Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU worry that the next generation are not actually that "accepting"

466 replies

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 19:33

Long story short but chatting with 14 yo DD this evening about many subjects and a family members "views" came up. For background this family member in my view is racist and homophobic.
DD stated FM should be cancelled. Never allowed to speak, voice their opinion ever.

I pointed out to DD that freedom of speech means just that. We can all hold opinions others don't like but we are all free to voice, protest and gather regardless.
DD is of an age where discussion/debate is not an option apparently and if you are offended by another's views you just cancel them instead of debating or accepting their view as different to yours.

This worries me as instead of challenging different opinions the next generation are just silencing them.

YANBU = yes we are growing an intolerant society

YABU = They deserve to be cancelled

OP posts:
waferingstranger · 21/10/2021 14:58

@NotDavidTennant

I find the people arguing the "debate never changes anyone's opinion" quite strange.

Are they saying that they have never changed their minds on anything? That if they heard a persuasive argument for something they didn't currently believe in that they would just adamantly refuse to change their beliefs?

I think changing anybody's mind on anything of actual importance is pretty difficult. Human beings are extremely stubborn.

Not that it's impossible. But I've got better things to do with my life than waste time trying to achieve those rare occasions where someone is actually receptive to new ideas.

Kanaloa · 21/10/2021 12:13

@NotDavidTennant

I find the people arguing the "debate never changes anyone's opinion" quite strange.

Are they saying that they have never changed their minds on anything? That if they heard a persuasive argument for something they didn't currently believe in that they would just adamantly refuse to change their beliefs?

OP has been politely debating this man for TWENTY YEARS and he still thinks ‘two blokes together isn’t natural.’ I mean at a certain point you need to write someone off. Otherwise we spend our whole lives stroking Donald Trump’s hair and saying ‘oh honey no, women are people with equal rights. Oh I know, not in your opinion. Never mind I’ll try again tomorrow.’

At a certain point you just need to say firmly ‘no. That’s not right and I’m not continuing with this.’

WomanStanleyWoman · 21/10/2021 11:39

@mustlovegin

They are to be smashed. Fuck that. Freedom of speech is not freedom of consequence. End of discussion

Lovely way to go about preaching tolerance

Oh, it’s the ‘not tolerating intolerance IS intolerance’ line. Total bollocks.
TheKeatingFive · 21/10/2021 10:10

Those are good arguments and I think a lot of people would be receptive to them and be willing to think more deeply if presented with them.

Exactly. These are the type of conversations we should be having if we want society to actually evolve.

Not 'smash them' Hmm

1Week · 21/10/2021 10:02

Jeez stupid typo - meant to say it's not correct to conflate race with criminal behaviour

1Week · 21/10/2021 10:01

Look at it this way though.
Uncle "Be careful of those black lads in Xtown, they're all in gangs" OK racist

Uncle "Gangs are a major problem in Xtown and statistically males of Afro-Carribean descent age 14 to 26 are more likely to be caught up in it. So,
Dniece remain vigilant while in X Town."

Is that racist? Some would argue yes, so shut up.

Some would say no, naming the problem is the first step to solving it.
Some would say it's not correct to conflate criminality with criminal behaviour, poverty and socio economic deprivation are the relevant factors.
Some would say its victim blaming to expect the teen girl to adjust her behaviour for fear of trouble and its the trouble makers who should be taught better.

Those are good arguments and I think a lot of people would be receptive to them and be willing to think more deeply if presented with them. Not everyone no, and possibly not OP's FM, but on the scale of a country I think enough would to make a difference at the ballot box.

I don't blame OP's daughter for not wanting to debate Uncle. Or any individual who is sick and tired of it. Maybe changing one old man's mind doesn't matter in the scheme of things.

But societally, nobody wanting to debate anything contentious or nuanced is a disaster, imo, how will we ever get to the root of a particular problem if we can't dissect all the spiralling factors that go into it? That's what's worrying about many of the younger generation.

TheKeatingFive · 21/10/2021 09:58

I think many people cannot grasp this important concept. Maybe they are too young to understand this, they need more life experience

I think you're right

berlinbabylon · 21/10/2021 09:58

@NotDavidTennant

I find the people arguing the "debate never changes anyone's opinion" quite strange.

Are they saying that they have never changed their minds on anything? That if they heard a persuasive argument for something they didn't currently believe in that they would just adamantly refuse to change their beliefs?

I agree - when I was a teen I agreed with capital punishment. I don't anymore. People do change their views but most MNers like to believe the opposite.

Some people won't change their minds, but many will. Or you may at least sew the seeds of doubt which will make them keep any abhorrent views to themselves. We all live in bubbles and need our views challenging. There are plenty of things I've learnt on MN eg about invisible disabilities.

mustlovegin · 21/10/2021 09:56

how do you know you won't be 'smashed' in time for some of your views?

I think many people cannot grasp this important concept. Maybe they are too young to understand this, they need more life experience

berlinbabylon · 21/10/2021 09:55

We had early warning of this in that incident with Gordon Brown and the woman who tried to talk to him about immigration. She wasn't a racist, she had legitimate concerns, but he pigeonholed her as a racist and fobbed her off. Refusing to talk to people about certain things doesn't mean they stop having those concerns. It means an opportunity to exchange information and views is lost and the person written off as a bigot is left feeling slighted. No wonder the far right was able to win so many people over

I agree. If you keep closing people down and don't engage with their views, you end up with Brexit and Trump.

If someone expressed concern about immigration they were being racist. Expressing concern about pressure on amenities is not racist but nobody would listen (and it didn't help that the EU didn't listen to Cameron when he tried to explain the concerns, either).

There is also a difference between out and out racism and using an expression like "whiter than white" that people may not realise is racist until you point it out to them. Same with the word "spooky" which is considered racist in the US as it was used about black air force personnel in WW2. I didn't know that until this week.

There are some issues where there are shades of grey - eg the trans issue because of the impact on biological women and teens and young adults needs to learn that there are shades of grey. And they also need to learn that not everyone agrees with them.

TheKeatingFive · 21/10/2021 09:52

They are to be smashed. Fuck that. Freedom of speech is not freedom of consequence. End of discussion

You're sending them right into the arms of the alt right with that kind of attitude. So long as you're happy with that.

And as the prevailing understanding of what actually constitutes racism and homophobia evolves all the time, how do you know you won't be 'smashed' in time for some of your views?

QueEsEsto · 21/10/2021 09:46

I find the people arguing the "debate never changes anyone's opinion" quite strange.

Same here. That's not been my experience.

Are they saying that they have never changed their minds on anything? That if they heard a persuasive argument for something they didn't currently believe in that they would just adamantly refuse to change their beliefs?

That's what I've noticed. Some people would rather die or go silent when there's nothing else to say than say "you know what, I think you have a point. I disagree with you on the other point but I can agree on this one". For these people, it"s all or nothing. In or out. With us or against us. No middle ground. So I'm not surprised some would think debate never changes minds. It can only change minds when people come into a debate with an open mind and an aim to listen to each other, not just reply; when you don't see an enemy for life but a person with a ludicrous/hateful/ignorant opinion on something, which can be changed.

That said, I also think people can decide to ignore who they choose to ignore for their own reason. It isn't always the best course of action but neither is debating for years with the same person about the same views.

mustlovegin · 21/10/2021 09:44

They are to be smashed. Fuck that. Freedom of speech is not freedom of consequence. End of discussion

Lovely way to go about preaching tolerance

ShrillSiren · 21/10/2021 09:40

@NotDavidTennant

I find the people arguing the "debate never changes anyone's opinion" quite strange.

Are they saying that they have never changed their minds on anything? That if they heard a persuasive argument for something they didn't currently believe in that they would just adamantly refuse to change their beliefs?

Well, quite.

It's obvious that the people who like and agree with cancellation have ALL the right opinions and would never need to be cancelled. Therefore people that are cancelled must be bad and not listened to.
They couldn't possibly listen or even debate what someone else has to say and maybe change their position or encourage someone else to change theirs. Much better to put their fingers in their ears and ignore while revelling in their correctness.

goodgirlinchachaheels · 21/10/2021 09:37

Racism and homophobia are not up for debate. They are to be smashed. Fuck that. Freedom of speech is not freedom of consequence. End of discussion.

NotDavidTennant · 21/10/2021 09:32

I find the people arguing the "debate never changes anyone's opinion" quite strange.

Are they saying that they have never changed their minds on anything? That if they heard a persuasive argument for something they didn't currently believe in that they would just adamantly refuse to change their beliefs?

TheKeatingFive · 21/10/2021 09:14

Thats how it works among ordinary people.

Exactly. It's not the impact on rich powerful people. It's what it does to ordinary people's confidence to express their views.

mustlovegin · 21/10/2021 09:13

After that hullabaloo against a once beloved national treasure, how do comfortable do you think Sue in accounts would feel about objecting to workplace plans to turn the loos mixed sex? Do you think she'd feel she'd get a fair hearing, her views considered, or would she have her card marked?

Yes, the objective is to instil fear

mustlovegin · 21/10/2021 09:12

But I agree with the OP that those who are targeted can suffer real consequences in the meantime

mustlovegin · 21/10/2021 09:10

Does it fundamentally change what people think?

Do you believe that if it’s not said aloud it doesn’t exist?

I think people instigate a cancellation campaign in the hope that the belief will die out or will not catch on.

I agree that you cannot completely eradicate an idea, especially when it's supported by science or held by the majority of people

1Week · 21/10/2021 08:57

@DysmalRadius

I'm not sure I really understand - surely, in order to cancel someone, you at least have to let them know they are cancelled?

Take the example of JK Rowling - there was lots of online froth from the instigators, but that in itself sparked debate, so even if the originators of the 'cancellation' were refusing to engage, it didn't actually curb the debate itself and it certainly didn't stop JK from posting, defending herself and engaging with those who were slamming her to have her say.

Similarly, in cases where people have expressed GC views at work, any attempt at 'cancellation' still has to follow employment law which affords the 'accused' the right to defend their position and take it to tribunal etc (as with Maya Forstater etc).

So what is the mechanism by which 'cancelling' someone achieves it's goal?

It's because of the example it sets to ordinary people. After that hullabaloo against a once beloved national treasure, how do comfortable do you think Sue in accounts would feel about objecting to workplace plans to turn the loos mixed sex? Do you think she'd feel she'd get a fair hearing, her views considered, or would she have her card marked?

Thats how it works among ordinary people.

TheKeatingFive · 21/10/2021 08:34

Their views were never challenged. The only people who spoke about their concerns openly were the Farages and Trumps of this world.

Exactly. And it isn't even a surprising outcome. Of course being frozen out of engagement with one side of the debate sends people straight into the arms of the other. That's exactly what 'cancelling' is designed to achieve.

Malin52 · 21/10/2021 08:13

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g

I learned a hard lesson after the Brexit referendum. I was born in the early 1960s. Through my lifetime I genuinely thought the number of people with racist views was falling like a stone, because in the lefty liberal circles I move in nobody said these things. Then, after June 2016, the number of people expressing racist views quite openly rocketed. I realise now they never stopped thinking those things. They had just felt unable to say them openly. Brexit emboldened them to think it was fine now, they could say anything and there would be no consequences.

We had early warning of this in that incident with Gordon Brown and the woman who tried to talk to him about immigration. She wasn't a racist, she had legitimate concerns, but he pigeonholed her as a racist and fobbed her off. Refusing to talk to people about certain things doesn't mean they stop having those concerns. It means an opportunity to exchange information and views is lost and the person written off as a bigot is left feeling slighted. No wonder the far right was able to win so many people over.

This. People who had reasonable concerns about immigration were shut down as 'racist'. Their views were never challenged. The only people who spoke about their concerns openly were the Farages and Trumps of this world. The only people who spoke to their concerns. No matter if they were a little stronger.
derxa · 21/10/2021 08:06

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g

I learned a hard lesson after the Brexit referendum. I was born in the early 1960s. Through my lifetime I genuinely thought the number of people with racist views was falling like a stone, because in the lefty liberal circles I move in nobody said these things. Then, after June 2016, the number of people expressing racist views quite openly rocketed. I realise now they never stopped thinking those things. They had just felt unable to say them openly. Brexit emboldened them to think it was fine now, they could say anything and there would be no consequences.

We had early warning of this in that incident with Gordon Brown and the woman who tried to talk to him about immigration. She wasn't a racist, she had legitimate concerns, but he pigeonholed her as a racist and fobbed her off. Refusing to talk to people about certain things doesn't mean they stop having those concerns. It means an opportunity to exchange information and views is lost and the person written off as a bigot is left feeling slighted. No wonder the far right was able to win so many people over.

Excellent post
TheKeatingFive · 21/10/2021 07:47

Although I do worry that some of them might agree with the concept of wrongthink and Big Brother, since that seems to be the way that a lot of them are going.

Unfortunately yes