Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think it’s rather sensible for young women to consider earning potential/ wealth when choosing a life partner?

345 replies

OompaLumpaLabrador · 20/10/2021 14:56

My mum always said that it doesn’t matter how wealthy or otherwise a man is, as long as you love each other. Which I guess is easy to say when, as a young nurse, you fell for a very decent and lovable surgeon ( my dad).

But I’m 43 now, and the life choices friends have made are all coming out in the wash. And the reality appears that those of us who opted to spend our lives with men and women with money have by far the better deal. There’s more freedom around healthcare, education, location, travel and work ( give up, part time, full time). The unpleasant and time consuming household chores are outsourced. There seems less stress in the partnerships because there are no money worries. The partnerships just seem easier. And if it doesn’t work out, a decent divorce settlement means women aren’t left high and dry.

Of course, love comes first. And maybe I’m getting cynical in my old age. But I’m not sure I’ll be giving my daughters quite the sake advice as my mum gave me. AIBU?

OP posts:
worriedatthemoment · 22/10/2021 21:56

@TractorAndHeadphones no the oP mentions a partner that can support her dd being a sahm or working part time
Women want it equal but then don't as you have almost criticised a woman supporting a man and being the higher earner
Being with someone just because they have good earning potential doesn't make it all perfect has to be more and money as well , just more to fight over in a divorce
And many high earning men do need a sahm etc in order to facilitate their careers
Although not impossible its hard to have two high earning , long hrs , career driven people and have a family without hiring lots of outside help , and whilst for some thats fine for others they want more of a family/ work life balance
People should choose a partner who they respect and who respects them , have similar beliefs etc

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/10/2021 21:50

@GreenLeafs

Not necessarily. Some men are very self important and despite the woman being the higher earner or with more earning potential still bully/demand she stays at home. Anyway, I think it’s wise to pair up someone with similar values & priorities.
Well true - and in the OP's context attitudes towards money is also a value/priority. While her mother said 'just love is enough'. Not 'marry a rich man who can take care of you'.

I personally value earning potential and chose a career path that would lead to it. Money gives me choice and freedom. To pay for things that make my life easier like a housekeeper and a gardener. DP is the same. If our earning potential dropped of course we would flex but otherwise outsourcing these things are important to us.

I couldn't be with someone who expected me to do half the chores efficiently, or chose happiness in a job over money (of course if the job is toxic and stressful it's a different story), but sacrificing money for an 'easy life' workwise doesn't make sense to me because I'm very good at work. I'm shit at everything else in my life that other people can do easily, like housework.

That's just me anyway

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/10/2021 21:34

[quote onlychildhamster]@DillonPanthersTexas Also the definition of 'well paid career' changes with time. 20 years ago, marrying a civil servant or high street solicitor probably would have been considered a solid option even in London. Today, while the civil servant in their 40s might have been able to get on the property ladder, he would be relatively poor compared to many people of the same age in London as his wage hasn't gone up relative to the top 1% or 5% where there is a disproportionate number in London. By the same token, someone picking a 22 year old guy working in the City because he earns 70k shouldn't expect that his income wouldn't fall in real terms; he could (like the civil servant and the high street solicitor) be struggling to pay childcare bills or upgrade to a bigger house in 20 years. Income inequality is only grow with time, unless you are the top 1%[/quote]
But that's still a higher salary compared to someone in an unskilled job/job without major progression potential. Like a call center operator, warehouse worker, or driving examiner (yes, this last one may be surprising but plenty have quite because of this).

Now I'm sure someone will be along to tell me 'but I know so and so who started as one of these who is now earning the big bucks'. Of course, anything is possible. But again it depends on the age - someone in their early/mid twenties understandable. Someone in their mid thirties - what are they waiting for (barring adverse life circumstances such as illness or caring responsibilities).

In real life the majority of people aren't 'hunting' for very wealthy men, or dumping men who earn an okay salary in the hopes of landing one of your City men.

They are deciding whether to carry on a relationship with someone who lacks earning potential. And if they're on an upward trajectory themselves with a decently paid career - they wonder whether they can be arsed to carry a lower earning partner.

Now, if said partner is wonderful, a perfect match in every way, except for their earning potential - then there isn't much of a question! They should if they're that perfect happily support the higher earner. Just like how low paid women happily give up their jobs to support high earner husbands, right? right???

However what GENERALLY happens is that women are with an 'ok' man. They can see themselves falling in love with him, getting on well, but he's not the 'one'. In that case it would be wise to think of the practicalities of life together and whether they want to pursue the relationship.

And finally if you read the OP - she's not talking about luxury cars, or yatchs. But things that make life easier. Like outsourcing the housework. Money doesn't solve all problems but it solves a lot.

GreenLeafs · 22/10/2021 21:25

Not necessarily. Some men are very self important and despite the woman being the higher earner or with more earning potential still bully/demand she stays at home.
Anyway, I think it’s wise to pair up someone with similar values & priorities.

DillonPanthersTexas · 22/10/2021 20:49

But this is nothing to do with being a high earner. I know a few men that fit your description and they earn peanuts.

Well, to a certain degree you need to be the higher earner in order to insist that someone quits their job and stays at home while you provide for them. Personally, a couple both working it all goes into the same pot, winner.

GreenLeafs · 22/10/2021 20:40

@DillonPanthersTexas

Any evidence for this statement? Did you conduct a national survey?

Purely an anecdotal opinion. Never understand men who gets threatened by their partners earning more then them. Also never understand blokes who insist their partners quit their jobs and stay at home. All a bit too controling for me.

But this is nothing to do with being a high earner. I know a few men that fit your description and they earn peanuts.
DillonPanthersTexas · 22/10/2021 20:29

Any evidence for this statement? Did you conduct a national survey?

Purely an anecdotal opinion. Never understand men who gets threatened by their partners earning more then them. Also never understand blokes who insist their partners quit their jobs and stay at home. All a bit too controling for me.

saf1ya7 · 22/10/2021 18:33

“ I also believe that men who actively seek out to be the traditional bread winner and sole provider have a higher tendency to be the sort of controlling twats who get all insecure and upset when their partner earns more then them. They seek validation of their ill conceived alpha status by having a SAHM.”

Any evidence for this statement? Did you conduct a national survey?

Dishwashersaurous · 22/10/2021 18:03

Onlychildhamster

That's a really good point, and applies to both the partner and the woman.

Graduate jobs at the same level 25byears ago now have very very different management level salaries.

No one could have predicted a ten year civil service pay freeze and the massive gap between senior people in the public and private sector

onlychildhamster · 22/10/2021 17:59

@DillonPanthersTexas Also the definition of 'well paid career' changes with time. 20 years ago, marrying a civil servant or high street solicitor probably would have been considered a solid option even in London. Today, while the civil servant in their 40s might have been able to get on the property ladder, he would be relatively poor compared to many people of the same age in London as his wage hasn't gone up relative to the top 1% or 5% where there is a disproportionate number in London. By the same token, someone picking a 22 year old guy working in the City because he earns 70k shouldn't expect that his income wouldn't fall in real terms; he could (like the civil servant and the high street solicitor) be struggling to pay childcare bills or upgrade to a bigger house in 20 years. Income inequality is only grow with time, unless you are the top 1%

DillonPanthersTexas · 22/10/2021 17:49

What is a well-paid career?
30K is the median salary but loads of people thinking this is a huge amount. Many people manage at least that by the time they're 40

Depends where you live I guess, £30k is not very much in London but probably not bad in Cornwall or the North West. Either way, geography aside, you give yourself options in life by being financially self sufficient rather then hitching your wagon to someone on the basis of them providing for you. I also believe that men who actively seek out to be the traditional bread winner and sole provider have a higher tendency to be the sort of controlling twats who get all insecure and upset when their partner earns more then them. They seek validation of their ill conceived alpha status by having a SAHM.

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/10/2021 17:34

@WalkingOnTheCracks

I think you've got the question the wrong way round. You have to look for a partner who has an outlook and aspirations that are compatible with yours. So, yeah, if eventually you'd like a house with a swimming pool, then you should probably not commit to someone whose dream home is a yurt within hiking distance of Stonehenge. But that's not because you're considering long-term earning potential. It's because you're considering long-term compatibility.

One of my daughters is considering a profession which makes her happy but which is unlikely to make her materially 'successful'. She's aware of that, and she knows what she's doing.

Good for her, I say.

Neither is she on the look-out for a life-partner with 'earning potential'.

Good for her, I say again.

Also, I know some fucking miserable rich couples.

The questio is where there are mor miserable rich or poor ones
TractorAndHeadphones · 22/10/2021 17:34

@DillonPanthersTexas

I love how people say this as though all you have to do is want a well-paid career and you'll get one. Most people will never have a well-paid career, whether they want it or work hard or not.

I think the key message is that you should aim to be financially independent, that does not necessarily mean 'well paid', but enough at least to pay your way in life and have a bit left over for savings and occasional treats.

What is a well-paid career? 30K is the median salary but loads of people thinking this is a huge amount. Many people manage at least that by the time they're 40
TractorAndHeadphones · 22/10/2021 17:31

@NiceGerbil

Tractor- were you hunting or was it accident?

You can find both types in city of London.

Canary wharf the first type are more prevalent but still plenty of the second!

Good luck to anyone who is bedazzled by cash and fancy watches etc and settles down with type a...

Don't need to hunt - I'm a high earner in a male-dominated profession, Plenty of eligible singles about ;)

In fact DP and I both plan to go part-time, and we can afford to do this because we're both high earners

KatharinaRosalie · 22/10/2021 17:24

Most people will never have a well-paid career, whether they want it or work hard or not.

So where are all those hordes of well-earning men supposed to come from, that we should aim to catch instead of having our own incomes?

PreparationPreparationPrep · 22/10/2021 13:11

Also, I know some fucking miserable rich couples.

🤣We all probably know some poor ones too!

BonneMaman15 · 22/10/2021 12:46

Surely if you want a certain standard of living, you work for it and make it happen? Or are you saying you need to find a man with money for that?

DillonPanthersTexas · 22/10/2021 12:33

I love how people say this as though all you have to do is want a well-paid career and you'll get one. Most people will never have a well-paid career, whether they want it or work hard or not.

I think the key message is that you should aim to be financially independent, that does not necessarily mean 'well paid', but enough at least to pay your way in life and have a bit left over for savings and occasional treats.

VladmirsPoutine · 22/10/2021 11:31

It's not a zero sum game. In any case millionaires need someone to love them too.

Namenic · 22/10/2021 11:27

If you can’t earn much, then it’s important to alter your lifestyle to fit your earnings.

Women should do this independently of who their partner is. You can earn a lot and spend a lot or earn a little and be frugal. You can also look at relationships that are not partner-based - parents, siblings, friends who you support and could support you if anything happened. Life is uncertain and risky, so it’s helpful to try and build relationships of mutual support (not just in nuclear family). Personally I think it’s unreasonable to expect a partner to do something you would not be willing to do yourself (eg earn a high salary or take parental leave).

WalkingOnTheCracks · 22/10/2021 11:07

I think you've got the question the wrong way round. You have to look for a partner who has an outlook and aspirations that are compatible with yours. So, yeah, if eventually you'd like a house with a swimming pool, then you should probably not commit to someone whose dream home is a yurt within hiking distance of Stonehenge. But that's not because you're considering long-term earning potential. It's because you're considering long-term compatibility.

One of my daughters is considering a profession which makes her happy but which is unlikely to make her materially 'successful'. She's aware of that, and she knows what she's doing.

Good for her, I say.

Neither is she on the look-out for a life-partner with 'earning potential'.

Good for her, I say again.

Also, I know some fucking miserable rich couples.

Pythonista · 22/10/2021 09:23

And with that attitude, why would a man who is comfortably off bother with a woman who isn't?

SpinsForGin · 22/10/2021 09:20

I would say it more important to marry someone who will take on their fair share of responsibilities.
Doing 50% of childcare, housework and the mental load is worth more than money and makes it easier for both partners to work.

Newmumatlast · 22/10/2021 08:47

@lazylinguist

No, women should consider getting their own well paid career.

I love how people say this as though all you have to do is want a well-paid career and you'll get one. Most people will never have a well-paid career, whether they want it or work hard or not.

You're not wrong. But I guess rather than the plan being to rely on finding a well off man (also not guaranteed) plan for yourself first.
Newmumatlast · 22/10/2021 08:45

@Strangevipers

I would marry my husband all over again even he is didn't have a dime.

You can't buy happiness, you can try but why bother. You could miss out on the love of your life for someone who you do love but you've settled for because they have money.

Woman have the opportunity to make their own money these days, that's the best option

I agree and also not only that but you cannot guarantee where you'll end up. You could marry someone super rich and the chances of them staying rich are decent.. but the statistical chance of marrying someone super rich if you yourself have nowhere near those credentials is surely low. Marry someone well off but not super rich and you never know if they'll die young not leaving much, or lose their job and not find another paying well, or decide to change career for one much lower paid, or go bankrupt etc. Point is this is why you're so much better relying on yourself, marrying for love and then working together to build wealth. It takes longer and isn't guaranteed but win or lose on the money front you still have love.