to homemake. There is nothing with not wanting to have a career. If we are going tk say women have choices then we need to also say that it’s perfectly ok for women to opt out of careers and focus on being at home and home making.

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/10/2021 21:57

@KaycePollard

There’s no adverse impact on the careers of childless women.

Oh yes there is. THat's a daft thing to claim.

Women generally are paid less for the same work as men ... it's to do with social conditioning and a negative reaction to women when they overcome that conditioning and try to negotiate their salaries up.

www.vox.com/2018/2/19/17018380/gender-wage-gap-childcare-penalty
KaycePollard · 22/10/2021 21:45

There’s no adverse impact on the careers of childless women.

Oh yes there is. THat's a daft thing to claim.

Women generally are paid less for the same work as men ... it's to do with social conditioning and a negative reaction to women when they overcome that conditioning and try to negotiate their salaries up.

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/10/2021 14:55

The best run teams I’ve worked with had a mix of part /full timers, excellent handover so people got answers even if part timer wasn’t working. Goodwill between full and part timers as nobody fel thta the others were clock watchers.

In badly run teams the part timers are sidelined, everyone is left to their own devices. Everyone suffers but part-timers bear the brunt.

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/10/2021 14:48

@themuttsnutts

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-58786739 This article outlines the gender pay gap. Pay attention, in particular, to this paragraph:

^The median pay gap is not the same as paying women less than men to do the same work, which is illegal in the UK. But using the median pay measure is helpful in understanding the number of women in companies who hold senior roles.

The BBC's analysis found that by sector, the worst gender pay gaps on average are in education (26%), finance and insurance (24%) and construction (23.8%).

^
So, why do women hold fewer senior roles. Interestingly @TractorAndHeadphones, you say childless women are unaffected, from which I am inferring that it all goes wrong for women once they have children.

Yes. The gender pay gap is the difference in salary between both genders across the board. The equal pay gap is the difference in pay per gender in the same role. Hence the article talks about the median pay and senior roles.

It varies enormously by industry but In mine (tech/finance) many women choose not to come back after maternity leave or go part-time.

In order to get promoted there’s a certain level of flexibility/availability required. Juggling it isn’t easy. The ones who have stayed have supportive spouses, flexible working (e.g leave at 3 for the school run, then log in again at night) and cohesive teams.

While I have seen things like women being sidelined for promotion etc in the last few years it’s not been about gender but the attitude of the manager and team.
Clock watching isn’t necessary in highly skilled jobs - but you need to provide a good service. Well

themuttsnutts · 22/10/2021 13:41

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-58786739 This article outlines the gender pay gap. Pay attention, in particular, to this paragraph:

^The median pay gap is not the same as paying women less than men to do the same work, which is illegal in the UK. But using the median pay measure is helpful in understanding the number of women in companies who hold senior roles.

The BBC's analysis found that by sector, the worst gender pay gaps on average are in education (26%), finance and insurance (24%) and construction (23.8%).

^
So, why do women hold fewer senior roles. Interestingly @TractorAndHeadphones, you say childless women are unaffected, from which I am inferring that it all goes wrong for women once they have children.

HikingforScenery · 22/10/2021 13:36

It’s not fair to want only your husband to bear the financial responsibility.

If it’s any consolation, I felt the same when mine were that age. We agreed for me to be sahp for a bit.

I’ve not got my career drive back now that they’re more independent than they were at 3 and 5. Now they drive me to show them a good balance of ambition and family life.
Good luck OP
Also, I can’t believe you’d husband spoke to you like that! In the street!

DrSbaitso · 22/10/2021 13:32

@themuttsnutts

Do men tend to marry lower paid women because women are generally lower paid? I definitely think this is the case among my peers.

As for age and earning more, yes, there is a point that pay peaks but then it drops off again quite a bit as you get older - certainly over 50, maybe younger. Ageism is also alive and well in our society and, this time, it doesn't discrimminate against women, in particular.

Partly because women are generally lower paid, and partly because, again generally, men don't look for ambition and a good career in a partner the way women do. It just isn't something that tends to matter to them so much when seeking a life partner.
TractorAndHeadphones · 22/10/2021 13:23

@themuttsnutts

Do men tend to marry lower paid women because women are generally lower paid? I definitely think this is the case among my peers.

As for age and earning more, yes, there is a point that pay peaks but then it drops off again quite a bit as you get older - certainly over 50, maybe younger. Ageism is also alive and well in our society and, this time, it doesn't discrimminate against women, in particular.

What do you mean by generally lower paid? Even if one half of a couple earns 30K and the others 40K it’s still not a major gap compared to one earning half the salary of the other.

Professional women start out at equal pay and in fact outperform their male counterparts at the start of their career. The equal pay gap appears mid career. There’s no adverse impact on the careers of childless women.

Two programmers marrying doesn’t count as marrying a ‘lower paid’ partner. . A teacher marrying a nursery worker , definitely. Someone on a generic civil service job? Impossible to say.

It’s not that simple.

themuttsnutts · 22/10/2021 13:02

Do men tend to marry lower paid women because women are generally lower paid? I definitely think this is the case among my peers.

As for age and earning more, yes, there is a point that pay peaks but then it drops off again quite a bit as you get older - certainly over 50, maybe younger. Ageism is also alive and well in our society and, this time, it doesn't discrimminate against women, in particular.

frazzlesmore · 22/10/2021 09:31

I don't have a problem with SAHPs & myself had long maternity leaves, but I hate the narrative that mothers only work if they have to. You often see DH is "addicted to his job" or "would never want to stay at home" or "thrives in the work environment" etc & these are all seen as positives for men but the same isn't true for women. Why not?

I look at my friendship group & a lot of those mothers could not work but chose too. They are detectives, surgeons, GPs, teachers, etc. It's good for society that they stay working & they are good at their jobs & enjoy them despite not being men.

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/10/2021 09:11

@frazzlesmore

Another really obvious point that has only been mentioned once on here is that, in the vast majority of cases, the men earn more than the women and so, for pragmatic reasons, it just doesn't make sense for the man to give up work or reduce his hours. Childcare keeps being cited as a joint cost but, if it costs as much as one person's salary, whether it is shared or not, what is the point?

I thought twenty something women now outearned men & it was taking time off work/becoming a mother that impacted women's earnings?

I do think it's more nuanced then I earn 3k & childcare is 2.5k so what's the point. There is definite benefits to staying in work as opposed to having a gap if that's what someone wants to do. I started a new career after dc1 & childcare was quite a bit more then my salary however now mine are in primary, I'm p/t & can wfh etc & earn pretty well now, so for me it was definitely worth it.

Yes that’s correct - at more junior levels it’s the same. But also because entry level salaries tend to be fixed for graduate schemes and the like
TractorAndHeadphones · 22/10/2021 09:08

@themuttsnutts

There is a lot of bashing against women who are either staying at home with very young children or working part time.

However, a question that hasn't been asked yet is how many men are offering to go part time or stay at home while the woman furthers her career?

And, are these women, incidentally, coming home and asking their husbands 'what they do all day?' If not, why are they all coming on here and asking other women with toddlers 'what they do all day' or suggesting they are 'sponging off their men?' Come on, you know children are hard work. You have all done maternity leave so, really, we all know better so we should be treating one another better.

Another really obvious point that has only been mentioned once on here is that, in the vast majority of cases, the men earn more than the women and so, for pragmatic reasons, it just doesn't make sense for the man to give up work or reduce his hours. Childcare keeps being cited as a joint cost but, if it costs as much as one person's salary, whether it is shared or not, what is the point?

And why do men earn more? Because sexism is alive and kicking in the 21st century workplace and, judging by the attitudes on here, it is particularly prevalent in women vs other women.

No, men don’t earn just because of sexism. It’s because of age (older = more earnings). Also because men tend to marry lower paid women but not the other way round. Finally we don’t know how many are actually at home because childcare. Many don’t want to put their kids in nursery while the dad would be happy to.
frazzlesmore · 22/10/2021 09:03

Another really obvious point that has only been mentioned once on here is that, in the vast majority of cases, the men earn more than the women and so, for pragmatic reasons, it just doesn't make sense for the man to give up work or reduce his hours. Childcare keeps being cited as a joint cost but, if it costs as much as one person's salary, whether it is shared or not, what is the point?

I thought twenty something women now outearned men & it was taking time off work/becoming a mother that impacted women's earnings?

I do think it's more nuanced then I earn 3k & childcare is 2.5k so what's the point. There is definite benefits to staying in work as opposed to having a gap if that's what someone wants to do. I started a new career after dc1 & childcare was quite a bit more then my salary however now mine are in primary, I'm p/t & can wfh etc & earn pretty well now, so for me it was definitely worth it.

IntermittentParps · 22/10/2021 08:45

@themuttsnutts

There is a lot of bashing against women who are either staying at home with very young children or working part time.

However, a question that hasn't been asked yet is how many men are offering to go part time or stay at home while the woman furthers her career?

And, are these women, incidentally, coming home and asking their husbands 'what they do all day?' If not, why are they all coming on here and asking other women with toddlers 'what they do all day' or suggesting they are 'sponging off their men?' Come on, you know children are hard work. You have all done maternity leave so, really, we all know better so we should be treating one another better.

Another really obvious point that has only been mentioned once on here is that, in the vast majority of cases, the men earn more than the women and so, for pragmatic reasons, it just doesn't make sense for the man to give up work or reduce his hours. Childcare keeps being cited as a joint cost but, if it costs as much as one person's salary, whether it is shared or not, what is the point?

And why do men earn more? Because sexism is alive and kicking in the 21st century workplace and, judging by the attitudes on here, it is particularly prevalent in women vs other women.

Quite.
Neonplant · 22/10/2021 01:52

@WayneBruce

What's rhe female version of a cockloger?

I couldnt personally, but everyone's different.

Cocklodgers tend not to do the bulk of the childcare and housework. So that not what op is. Good try, but you might want to think before posting next time....
mimi0708 · 22/10/2021 01:22

@themuttsnutts

There is a lot of bashing against women who are either staying at home with very young children or working part time.

However, a question that hasn't been asked yet is how many men are offering to go part time or stay at home while the woman furthers her career?

And, are these women, incidentally, coming home and asking their husbands 'what they do all day?' If not, why are they all coming on here and asking other women with toddlers 'what they do all day' or suggesting they are 'sponging off their men?' Come on, you know children are hard work. You have all done maternity leave so, really, we all know better so we should be treating one another better.

Another really obvious point that has only been mentioned once on here is that, in the vast majority of cases, the men earn more than the women and so, for pragmatic reasons, it just doesn't make sense for the man to give up work or reduce his hours. Childcare keeps being cited as a joint cost but, if it costs as much as one person's salary, whether it is shared or not, what is the point?

And why do men earn more? Because sexism is alive and kicking in the 21st century workplace and, judging by the attitudes on here, it is particularly prevalent in women vs other women.

This. Whenever people see SAHD they are always amazed, praise the guy for staying at home and looking after children. But if you are a woman choosing to stay at home looking after your kids, it's sponging off men. Women are damned whatever they do.

There should be a lot more support for parents honestly if we want to see more women working.

themuttsnutts · 22/10/2021 00:03

There is a lot of bashing against women who are either staying at home with very young children or working part time.

However, a question that hasn't been asked yet is how many men are offering to go part time or stay at home while the woman furthers her career?

And, are these women, incidentally, coming home and asking their husbands 'what they do all day?' If not, why are they all coming on here and asking other women with toddlers 'what they do all day' or suggesting they are 'sponging off their men?' Come on, you know children are hard work. You have all done maternity leave so, really, we all know better so we should be treating one another better.

Another really obvious point that has only been mentioned once on here is that, in the vast majority of cases, the men earn more than the women and so, for pragmatic reasons, it just doesn't make sense for the man to give up work or reduce his hours. Childcare keeps being cited as a joint cost but, if it costs as much as one person's salary, whether it is shared or not, what is the point?

And why do men earn more? Because sexism is alive and kicking in the 21st century workplace and, judging by the attitudes on here, it is particularly prevalent in women vs other women.

NeverChange · 21/10/2021 22:56

My friend had similar with her DH after her kids were born.

She deliberately let the housework go to shit, including laundry which left him without shirts for work. Suggested a cleaner or cutting her hours and it worked.

She now does occasional secretarial temping (she's not there long enough to get bother a out the job) and has 2 weeks every year with a company that need extra staff in the run up to Christmas and Easter. Gives her enough money to have some of her own but still manages to be home a lot.

RavingAnnie · 21/10/2021 22:50

I imagine you are feeling the way you are because you are feeling pressured by his unreasonable attitude to go back to working full time. Rather than as a. Couple deciding what's best for you, your partner, your children, and all of you as a family, you've just decided to go back to work because your husband's a nob. And that is probably, and understandably, making you feel resentful.

likeafishneedsabike · 21/10/2021 22:40

Hi OP - glad you’re in a better place. It’s such a slog with a 3 and 5 year old but you will be so glad in the long run that you have a ‘proper’ job. Even by the last year of primary I saw how my DC’s friends regarded their mums who didn’t work out of the home. It’s a bit sad because these are women who have sacrificed their careers and earning power for their children, but who are then understandably reluctant to let their children become independent. Its honestly a great piece of role modelling and building for the future, although it doesn’t feel like it right now.
Not sure how your 35 hours spread across the week but 7 hours a day sounds totally manageable in the long run. Only an hour a day more than they will be at school so no long nights for the DC in after school club etc. As they start to stay up a bit later the family evenings will get longer and you’ll get a lot of time with them. This part - when they presumably need to be fed and into the bath at 6.30ish - feels like a rush but it won’t last. It’s a short phase in the grand scale of things. We have upper primary/lower secondary DC and get plenty of time in the evenings despite working long hours - because they are always awake Grin

Anonymouseperson · 21/10/2021 22:24

I just caught up on all your replies. I’ve been at work etc. today. I was having a really bad day when I wrote this and feeling sad. I’m not feeling so negative now. Going to work was actually good, I cleared my head a bit. Maybe I was silly. Like I said, I would never say any of this stuff out loud to anyone actually in my life! I’m here because I was thinking it and I didn’t have anywhere else to say it. I might have to remove myself from here later as it has made me feel quite bad reading some of the replies and that’s entirely my own fault. I started this. I take responsibility for it.

P.S. I’m not a shopaholic and we weren’t broke. I’ve worked since my babies were 6 months old. I don’t think he’s that much of an arsehole he was just a bit stressed, and we were both sleep deprived. I’m sure we’ll work it out. I just needed to vent a bit! Thank you.

OP posts:
OakPine · 21/10/2021 22:15

Does your husband worry that he doesn't keep the house clean enough.
Does your husband worry that he is not spending enough time with the kids.
Does your husband consider that he might give up work to keep the house cleaner.

Swipe left for the next trending thread