Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU worry that the next generation are not actually that "accepting"

466 replies

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 19:33

Long story short but chatting with 14 yo DD this evening about many subjects and a family members "views" came up. For background this family member in my view is racist and homophobic.
DD stated FM should be cancelled. Never allowed to speak, voice their opinion ever.

I pointed out to DD that freedom of speech means just that. We can all hold opinions others don't like but we are all free to voice, protest and gather regardless.
DD is of an age where discussion/debate is not an option apparently and if you are offended by another's views you just cancel them instead of debating or accepting their view as different to yours.

This worries me as instead of challenging different opinions the next generation are just silencing them.

YANBU = yes we are growing an intolerant society

YABU = They deserve to be cancelled

OP posts:
Thatsplentyjack · 20/10/2021 20:09

But race and sexuality are protected characteristics, so it's against the law to discriminate against them so....

DriftingBlue · 20/10/2021 20:07

I remember being at university back in the previous century and working for an organization that was actively targeted by a notorious hate group. We would get vile mail and the worst were the faxes because those cost us precious money in toner. While we didn’t condone the active harassment, we still defended the groups right to exist and engage in more generic political actions, even speaking on campus. We had the ability to counter with our own, better message.

I can’t condone a society that seeks to control individual beliefs and speech. That ideal is simply too important to sacrifice.

Bringham · 20/10/2021 20:07

I think the problem with debate is it has to be an open debate from both sides. Is FM likely to listen to your kid?

I have a racist family member, I have cut them out due to this. I simply do not wish to spend time with someone who has said the things they do. Mumsnet would probably call me low contact as I go to family parties where they are also present but don't engage. I'm not fb friends either

I'd never use the word cancel, but presumably another person could say I have. The low contact/no contact/grey rock has always been used though in these situations

I dont debate them. A) because its pointless. They wouldn't listen and b) because I don't want to bring each family occasion into a debate. I'm pretty sure you wouldn't want you DC to be starting debates at family parties etc. That makes me look like I'm the problem and would be accused of starting fights

I agree also that as a gay woman, having to "debate" with people who actively are against my family and is harmful usually. I simply don't engage

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 20:06

Sciurus83
Not when it comes to racism and homophobia, no we don't need to tolerate those views and hold space for them any more they are not tolerable in a civilised society

Nobody is tolerating those views. The opportunity to debate them and through debate we can change closed minds, is all I want is all I ask.
Not this cancel culture. Silence those who have apposing views is a dictatorship.
Do you want a dictatorship?

OP posts:
SecondRateFrog · 20/10/2021 20:06

@SachaStark2

But technically, what the FM is expressing is actually hate speech, if it’s motivated by racism and homophobia. Under the guise of freedom of speech.
Saying something racist or homophobic is generally not in itself a crime, though it's more likely to be in Scotland.
Freddiefox · 20/10/2021 20:05

@TractorAndHeadphones

Well in my home it me. I decide what I find acceptable in my home.
Outside the home I hear what I find sexist and homophobic comments all the time. Sometimes
I challenge them sometimes I can’t be arsed, but I don’t have to give them my time to debate with them.

The op wants her dd to debate with the FM, it’s hard to do that all the time.

EarringsandLipstick · 20/10/2021 20:05

@LuchiMangsho

Actually there is actual evidence by sociologists and economists that very few people’s views are ever changed by debate and persuasion.

It’s nice to think that this can happen. It’s actually not true. And in my personal experience on everything from sexuality to race to politics I have never met a person whose worldview has shifted significantly through debate (as opposed to changing societal norms and not being able to say sexist or racist things).

💯 this.
LuchiMangsho · 20/10/2021 20:04

Actually there is actual evidence by sociologists and economists that very few people’s views are ever changed by debate and persuasion.

It’s nice to think that this can happen. It’s actually not true. And in my personal experience on everything from sexuality to race to politics I have never met a person whose worldview has shifted significantly through debate (as opposed to changing societal norms and not being able to say sexist or racist things).

EarringsandLipstick · 20/10/2021 20:04

@LuchiMangsho

I mean as a non white person, can I say that someone expecting me to DEBATE a racist viewpoint would not be met with politeness?

It doesn’t cause me harm or distress to be told I am a lesser human being because of the colour of my skin or my sexuality??!

Yes, agree entirely.
EarringsandLipstick · 20/10/2021 20:03

I use facts and data to shoot their arguments down.

Someone who holds & voices hateful views will not be open to changing their opinion based on facts or data.

They did not arrive at their position through any evidence in the first place.

LuchiMangsho · 20/10/2021 20:02

And ‘where are you from?’ is not offensive but it’s offensive if I say ‘South London’ and you say ‘no really where are you from?’ And people who refuse to see this are the reason we need diversity training in the first place.

Most non white people are so used to microaggressions (nothing micro about something that makes me feel like shit btw), that we genuinely wouldn’t bat a lid.

VillKrill · 20/10/2021 20:01

Also, a lot of people who express racist, sexist views etc are simply ill-informed and are absolutely capable of changing their views. The answer is to talk to them, explain why their views are wrong, find out why they believe those things, etc, rather than creating a “them and us” scenario in which you start to see anyone with differing opinions as wholly inferior beings. Of course there are some people with whom it’s impossible to engage, but IME they’re in the minority. As a society we can only move forwards if we communicate openly with each other.

EarringsandLipstick · 20/10/2021 20:01

They do not cause harm or distress to others it is a personal opinion.

What?!

Of course their expression of racist or homophobic views causes harm, regardless of where it's expressed. It doesn't need to be targeted at eg a gay person or black person to be hateful & dangerous.

The beliefs that stand behind their speech must be challenged and never accepted. Not debated or given due consideration.

LuchiMangsho · 20/10/2021 20:00

I mean as a non white person, can I say that someone expecting me to DEBATE a racist viewpoint would not be met with politeness?

It doesn’t cause me harm or distress to be told I am a lesser human being because of the colour of my skin or my sexuality??!

thistimelastweek · 20/10/2021 20:00

I grew up in a household where loud passionate debate was encouraged.

I don't want to silent my opponents. I want to challenge and debate.

Bring the arguments into the light. It's the healthy way.

EarringsandLipstick · 20/10/2021 19:59

I want them to discuss and debate both points of view.

There aren't 'both points of view' for racism, homophobia or any other form of hate speech.

It's alarming you think your DD has any responsibility to discuss 'both sides' of such matters & essentially educate the (presumably older) FM.

It's entirely fair for DD to refuse to engage with such person.

However, 'cancelling' someone is an approach & a terminology i whole-heartedly reject. It's nonsensical as you can't cancel a person. It's being used to mean 'destroy their personal or professional lives, and shut them down from engaging in any activity, regardless of whether it's linked to their views or not'. And it's massively abusing the power some groups or individuals acquire.

Individuals should be called to account for their expressed views & actions, and this might have consequences which should be enacted through due process.

TractorAndHeadphones · 20/10/2021 19:59

@Bonsaibreaker

But technically, what the FM is expressing is actually hate speech, if it’s motivated by racism and homophobia. Under the guise of freedom of speech.

No its not.
They do not cause harm or distress to others it is a personal opinion.
While I disagree with them and debate it endlessly I cannot control their thoughts nor would I want to.

Instead I point out where they are wrong. I use facts and data to shoot their arguments down.

There are nearly 8 billion people on earth. They are from many different cultures, religions who decides who's opinions are wrong and who's are right?

Exactly. Nobody has the authority to cancel people.
SachaStark2 · 20/10/2021 19:59

Racism and homophobia isn’t somebody’s “personal opinion” Hmm

TractorAndHeadphones · 20/10/2021 19:58

@Freddiefox

I think it depends on where the person is voicing their opinions.

If you are sexist, you are not welcome to make sexist comments in my home.

I have to hear them outside my home, but it’s gets tiresome challenging views all the time.

If they are openly sexist, homophobic or racists why should she have to debate with them. Why give the air time.

But who has the authority to decide whether something is racist, homophobic or sexist? If someone say something like 'girls are bad at maths' or 'too many foreigners have ruined the country' fair enough, every can agree.

However in modern times anything and everything (if you follow activists and the like on Twitter) counts as some sort of 'phobic'. For example the huge fuss made around 'microagressions', where questions like 'where are you from' are considered insulting (according to a work diversity training).

Furthermore cancel culture has been used by the trans lobby to shut down very real questions about the erosion of women's right!

So yes, while people with clearly whatever-ist views shouldn't be entertained - it should be in the form of people speaking OUT against them, to their faces. Not just deleting their views, because that leads down a slippery slope.

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 19:57

But technically, what the FM is expressing is actually hate speech, if it’s motivated by racism and homophobia. Under the guise of freedom of speech.

No its not.
They do not cause harm or distress to others it is a personal opinion.
While I disagree with them and debate it endlessly I cannot control their thoughts nor would I want to.

Instead I point out where they are wrong. I use facts and data to shoot their arguments down.

There are nearly 8 billion people on earth. They are from many different cultures, religions who decides who's opinions are wrong and who's are right?

OP posts:
AnneLovesGilbert · 20/10/2021 19:56

Your daughter needs to be challenged on her views that opinions which diverge from her own can be ignored and that people should be cut off for having different views.

You should also be challenging offensive comments made in her presence.

It’s definitely a problem but it’s not got all of them yet.

My DSC are a bit younger but not much and they love a proper debate, are better at listening than a lot of adults I know, and are willing to disagree politely, go away and think about complicated topics and even, occasionally, change their minds.

Long may it last.

SachaStark2 · 20/10/2021 19:55

A teenage student of mine expressed their viewpoint quite well, I thought, with regards to hate speech a few months back. They said, “My existence is not a topic that is up for debate, and I won’t engage with somebody who thinks it is.”

Which is fair enough, I think.

The trouble is, OP, that you’re conflating cancel culture with hate speech: of course the former isn’t okay, but neither does freedom of speech protect the latter. Rightly.

Sciurus83 · 20/10/2021 19:54

Not when it comes to racism and homophobia, no we don't need to tolerate those views and hold space for them any more they are not tolerable in a civilised society. I disagree with you, why should DD or anyone, especially those affected, have to put in the emotional energy to debating the abhorrent. At some point it is ok to say NO, this is not acceptable. Racism and homophobia are the point at which now I am completely fine with that. You debate them if you feel that way, but you can't make someone else engage with abhorrent and upsetting views, they don't need to be tolerated.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 20/10/2021 19:53

I learned a hard lesson after the Brexit referendum. I was born in the early 1960s. Through my lifetime I genuinely thought the number of people with racist views was falling like a stone, because in the lefty liberal circles I move in nobody said these things. Then, after June 2016, the number of people expressing racist views quite openly rocketed. I realise now they never stopped thinking those things. They had just felt unable to say them openly. Brexit emboldened them to think it was fine now, they could say anything and there would be no consequences.

We had early warning of this in that incident with Gordon Brown and the woman who tried to talk to him about immigration. She wasn't a racist, she had legitimate concerns, but he pigeonholed her as a racist and fobbed her off. Refusing to talk to people about certain things doesn't mean they stop having those concerns. It means an opportunity to exchange information and views is lost and the person written off as a bigot is left feeling slighted. No wonder the far right was able to win so many people over.

VillKrill · 20/10/2021 19:52

YANBU. The whole idea of “cancelling” people you don’t agree with is ridiculous of course, and inherently childish; I think a lot of young people for whom this is an acceptable reaction now will grow out of it sooner or later when they’ve lived a little more and realised how dangerous authoritarianism actually is.