Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU worry that the next generation are not actually that "accepting"

466 replies

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 19:33

Long story short but chatting with 14 yo DD this evening about many subjects and a family members "views" came up. For background this family member in my view is racist and homophobic.
DD stated FM should be cancelled. Never allowed to speak, voice their opinion ever.

I pointed out to DD that freedom of speech means just that. We can all hold opinions others don't like but we are all free to voice, protest and gather regardless.
DD is of an age where discussion/debate is not an option apparently and if you are offended by another's views you just cancel them instead of debating or accepting their view as different to yours.

This worries me as instead of challenging different opinions the next generation are just silencing them.

YANBU = yes we are growing an intolerant society

YABU = They deserve to be cancelled

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 23/10/2021 01:01

I still haven’t seen one person explain what the value of continuing to give attention to this man is. After 20 years of op trying to ‘debate’ him he still thinks it’s unnatural to be gay and is racist.

It’s hard enough to help someone change who actually wants to change. This man doesn’t.

AveryGoodlay · 23/10/2021 00:46

I'm not really sure what you're wanting me to say?

Yes. Very typical really.
Usually topical.
"Read in the paper veterans are homeless while immigrats are given 4 bed houses and full benefits"
"It's always black people in gangs or drug dealing"
"I mean each to their own but its not natural two blokes'
He told my son to stay away from a certain area where we live as its a "black" area and dangerous. Yes it has very high levels of crime and very multi cultural but FM does not understand racisim plays a huge part in poverty/lack of opportunity he believes its "cos its a black area" How does this fall into the category of not causing harm to others?

Bonsaibreaker · 22/10/2021 23:57

You didn't reference your uncle in that post.

So my OP and subsequent 10 posts don't matter?

It is only an insult if you belive you took my quote out of context. Did you?

OP posts:
AveryGoodlay · 22/10/2021 23:50

You didn't reference your uncle in that post.

If you're resorting to insults, you've lost the argument.

Whether or not someone goes out of their way to cause distress or harm, that is what racist/sexist/ableist/homophobic attitudes do.

Bonsaibreaker · 22/10/2021 22:56

Avery I said my uncle does not go out of his way to cause distress or harm. I didnt say every racist or homophobe doesn't.

If you are going to quote me do so it context otherwise you look like a dick.

OP posts:
AveryGoodlay · 22/10/2021 22:51

I disagree with cancel cultute. But I also disagree with the thinking that I have to "debate" why people think I'm inferior to them because I'm black.

I'm also fed up of having to "justify" why black people or women or whoever deserves to be treated equally.

It isn't my job to educate ignorant and thick people. I don't understand why someone would fall over themselves to insist that racists/sexists/homophobes etc do not cause harm or distress to others it is a personal opinion..

crazeelala2u · 22/10/2021 14:18

@Avarua

Opinion is the lowest form of knowledge.
I absolutely will be using this saying moving forward in my life. That's brilliant.
1Week · 22/10/2021 12:25

@user1470132907

They are free to speak but not free of consequences when their speech does real harm to people in a more vulnerable position than the speaker. That’s why it’s a hate crime
Are hurt feelings real harm and is that a hate crime?

That's a very dangerous road to go down.

Brefugee · 22/10/2021 12:17

If people only hear views they agree with, they don't learn how to make calm rational arguments against those views.

Fingers in ears and "la la la i can't hear you" when you meet a racist/homophobe/transphbe whatever, means that those views are still out there, but you can't counter them. That is stupid and dangerous.

NurseButtercup · 22/10/2021 12:05

@NewlyGranny

Nobody has to debate anybody; nobody has to listen in silence to someone they disagree with, unless it's a formal debate or panel show and you're in the audience or a panel member awaiting your turn.

Freedom of speech is no guarantee everyone will be listened to; people are free to walk away if they don't like what they hear or aren't interested.

And of course intelligent, thoughtful people are open to growth and changing their ideas if they acquire new experiences or information and encounter reasoned arguments.

The trouble comes when ideas and attitudes are fixed and the person is always on transmit, never receive. That can be at any age, but is commonest, in my experience, in the very old and very young.

If FM is going to spout racist tropes in someone else's house, the householder has a right to change the subject or chide FM for being repetitive.

I've found it helpful to say something like, "We've heard your thoughts on this many times and you've heard ours. If you haven't anything new to share, perhaps we could just assume nothing's changed and talk about something that new?" And introduce a topic.

But 16yo shouldn't be left to tackle racist talk alone, lest it be perceived as teenage rebellious nonsense that nobody else holds with. FM should be the one feeling isolated in their views, not DD.

Well said

Not everyone has the capability or capacity to engage in critical thinking, which is required in order to debate and challenge harmful views and self reflect.

KrispyKale · 22/10/2021 11:40

It's a modern iteration of the shunning that was commonplace within religious communities.

user1470132907 · 22/10/2021 10:51

They are free to speak but not free of consequences when their speech does real harm to people in a more vulnerable position than the speaker. That’s why it’s a hate crime

JennieLee · 22/10/2021 10:48

My late father-in-law had worked as a colonial policeman and grew up at a time when male homosexually was illegal. My children, now adult,. understood he had grown up in a different era. He was always courteous to NHS staff and was a strong supporter of the EU. People are complicated...

Bonsaibreaker · 22/10/2021 10:38

Newley

There are a few inaccuracies in your post that I have already explained.

DD is 14 not 16
Uncle does not visit our home.
DD is not left to tackle her uncles comments on her own. In fact I have already said she doesn't have to tackle him at all.
The issue is she feels there should be no debate ever with anyone one who has opposing views.

OP posts:
Bonsaibreaker · 22/10/2021 10:17

Kanaloa

And from what op says in her updates, the daughter hasn’t said that. OP says in the opening post that she has said that, but later states that her daughter in fact doesn’t want to ‘cancel’ the uncle but she (the op) thinks her daughter should ‘debate’ him. That’s the issue

I have explained what DD means when she says cancel uncle. I have also said DD does not have to debate her uncle if she chooses not to. This wasn't about her uncle it was about her view that people with thoughts and opinions that do match her own should be cancelled, not debated with and not voice their opinions at all.

OP posts:
JumperandJacket · 22/10/2021 10:06

I read some interesting research about student bias in giving feedback on lecturers recently. Apparently student feedback tends to be hugely biased racially and sexually (more so than feedback generally)- white male lecturers are given much better feedback than black and/or female lecturers, although on any objective standard (such as student outcomes) they were no better. This was the case even where students thought of themselves as unbiased and opposed to prejudice.

I found it very interesting as an example of the harmful effects of thinking of yourself purely as good and others as bad. Were the students so sure of their lack of bias that they didn’t reflect at all? Certainly there’s a world of difference between patting yourself on the back for your lack of prejudice and actually acting without prejudice.

NewlyGranny · 22/10/2021 09:57

I do think the silencing culture is an outgrowth of SM practices where you can block to your heart's content and eliminate voices that disagree with you. It's taking this entitlement and trying to apply it in real life that creates the problems.

Kanaloa · 22/10/2021 09:56

And from what op says in her updates, the daughter hasn’t said that. OP says in the opening post that she has said that, but later states that her daughter in fact doesn’t want to ‘cancel’ the uncle but she (the op) thinks her daughter should ‘debate’ him. That’s the issue.

NewlyGranny · 22/10/2021 09:54

Nobody has to debate anybody; nobody has to listen in silence to someone they disagree with, unless it's a formal debate or panel show and you're in the audience or a panel member awaiting your turn.

Freedom of speech is no guarantee everyone will be listened to; people are free to walk away if they don't like what they hear or aren't interested.

And of course intelligent, thoughtful people are open to growth and changing their ideas if they acquire new experiences or information and encounter reasoned arguments.

The trouble comes when ideas and attitudes are fixed and the person is always on transmit, never receive. That can be at any age, but is commonest, in my experience, in the very old and very young.

If FM is going to spout racist tropes in someone else's house, the householder has a right to change the subject or chide FM for being repetitive.

I've found it helpful to say something like, "We've heard your thoughts on this many times and you've heard ours. If you haven't anything new to share, perhaps we could just assume nothing's changed and talk about something that new?" And introduce a topic.

But 16yo shouldn't be left to tackle racist talk alone, lest it be perceived as teenage rebellious nonsense that nobody else holds with. FM should be the one feeling isolated in their views, not DD.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 22/10/2021 09:36

@Kanaloa

Yes, this is where you end up with white middle class twats telling a black guy who grew up under segregation laws that he is a racist who doesn't understand privilege because he doesn't toe their line about what counts as racism.

But in this specific case this isn’t what’s happening. The uncle is telling a young mixed race girl that gay people are unnatural and gangs are only black people/only black peoples commit gang crime. I can see why she wouldn’t want to continue to listen to that - I wouldn’t either!

Not wanting to hear about it is fine. Saying he should be cancelled and never have his opinions on anything listened to ever, is not.
Kanaloa · 22/10/2021 03:40

Yes, this is where you end up with white middle class twats telling a black guy who grew up under segregation laws that he is a racist who doesn't understand privilege because he doesn't toe their line about what counts as racism.

But in this specific case this isn’t what’s happening. The uncle is telling a young mixed race girl that gay people are unnatural and gangs are only black people/only black peoples commit gang crime. I can see why she wouldn’t want to continue to listen to that - I wouldn’t either!

LobsterNapkin · 22/10/2021 03:35

@goodgirlinchachaheels

Racism and homophobia are not up for debate. They are to be smashed. Fuck that. Freedom of speech is not freedom of consequence. End of discussion.
Yes, this is where you end up with white middle class twats telling a black guy who grew up under segregation laws that he is a racist who doesn't understand privilege because he doesn't toe their line about what counts as racism.
Blackberrycream · 21/10/2021 18:05

@mustlovegin

how do you know you won't be 'smashed' in time for some of your views?

I think many people cannot grasp this important concept. Maybe they are too young to understand this, they need more life experience

This is the part some seem to be missing. Self reflection is key. Anyone who thinks they have all the answers is a little bit dangerous. As the trans debate has shown, an absolute attitude to shutting down intolerance might be the banner but in reality it is the exact opposite. 1984 indeed. Issues that have been raised here as racist would not be seen that way in a working class neighbourhood. Council housing access and priority lists stand out. The veteran memes are simplistic but refer to genuine concerns. Inner city, working class neighbourhoods are where you see the most widespread mixing of cultures. If you are not from that demographic, it might be wise to think about why people are saying what they are saying before jumping in with labels. I honestly see more casual racism from middle class, left leaning liberals than any other group. There was an example earlier on the thread. There seems to be a patronising we speak for all black people attitude.
Kite22 · 21/10/2021 16:49

First of all, fair play to you @Bonsaibreaker for keeping coming back to the thread and responding to people - even people who are twisting what you are saying.

However, I can't agree with you saying this is "the norm" at all:

It's the norm not her version.
No debate.
No opposing opinions allowed.
No voice unless it agrees.
No debate.
If an opinion thought or view will offend anyone then its the wrong view.

I speak with lots of young people, some of whom I am related to and some not, and this isn't "normal" for any of them. They will all engage and challenge views that they feel are fundamentally wrong. I don't come across this idea of "cancelling" at all.

1Week · 21/10/2021 15:15

That's understandable on an individual level.

But I think op was making the broader point that on a societal level you cant just ignore or cancel people who don't think like you do.

They vote. So either convince them of the best ideas or take away their franchise. Because cancelling great swathes of people for wrong think won't cancel the wrong think.