Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU worry that the next generation are not actually that "accepting"

466 replies

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 19:33

Long story short but chatting with 14 yo DD this evening about many subjects and a family members "views" came up. For background this family member in my view is racist and homophobic.
DD stated FM should be cancelled. Never allowed to speak, voice their opinion ever.

I pointed out to DD that freedom of speech means just that. We can all hold opinions others don't like but we are all free to voice, protest and gather regardless.
DD is of an age where discussion/debate is not an option apparently and if you are offended by another's views you just cancel them instead of debating or accepting their view as different to yours.

This worries me as instead of challenging different opinions the next generation are just silencing them.

YANBU = yes we are growing an intolerant society

YABU = They deserve to be cancelled

OP posts:
mustlovegin · 20/10/2021 20:29

Many on this thread need to go and look up a legal definition of 'hate speech'. It's not what some think it is

Bringham · 20/10/2021 20:28

@Thatsplentyjack

Really? You're a black woman and your white family member is openly racist infront of you/to you and you still have contact with them?
And expects her presumably non white daughter to try and debate him, despite acknowledging herself she's tried for years and failed.

Don't you think watching this is probably having an impact on your daughter? She's probably protective of you and seeing this play out must be very difficult

Stormyseasallround · 20/10/2021 20:28

I can welcome your right to freedom of speech while also not wanting to listen to it myself.

So I’ve heard racism / homophobia / sexism / transphobia in a wide multitude of forms already. I’ve listened, I’ve reasoned, I’ve debated. I’m still hearing the same shit. I don’t want to listen to it anymore.

I’m entitled to peace and quiet. I’m entitled to live a calm and peaceful life. I don’t need to keep engaging in the same tired old battles, with same tired old bigots.

Have your discussions, enjoy them, just not with me.

LuchiMangsho · 20/10/2021 20:27

I am going to bow out of this thread aka not debate it because in 2021 being told that it is my job to be open to debates about racism is frankly way too depressing. (I am well aware of how racist the world is btw- I just lived through Trump’s America which was fun).

Thatsplentyjack · 20/10/2021 20:26

Really? You're a black woman and your white family member is openly racist infront of you/to you and you still have contact with them?

LuchiMangsho · 20/10/2021 20:25

Mumsnet has actually always been a really horrible place for non white people. I don’t think any tides have changed.

And when people say they don’t like immigrants as my white South African friend often says (people don’t realise she’s one), when they do ‘they say oh we don’t mean people like YOU.’

I am frankly tired of having to prove my humanity and worth because of the colour of my skin by being even better.

Ledition · 20/10/2021 20:25

I think at 14 she's the same as the previous generation. Things are black and white for many kids that age - good vs bad, fair vs unfair, things are either right or wrong to them. Their brains need more time to develop and they need more life experience before they can grasp nuance and shades of grey. I was quite stubborn in my views at that age. It will pass.

Plus she's not exactly wrong about the racist/homophobic family member. That shit shouldn't be tolerated really but I must admit I have older family members who are the same and I never challenge it, I just ignore/change the subject. Unless it was said in front of the person they're insulting then I'd challenge it but otherwise there's no point, they're never going to change so it's not worth wasting time and anger on them.

LaetitiaASD · 20/10/2021 20:25

@LuchiMangsho

I mean as a non white person, can I say that someone expecting me to DEBATE a racist viewpoint would not be met with politeness?

It doesn’t cause me harm or distress to be told I am a lesser human being because of the colour of my skin or my sexuality??!

This is pretty much the only viewpoint that has any weight behind it on this thread.
Bringham · 20/10/2021 20:25

I think its a lot to expect your daughter (who I assume is also black or mixed heritage) to debate with a racist older family member, when she's seen her black mothet try and fail for years.

LaetitiaASD · 20/10/2021 20:23

@SparklyLeprechaun

I had the same views at 14. It is a very black or white age. I don't think it says anything about the next generation, we all become wiser with experience.
I'm not sure why losing a zero tolerance approach to racism or homophobia would be described as becoming wiser. I have honestly found myself getting more and more progressive and angry as I get older, and whilst I'm wavering a bit I've gone from young Tory to 18 year old labour to [much older] "Corbyn was far from perfect, but basically about right and I'd take him right now as PM above most others". [Remembers GC vs TRA. Damn]
LittleDandelionClock · 20/10/2021 20:22

Problem is, people define different things as racist, and homophobic, and bigoted.................

As a pp said, there is a world of difference between someone hating on/beating up gay men and women, and using the N word, and deplorable behaviour like making monkey noises and throwing bananas onto the football pitch etc................. and someone like that woman a pp mentioned, who expressed a genuine concern (to Gordon Brown,) about the number of immigrants coming over to the UK.

I deplore racist and homophobic behaviour, and think genuine racism and homophobia and bigotry should be called out. However, there does seem to be a hardcore of certain people, usually young, but not always, as I know a few 40 to 60 year olds like this, who call 'racist!' if someone says they disagree with so many illegal immigrants (on the boats) being allowed into the UK when we have so many of our own to look after. And they are called bigoted and hateful, if they use the wrong terminology... (Regarding a person's skin colour, or sexual orientation, or disability etc....) Many people who do use the wrong terminology occasionally very rarely mean any harm, and are almost always not 'bigoted!'

And some people are instantly accused of being thick and racist if they voted for Brexit, even though some of the most industrious and intelligent people I know voted for Brexit. I have known some far left people completely ghost someone they previously got on with well, when they discovered they voted Conservative. Not even a discussion with them or anything, they were just dead to them.

I know one woman at work who refused to engage with or acknowledge someone she knew, and called them a bigoted cunt (lovely!) because they said they couldn't tell the difference between someone from Malaysia and someone from Indonesia, as they looked similar to her. That was not racist or bigoted, she was stating a fact. She could not tell the difference. She was labelled a massive racist.

I am white, and blonde, and blue eyed, and British, and have been mistaken a number of times (when in Spain, Italy, and Greece,) for a Swede or a Norwegian. Was I offended? Not even slightly. Then again, the Indonesian woman was not offended either; it was the white, 30 year old British woman who was offended on her behalf...

So incredibly narrow-minded, intolerant, and bigoted, and yes, I agree with you @Bonsaibreaker many of these 'social justice warriors' are not remotely 'accepting' at all. These type of far left judgemental people display the kind of abhorrent and intolerant behaviour that they accuse others of. Yet they can't see it.

I am also very pleased to see such a high vote for YANBU. Showing that the tide is turning on mumsnet!

ThirdElephant · 20/10/2021 20:22

On the other hand, my own response to racist family members growing up was actually to leave the room when they started. I had learned that argument was futile- it just got heated and shouty, I was never going to change their mind.

So I see what your DD is saying.

LuchiMangsho · 20/10/2021 20:21

Phones and internet safety are not the same as racism!

Most non white people know exactly when someone has been racist towards them. And I’ll tell you that the person being racist does too.

There have been very few/ aka almost no incidents in my life (I have lived on three continents) where I have thought ‘oh I wonder if that person meant that thing quite like that.’

It’s the same as sexism. If a guy says to a woman ‘I don’t like it when you smile at other guys’ he’s not a little bit sexist or a tiny bit possessive. It’s a massive red flag.

Freddiefox · 20/10/2021 20:21

@Bonsaibreaker

I dont want DD to just ignore him. I want her to say no. I want her to challenge him. I have and despite my arguments being ignored I want the next generation to challenge him too.

He never listened to me and he probably won't listen to her but I want him to know its not just my generation its every generation after me.
I want him to see he is outdated, wrong, a bigot.
It is probably a losing battle but we all start somewhere.

It’s so tricky op, I really feel for your dd. I remember challenging an uncle of mine. It was regarding women being in the kitchen. But it was ‘just joking’ no one else challenged him, not my mum or dad, or brother, nan. No one they all sat there. It was very awkward afterwards, and I didn’t see him for a long time. Mainly because of the way it made me feel, but also because why would I want anything to do with someone who felt like that about women, particularly as you know I’m one.

Why should I have to listen to his bullshit and give it my time of day.

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 20:21

Tractot

What do you mean I have gone too far?

OP posts:
mustlovegin · 20/10/2021 20:20

YANBU OP.

MrsSkylerWhite · 20/10/2021 20:20

YANBU

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/10/2021 20:20

@Thatsplentyjack

I honestly don't think race or sexuality should be up for debate, they are things people can't change about themselves and shouldn't have to feel the need to defend or debate them. If someone choses not to accept people die to their race or sexuality then there will be no changing that persons mind.
It's vastly more nuanced than that.

I've talked an American around about Central America. He thought mass migration was an issue. A very simple bad thing. I spoke to him factually about American interventionism, trade issues, debt, war on drugs and many other issues meaning he then understood that migration was a symptom not a cause and that had the US behaved differently, Central Americans wouldn't have be forced to migrate. Also the very real benefits of migration to the US.

Frankly he was horrified some 'British girl' knew more than him.

I could have just said, "bigot, you hate all Hispanic people". And he would have learned nothing.

TractorAndHeadphones · 20/10/2021 20:20

@KrispyKale

I do think they are getting a LOT of reinforcement online to the idea of really despising people. That's what's different I think to my experience of being a rather zealous teen.
Exactly - people's first reaction is to hurl hate at each other and be reductionist.
Thatsplentyjack · 20/10/2021 20:20

And surely entering into a debate means theat you are opening yourself up to allow someone to try and convince you their opinion is the correct one, for both sides. I don't want to listen to someone try to justify and convince me that racist or homophobic views are OK.

Bringham · 20/10/2021 20:19

@KrispyKale
I think the point is that debate is usually very ineffective. In this situation for example. fm has to be willing to be non defensive, even when challenged by one of the children of the ffamily.

I'd bet lots of money that in this situation fm makes a racist comment, dc plucks up courage to say something. Fm will say its just a joke and ridicule dc for being too sensitive, if dc continues then they will be seen as picking a fight/ ruining family dinner/ being awkward. Fm won't be there for a debate, they won't be open for learning something new, they will be defensive as hell and shout about people being over sensitive

WoodburnersRUs · 20/10/2021 20:19

This is why the Tory landslide was a surprise. So many shy tories who don’t feel able to express why they vote the way they do because there is little debate, more that they don’t much want to be called “scum” or whatever. I want to know who is racist and homophobic and whatever other thoughts people have so I know who to avoid having in my friendship group. Let them say it. I want to know who they are! And I don’t want them underground, I want them out in the open, having their toxic views taken apart politely by someone cleverer than them. Won’t be hard.

LuchiMangsho · 20/10/2021 20:19

I don’t want to enter into the trans debate because genuinely every thread on tolerance on MN comes down to that. But in this case the OP OPENLY admits that the elderly family member is bigoted. There is no actual debate about his bigotry.

KikoLemons · 20/10/2021 20:19

No-one would dare to say racist speech should be allowed. But no-one can define what racist speech is. Some people can find anything racist, (or homophobic or transphobic or blasphemous or sexist or disablist or ageist....)

That's the point. You see it on MN all the time as a microcosm. PPs make an observation and everyone, (some people) pounces. We all say things every single day that could be no-platformed by a different sort of bigot, That way lies persecution and some very real horrors.

KrispyKale · 20/10/2021 20:18

I do think they are getting a LOT of reinforcement online to the idea of really despising people. That's what's different I think to my experience of being a rather zealous teen.