Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think it’s rather sensible for young women to consider earning potential/ wealth when choosing a life partner?

345 replies

OompaLumpaLabrador · 20/10/2021 14:56

My mum always said that it doesn’t matter how wealthy or otherwise a man is, as long as you love each other. Which I guess is easy to say when, as a young nurse, you fell for a very decent and lovable surgeon ( my dad).

But I’m 43 now, and the life choices friends have made are all coming out in the wash. And the reality appears that those of us who opted to spend our lives with men and women with money have by far the better deal. There’s more freedom around healthcare, education, location, travel and work ( give up, part time, full time). The unpleasant and time consuming household chores are outsourced. There seems less stress in the partnerships because there are no money worries. The partnerships just seem easier. And if it doesn’t work out, a decent divorce settlement means women aren’t left high and dry.

Of course, love comes first. And maybe I’m getting cynical in my old age. But I’m not sure I’ll be giving my daughters quite the sake advice as my mum gave me. AIBU?

OP posts:
user1471554720 · 20/10/2021 19:39

Having a professional career is all well and good, but your salary won't buy you much luxuries if you are the main breadwinner (not through choice). You will be on a budget and won't really be able to enjoy any benefits of your hard work eg meals out, treats.

When I was with my ex partner, he was in and out of basic jobs. Because I was paying a full mortgage myself and keeping a house going, I never had any money for nice things, good quality clothes, summer holidays. I was managing staff and they had a better lifestyle than me. This was because they were with partners who earned the same as them.

I would advise anyone starting out to think carefully about their partner and choose someone with some bit of get up and go. I know there are people who are happy to stay in a min wage job or be in and out of work. If you are their partner, your salary will have to keep the whole household going. You will be working fulltime for 40 years, surrounded by professionals who have a nice lifestyle. You will become very resentful if you feel you are working, have little free time and also have no spare money for savings treats etc

Cocomarine · 20/10/2021 19:34

@SofiaMichelle

I really couldn't find it in myself to be envious of freeloaders, *@Cocomarine*

There's so much satisfaction in life to be had from paying your own way rather than sponging.

Those are my friends @SofiaMichelle not freeloaders or spongers. They have wealthy husbands for the exact same reason that I have a not-wealthy husband: because that’s simply what they earn. They didn’t target high men. Neither did my husband target me.

Or is he a sponging freeloader too?

bumsnett · 20/10/2021 19:33

@MamsellMarie

I think it's more your DDs should be thinking about their earning power - hilarious that your DM was a nurse. They're paid wellish now but when I qualified in 1972 I could barely afford to run a car let alone pay a mortgage which today's young people seem to expect. I discouraged my DDs from NHS, steered them towards 'men's' jobs. They have cleaners and nice houses.
What type of jobs did they go into?
choli · 20/10/2021 19:31

I know women whose mission in life was to be a SAHM. They chose their partner on that basis. It worked for some, not for others. I wouldn't want it.

SofiaMichelle · 20/10/2021 19:31

I really couldn't find it in myself to be envious of freeloaders, @Cocomarine

There's so much satisfaction in life to be had from paying your own way rather than sponging.

frazzlesmore · 20/10/2021 19:30

@onlychildhamster ok, this wasn't inheritance in that sense that people I know received (including myself) as the parents were all alive. The ones I know who inherited due to death are in the 1.5m-2m houses.
But you are still lucky to inherit anything, plenty don't. Obviously it's also much harder to build equity these days.

Cocomarine · 20/10/2021 19:06

My 3 best friends all earn under £20K because they are part time (1 doesn’t work).
Husbands earn approx £100K for 2 and £150K for the other.

In my household, it’s me earning £70K and husband on less than £20K.

I must admit that I’m slightly envious sometimes when I’m the one working long hours and actually earning a fantastic salary.. but they’re the ones on very expensive holidays that I couldn’t afford!

We’re all just as happy in our marriages, but all other things being equal would it be nice if my husband earned more? Yeah 🤣

I don’t really feel jealous of people who earn more having nicer holidays - just seems a bit unfair when friends working part time do! These are all sons marriages and it’s not because of childcare. It’s women who were part time when children were young and then never had to up their hours again later, due to high earning partners.

ChiefInspectorParker · 20/10/2021 19:02

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

tiggerwhocamefortea · 20/10/2021 18:55

The problem is, for most women, having kids fucks your earning capacity and takes away your self sufficiency

I disagree

But then again these are the women that choose to take a year or more out of the workplace

I'm the main earner by 4x DH - my career has only gone from strength to strength and recently just had a £8k pay rise but I could also only take 20 weeks Maternity leave each time

It's just that a lot of women choose to bury their heads in the sand about it then blame their partners for it 10 years down the line

BillMasen · 20/10/2021 18:52

@SnowyQueen

Let’s rephrase this: “AIBU to think it’s rather sensible for young men to consider earning potential/ wealth when choosing a life partner? So he doesn’t subsidise his low earning/non-working partner?”
Yeah that thread would have gone differently…
Nomoreporridge · 20/10/2021 18:50

[quote worriedatthemoment]@Nomoreporridge but if yoh had a partner that only earned minimum wage and spent within means and valued your money then wouldn't be an issue
You could marry someone really rich who could gamble and loose it all , plenty are in this position [/quote]
That’s true. I wouldn’t have minded that.

Just wish I’d taken into consideration that being in love is a good foundation for a relationship, but it needs to be shored up by less sexy things- like dependability, shared values and stability.

worriedatthemoment · 20/10/2021 18:37

@Nomoreporridge but if yoh had a partner that only earned minimum wage and spent within means and valued your money then wouldn't be an issue
You could marry someone really rich who could gamble and loose it all , plenty are in this position

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 20/10/2021 18:36

I’d be very unhappy if my children chose a partner based on their earnings. They should be concentrating on their own potential and not be so entitled as to think someone else should fund them imo.
A work ethic is very important in a partner as I wouldn’t chose a partner who couldn’t or wasn’t willing to pay their half of bills etc.

nonevernotever · 20/10/2021 18:34

I would always advocate choosing someone who is kind, intelligent, funny and who shares similar values to you. Earning potential wouldn't compensate me for being with someone who wasn't those things.

G5000 · 20/10/2021 18:32

The problem is, for most women, having kids fucks your earning capacity and takes away your self sufficiency

I disagree. Not with the fact that pregnancy discrimination and motherhood penalty exist, but most women do not need to fuck their careers. It's more likely if the DH earns significantly more though. She will become SAHM or work very part time to do all the childcare and housework, as it does not make financial sense for him to take any time off. Give it 15 years, her CV is not worth the paper it's written on, can't support herself and she's stuck with the husband whether she wants it or not.

SnowyQueen · 20/10/2021 18:29

Let’s rephrase this: “AIBU to think it’s rather sensible for young men to consider earning potential/ wealth when choosing a life partner? So he doesn’t subsidise his low earning/non-working partner?”

Nomoreporridge · 20/10/2021 18:26

YADNBU.

Lots of posters talking about how you should teach daughters to be financially independent. Totally agree with this. It’s what my mother advised me, but here’s the rub…

I married a financial disaster of a man ( as it turned out). Cost me a fortune to get rid of him and was the worst financial decision I ever made. It still has financial ramifications for me today.

Making your own sound financial decisions doesn’t insulate you from financial stress if you choose the wrong man.

So yes, if I had my time again I’d totally consider earning potential.

Watchingyou2sleezes · 20/10/2021 18:26

Whilst their own earnings are important you don't want them hooking up long term with any of the dead weight types that far too frequently appear as topics on these pages.

Mine are v. lucky for lots of reasons but possibly the best thing that I'll ever be able to do is to make sure any bums that come along are sent permanently packing long before they can get their hooks in.

tiggerwhocamefortea · 20/10/2021 18:26

@araiwa

Gold-digger is the phrase you're looking for
GrinGrinGrinGrin
SnowyQueen · 20/10/2021 18:24

YABU. We shouldn’t encourage young women to be shallow gold diggers. What’s wrong with being in a relationship with a kind, selfless man who works hard for his money, but earns £20k rather than £50k? Would you rather they end up as a “kept woman”? Women can make their own money!!

Cbtb · 20/10/2021 18:23

I can’t imagine loving someone who was wasteful with money or who was not a hard worker or was prepared to pull weight around house and learn. So they don’t have to be rich but they need to be hardworking and contentious. It’s not being a gold digger it’s choosing a life partner whose aims in life align with your own.

DriftingBlue · 20/10/2021 18:23

I would advice both young women and men to consider the career prospects of potential partners. That doesn’t necessarily mean money, it means someone who shares similar values surrounding education and work ethic.

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 20/10/2021 18:23

Life is easier when you have money.

Wow. Startling revelation. Thanks OP - not sure where we’d all be without your searing insights.

SuperTiredBaileys · 20/10/2021 18:20

Wow OP!! What planet do you live on!

I married my husband because I love him! We get on, never argue, have the same values and generally are soul mates. At what point do you think I should have interviewed him about his earning potential? Or should I have married someone I didn't love, had no connection with and shared no values with because they had money?

If you happen to have fallen in love with (and feel close to, and cherish, and share the same values as, and love living with, and want children with etc...) someone with money, well lucky for you both that you won't have to struggle financially! But money should in my opinion, no way influence who you marry!

For what it's worth, I'm very happy! And so is DH and so are DC - I know some wealthy families who are also happy, but some who really really aren't!

whineochoc · 20/10/2021 18:20

@Marelle

I'm teaching my kids the importance of financial self-sufficiency The problem is, for most women, having kids fucks your earning capacity and takes away your self sufficiency. It doesn’t matter how hard you worked before kids, that won’t stop your employer holding you back and giving the opportunities to others who are able to be more dedicated because they don’t have kids. It won’t stop you having to reduce your hours to fit around childcare, or take days off to look after sick kids. No doubt you will lose money by having kids, and you need a wealthy husband to compensate for what you’ve lost.
This is so on point. Pre-kids my career was great, I was travelling for work earning promotions. Two kids later I'm 32 hours a week and fitting my hours around childcare. My motivation has changed and work desire to do all hours to excel is no longer there.