Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you consider your spouse's family to be your family?

265 replies

bridepanic · 20/10/2021 14:12

Just curious really - I see a lot of people on here who discuss their husband's family as very separate to themselves and their family.

I'm about to get married, and am very close to my fiancé's family and he's very close to mine. We are very much of the mind that our families just become our family, jointly. Problems we face in the future with care/illness or joys that happen (nieces and nephews) are things we will share and experience together.

Growing up, my Mum's family had that attitude towards the in-law's, although my Dad's very much didn't, so I have seen how this isn't always the case in practice as well as just on here.

I realise that at the end of the day, if something happens, our families will always retain a certain 'loyalty' or bias towards their own child/sibling, so don't need to be told my POV is very naive. I'm just curious as to how others feel and why they feel like that - does it come from you or your in-laws creating that distance?

OP posts:
Boood · 20/10/2021 15:10

No. I would have said yes before lockdown, but they barely lifted a finger to stay in touch, and when we did speak it became clear that they weren’t really interested- it was all very superficial. I feel released from an obligation now. Plus, my husband and I have spent more time together than we ever thought we would, and now things are back to normal it’s good to get a bit of space, even if only because it gives us something new to talk about. So we tend to go off and see our own families separately now.

JustLyra · 20/10/2021 15:09

Yes I do.

DH doesn’t with my family, but then I have nothing to do with my family either.

Mil has lived with us since FIL died. DH was widowed when he and I met and this weekend I’m going away for a girly weekend with his MIL, his SIL, MIL and BIL’d gf. We’re all very close and I love it.

Isababybel · 20/10/2021 15:09

I would say no actually. I do not get on with mil at all due to her personality but thats a whole boring story.
Sil i do like but she never refers to me as being aunty to her children, she says "uncle dhname and then my name" so because of that i feel pushed away and not like she sees me as family. So i put up a wall too.

AliasGrape · 20/10/2021 15:08

Yes and no really.

His parents I guess so. They're good people, hugely frustrating at times but generally nice and kind and always been welcoming to me. We spend a fair bit of time with them, I've been known to do things with MIL separately to DH, and I'm fond of them. They're my daughter's grandparents and it's important to me that they have a close relationship. They're not particularly warm or open in the way my family are, they're a bit 'stiff' and FIL in particular is very self centred in a way that can really wind me up. I'm never 100% relaxed and comfortable around them in the way I'd be with my own family and always fall into a slight best behaviour mode. They're lovely with DD now but were quite disinterested when she was first born in a way that has left me feeling a bit differently about them and is hard to shake off. DH's brother I barely know, they live in another country. I get on fine with him and his wife when we do see them, and we exchange polite messages about our babies who were both born around the same time, but it doesn't go any further than that.

DH definitely more relaxed around my family than I am with his, I don't know whether hed say they were his family though. We stayed with some of them recently and I overheard him saying to one of his colleagues on the phone that we were going to stay with family rather than with 'my wife's family' or 'my in laws' so maybe he does?

M0rT · 20/10/2021 15:08

I like my in laws and contact them and they me separately to my husband.
I wouldn't really meet up with them alone though.

As regards problems and care needs I defer to my DH re his family and he to me re mine.
So if I need to support someone in my family he picks up my slack or accepts me being less available to him and vice versa.
We would both communicate with the person affected directly but most people when it comes down to it only want the really close when they are vulnerable and need help.

HazelandChacha · 20/10/2021 15:08

Married 25 years.

I used to call BIL’s DS our DN. it soon became apparent that his wife’s family is treated a lot different to our own (time & effort visiting, DC gifts etc) so I gave up bothering much.

We’ve lived in this house 7 years and they have never even seen it, we always used to have to visit them. I now let DH go on his own. DH sees my siblings DC as his DN’s as they put as much effort into seeing us as we do seeing them.

AuntieStella · 20/10/2021 15:07

Yes, but it took time (married over 25 years)

It was a bit of a shock when I first realised that my in-laws were my DC's blood relatives, though!

But over the years, we've just all become fixtures in each other's lives

furbabymama87 · 20/10/2021 15:06

No but we don't see them regularly and there are issues from his childhood so he keeps them to special occasions only. He talks to my family much more than he sees his own.

bridepanic · 20/10/2021 15:05

@Crunchymum

We are very much of the mind that our families just become our family, jointly I find the notion of joint families very twee.

I am one of 4 children, DP (of 15 years) is one of 6 children.

We are all grown-up, married [or with long term partners] and have children of our own. I don't think joint families work on this scale?

Do my family join with DP's family but not my other siblings in-laws?
Do we all join together? So are my SIL parents - whom I have met a few times - now my family or are they my in-laws family?

Relationships develop organically. No need to label or have concrete expectations.

I am not being obtuse just giving an alternative example.

@Crunchymum I think you are possibly taking this too literally - for me I think family is about the emotional connection and sense of family, and yes, I do feel like families work on the scale you're talking about!

It means caring when my BIL's Mum died, for example, despite never having met her, and going out of our way to try and care for him. I don't think it means 100's of people have to spend christmas together.

OP posts:
steppemum · 20/10/2021 15:04

Slightly difficult as we don't share a common language sorry, that isn't right. I have learnt their language to communicate with FIL and aunties etc
My SIL and BIL all speak English, although we usually speak in their language

DarlingFell · 20/10/2021 15:03

Yes, definitely. My in laws are lovely, they are definitely 'my' family.

washingmachines4 · 20/10/2021 15:02

yes, lovely bunch - I am very lucky

steppemum · 20/10/2021 15:01

I consider mine family.

Slightly difficult as we don't share a common language, but I do consider them to be my family and would go the extra mile in just the same way as for my family.
Dh is the same with mine, even more so as we spend a LOT of time with mine as we live locally.

But I don't love them the same way as my own, hmm siblings maybe, but parents, well, my Mum is my Mum, nothing can change that.

SisterAgatha · 20/10/2021 15:01

In theory I agree with you, but sometimes the family don’t want you back and that’s the end of that.

TillyDevon · 20/10/2021 15:00

My MIL very much felt like a mum to me too even though I’m extremely close to my own. She took me in as another daughter and when one of her own DC died she checked I was ok and looked after me literally as if I’d grown up with them all, I’ll never forget her and constantly grateful too for the goodness DH knew around him growing up as he’s so big hearted and thoughtful himself.

We did have differences as I grew up differently (Eg boarding school, very different circle) but none of it mattered.

SirenSays · 20/10/2021 15:00

God no. I did consider DHs grandparents to be family and it absolutely destroyed me when they died. I can't stand the rest of them and neither can DH.

inferiorCatSlave · 20/10/2021 14:59

There are no good/close IL relationship in either DH or my family - they verge from not speaking to distant politeness.

DParents relationship with all their chidlren's DPs get worse with time and even worse with children.

Maternal DGP marriage met NC with many of both their family - DMum no idea why - DDad distant polite - met other DGP less than 5 times ever. Paternal DGP - DF distant but polite - DGM very bad to DIL though uncle DP met after wife died was never acknowledge by them at all.

FIL refuse to see his IL over two decades over an unbeliveably minor incident - his DP were awful to all their DILs - and they have some stories.

I really tried - was anxious to get on - started well went down hill with engagement and got worse and worse. I'm not family that's always made clear and after 2 decades I'm pretty much done with teh PA and games - though we still see them reqgularly at least before covid I'm often busy and distant. If something happend to DH - I wouldn't expect to hear from them again especially as kids are teens and capable of contact themselves.

iloveayankeecandle · 20/10/2021 14:57

My dh isn't that close to his parents. Sees his mom roughly once a week for an hour and his dad once every two weeks for an hour max. They drive him up the wall. He spends a lot more time with my parents and does a lot for them. I used to really try with the in laws and encourage us to meet socially etc but over the years I've realised that I don't really like them. So I just keep them at arms length but maintain a pleasant relationship with them for the sake of my children.

Honeyroar · 20/10/2021 14:57

Yes and no. I consider them family and like them, but I call my husband’s nieces and nephews that rather than my nieces and nephews because they were all over 13 when I met him. I just call them their names.

imnotacelebritygetmeoutofhere · 20/10/2021 14:57

Absolutely, yes. I always say I married a family not a person, and he feels the same about mine. I consider them as much my family as the family I was born into. Some of them are lovely, some are annoying, that's life. I happily take care of their birthday presents, etc.
I'm always a bit baffled when I see people here referring to families as separate units. I've only ever known my way.

bridepanic · 20/10/2021 14:56

@Youcancallmeval

Not at all. One of my friends refers to 'our nephew' when referring to her partner's nephew. I think it is weird to hijack someone else's family.
Oh so this is interesting!

My SIL just had a baby (first in family) and I didn't expect to feel so totally like he was part of my family. My SIL has always pushed very hard that the in-laws know they are aunts and uncles as much as her siblings are. I think she (and everyone in their family) would be horrified at anyone saying I or the other in-laws were hijacking their family when we say OUR nephew.

OP posts:
nurserypolitics · 20/10/2021 14:55

I don't think they're my family, but I do think my DH is and so therefor I now have some familial obligations to them, if that makes sense? And also they're very much my daughter's family, so we're forever linked that way.

I actually really like DH's family, his parents are great, we see them very regularly. I also really like his extended family, aunts and uncles etc. I would happily chat to them individually, and I get on with them. PIL are currently very independent, but if there were issues in future years around their care I would 100% view it as a joint, 'family' problem.

However - they're not my family. I would never fight with them the way I do with my parents on occasion and assume it would all go back to normal. If anything sensitive has to be raised, I'd defer entirely to DH. My parents will always take my side, and I'd expect the same from his. All families have their own unique rituals, attitudes to illness, way things are done - you can observe these, but you can never really become an insider. DH will help out with, say, DIY for my parents, but when we were annoyed at something they were doing while watching DD I was the one to raise it.

A good example of it was in the extended family where the MIL is now in her 90s and requires increasing care, including support getting changed. Her kids are staying overnight in rotas atm, and there was talk of one of the in-laws who has been a much loved and cherished in-law for 40 years joining the rota, but the MIL just wasn't as comfortable with them helping her get changed in that situation as her own children. That entirely makes sense to me, and is the sort of thing I don't think time often changes.

plantbasedlondoner · 20/10/2021 14:54

I absolutely adore my Mother in Law (hate that term) and since the time DH and I first started dating, she has been warm and loving to me, treating me like a friend. I realise how rare that is in many ways. I am also very close to my two sisters-in-law although sadly my family are all in the same country as us whereas my husband's are overseas so we haven't seen them in 2 years with the pandemic. I am very close to my own family and think we are a few years away from reaching that level of closeness (probably unrealistic) but I do think for me I see them as my family.

TheFlyHalfsMum · 20/10/2021 14:54

Not completely, but more and more, yes.

BadlyFormedQuestion · 20/10/2021 14:52

Surely it depends on individual personalities and circumstances.

All of my husband’s family have made it abundantly clear that I am not part of their family. My children aren’t either. MIL makes it clear that the children from his first marriage are his real family (and his ex, who doesn’t even like MIL, is her real DIL) and the baby we have together is less important than them. She has really gone all out to make it obvious this is the case, right from the start.

Neither of H’s siblings nor any other member of his extended family have even met our one year old. They’ve made sure to see the children from the first family though (at MIL’s).

So… nope. I don’t consider these people to be my family. I don’t even consider them acquaintances. They are a smaller part of my life and have even less interest in me than his colleagues.

In contrast my first PIL really felt like my family. Losing that was probably the hardest thing about ending that relationship. I know my ex-MIL would rather have kept me than her son. 🤣