Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want to work?!

343 replies

Anonymouseperson · 20/10/2021 21:33

I’m a mum of two (aged 3 and 5). I worked part time freelance from when my kids were 6 months old. I’ve recently started a new job (35 hours a week) because I thought I should try and get my career back on track and wanted to take the financial pressure off my husband.

I used to be very career driven. I loved my job. I was proud of it. Now, I just don’t give a monkeys. I work so much, my house is a mess and I don’t get to do as much with the kids in the week as I’d like.

This is going to sound really horrible, which is why I’m posting anonymously, but sometimes I just wish I’d married someone richer who would just look after me and the kids without question. Someone who wouldn’t expect me to work, but also if I didn’t work wouldn’t quibble over what I was spending.

Part of my reason for wanting to earn more was my husband’s attitude to money. I am not a spendthrift. I don’t shop really, or do beauty treatments or anything. I bought a £12 lamp once for the front room from wilko and he went ballistic on the front step in front of all the neighbours when he saw the shopping bag, saying I should “make some f-ing money before you go spunking it away all the time!” (He later apologised for that).

My point is, I work because I can’t stand him getting all stressy with me about money, not because I want to.

AIBU: Is it anti feminist to just want to raise my kids and be looked after?!

I feel guilty even writing this because it’s not who I used to be. I was Ms Ambitious - but I’m not anymore. Also I know a lot of people have it worse and I don’t want to be ungrateful. I’m sorry if it comes over that way.

Maybe I’m just a bit depressed?!

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 26/10/2021 12:19

@IntermittentParps in the absence of SEN childcare and home making is as much work as one makes it. It’s not in itself difficult.
You can choose to clean every day or not. Drive kids to various activities , or park them at home in front of TV.
How many sole breadwinners really care about how clean the house is for example? Or whether laborious meals are made as opposed to throwing something together?

I very much agree that a lot of women are ‘forced’ into being SAHP, lack of work flexibility and part time jobs etc but I don’t believe that the majority of SAHP add as much value as Workinf partner once kids in school

IntermittentParps · 26/10/2021 12:15

@DrSbaitso

I also wonder if we could as a society a) come to respect home-making/childrearing more

What would this respect look like in real terms? Bearing in mind that whatever you do, you'll never get universal approval.

Well, as I made clear, I'm just thinking out loud, and throwing out vague ideas. But I did mention ring-fencing money for at-home partners. Again, I don't know how.
IntermittentParps · 26/10/2021 12:13

@vivainsomnia

I also wonder if we could as a society a) come to respect home-making/childrearing more It comes down to the same outcome. If both parties agree and have a joint happy arrangement, all is fine. The problem is when they don't.

Some of the messiest, dirtiest houses I have been too were sahp's. Not all sahms are amazing home makers, cooking lovely meals, keeping the house clean and the kids well disciplined, stimulated, educated.

The working husband has no control over it and indeed, might think a paid cleaner would do a better job.

What happens then?

I don't know what happens then. No solution is 100% going to apply to or suit everyone.
Hankunamatata · 26/10/2021 11:54

Iv been the sole wage earner and I never realised how much pressure comes with it until I was in the situation, even if its unintentional.

Me and dh find a written down budget with everything split into savings pots helps so if we need to buy a lamp or a rug etc and theres money in that pot then either of us can.

DrSbaitso · 26/10/2021 11:47

I also wonder if we could as a society a) come to respect home-making/childrearing more

What would this respect look like in real terms? Bearing in mind that whatever you do, you'll never get universal approval.

vivainsomnia · 26/10/2021 11:28

I also wonder if we could as a society a) come to respect home-making/childrearing more
It comes down to the same outcome. If both parties agree and have a joint happy arrangement, all is fine. The problem is when they don't.

Some of the messiest, dirtiest houses I have been too were sahp's. Not all sahms are amazing home makers, cooking lovely meals, keeping the house clean and the kids well disciplined, stimulated, educated.

The working husband has no control over it and indeed, might think a paid cleaner would do a better job.

What happens then?

IntermittentParps · 26/10/2021 11:25

If the person going out to work doesn’t want to be solely responsible for financially supporting the household, then I don’t think the other person should decide to not bring any money in.
I never suggested people shouldn't agree on how they run their finances Confused

Howshouldibehave · 26/10/2021 11:15

And the partner out at work is just as dependent on the partner who is at home looking after THEIR shared children and THEIR shared house; if that person wasn't at home they'd have to pay someone for that work

Childcare maybe, but they’d just do all the house stuff after/before work or at the weekends just like the rest of us. We don’t pay to have a cleaner/housekeeper etc, we just fit it in when we can.

It’s fine for one person to stay at home and do housework and child stuff and the other person to be the sole wage earner IF they are bath happy with it. If the person going out to work doesn’t want to be solely responsible for financially supporting the household, then I don’t think the other person should decide to not bring any money in.

IntermittentParps · 26/10/2021 11:11

@DrSbaitso

And the partner out at work is just as dependent on the partner who is at home looking after THEIR shared children and THEIR shared house; if that person wasn't at home they'd have to pay someone for that work.

Without in any way trivialising the very real work of homemaking and child rearing, this simply isn't true. The first and most immediate need is money. The working partner is not just as dependent at all. With that money, they could indeed pay someone to do the work they can't do themselves (and for most people, the only thing is likely to be childcare in working hours, which becomes a lot more affordable once kids are at school). If your income is suddenly cut off and you don't earn, you're much more stuffed than if you do earn but suddenly have to pay for some childcare and do your own housework.

Look at how many women on here are in miserable relationships but don't leave because of money.

I don't disagree that many women are trapped in relationships because of money. I just think we as a society need to change the way we think about work that isn't going out to work in a job. Many of the comments on here I find so deplorable/offensive are along the lines of 'you need paid work to respect yourself', which is an attitude I really object to. I also wonder if we could as a society a) come to respect home-making/childrearing more and b) enshrine that in law and/or the way we as a society manage family money. Totally thinking out loud and throwing things out here, but for example is there a way to ring-fence money for at-home partners? The equivalent of a family having a shared bank account and separate personal ones, but formalised somehow? As I say, that's just thinking out loud. But I hope you take my point.
DrSbaitso · 26/10/2021 11:05

And the partner out at work is just as dependent on the partner who is at home looking after THEIR shared children and THEIR shared house; if that person wasn't at home they'd have to pay someone for that work.

Without in any way trivialising the very real work of homemaking and child rearing, this simply isn't true. The first and most immediate need is money. The working partner is not just as dependent at all. With that money, they could indeed pay someone to do the work they can't do themselves (and for most people, the only thing is likely to be childcare in working hours, which becomes a lot more affordable once kids are at school). If your income is suddenly cut off and you don't earn, you're much more stuffed than if you do earn but suddenly have to pay for some childcare and do your own housework.

Look at how many women on here are in miserable relationships but don't leave because of money.

Muim · 26/10/2021 10:54

@Anonymouseperson Its not good or bad and tbh peoples opinions are irrelevant. Its what you want, and its hardly selfish is it. You want to be with your kids more. Maybe if you said you didnt want to work, not have the kids and go off on daily shopping trips maybe that would be different.

IntermittentParps · 26/10/2021 10:43

FlowerArranger, while I don't disagree at all with the principle of the importance of protecting women's interests, I do wonder if we all need a massive shake-up of how we view and treat work (of all kinds, including raising a family and running a house) and the economics and the social meanings of it.

I cannot agree with the characterisation of a woman (or a man for that matter) who is at home looking after children as 'not working and being entirely dependent on a man/partner'.
It IS work. People pay for childcare and housekeepers, cleaners, cooks...

And the partner out at work is just as dependent on the partner who is at home looking after THEIR shared children and THEIR shared house; if that person wasn't at home they'd have to pay someone for that work.

We need the world of work to be more flexible and to not reward men (largely it is men) simply for not going off on parental leaves. And work culture needs to respect parental leave more; pay properly and make it smooth for people to re-enter at the same level. Not to mention making it completely equally shared between men and women.

TractorAndHeadphones · 25/10/2021 23:16

@TheViewFromTheCheapSeats

‘The days of men handing over their salary to wives to manage (like my grandparents) are gone, but the attitude that women should continue to place themselves at his mercy has stayed.’

@TractorAndHeadphones you can’t speak for everyone. I pretty much manage all finances in the joint account. Obviously everyone can see them, but I have a bit more time to do things like insurances, savings etc and organise the outgoings. Mutual trust and a healthy relationship hasn’t died as a concept, people still live happily in traditional set ups because they can and want to. It’s ok to be different, for me that’s the big thing- choice. Women do what they want.

But do the majority of people do that? In my grandparents’ day it was a given and expected. Nowadays it’s the minority.
PetriDisher · 24/10/2021 19:46

No, you don't sounds like a dickhead. It's a variation on the fantasy of winning the lottery or suddenly inheriting a pile of money from a long-lost relative that gives the financial freedom to live your life exactly as you'd wish.

May I recommend that fantasy as superior to the rich-husband one, though? A) the lottery win doesn't make you dependant on someone else and B) doesn't risk breeding resentment in your real life as it's really not your DH's fault that neither of you have a wealthy ageing aunt in the background (as far as you know...)

He was being a complete dickhead about the lamp, though, and what he said was an unacceptably nasty thing to say to the mother of his children. Only you know if it was a total one-off that he's ashamed of or a pattern of behaviour that you need to get away from.

user1487194234 · 24/10/2021 09:45

I work full time but I don't see anyone else bringing up my kids

Eggsdancing · 24/10/2021 09:20

I also just don't understand the attitude of expecting someone else to be rich enough to pay your way. Pay your own way. Your a grown woman, you have two dcs to think of, you don't need to be paid for

I don't agree with this, many women would stay at home with the kids rather than work if the money was there, nothing 'wrong' with it as the mum gets to bring up her kids and keep house. Yet on mn the women are looked down on.

Eggsdancing · 24/10/2021 09:16

He sounds like a prick...id work on getting out tbh

oh ffs why does every little spat on mn come back to this advice?

Eggsdancing · 24/10/2021 09:15

What's rhe female version of a cockloger

gold digger

bozzabollix · 24/10/2021 09:10

What is un feminist as some posters have already noted, is the condemnation of women for taking a back step career wise. It’s up to individual families how they decide to arrange their family life. Working full time and raising a family is really hard, if people have a choice not to and take it then that’s totally up to them.

I’m a freelancer so it’s not as simple as working/not working but definitely took my career down a few notches after the kids were born. That was a purely economic decision, my husband is in a very inflexible but high earning job, his ability to not have to take the kids into account and take additional responsibility at work has benefited us as a family financially. Had I been in his job he would’ve been the person to take on the majority of the parental responsibility- and he’d have been bloody good at it too.

I’m going to be stepping up work during the next year but have realised just how unfriendly the job market is to people with pre school/primary aged kids. Whilst women are tearing into other women for being ‘Fanny lodgers’ we aren’t actually looking at changing the working culture that makes it hard for all of us. It’d be a far better direction to stick your anger in.

TheViewFromTheCheapSeats · 24/10/2021 09:09

‘The days of men handing over their salary to wives to manage (like my grandparents) are gone, but the attitude that women should continue to place themselves at his mercy has stayed.’

@TractorAndHeadphones you can’t speak for everyone. I pretty much manage all finances in the joint account. Obviously everyone can see them, but I have a bit more time to do things like insurances, savings etc and organise the outgoings. Mutual trust and a healthy relationship hasn’t died as a concept, people still live happily in traditional set ups because they can and want to. It’s ok to be different, for me that’s the big thing- choice. Women do what they want.

TheViewFromTheCheapSeats · 24/10/2021 09:04

I don’t have a fantastically rich husband. I do however have one that wants to see me and the children happy and never queries finances.
I had a career, then we had an Sen child as well as a big family and we decided I’d be at home a while. It’s a mutually beneficial arrangement in that we aren’t both so tired we want to cry 24/7. I take a massive slack of the home and family life, he works but without the nursery run crazy and can rest at the end of the day. I enjoy my children rather than being too tired to interact a lot of the time.
It’s more than just money, I’m not living off him. He has the family he wants.
We’ve made big compromises on where we can live and what we do money-wise. I have full access to all monies in joint accounts with no comments on spending though. I wouldn’t have given up work otherwise.
Maybe one day we’ll switch roles if it works out that way, he can stay at home. However at the moment it has suited us this was round. I would also though enjoy seeing him happy and I’d love coming home from work to a meal and a slob out!

dottiedodah · 24/10/2021 08:56

I think your husband was very rude to you .however does he feel the pressure of being the only breadwinner. Many women feel like you ,but being reliant on someone else for money also shifts the power to them.can you look for a pt role elsewhere if not available here. Or condense your week into 4 days maybe

Tumbleweed101 · 24/10/2021 08:52

You have young children and a full time job it’s not surprising you feel overwhelmed and wish that you could just be at home and concentrate on that side of family life. There is so much expectation we can manage it all and if we are single or have an unsupportive partner it can get too much. I would love to be a SAHM and as a single parent who works full time I can find having all the responsibilities overwhelming. I often fantasise about having someone who could take away some of the burdens so I didn’t have to work (I’m sure in the real world I still would lol).

FlowerArranger · 24/10/2021 08:31

@MarshmallowSwede

If you’re a woman who thinks the only reason a woman is worthy of a man’s respect is to basically emulate men and work and do everything men do.. you’re a misogynist.

Women have always been the primary caregiver of children and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that. It baffles me this certain mindset of certain “feminists” who look down upon and hold motherhood and home making with such disdain.

There is nothing wrong with being a woman who loves to homemake. There is nothing with not wanting to have a career. If we are going tk say women have choices then we need to also say that it’s perfectly ok for women to opt out of careers and focus on being at home and home making.

Working, with all that entails, has nothing to do with gaining men's respect. It's a sensible thing to do.

There is no reason why men cannot be the primary caregiver, but generally they don't want to because they recognise that taking time out of the workplace will jeopardise their long term professional and economic interests.

Feminists do not look on motherhood with disdain, but they do emphasise the importance of protecting women's interests. Having a career and maintaining economic independence is generally a good idea.

Not working and being entirely dependent on a man is risky. Just read the relationship board and despair at all the women posting about being trapped in totally shitty and sometimes abusive relationship because they are economically dependent on some man who cannot be arsed to pull his weight in the family...

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 23/10/2021 21:03

@MarshmallowSwede

If you’re a woman who thinks the only reason a woman is worthy of a man’s respect is to basically emulate men and work and do everything men do.. you’re a misogynist.

Women have always been the primary caregiver of children and there is absolutely nothing wrong with that. It baffles me this certain mindset of certain “feminists” who look down upon and hold motherhood and home making with such disdain.

There is nothing wrong with being a woman who loves to homemake. There is nothing with not wanting to have a career. If we are going tk say women have choices then we need to also say that it’s perfectly ok for women to opt out of careers and focus on being at home and home making.

The OP wants to ‘not work and not have her DH quibble over what she spends’.

But nice try making it sound like something much more noble.

Swipe left for the next trending thread