Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How can I support my friend when she is lying?

114 replies

ihatetheschoolrun · 20/10/2021 20:19

Won't go into to much as possibly outing but feel like me and OH keep getting dragged into things.

OH is good friends with her ex and we have been good friends for 15 years. They are going through a messy breakup they aren't married and she is refusing to leave his house and has randomly took out an injunction on him. He has offered her a large amount of money but still won't move.

He has sold his house but can not complete on it with her living there. We have said we don't want to know anything as it has caused so many arguments between us. However ex has turned up at ours tonight in tears and can't take anymore he is paying bills on his rented property and his mortgage and all bills for her to live there and is struggling.

What the hell am I supposed to do? I've had to come upstairs because I feel bad but she seems happy with her self on our girls group chat?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RedMarauder · 22/10/2021 17:23

@SisterAgatha Unfortunately it is true in England that if you aren't married or in a civil partnership with someone and the relationship breaks down they owe you nothing for living with them like a spouse, regardless of whether you have children with them or not.

He may owe her money for some of the improvements done on his house, which is why he offered her the 30K. I know of a handful of former co-habiting couples where this was the case and so the non-home owner got given cash to prevent them taking legal action to get it.

Doyouknowtheway · 22/10/2021 14:46

If she hasn't outright lied to you then maybe her keeping certain issues quiet is her way of holding things together, not everyone shares all information with friends and family. If she's been abused maybe she's ashamed, maybe she's not wanting to get in a battle with him to win friends sympathy. Possibly her time and mental space is focusing on her next move( where will they live now, how to know who can she trust after she's had her trust ruined by this man). On the otherhand she may have the ability and funds to find a new home but isn't finished with punishing him yet. Who knows, but I would still offer support plus advice if she was seeking it. Obviously she can't stay there indefinitely and may need telling this, it would be best for her and the kids of she was to plan and move somewhere she'd like to settle again, rather than be shipped out, things on the streets and then looking for accommodation last minute.

cultkid · 21/10/2021 18:51

Kids are a game changer you didn't mention them in the first place

She will have gotten legal advice to stay there

Where is she supposed to live

SisterAgatha · 21/10/2021 18:45

He doesn’t actually owe her anything, his only obligation is to provide for half of his children’s costs.

Untrue. If she gave up a career to care for the children and has decreased her employment opportunities due to childcare etc had they been married he may have had to pay spousal maintenance for a limited period.

Not every woman who leaves a relationship is a robber.

AnneLovesGilbert · 21/10/2021 13:50

She’s not his wife. That’s the whole point. And it’s not the family home anymore. They’re two separate adults and only he owns it. If she had a right to be there he couldn’t have sold it but he has.

Anoisagusaris · 21/10/2021 13:30

Leaving aside whether the abuse allegations are correct - he cheats on his wife and then it’s supposedly ok to make her and his children leave their family home??

LetHimHaveIt · 21/10/2021 13:18

'Generous offer'? Are you ok?

AnneLovesGilbert · 21/10/2021 13:10

Why is everyone so sure he refused to marry her? Maybe she didn’t want to get married. Either way, no one forced her to have children unmarried if it meant that much to her, never mind twice.

She was naive and stupid to live with a man she wasn’t married to in a house she has no part of.

All that aside, OP, no one is making you get involved. That’s a choice. Both you and your partner are able to step back at any moment. Why on Earth would you bring trouble into your own relationship by taking sides? That’s incredibly daft and unnecessary.

Laladell · 21/10/2021 13:10

One would imagine that the non molestation order being put in place is what's helping her get away from her abuser (no quotation marks 🙄)

NailsNeedDoing · 21/10/2021 12:31

Well, he's valuing their relationship, progeny and all, at £2,000 pa. How generous. As Aretha Franklin didn't quite say: 'Who's screwing who?'

He’s not putting a value on their relationship ffs. He’s made a generous offer to enable her to set up a new home. He doesn’t actually owe her anything, his only obligation is to provide for half of his children’s costs.

Whatever happened in their relationship is irrelevant now. They are separated and need to move on, but she is the one preventing that. If she has the option, which she clearly does, why would she want to stay in a house that belongs to her ‘abuser’? If he was that terrible, surely she’s just want to get away and make as clean a break as possible hen there are children involved, especially condo she has been offered the means to do that.

It sounds like she’s staying just to punish him for his affair because she wants revenge.

TooBigForMyBoots · 21/10/2021 11:49

I'm not sure she is the one lying here @ihatetheschoolrun. But I know that he's definitely a liar, as do you.

LetHimHaveIt · 21/10/2021 09:14

@NailsNeedDoing

I wouldn’t have much sympathy with someone who was screwing over their ex financially, even if they were cheated on.

Relationships end, people need to deal with it without expecting their exes to fund them indefinitely.

Well, he's valuing their relationship, progeny and all, at £2,000 pa. How generous. As Aretha Franklin didn't quite say: 'Who's screwing who?'
dworky · 21/10/2021 08:56

If he abused her you should not be talking to him or allowing him in your home.

NewlyGranny · 21/10/2021 08:45

Her "girls' night" might well be her gathering her friends to tell everyone what's going on and ask for support. You listened to his side: go and listen to hers.

Lovemusic33 · 21/10/2021 08:37

I managed to get an injunction against my ex, there needed to be prep of of abuse and harassment, he was arrested and charged with harassing me (phone evidence) and it went to court. I was physically and sexually assaulted by this man but to the outside world he appeared like to be a lovely person, I felt like no one believed me. What you see maybe much different to what has been going on in their relationship?

If she has been living in the house for 15 years and they have 2 children I think £30,000 is laughable, I’m guessing it’s at least a 3 bed house? Possibly selling for well over £200,000? If she has been contributing to bills and the mortgage for 15 years she should be entitled to more?

I do understand it may seem like she’s digging her heals in and causing trouble but £30,000 isn’t going to get her a 3 bed house for her and her dc.

Quartz2208 · 21/10/2021 08:23

Also the fact that they were together for 15 years, he didnt marry her and he is saying it is HIS house tells me everything I would need to know about this man

Quartz2208 · 21/10/2021 08:22

Has her story changed at all

Is he now starting to tell you his story or has he been constant throughout as well

Because that will tell you a lot. Because it could very much be either way and it is interesting that you go to your friend lying.

Which means either she is or he did a damned good job at making you think she is.

Given some of what you are saying he said to you (given the fact that he had an affair is definitely true) makes me inclined to think he is damage control and smoothing things over with you and she is telling the truth

But you know the people

NailsNeedDoing · 21/10/2021 08:19

I wouldn’t have much sympathy with someone who was screwing over their ex financially, even if they were cheated on.

Relationships end, people need to deal with it without expecting their exes to fund them indefinitely.

ThinWomansBrain · 21/10/2021 08:04

hopefully other women in your "girls group" chat are more adult and supportive, so she isn't reliant on your support/friendship

theremustonlybeone · 21/10/2021 08:04

having just re read your OP you really have been suckered in by this man. A man who has an injunction out against him (which you seem to think just get handed out with no evidence) he is offering 30K after 15yrs and DC together and expects her just to move. He is happy to make his DC homeless and now getting his ex friends to turn against her as she is clearly 'lying'. He is truly doing a number on you

LIZS · 21/10/2021 08:03

You are only getting drawn in because you allow yourselves to be. I doubt you know the full truth of what happened, it is he said she said. How is he able to sell the house from under them? He makes them homeless but "offers" to control how she can rent. Hmm

theremustonlybeone · 21/10/2021 07:59

Sadly she is entitled to nothing as they are unmarried, unless she can register an interest in the property. The non mol order has nothing to do with the property. He needs to go through a legal eviction route if she wont leave. However given his children are living in the property what is his view about them being homeless? Or is he going to suggest they come and live with him so your friend is doubly shafted as she wont get maintenance either.

If she was a victim of abuse you likely wont be aware, he may be a master manipulator and doing all the tears and woe is me which narcs are good at to get folks on side. I wouldnt be getting drawn into that and wouldnt trust this man. Courts dont just dish out injunctions without evidence, just because he sees his kids doesnt mean he is safe around their mother.

Beaudalaire · 21/10/2021 07:53

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the user's request.

HeadNorth · 21/10/2021 07:45

OP - why do you assume the woman is lying and the man telling the truth? Personally, I wouldn't take sides in a divorce. If you let him come to your house with his sob story, then you should go to her girls night in. Or avoid them both.

Thatsplentyjack · 21/10/2021 07:42

@RedMarauder, yesterday because they just hand out non molestation orders to people willy nilly.

Nowhere did I say she had any rights to the house. So I've no idea why you felt the need to explain that one to me.

From what the OP had said, ice come to the conclusion that I feel sorry for the woman. You can come to any conclusion you like.