Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU worry that the next generation are not actually that "accepting"

466 replies

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 19:33

Long story short but chatting with 14 yo DD this evening about many subjects and a family members "views" came up. For background this family member in my view is racist and homophobic.
DD stated FM should be cancelled. Never allowed to speak, voice their opinion ever.

I pointed out to DD that freedom of speech means just that. We can all hold opinions others don't like but we are all free to voice, protest and gather regardless.
DD is of an age where discussion/debate is not an option apparently and if you are offended by another's views you just cancel them instead of debating or accepting their view as different to yours.

This worries me as instead of challenging different opinions the next generation are just silencing them.

YANBU = yes we are growing an intolerant society

YABU = They deserve to be cancelled

OP posts:
Siameasy · 20/10/2021 21:02

[quote Bringham]@Siameasy
The situation here those is the OP is a black woman who has been debating her openly racist elderly white male relative for years with zero effect and now expects her 14 year old daughter to continue this on(even though it appears she wants nothing to do with him)[/quote]
I think the DD should just disengage with the FM. But this idea of “cancelling” is silly. Cancelling isn’t real. Its arrogant to think that because I shun or avoid someone that that person is “cancelled”. Unless they die, said person continues as before but no longer had contact with you!

As a wider debate though I hear the term “hate speech” a lot but I find it a meaningless term. And goodness we do need to remember the difference between subjective and objective.

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 21:01

That's fine, and they absolutely should be challenged, but I don't think it's up to your 14 year old daughter to challenge a family member on their views when she doesn't want to.

She is not doing it on her own. She does want to but the current "cancel" culture makes the youth of today lazy and complacent.

OP posts:
Blofeld · 20/10/2021 21:01

*Grey areas

Silenceisgolden20 · 20/10/2021 21:01

@Bonsaibreaker

Bringham

You've allowed this in the guise of teaching her not to walk away, you've exposed her to this for years by your own admission. Its okay to not engage with someone who is being actively hurtful to her

Of course I exposed her to this. I am black their father is white do you think racisim is new to them?
What I hope I am teaching her is not to walk away. I hope I am teaching her to fight for the opinions she holds and not back down to peer pressure or social media.
Yes she loves her uncle and he's only ever been kind to her but that should not mean she cannot challenge him.

How is he being kind to her with racist views? Eh?
Blofeld · 20/10/2021 21:01

Although I can see where you’re coming from, being racist and homophobic AND specifically discriminating against people with protected characteristics is against the law - equality act 2010. So there’s not really a debate to be had and society has deemed these views unacceptable.

However there are many very areas of course which does make it less clear cut

Silenceisgolden20 · 20/10/2021 21:00

@Bonsaibreaker

Racism is not difference of opinion. That is completely minimising it. It is hurtful, damaging and it destroys people's lives.

Nobody is minimising it ffs.

7 billion people on the planet some of them are racist. Should they be? Of course not but that doesn't mean racisim doesn't exist!
Some people are misogynistic
Some are sexist.
Some are homophobic
We need to challenge those views in order to change them instead of pretending 7 billion people all think the same way. That's just stupid.

But you are. You are saying it is a difference of opinion. Ffs yourself!.
Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 20:58

Bringham

You've allowed this in the guise of teaching her not to walk away, you've exposed her to this for years by your own admission. Its okay to not engage with someone who is being actively hurtful to her

Of course I exposed her to this. I am black their father is white do you think racisim is new to them?
What I hope I am teaching her is not to walk away. I hope I am teaching her to fight for the opinions she holds and not back down to peer pressure or social media.
Yes she loves her uncle and he's only ever been kind to her but that should not mean she cannot challenge him.

OP posts:
Flingingmelon · 20/10/2021 20:58

YANBU - I do think views should be challenged and I don't think that people should be automatically canceled, even if their opinions are abhorrent.

When I think the issue lies on both sides, is that tolerance and respect seem to have been completely left by the wayside. And by tolerance I mean just that - not to be confused with acceptance.

There was a self ID discussion in the comments of a Simple Politics Instagram post recently and I nearly fell off my chair in shock as it unfolded. Tolerance and respect was front and centre. The people discussing did not agree, but no one was called anything nasty and it really appeared as though everyone was looking for common ground.

I thought my eyes were broken, it's become so unusual.

PurpleOkapi · 20/10/2021 20:58

Most people hold a rather more nuanced worldview at 40 than they did at 14. Your DD probably will, too. The subject matter (racism, etc.) may change over time and through different generations, but the basic pattern really doesn't.

Thatsplentyjack · 20/10/2021 20:56

@Bonsaibreaker

Racism is not difference of opinion. That is completely minimising it. It is hurtful, damaging and it destroys people's lives.

Nobody is minimising it ffs.

7 billion people on the planet some of them are racist. Should they be? Of course not but that doesn't mean racisim doesn't exist!
Some people are misogynistic
Some are sexist.
Some are homophobic
We need to challenge those views in order to change them instead of pretending 7 billion people all think the same way. That's just stupid.

That's fine, and they absolutely should be challenged, but I don't think it's up to your 14 year old daughter to challenge a family member on their views when she doesn't want to.
Tilltheend99 · 20/10/2021 20:56

You are neither right nor wrong. It’s also ironic that you want people to vote on this lol.

Your racist relative deserves to have their views rigorously rebuffed but there comes a point where a stubborn person who won’t look at things from a different view point maybe need to just be ignored. Which is not dissimilar to being ‘cancelled.’

Your daughter is also taking an extreme hardline and may need to consider generational, cultural, educational opportunities, lack of access to travel etc in judging if this person should be cancelled or if they can be persuaded that they should be more tolerant through discussion or meeting a wider circle of people.

I feel sorry for gen z as the fear of being judged on social media is palpable for them. To me it is a hobby, a networking tool, a debating platform, and a place to share information. That’s because I grew up in a time when the internet was not wide spread which gives me perspective.

To these kids it is there whole platform onto the world and how they are perceived there is much more important than the ‘real world’ They feel they can’t put a foot wrong. If the consensus is to ‘cancel’ someone it would be very hard to go against the consensus (luckily the consensus is usually about positive concepts like anti racism etc)

This also spills into other things. Myself and DH have noticed that the younger colleagues we know who are just starting out are often very reluctant to give their own opinions on things or to put forward their own ideas. They are also easily swayed by a more popular seeming view point, They are scared to be wrong.

It’s not really their fault. Critical thinking, debate, and media studies should be part of the compulsory core curriculum. But Michael Gove really narrowed education down so that it was just about transferable employment skills. The Oxbridge elite don’t want the general public using critical thinking. Employers will eventually struggle anyway as in most cases staff do need to think for themselves to bring about any sort of innovation.

Marchingredsoldiers · 20/10/2021 20:55

Cancelling is very powerful. It is like casting someone on desert island. It is an attempt to cut someone out of their community, which humans need to survive. We are hard-wired to interact with others and removal of that interaction is pretty cruel.

Wishing to cancel someone is as lacking in empathy as the other person being rasist. It is used as a punishment because the other person has broken some social code.

Obviously it doesn't work like that in real life because it would need everyone to cut the "offender" off. And that doesn't happen. But that is what the OP's dd is trying to do. Teenagers are still developing empathy. This could be an opportunity to train it.

DriftingBlue · 20/10/2021 20:53

Op, while I am against censorship and cancel culture, I think you are taking the wrong approach with your child and this family member.

No individual ever has a responsibility to engage with a person expressing hateful ideas. Refusing to be closely involved with that person is always an option. Limiting contact with a family member that causes you pain isn’t cancel culture. If your child were trying to get your family member fired, removed from housing, or otherwise ostracized by the greater society, that would be engaging in cancellation. Your teen is just doing what normal people do, recognizing a harmful situation and disengaging.

Freddiefox · 20/10/2021 20:52

@Bonsaibreaker

Why isn’t her lack of contact with him enough to teach him that his views are not acceptable to her! Why if the only way for her to communicate her disgust with his views be to debate with him.

Nowhere have I said she is lack of contact. You made that up.

@Bonsaibreaker

You said she wants to cancel him.

I’ve not said she had no contact with him currently. I’ve not made anything up.

I’m suggesting that rather then debate with him she has no contact with him, and that teaches him a lesson, rather than her engaging him.

Why should she had to teach him?

Thatsplentyjack · 20/10/2021 20:52

@Heiferr

This thread proves exactly why we still have such an issue with racism. So many people categorising racism as a "difference of opinion". If that is what is being perpetuated in homes, I worry more about that than I ever would about cancel culture.
I completely agree. I can't quite believe how many people are calling out and out racism and homophobia "a difference of opinion", its not.
TheVanguardSix · 20/10/2021 20:52

I think you're homing in on 'debate' too much when "I want DD to be able to debate why racism and homophobia are wrong" really isn't up for debate, is it?
Critical thinking is where you want to lead her.
I think you've blurred the lines between differences of opinion and hate speech, OP. Sorry, but I don't care how nice FM is. They say Jeffrey Dahmer was a charmer. I still wouldn't have a drink with the guy. Not comparing your FM to a serial killer, but you don't need to be nice about a racist just because they give the kids extra sweeties when they visit. A lot of assholes are lovely people and vice versa.

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 20:51

Racism is not difference of opinion. That is completely minimising it. It is hurtful, damaging and it destroys people's lives.

Nobody is minimising it ffs.

7 billion people on the planet some of them are racist. Should they be? Of course not but that doesn't mean racisim doesn't exist!
Some people are misogynistic
Some are sexist.
Some are homophobic
We need to challenge those views in order to change them instead of pretending 7 billion people all think the same way. That's just stupid.

OP posts:
Thatsplentyjack · 20/10/2021 20:48

And actually if you were standing in the middle of a town center shouting "I hate black people", I think you may be taken away by police. I could be wrong though.

Bringham · 20/10/2021 20:48

@Bonsaibreaker

Bringham and now expects her 14 year old daughter to continue this on(even though it appears she wants nothing to do with him)

Actually no.
I expecty daughter to challenge things she feels passionate about.
I dont care if she challenges fox hunting or global warming. I just want her to challenge not cancel.

Where would be be if we all gave up at the first hurdle?

It's not the first hurdle though is it? She's watched her mother debate this man for years and get no where. She's not left at the first sign if trouble, she's watched this man spout his views on her, her family and why they aren't equal for years.

You've allowed this in the guise of teaching her not to walk away, you've exposed her to this for years by your own admission. Its okay to not engage with someone who is being actively hurtful to her

Thatsplentyjack · 20/10/2021 20:47

Here you go @Siameasy. I didn't actually use the term hate speech, but a pp (not sure if it was you) said some people needed to look up the definition, because it doesn't mean what a lot of people think, yet it does mean what I thought it ment. Just thought I better double check.

*hate speech

noun

abusive or threatening speech or writing that expresses prejudice against a particular group, especially on the basis of race, religion, or sexual orientation.

"we don't tolerate any form of hate speech*

I don't think it is always subjective. Some opinions are just blatant hate speech.

MeAndDebbieMcGee · 20/10/2021 20:47

The concept of hate speech and particularly hate speech being a criminal offence is relatively new and we're still getting to grips with it. Time will tell if it's useful overall or not to categorise communication in this way. I tend to think not, on the whole, but a lot of people disagree with me.

DandyHighwayWoman · 20/10/2021 20:47

I detest the term ‘cancelled’

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 20:47

Why isn’t her lack of contact with him enough to teach him that his views are not acceptable to her! Why if the only way for her to communicate her disgust with his views be to debate with him.

Nowhere have I said she is lack of contact. You made that up.

OP posts:
Heiferr · 20/10/2021 20:46

This thread proves exactly why we still have such an issue with racism. So many people categorising racism as a "difference of opinion". If that is what is being perpetuated in homes, I worry more about that than I ever would about cancel culture.

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 20:45

Bringham
and now expects her 14 year old daughter to continue this on(even though it appears she wants nothing to do with him)

Actually no.
I expecty daughter to challenge things she feels passionate about.
I dont care if she challenges fox hunting or global warming. I just want her to challenge not cancel.

Where would be be if we all gave up at the first hurdle?

OP posts: