Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU worry that the next generation are not actually that "accepting"

466 replies

Bonsaibreaker · 20/10/2021 19:33

Long story short but chatting with 14 yo DD this evening about many subjects and a family members "views" came up. For background this family member in my view is racist and homophobic.
DD stated FM should be cancelled. Never allowed to speak, voice their opinion ever.

I pointed out to DD that freedom of speech means just that. We can all hold opinions others don't like but we are all free to voice, protest and gather regardless.
DD is of an age where discussion/debate is not an option apparently and if you are offended by another's views you just cancel them instead of debating or accepting their view as different to yours.

This worries me as instead of challenging different opinions the next generation are just silencing them.

YANBU = yes we are growing an intolerant society

YABU = They deserve to be cancelled

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bonsaibreaker · 24/10/2021 08:14

This is a very confused thread and probably a result of OP trying to fit in with white relatives her whole life, and now teaching her dd to do the same.

🤣

OP posts:
SharonasCorona · 24/10/2021 07:51

@slashlover

OP you say this I am trying to teach her she can choose to engage or not but that's not true is it? Other post say

I want DD to challenge them.
I want them to discuss and debate both points of view. I want DD to be able to debate why racisim and homophobia are wrong.
I dont want DD to just ignore him.
I want her to say no.
I want her to challenge him.
I dont want DD thinking she can be complacent.
Walking away is the easy option and changes very little.
I am trying to teach her that if you believe in something it's OK to stay and fight. You just have to fight the right way.
I expecty daughter to challenge things she feels passionate about.
I dont care if she challenges fox hunting or global warming. I just want her to challenge not cancel.
What I hope I am teaching her is not to walk away. I hope I am teaching her to fight for the opinions she holds and not back down to peer pressure or social media.

If your DD doesn't want to engage with this man then she doesn't have to. She's seen you try and fail for 14 YEARS so why should she continue to try when she knows it's futile?

Yes, and she has already cancelled him by not allowing him in her home, and yet expects a lot more from her dd.

This is a very confused thread and probably a result of OP trying to fit in with white relatives her whole life, and now teaching her dd to do the same.

Puppermam · 24/10/2021 07:46

You can't debate racism. I agree with your daughter.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 24/10/2021 07:43

@Kite22

Las few posts have been a bit strange. SharonasCorona - you need to read the thread again, as that definitely isn't what the OP is saying AT ALL. Hmm

and GirlCat - you are just making stuff up.
This isn't what the thread is about either if you read it through.

Why do people just make stuff up on threads like this ? Confused

They’ve tasted blood.
SharonasCorona · 24/10/2021 07:40

@LittleDandelionClock

Problem is, people define different things as racist, and homophobic, and bigoted.................

As a pp said, there is a world of difference between someone hating on/beating up gay men and women, and using the N word, and deplorable behaviour like making monkey noises and throwing bananas onto the football pitch etc................. and someone like that woman a pp mentioned, who expressed a genuine concern (to Gordon Brown,) about the number of immigrants coming over to the UK.

I deplore racist and homophobic behaviour, and think genuine racism and homophobia and bigotry should be called out. However, there does seem to be a hardcore of certain people, usually young, but not always, as I know a few 40 to 60 year olds like this, who call 'racist!' if someone says they disagree with so many illegal immigrants (on the boats) being allowed into the UK when we have so many of our own to look after. And they are called bigoted and hateful, if they use the wrong terminology... (Regarding a person's skin colour, or sexual orientation, or disability etc....) Many people who do use the wrong terminology occasionally very rarely mean any harm, and are almost always not 'bigoted!'

And some people are instantly accused of being thick and racist if they voted for Brexit, even though some of the most industrious and intelligent people I know voted for Brexit. I have known some far left people completely ghost someone they previously got on with well, when they discovered they voted Conservative. Not even a discussion with them or anything, they were just dead to them.

I know one woman at work who refused to engage with or acknowledge someone she knew, and called them a bigoted cunt (lovely!) because they said they couldn't tell the difference between someone from Malaysia and someone from Indonesia, as they looked similar to her. That was not racist or bigoted, she was stating a fact. She could not tell the difference. She was labelled a massive racist.

I am white, and blonde, and blue eyed, and British, and have been mistaken a number of times (when in Spain, Italy, and Greece,) for a Swede or a Norwegian. Was I offended? Not even slightly. Then again, the Indonesian woman was not offended either; it was the white, 30 year old British woman who was offended on her behalf...

So incredibly narrow-minded, intolerant, and bigoted, and yes, I agree with you @Bonsaibreaker many of these 'social justice warriors' are not remotely 'accepting' at all. These type of far left judgemental people display the kind of abhorrent and intolerant behaviour that they accuse others of. Yet they can't see it.

I am also very pleased to see such a high vote for YANBU. Showing that the tide is turning on mumsnet!

I am also very pleased to see such a high vote for YANBU. Showing that the tide is turning on mumsnet!

Because we don’t want to sit and talk to racists and don’t see racism as a ‘difference of opinion’? And that makes me judgemental and intolerant?

It’s attitudes like these that make me pull away from white people and think I’m better off with my Asian, South East Asian and black friends.

Kite22 · 24/10/2021 00:01

Las few posts have been a bit strange.
SharonasCorona - you need to read the thread again, as that definitely isn't what the OP is saying AT ALL. Hmm

and GirlCat - you are just making stuff up.
This isn't what the thread is about either if you read it through.

Why do people just make stuff up on threads like this ? Confused

Blackberrycream · 23/10/2021 21:11

Well this thread has taken quite weird turn.
A mother of a mixed race child is being told her child is doubly vulnerable hmmm. I hope those lecturing her are actually bringing up black or mixed race children. If not, the presumption is quite something.
You cannot shield your child from racism. You teach them to navigate it and aim to give them the confidence to go out into the world knowing their own worth.
Calling out every instance would really not help them. Nobody does that. It is utterly unrealistic. It’s actually not the open statements that impact as much as the more subtle slights and assumptions. They are much harder to address as well.

Bonsaibreaker · 23/10/2021 20:13

You have clearly not read the thread Girlcat

My DD is no more vulnerable than the next 14 yo why are you trying to make her a victim?

Yes I want DD to be able to debate and have a voice. I want her to know she can despite being female and black her voice can be heard but so can the voices that disagree with her.

Are you saying that because my DD is black I should advise her to stay silent?

OP posts:
1Week · 23/10/2021 20:01

Jeez leave OP alone. Its a valid question to ask, is debate better than cancellation, within the family or in broader society. A timely question at that.

She is not forcing her DD to do anything but obviously like any mother she has a preference and advice she'd give to her child.

TheGirlCat · 23/10/2021 20:00

@Bonsaibreaker

your vulnerable daughter Where have I said she is vulnerable?

Why are you making stuff up?

A 14 year old child is vulnerable. She's also doubly vulnerable as a mixed race child, so is vulnerable to the opinions of her FM. Sorry you as her parent and adult don't understand this and needed that a 14 year old is vulnerable to even be explained to you. Hmm
TheGirlCat · 23/10/2021 19:58

@Bonsaibreaker

I dont want DD thinking she can be complacent.

Walking away is the easy option and changes very little.
I am trying to teach her that if you believe in something it's OK to stay and fight. You just have to fight the right way.
No its not her job to educate a 74 yo racist white man. However as the next generation she as we all did before her have a responsibility to at least try.

This thread is about tolerance of others opinions good or bad in my view, I shall read them all.

NO! It is not the 'responsibility' of a 14 year old to even try to educate anyone. And you have no right to think it is. How dare you. Quite frankly I am concerned at the harm you are doing to your daughter. Sometimes walking away is the safest and most wisest move to make. Unfortunately you seem to lack the wisdom and maturity to realise this. In this, your daughter is way ahead of you and you could learn from her.
Bonsaibreaker · 23/10/2021 19:42

your vulnerable daughter
Where have I said she is vulnerable?

Why are you making stuff up?

OP posts:
TheGirlCat · 23/10/2021 19:37

@Bonsaibreaker

I dont want DD to just ignore him. I want her to say no. I want her to challenge him. I have and despite my arguments being ignored I want the next generation to challenge him too.

He never listened to me and he probably won't listen to her but I want him to know its not just my generation its every generation after me.
I want him to see he is outdated, wrong, a bigot.
It is probably a losing battle but we all start somewhere.

OP, maybe your DD as a BAME woman doesn't have the emotional energy to expend on a man she knows is a waste of her breath. You have the right to challenge him if you wish, but you don't have the right to ask your vulnerable daughter who may not have the mental health or energy to do so, to challenge him. Her choice and how she deals with him is her path to choose. You can't force her to be like you. Just because you have the emotional energy doesn't mean she does. Her cancelling a racist - UNREPENTANT racist at that (since if he won't change his mind for you, an adult, he isn't going to for a 'silly child' - in his opinion) is a valid option for her and you must respect it and accept it. Mental health is important.
Blackberrycream · 23/10/2021 19:23

@SharonasCorona

It seems to be the general gist of this thread is it’s ok to spend time with racist and homophobic people.

Which scares the shit out of BAME people like me.

I don’t think that’s the argument at all. The argument is who decides.I’m deeply suspicious of people who presume that they are free of bias. Some of the incidents pointed out as racist on this thread are in my opinion being seen through a class bias. A pp pointed out research into racial bias in students. We are all a product of our experiences to some extent. Older Jamaican communities can be quite homophobic So can other BAME ( sorry I don’t like that but you used it) groups. I don’t agree with those views and make that clear but I don’t think the way forward is cutting people off. Things improve as people mix I think.
Bonsaibreaker · 23/10/2021 19:16

It really isn't the gist. Every poster has called out my FM but the point of the thread is the no debate/cancel attitude some have seen that others have just focused on FM.

OP posts:
SharonasCorona · 23/10/2021 18:44

It seems to be the general gist of this thread is it’s ok to spend time with racist and homophobic people.

Which scares the shit out of BAME people like me.

Kite22 · 23/10/2021 18:09

If people only hear views they agree with, they don't learn how to make calm rational arguments against those views.

Fingers in ears and "la la la i can't hear you" when you meet a racist/homophobe/transphbe whatever, means that those views are still out there, but you can't counter them. That is stupid and dangerous.

Totally agree with this.
Frighteningly even more so with the way the internet "listens" to your views and gives you lots of "feeds" of only groups that agree with you - so people become more and more entrenched in their own thinking as they only hear the views of others that agree with them.
I whiled away many, many hours in my teens and 20s debating all sorts of things with other people. It is how you learn and how you help other people learn. It is about listening to what other people's experience is, what their thoughts are, and conceding they might have a point about a, b, and c, and that you can see what they are saying, but that with X, Y, and Z, what they are saying can clearly be proven to be wrong, or that it is offensive (and explain why it is offensive), or whatever issue you have with what is being said.
Sticking your fingers in your ears and refusing to engage with anyone who has different views from you is a very narrow way of thinking, and quite worrying if lots of people start to do that.

Bonsaibreaker · 23/10/2021 16:10

Not your DD's role to debate him. The point about not shutting out views is good however

I never said it was her role.
Please read the thread. I have explained that this is not about her debating her uncle but her views on debate and cancel culture.

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 23/10/2021 16:01

@Bonsaibreaker

Kanaloa

And from what op says in her updates, the daughter hasn’t said that. OP says in the opening post that she has said that, but later states that her daughter in fact doesn’t want to ‘cancel’ the uncle but she (the op) thinks her daughter should ‘debate’ him. That’s the issue

I have explained what DD means when she says cancel uncle. I have also said DD does not have to debate her uncle if she chooses not to. This wasn't about her uncle it was about her view that people with thoughts and opinions that do match her own should be cancelled, not debated with and not voice their opinions at all.

Just read the update... this is not U...

this trhead somehow loads weirdly for me so now im confused

TractorAndHeadphones · 23/10/2021 15:59

@Bonsaibreaker

Tractot

What do you mean I have gone too far?

Not your DD's role to debate him. The point about not shutting out views is good however
Cameleongirl · 23/10/2021 14:50

@mustlovegin. That too, of course!

mustlovegin · 23/10/2021 09:06

In other words, real life is far more complicated than cancel culture suggests and that’s the dilemma. Cancel someone you love, try to change them with rational arguments, or do nothing?

Can't they just agree not to discuss these topics? That's a reasonable way forward

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 23/10/2021 07:46

@NewlyGranny

I do think the silencing culture is an outgrowth of SM practices where you can block to your heart's content and eliminate voices that disagree with you. It's taking this entitlement and trying to apply it in real life that creates the problems.
Excellent point.
Cameleongirl · 23/10/2021 01:27

@Kanaloa I thought the OP’s point was that while her DD says she wants to cancel everyone who expresses hateful views, her real life behavior contradicts this, because she loves and enjoys spending time with an elderly uncle who’s racist and homophobic.

In other words, real life is far more complicated than cancel culture suggests and that’s the dilemma. Cancel someone you love, try to change them with rational arguments, or do nothing?

Kanaloa · 23/10/2021 01:02

I do by the way understand pointing out things to people. For example I have occasionally said something like ‘I think the correct term is x because of such and such’ when someone has used an offensive or very outdated term.

But debating someone who openly airs racist and homophobic views that he KNOWS you dislike because you’ve told him is really just pouring fuel on it and encouraging him. Obviously he isn’t going to stop suddenly after 20 years and think ‘actually everyone deserves the same chance as me’ so why give the attention.