Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you consider your spouse's family to be your family?

265 replies

bridepanic · 20/10/2021 14:12

Just curious really - I see a lot of people on here who discuss their husband's family as very separate to themselves and their family.

I'm about to get married, and am very close to my fiancé's family and he's very close to mine. We are very much of the mind that our families just become our family, jointly. Problems we face in the future with care/illness or joys that happen (nieces and nephews) are things we will share and experience together.

Growing up, my Mum's family had that attitude towards the in-law's, although my Dad's very much didn't, so I have seen how this isn't always the case in practice as well as just on here.

I realise that at the end of the day, if something happens, our families will always retain a certain 'loyalty' or bias towards their own child/sibling, so don't need to be told my POV is very naive. I'm just curious as to how others feel and why they feel like that - does it come from you or your in-laws creating that distance?

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 20/10/2021 14:51

@Froppysue

Absolutely, I’m very fortunate that I gained a second family (that I probably like more than my own!) My mil treats me like a second daughter, sil is my best friend (dh & I have the same friendship group). Dhs gran I call gran as I never had one myself. His parents are separated but I am close to fil too, he used to come round numerous days a week to help when dc were small and any sporting events the whole family are there cheering each other on. Mil misses the dc if she hasn’t seen them for a week and loves taking them for days out and overnight too. Very aware of how lucky I am.
But again you’d see the difference if you split and he was with someone else

Family is irrelevant of who is your partner. For your husbands family this is not th case. Yes it is for your kids, but not you.

Miggymoggymugwumps · 20/10/2021 14:51

Absolutely not, I've just tolerated them throughout our marriage!

Youcancallmeval · 20/10/2021 14:49

Not at all. One of my friends refers to 'our nephew' when referring to her partner's nephew. I think it is weird to hijack someone else's family.

Bluntness100 · 20/10/2021 14:49

@miltonj

Yes they are my family. We have fallings out and don't always get on. I don't always even particularly like them, but we are family.
But if you split I think you’d realise you are not family, particularly if he met someone else. So you are family as long and only if you’re together.
AnneLovesGilbert · 20/10/2021 14:49

No. But neither does he. Not seen them in years and it’s a blessed relief. They’re horrific.

He sees mine as his family and they feel the same way about him. He’s very close to my mum who we see a lot and he gets on well with my siblings and their spouses.

Froppysue · 20/10/2021 14:49

Absolutely, I’m very fortunate that I gained a second family (that I probably like more than my own!)
My mil treats me like a second daughter, sil is my best friend (dh & I have the same friendship group). Dhs gran I call gran as I never had one myself.
His parents are separated but I am close to fil too, he used to come round numerous days a week to help when dc were small and any sporting events the whole family are there cheering each other on. Mil misses the dc if she hasn’t seen them for a week and loves taking them for days out and overnight too.
Very aware of how lucky I am.

CityMumma78 · 20/10/2021 14:49

No. I have been with my husband for 20 years and we have two children. I don’t consider his family to be my family.

Bluntness100 · 20/10/2021 14:48

Hmm interesting question, yes and no, they are our daughters family, I suppose when it comes to it I feel we are looking family, but ultimately they are my husbands family. I get on fine with them. We socialise together with his brother and wife, but he’s not my brother. The bond will never be the same.

And ultimately if I split with my husband he would remain part of their family but I would not. Which is how it should be. Whereas if I split with my Husband I would remain part of my family and he would not. My daughter would remain part of both families.

Aquamarine1029 · 20/10/2021 14:48

Nope. 300 miles and about 200 years of human social evolution separates us.

🤣🤣🤣

miltonj · 20/10/2021 14:47

Yes they are my family. We have fallings out and don't always get on. I don't always even particularly like them, but we are family.

NavigatingAdolescence · 20/10/2021 14:46

Nope. 300 miles and about 200 years of human social evolution separates us.

DH is close to my family because they are geographically closer and more engaged with us - with his we are very much out of sight, out of mind (unless someone DH never knew dies, in which case he must be called immediately).

Gertie75 · 20/10/2021 14:46

Not really no, ils are nice enough people but if anything happened to dh I wouldn't make an effort other than getting the kids to send cards.

Dh however seems to care more about my parents than his, he was devastated when my Dad died and is close to my Mum, he does love his parents and they get on well but he sees more of my family than his, it's always me who has to remind him of birthdays and prompt him to visit them even though they're only half hour away.

bridepanic · 20/10/2021 14:46

@DivaVergent

Congratulations on your upcoming wedding, I hope it is a joyous day!

I don't consider DH's family as my own family, and he feels the same about mine. It has never occurred to us that it would be anything but our own choice as to how we would like things to be.

We keep things lighthearted with the older generations and help out when needed but nobody is in anyone else's pocket. Generally the older PIL get the less likely they will be to change. Fitting into their world is what they require from you IME, you are a grown up and it's up to you to decide whether that suits you.

You may be naive perhaps, and I think it could help for you to be prepared that some life events could affect your relationship with PIL, say if you have DC, move or change job or someone has health issues.

Another major issue right now is childcare. With some PIL they may expect to call the shots if they are providing free childcare. How will you feel about that?

@DivaVergent Thank you for your good wishes!

You raise some interesting points - we live far enough away from both our mother's that they won't be able to provide any formal childcare for future children (still a way off!), so no worries on that front. I actually have always put in place very strict boundaries with my parents about mixing 'business' and family so would never, ever accept childcare from parents anyway, for fear of causing these exact issues.

Also sadly we have already experienced some of the other problems such as illness you have discussed - my Dad died 4 years ago after having cancer for 2 years. My fiancé supported us through that and spoke my Dad's eulogy, and also has been instrumental in helping my Mum adjust to widowhood, so I feel confident we do see our families as both of our concerns in these situations!

OP posts:
lunkitsmum · 20/10/2021 14:46

I hoped and wanted to be part of dh family as I have little of my own but unfortunately the feeling wasn’t mutual- they really want minimal involvement with us and our children. No fall out, just how it is sadly.

MedusasBadHairDay · 20/10/2021 14:46

I can't imagine my DHs family and mine spending time together, actually I lie, they did it once when we got married. My family tried to be welcoming, but DHs family kept to themselves, and have declined any invites to events where my family will be since. I should point out my family aren't some nightmare family, there was no drama or anything, just little in common.

readwhatiactuallysay · 20/10/2021 14:45

Absolutely they are family.

They are lovely people which helps.

LuchiMangsho · 20/10/2021 14:45

My in laws yes. Wider family not so much.

MrsToothyBitch · 20/10/2021 14:45

Most of them- DPs mum is low contact so I don't know her well but I prefer his dad to my own parents tbh. My parents are v fond of DP and he of them. I'm an only but DPs sibs are lovely and I enjoy time with them. His sister isn't 100% reliable but I accept that, set expectations accordingly and still enjoy time together - it is what it is.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 20/10/2021 14:44

Ex husband of 20 years. I had zero interest in his family. We had nothing in common at all and they were not nice people.

Holly60 · 20/10/2021 14:44

@Crunchymum

We are very much of the mind that our families just become our family, jointly I find the notion of joint families very twee.

I am one of 4 children, DP (of 15 years) is one of 6 children.

We are all grown-up, married [or with long term partners] and have children of our own. I don't think joint families work on this scale?

Do my family join with DP's family but not my other siblings in-laws?
Do we all join together? So are my SIL parents - whom I have met a few times - now my family or are they my in-laws family?

Relationships develop organically. No need to label or have concrete expectations.

I am not being obtuse just giving an alternative example.

I would answer your question about your SIL’s family with ‘yes, in my opinion they are your family’. You don’t need to be close to them or speak to them much for them to be family. The same as with your blood relatives. That’s my opinion on it anyway.

I would hate it if my DDIL or DSIL didn’t see me as family. Luckily for me they do Grin

EnterFunnyNameHere · 20/10/2021 14:43

Not really, no. I am extremely find of them, but it's very much a case that my relationship with them is via DH. I wouldn't ring any of my in laws for example and it doesnt really bother me whether or not we see them - although enjoy their company when we see them. I'm sure DH feels the same about mine!

Terribleluck · 20/10/2021 14:42

Not really, nothing against them but I don't have a real relationship with them.

JurgensCakeBaby · 20/10/2021 14:41

Yes we all get on, DM and MIL text each other, we all go out together for dinner/days out or they come to us. My DB SIL and DNs often come to PIL with us because they live in the country and have lots of animals goats, chickens, horses etc so the DC love it. We often all spend Christmas together and have also holidayed together. However I think this is made easier by the fact DH is an only child and SIL has no contact with her parents and moved in with an aunt at 14, if DH had five siblings or even if SIL was closer to her mum mum's husband , dad and dad's wife and all took the same attitude it could get massive and out of hand quite quickly.

Holly60 · 20/10/2021 14:40

@IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves

I do yes, they are every bit as much my family as relatives on my side. I love them.
This is how I feel too
Crunchymum · 20/10/2021 14:38

We are very much of the mind that our families just become our family, jointly I find the notion of joint families very twee.

I am one of 4 children, DP (of 15 years) is one of 6 children.

We are all grown-up, married [or with long term partners] and have children of our own. I don't think joint families work on this scale?

Do my family join with DP's family but not my other siblings in-laws?
Do we all join together? So are my SIL parents - whom I have met a few times - now my family or are they my in-laws family?

Relationships develop organically. No need to label or have concrete expectations.

I am not being obtuse just giving an alternative example.