Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How can I support my friend when she is lying?

114 replies

ihatetheschoolrun · 20/10/2021 20:19

Won't go into to much as possibly outing but feel like me and OH keep getting dragged into things.

OH is good friends with her ex and we have been good friends for 15 years. They are going through a messy breakup they aren't married and she is refusing to leave his house and has randomly took out an injunction on him. He has offered her a large amount of money but still won't move.

He has sold his house but can not complete on it with her living there. We have said we don't want to know anything as it has caused so many arguments between us. However ex has turned up at ours tonight in tears and can't take anymore he is paying bills on his rented property and his mortgage and all bills for her to live there and is struggling.

What the hell am I supposed to do? I've had to come upstairs because I feel bad but she seems happy with her self on our girls group chat?

OP posts:
RedMarauder · 21/10/2021 07:39

OP if you and your DH want to remain friends with them both you should make an agreement to not have either of them in your house or go to their houses any more. They are both trying to get you on their side as spoils from their relationship split.

If you are going to see them arrange to see them in a public place e.g. pub, bar, restaurant.

Willyoujustbequiet · 21/10/2021 07:27

Shame on you OP.

You don't get non mol orders for no reason. The court has clearly seen evidence of his abuse.

How about you support the victim and not the perpetrator?. Take a long, hard look at yourself.
.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 21/10/2021 07:17

Why do you think she's lying and not him?
Has he shown you actual evidence that his claims are true?

brittleheadgirl · 21/10/2021 07:15

You sound like a dreadful friend.

Most women don't tell a soul they are being abused.

knittingaddict · 21/10/2021 07:12

Non molestation orders don't just fall off trees. My daughter didn't get one despite refuge, police, CPS, family courts etc.

pelosi · 21/10/2021 07:07

She would be a fool to believe him over the £30k unless he actually transfers it over.

RedMarauder · 21/10/2021 07:05

@LorenzoVonMatterhorn

How does her moving out help the children? Why should she believe he would hand over any money?
She hasn't got any rights to the house.

I bet he threatened to evict her when she wouldn't move which is why he got the non-molestation order against him.

He needs to follow the legal process to evict her. This means his sale will fall through.

RedMarauder · 21/10/2021 07:03

@Thatsplentyjack

Poor woman, she has been physically abused, cheated on and won't have any assets when she finally does have to leave the house because he's never put her name on the mortgage or married her, but had children with her. No wonder she's refusing to leave.
Not necessarily.

Lots of women go down her path of action when their relationships go shit and they split up. They pretend to be a victim when they are not and in some cases are the one being abusive. (I know a man who did this as well.)

If he threatened her to get her out of the house - even if he didn't mean it - and there is proof e.g. messages the Family Court would grant her an emergency non-molestation order. This would be served on him with no warning. There would be a return hearing within a month. Depending on whether he has a barrister or not, and what he said/did he would get an undertaking or an order to stop him repeating the behaviour.

She has absolutely no rights to the house as they aren't married. Doesn't matter if she had children with him or not. She does have rights to some profits from the sale of the house if she paid for or did any improvements on it.

knittingaddict · 21/10/2021 07:01

@StoneofDestiny

Can he not get the services switched off - gas, electric, water etc.
Wonderful. Tell an abusive man how to be even more abusive.
knittingaddict · 21/10/2021 06:58

[quote ihatetheschoolrun]@DawnFawn yes you're right.

Apologies is confusing lol.

She is saying he has been physically abusive and is a rubbish father etc. She has never mentioned abuse to me or any of the girls we know he has cheated and he moved out after that and let her stay in the house.

Also he has his kids 4/7 days a week and she has never said that he is a danger to the kids.

She has organised a "girls night" Saturday at the house but I feel so bloody awkward now and it just doesn't sit well with me.
[/quote]
You can't possibly know that she is lying about abuse. My daughter didn't mention abuse until just before she left.

This man going to friends in tears in something I recognise and would be wary of. It's what my ex son in law did. Went to neighbours houses in floods of tears about how much an innocent victim he was. He phoned her friends too. Probably went to everyine he knew. Cried all over the shop. He was 100% an abuser.

Dinosauria · 21/10/2021 06:48

@LadyTiredWinterBottom2

I don't know, the house belongs to him otherwise he would not have been able to sell it. She can't be a proper tenant because he wouldn't have been able to sell it unless he declare tenant in situ would he? Not completely au fait with this.

I sympathise with her but l would feel uncomfortable as her friend as well. How is this helping anyone? She needs to move on with her life. Silly games usually backfire.

Silly games?

So because she isn't married (why is this) she has given up 15 years of her life, and raised children, undoubtedly hurting her career prospects and now he wants to make her homeless. 30k isn't enough, nor I expect is what she deserves. If she had a piece of paper MN would be telling her to stay in the house.

Op you aren't trying to stay out of it, you've decided sided based on the tearful account of one if them. Sounds like you are being manipulated.

Thatsplentyjack · 21/10/2021 06:40

Poor woman, she has been physically abused, cheated on and won't have any assets when she finally does have to leave the house because he's never put her name on the mortgage or married her, but had children with her. No wonder she's refusing to leave.

LorenzoVonMatterhorn · 21/10/2021 06:37

How does her moving out help the children? Why should she believe he would hand over any money?

LadyTiredWinterBottom2 · 21/10/2021 06:32

I don't know, the house belongs to him otherwise he would not have been able to sell it. She can't be a proper tenant because he wouldn't have been able to sell it unless he declare tenant in situ would he? Not completely au fait with this.

I sympathise with her but l would feel uncomfortable as her friend as well. How is this helping anyone? She needs to move on with her life. Silly games usually backfire.

arcof · 21/10/2021 06:31

This is hella confusing

Saoirse82 · 21/10/2021 06:06

*your

Saoirse82 · 21/10/2021 06:06

I think you need to be a much better friend OP. Why would you take the word of the cheating, potentially abusive ex over you're friend? Why is his word better than hers? To me he sounds massively manipulate, most abusers tend to be.

pelosi · 21/10/2021 05:44

Blimey, massive drip feeds about the kids, physical abuse and cheating.

So they’ve had children and she has been raising them with a rubbish father. She should have married him before having kids, she would now be entitled to 50% of the house.

The fact that she has served papers on him and you didn’t even know what for shows you have no idea what’s going.

You’re not naive, you’re just agreeing with him that it’s his house and she and the kids aren’t entitled to any of it and she should be grateful for whatever he gives her. Whereas she has her kids to think of and their futures.

You seem a bit jealous or fixated on this £30k, but that won’t go far on buying a house, only a deposit.

Flowerpowwer6 · 21/10/2021 03:46

@ihatetheschoolrun

I'm trying to see things from both sides I've always stuck up her. But now I'm thinking why won't she move out then they can just be done with each other? I don't know maybe I'm being naive.
Ask her? Is he a rubbish dad?

Say no to the girls night say your not feeling up to it.

takingonestepatatime · 21/10/2021 03:42

[quote ihatetheschoolrun]@Stompythedinosaur he's offered her 30K though so she wouldn't be homeless and they have joint custody of the kiddies.

@Laladell that's interesting I never knew that they do have a court hearing coming up but what you are saying is she's already had a hearing for them to serve papers?[/quote]
£30 K out of how much - the house is the children’s.

MangoSeason · 21/10/2021 03:21

Maybe she has agreed to move out only when the magical 30k hits her bank account. Wise woman, if so.

stayathomer · 21/10/2021 03:10

A 'random injunction' really jumped out at me. How can you possibly know the full story by listening to one person's side? As for the group chat: Me having the shittest day of my life might still message 'how's everyone doing?' as I sit in tears. Whatever the truth I would either talk to her or just plain out tell her you can't meet her as you're in the middle and I'd move away from the friendship as I don't think you're really friends, it sounds like you're finished with her

Ponoka7 · 21/10/2021 02:32

He might be telling her that he will pay her when she's moved out and quite rightly she doesn't believe him, so is staying put until it's been through court. She might have an inkling that he'll move back in with the OW.
It's a myth put about by misogynists that injunctions are easy to get. There has to be evidence. Women very rarely 'cry abuse', but women are often abused. Especially when they don't just piss off because their partner has found someone else to shag.
My DD never told me, her friends or her elder sister about the abuse that she was going through. She didn't tell us when neighbours had to call the police.
Think carefully before you brand other women liars based on a cheats tears of self pity.

PersonaNonGarter · 21/10/2021 02:15

He sounds an abusive cheater, and she is trying to keep her kids in their home.

Not sure why this is all so terrible for you though.

LetHimHaveIt · 21/10/2021 01:55

@Viviennemary

She sounds like a selfish scrounger. I couldnt be friends with somebody like that.
She probably doesn't open the door to postmen, either 🙄
Swipe left for the next trending thread