Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU worry that the next generation are not actually that "accepting"

466 replies

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 19:33

Long story short but chatting with 14 yo DD this evening about many subjects and a family members "views" came up. For background this family member in my view is racist and homophobic.
DD stated FM should be cancelled. Never allowed to speak, voice their opinion ever.

I pointed out to DD that freedom of speech means just that. We can all hold opinions others don't like but we are all free to voice, protest and gather regardless.
DD is of an age where discussion/debate is not an option apparently and if you are offended by another's views you just cancel them instead of debating or accepting their view as different to yours.

This worries me as instead of challenging different opinions the next generation are just silencing them.

YANBU = yes we are growing an intolerant society

YABU = They deserve to be cancelled

OP posts:
WomanStanleyWoman · 20/10/2021 23:47

DD believes he should not voice his opinions on things she doesn't agree with not that he should not be in her life.

Good for her.

I have challenged him many times over the last 20 years. Sometimes he apologises and to be fair does try harder to keep it to himself but they are opinions he has.

If you’ve been challenging him for 20 years and he still hasn’t taken any notice, maybe your daughter has the right idea.

Kanaloa · 20/10/2021 23:47

@TheKeatingFive

Homophobia and racism are hate crimes so in this case, the law gets to decide

Is a white personal writing a book from a black person's POV racist though? Some would say yes. That's not illegal.

So much nuance to engage with.

Saying ‘it’s only black people who are in gangs is racist.’ There’s really no debate. And outside of being racist it’s stupid as well. Anyone who makes a statement like that doesn’t truly believe it, they’re saying it to be racist. Either that or they’re incredibly stupid and really believe no white person has ever been part of gang culture despite there being lots of cases of white teens (and adults) involved in gang culture.
WomanStanleyWoman · 20/10/2021 23:45

@TheKeatingFive

You make it sound like she was hanged in a public square.

Never said anything of the sort.

She was publicly and vocally cancelled though.

But what does cancelled mean? Has she been dropped by her publisher? Have her books been withdrawn from sale? Have TV stations stopped screening Harry Potter films?

What IS cancelling, in your view? Do you simply mean that some people have been very vocal in their disappointment in and disagreement with JK Rowling? Because that is not ‘cancelling’ someone. The people criticising her behaviour have just as much right to their views.

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 23:44

Cancelled doesn't mean out of her life sorry I thought I had made that clear in my OP.

DD believes he should not voice his opinions on things she doesn't agree with not that he should not be in her life. Hence why I say "no opinion, no voice"

I have challenged him many times over the last 20 years. Sometimes he apologises and to be fair does try harder to keep it to himself but they are opinions he has.
He is not and everyday fixture in our life but families are complex and not this idyllic politically correct equal society MN thinks it is.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 20/10/2021 23:41

Homophobia and racism are hate crimes so in this case, the law gets to decide

Is a white personal writing a book from a black person's POV racist though? Some would say yes. That's not illegal.

So much nuance to engage with.

Mantlemoose · 20/10/2021 23:40

I think it's up to each person to decide what they want to listen to /ignore/challenge. FWIW I agree with her, if someone has different beliefs/ideas to me that's fine, it's their choice and it isn't up to me to attempt them to change their views because I"m certainly not interested in them doing it to me. My DP is the opposite, he wants to debate everything with anyone who doesn't think like he does. Except me of course!

TheKeatingFive · 20/10/2021 23:39

Does it matter that certain things weren’t considered racist 20 years ago? Racism itself was still considered wrong.

How do you know your own current views won't be considered racist in 20 years, when debate has evolved even further?

Guess what, you don't.

TheKeatingFive · 20/10/2021 23:38

You make it sound like she was hanged in a public square.

Never said anything of the sort.

She was publicly and vocally cancelled though.

WomanStanleyWoman · 20/10/2021 23:38

@TheKeatingFive

Racism - unacceptable. Homophobia - unacceptable

You sound about twelve. There are layers and layers of nuance under both those headings and societal understanding changes all the time.

A lot of what would have been considered racist now wouldn't have been 20 years ago, our understanding evolves constantly:

Pathetic comment.

Does it matter that certain things weren’t considered racist 20 years ago? Racism itself was still considered wrong. Why put up with someone being knowingly racist?

Labyrinth86 · 20/10/2021 23:37

@TheKeatingFive

‘Cancel culture’, as the fashionable phrase is these days, IS challenging these views. It’s stating that racism and homophobia are unacceptable - no ifs, no buts.

Silencing/blanking/cancelling isn't challenging anything. It's running away from debate. I'm really astonished that this point has to be made.

Who gets to decide who or what views are 'acceptable'?

Homophobia and racism are hate crimes so in this case, the law gets to decide. I can't believe we have people defending these repulsive views tbh.
daisyjgrey · 20/10/2021 23:36

Speech is not free when it is hate speech.

Challenge the family member yourself, don't expect your 14 year old to do it instead Hmm

If you believe that this person is well within their rights to be racist etc (and vocally at that), then your child has just as much right to believe that the person should be 'cancelled'.

Silenceisgolden20 · 20/10/2021 23:36

I'd didn't say we cracked racism, what are you talking about?

WomanStanleyWoman · 20/10/2021 23:35

@TheKeatingFive

Really? Pretty sure Harry Potter books still sell in their millions.

What's your point? She was 'cancelled' by the righteous. Book sales have fuck all to do with that.

My point is that you have suggested someone was ‘cancelled’ because a group of people found her views unacceptable and decided they could no longer support her by buying her books, seeing Harry Potter films etc. You make it sound like she was hanged in a public square.

You really should read through your own comments before criticising me or questioning my maturity.

kirinm · 20/10/2021 23:35

Yeah you lost me at 'debate racism and homophobia'. No. You're facilitating it.

TheKeatingFive · 20/10/2021 23:35

Yes it would have been racist 20 years about, it was just tolerated.

So how do we know that we've 'cracked' racism now? Or don't we entertain the idea that our understanding of it might continue to evolve? Again, who ultimately arbitrates?

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 23:34

I think I would rather teach him that fact, than teach your children to put up with it.

I am not teaching my children to put up with it. I am teaching them to challenge it. Even if it is a much loved family member.

OP posts:
Silenceisgolden20 · 20/10/2021 23:34

Op you're going round in circles. Maybe she has a mind of her own and picks her own debates. Maybe she should challenge your views on what she should and should not say with her own brain

DysmalRadius · 20/10/2021 23:34

She has never once said she doesn't want him in her life. Where have I said she has said that?

TBF, your OP says 'DD stated FM should be cancelled. Never allowed to speak, voice their opinion ever.' so unless you really mean that literally, I am assuming that she means she doesn't want to be in a position where she has to listen to him. If she's only seeing him at family gatherings already, then the only further route to cancellation would appear to be not seeing him at all - what form does she suggest this cancellation takes?

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 23:32

Ha! And has it never occurred to you that telling your daughter she is wrong to cut this person off for their views is YOU putting yourself on a so-called pedestal? When does SHE get the right to challenge YOUR view?

Problem is she doesn't want to challenge anyones views. That's my point. Instead of challenging, having debate, fighting for what you belive she thinks no debate at all.

OP posts:
Silenceisgolden20 · 20/10/2021 23:32

@TheKeatingFive

Racism - unacceptable. Homophobia - unacceptable

You sound about twelve. There are layers and layers of nuance under both those headings and societal understanding changes all the time.

A lot of what would have been considered racist now wouldn't have been 20 years ago, our understanding evolves constantly:

Yes it would have been racist 20 years about, it was just tolerated.
TheKeatingFive · 20/10/2021 23:32

Really? Pretty sure Harry Potter books still sell in their millions.

What's your point? She was 'cancelled' by the righteous. Book sales have fuck all to do with that.

Labyrinth86 · 20/10/2021 23:31

I'd be proud of my kid for not entertaining racism and homophobia. How do you react to this FM when they say such things? Do you challenge the views? Is it more of an awkward silence with raised eyebrows or head down pretending they didn't say it? I think the best thing you can do is model the response you want your child to have - if that is challenging the views then make sure you're doing that. I genuinely don't think it's a young person thing though - as a society, we tend not to call out other people we're close to on the bad things they say in order to keep the peace. Typically people express their disapproval after the fact. If your child has seen this approach, I can completely understand their viewpoint.

Kanaloa · 20/10/2021 23:31

Right well I really wouldn’t see any point debating with someone who literally says out loud ‘it’s not natural two blokes’ or ‘it’s only black people in gangs.’

I mean what’s the point? Do you think you can point out enough cleverly debated facts that he’ll suddenly go ‘you know you’re right, gay people are natural and normal.’ Or ‘oh yes there are of course white people in gangs and organised crime.’

TheKeatingFive · 20/10/2021 23:31

Racism - unacceptable. Homophobia - unacceptable

You sound about twelve. There are layers and layers of nuance under both those headings and societal understanding changes all the time.

A lot of what would have been considered racist now wouldn't have been 20 years ago, our understanding evolves constantly:

WomanStanleyWoman · 20/10/2021 23:30

Well JK Rowling has been 'cancelled' so I'm not buying the argument that only extremists are cancelled, sorry. It's just anyone they don't want to engage with.

Really? Pretty sure Harry Potter books still sell in their millions.