Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU worry that the next generation are not actually that "accepting"

466 replies

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 19:33

Long story short but chatting with 14 yo DD this evening about many subjects and a family members "views" came up. For background this family member in my view is racist and homophobic.
DD stated FM should be cancelled. Never allowed to speak, voice their opinion ever.

I pointed out to DD that freedom of speech means just that. We can all hold opinions others don't like but we are all free to voice, protest and gather regardless.
DD is of an age where discussion/debate is not an option apparently and if you are offended by another's views you just cancel them instead of debating or accepting their view as different to yours.

This worries me as instead of challenging different opinions the next generation are just silencing them.

YANBU = yes we are growing an intolerant society

YABU = They deserve to be cancelled

OP posts:
Tittyfilarious81 · 20/10/2021 20:43

I hate cancel culture it teaches the next generation nothing at all about how to handle other people with different views . I've told my 15 year old if you don't like what someone says to you then go ahead and have an alternative opinion and if you don't agree with each other so be it.

Silenceisgolden20 · 20/10/2021 20:43

Racism is not difference of opinion. That is completely minimising it. It is hurtful, damaging and it destroys people's lives.

I'm bowing out, I think silence is better this as I will only get cross at this thread and go round in circles.

Heiferr · 20/10/2021 20:43

Why isn’t her lack of contact with him enough to teach him that his views are not acceptable to her! Why if the only way for her to communicate her disgust with his views be to debate with him.

This isn’t done uni debating club, this is her home or family. Why should she teach him. Let him learn from her absence.
Silence speaks volumes to.

1000% this.

@Bonsaibreaker it seems as if you are using your daughters stance on this to prove your own point about cancel culture. You need to separate the two. The fact that she has a strong enough opinion about said family member tells you that she's able to make a decision about who she wants to invest her time interacting with. In your position, I'd back her rather than banging the cancel culture drum.

Bringham · 20/10/2021 20:43

@Bonsaibreaker

Silenceisgolden20

As I am trying to teach my DD differences of opinion are ok.

If if those opinions are that her/her mothers skin colour presumably makes them inferior? That should be equally considered as the belief your family is equal to all other families?
Briony123 · 20/10/2021 20:42

Very few people ever actually listen to random family members they disagree with. The ranting racist grandparent would always just be ignored, surely that's "cancelling" them, they just never realised it?

RudestLittleMadam · 20/10/2021 20:42

The way I see it and what I teach my children is: we have freewill. We can say and do what we want to but there are repercussions if we say or do something bad. This works both ways. So for example, you don’t have to listen to other people's bigotry and they don’t have to listen to yours (if it is you that is the bigot). Works well enough for people you know like racist family members.

I don’t agree with cancelling people on social media or similar for their views alone unless they are inciting hatred (eg someone like Tommy Robinson). I prefer to know exactly who the racists/homophobes/misogynists are so I can choose to listen to them or not.

ejhhhhh · 20/10/2021 20:42

I agree with PPs who've suggested that refusing to tolerate racist/sexist/homophobic views is probably a better way of changing opinions than debating them. We don't tolerate lots of things that harm others, I don't see hate speech as being much different to driving whilst drunk for example. Lots of people of my father's generation used to drink and drive because they were mistakenly of the opinion that it was fine. Likewise my grandmother was openly racist. My dad stopped drinking and driving and my grandma stopped being racist in public not because anyone engaged in debate with them, but just because it was outright socially unacceptable. Some things we just don't need to debate. Tbh, I think the responsible thing to do, as a parent, is to stop seeing your racist and homophobic FM until they stop being racist and homophobic in your presence, and tell them why you've cut contact. That'll probably be more effective than debating with them.

LowlandLucky · 20/10/2021 20:41

The cancel brigade are the most intolerant bullies but can't see how vile they are.

Bringham · 20/10/2021 20:41

@Siameasy
The situation here those is the OP is a black woman who has been debating her openly racist elderly white male relative for years with zero effect and now expects her 14 year old daughter to continue this on(even though it appears she wants nothing to do with him)

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 20:40

Silenceisgolden20

As I am trying to teach my DD differences of opinion are ok.

OP posts:
toconclude · 20/10/2021 20:39

She's 14. I used to hear this kind of thing from teens in the 70s,80s,90s and 00s.You're catastrophising.

LittleDandelionClock · 20/10/2021 20:38

@EeeByeGummieBear

Unfortunately not engaging in debate isn't just what younger people do. I have recently been 'cancelled' by two people in their 40s who I volunteer with. I expressed a different point of view and asked for further discussion. I was told I was missing the point and shut me down. Surely if I was missing the point we needed to discuss it further? I've never been in this situation before as I've always worked places were discussion was accepted or even encouraged.
Oooh, I am curious now. What did you say?
Siameasy · 20/10/2021 20:38

@Bringham

You agree they are racist and homophobic though? Do you think DC should just listen to their beliefs?

The right to freedom of speech doesnr cover hate speech

But what is “hate speech”? Surely that is a subjective term.

Even whether something is racist or homophobic can be subjective.

For instance I can legally stand in my local high street with a placard saying “homosexuality is a sin” or “I’m against gay marriage”. Even if you thought that was “homophobic” I am legally allowed to express that view.

Part of growing up is understanding that there are few facts, many opinions.

Sneezecakesmama · 20/10/2021 20:37

Its scary that universities bar speakers with views they dislike. If we can't have open discussion there and debate why the speakers views are abhorrent then where?

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 20:36

Thatsplentyjack

Really? You're a black woman and your white family member is openly racist infront of you/to you and you still have contact with them?

Strangley yes.
He never uses derogatory language and is very loving towards my children but he always "others" me.
He will make comments about immigrants and "gangs" he means black gangs but he's racist but not white person racist if that makes sense?

OP posts:
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 20/10/2021 20:35

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g

I learned a hard lesson after the Brexit referendum. I was born in the early 1960s. Through my lifetime I genuinely thought the number of people with racist views was falling like a stone, because in the lefty liberal circles I move in nobody said these things. Then, after June 2016, the number of people expressing racist views quite openly rocketed. I realise now they never stopped thinking those things. They had just felt unable to say them openly. Brexit emboldened them to think it was fine now, they could say anything and there would be no consequences.

We had early warning of this in that incident with Gordon Brown and the woman who tried to talk to him about immigration. She wasn't a racist, she had legitimate concerns, but he pigeonholed her as a racist and fobbed her off. Refusing to talk to people about certain things doesn't mean they stop having those concerns. It means an opportunity to exchange information and views is lost and the person written off as a bigot is left feeling slighted. No wonder the far right was able to win so many people over.

Exactly this. There was a thread on Gordon Brown recently and a lot of posters just kept on posting “but that woman was a racist/bigot etc” on the flimsiest of evidence and Gordon’s say so. It is very worrying.
Silenceisgolden20 · 20/10/2021 20:34

@Bonsaibreaker

I dont want DD thinking she can be complacent.

Walking away is the easy option and changes very little.
I am trying to teach her that if you believe in something it's OK to stay and fight. You just have to fight the right way.
No its not her job to educate a 74 yo racist white man. However as the next generation she as we all did before her have a responsibility to at least try.

This thread is about tolerance of others opinions good or bad in my view, I shall read them all.

I disagree. It is not your 14 year old daughters responsibility to try and educate him on racism. A grown man knows how to do that, he knows damn well. That is not tolerance of opinions. Racism is not an opinion, it is wrong. End of. There is no discussion
Bringham · 20/10/2021 20:33

@Bonsaibreaker

I'd argue its complacent to keep debating the same person for years about racism when youre a black woman who's children are being exposed to those views and knowing that their mother has exhaustively tried to get a family member to see them, and their skin colour as equal for years. Time comes when it's important to protect yourself and your daughter

Why are you asking your daughter to be around someone that thinks she and her mother are inferior because of skin? Let alone encouraging her to engage him on it?

Thatsplentyjack · 20/10/2021 20:33

Honestly OP you should have cut contact with your family member a long time ago. Your dd shouldn't have to deal with that shit at such a young age, and I'm assuming he's been around her whole life. Watching you fail to change his mind for 14 years will surely have impacted her in some way.

Freddiefox · 20/10/2021 20:33

@Bonsaibreaker

I dont want DD thinking she can be complacent.

Walking away is the easy option and changes very little.
I am trying to teach her that if you believe in something it's OK to stay and fight. You just have to fight the right way.
No its not her job to educate a 74 yo racist white man. However as the next generation she as we all did before her have a responsibility to at least try.

This thread is about tolerance of others opinions good or bad in my view, I shall read them all.

Why isn’t her lack of contact with him enough to teach him that his views are not acceptable to her! Why if the only way for her to communicate her disgust with his views be to debate with him.

This isn’t done uni debating club, this is her home or family. Why should she teach him. Let him learn from her absence.
Silence speaks volumes to.

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/10/2021 20:33

@LuchiMangsho

Mumsnet has actually always been a really horrible place for non white people. I don’t think any tides have changed.

And when people say they don’t like immigrants as my white South African friend often says (people don’t realise she’s one), when they do ‘they say oh we don’t mean people like YOU.’

I am frankly tired of having to prove my humanity and worth because of the colour of my skin by being even better.

I love this one.

"How so?" And wait. People blush to the tips of their hair often.

I also deliberately refer to myself as an immigrant rather than an expat (stupid nonsense) and align myself with other immigrants because white immigrants I think have a duty of solidarity.

SarahAndQuack · 20/10/2021 20:32

I think every generation imagines their blend of bigotries and tolerances is 'the norm' and judges accordingly.

I can remember as a child, my dad was quite leftie and very keen to tell us what an awful thing discrimination was, and how important it was not to be racist or sexist or homophobic. But, of course, it was natural to think queers were disgusting, and obviously mum did the childcare because she was innately better and it, and the gypsies probably did nick stuff after all ...

I am sure when my DD is old enough to start lecturing me, she will be quite able to tell me what an awful person I am, and I will probably feel she should be more accepting as my views are just my opinions, aren't they? Since I am such a tolerant liberal type, and all.

(I will obviously try to question my beliefs if she does lecture me, but I bet we'll disagree sometimes too.)

Silenceisgolden20 · 20/10/2021 20:31

@Bonsaibreaker

But technically, what the FM is expressing is actually hate speech, if it’s motivated by racism and homophobia. Under the guise of freedom of speech.

No its not.
They do not cause harm or distress to others it is a personal opinion.
While I disagree with them and debate it endlessly I cannot control their thoughts nor would I want to.

Instead I point out where they are wrong. I use facts and data to shoot their arguments down.

There are nearly 8 billion people on earth. They are from many different cultures, religions who decides who's opinions are wrong and who's are right?

But racism does cause hurt and distress?
EeeByeGummieBear · 20/10/2021 20:31

Unfortunately not engaging in debate isn't just what younger people do.
I have recently been 'cancelled' by two people in their 40s who I volunteer with. I expressed a different point of view and asked for further discussion. I was told I was missing the point and shut me down. Surely if I was missing the point we needed to discuss it further?
I've never been in this situation before as I've always worked places were discussion was accepted or even encouraged.

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 20:29

I dont want DD thinking she can be complacent.

Walking away is the easy option and changes very little.
I am trying to teach her that if you believe in something it's OK to stay and fight. You just have to fight the right way.
No its not her job to educate a 74 yo racist white man. However as the next generation she as we all did before her have a responsibility to at least try.

This thread is about tolerance of others opinions good or bad in my view, I shall read them all.

OP posts: