Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask about the recruitment industry?

34 replies

BulliedNoMore · 20/10/2021 12:02

I work for social services currently and I am bored of it. Looking for a change. Have lots of transferable skills. Always been interested in working for a rectuitment agency since I was a temp myself years ago. A lot of the ads for recruitment companies on Indeed etc. have ludicrous salary ranges; starting very low then going to £80k or "uncapped". I understand that it's largely commission-based but how likely is it to get to these very high salaries? Also they say perks of the job include (for example) work trips to Vegas / Ibiza / Dubai etc. I guess if something seems to good to be true then it probably is.... But I would love to know your experiences... Is it a horrible dog eat dog world? Do you really get these high salaries? I am in a position now where I can't earn more than ~35k unless I move into management which I don't want to do as am a single parent (shared care but I have DC majority of the time. Also if recruitment really doesn't work with having smallish kids please be brutal and tell me...). Many thanks!!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BulliedNoMore · 20/10/2021 22:30

@DoThePropeller

Like any industry there is a huge range of roles and businesses.

I started in recruitment and now do board-level search but have only worked for lovely companies in the 15 years I’ve been doing it. Very family friendly (I work three days) and the pay is excellent.

Some industries are tough and salesy - I would say IT and finance being the most like this.

I think if you pick a sector you’re interested in and work for a small firm with good values, possibly start more research focused if you are keen on doing senior end of the market, or account management if freelance/temps is more interesting to you.

Thanks for this it is nice to hear it's not all bad 😊
OP posts:
BulliedNoMore · 20/10/2021 22:30

@edwinbear

I too lasted a year, I was in a start up, IT headhunting firm. I'm pretty tough by nature, (I've since successfully worked in sales in investment banking for 20 years), but sometimes I'd sit in my car and cry at lunchtime.

I covered NW London, living in SE London. I was expected to get up around 5.30am, drive to NW London to conduct the breakfast candidate meetings, then drive back to the SE London office, do a full day of cold calling and receiving threatening calls from candidates employers threating to break my legs, then drive back to NW London after work to conduct the after work candidate interviews. Candidates want to talk to you outside their own working hours i.e. evenings and weekends and if you can't/won't, they will soon find another recruiter who will.

There was so much back stabbing in the office about which candidate 'belonged' to which recruiter, I had to tell so many lies, both to find potential candidates and then to candidates about how good the job was to get them to apply. I made good money, certainly compared to friends of similar ages, but I wouldn't return for £1m a year. Investment banking has far more integrity than recruitment in my own experience.

Jesus that is brutal 😳 😪 I would hate lying to people.

what is sales in investment banking, out of interest?

OP posts:
DoThePropeller · 20/10/2021 21:24

Like any industry there is a huge range of roles and businesses.

I started in recruitment and now do board-level search but have only worked for lovely companies in the 15 years I’ve been doing it. Very family friendly (I work three days) and the pay is excellent.

Some industries are tough and salesy - I would say IT and finance being the most like this.

I think if you pick a sector you’re interested in and work for a small firm with good values, possibly start more research focused if you are keen on doing senior end of the market, or account management if freelance/temps is more interesting to you.

heymammy · 20/10/2021 21:01

@BulliedNoMore people getting fired all the time, usually within their first 6 months if they don't start making fees pretty quickly.

It really is all about the sales and not even remotely about helping people. The recruiter's primary relationship is with their clients and not their candidates

edwinbear · 20/10/2021 16:40

I too lasted a year, I was in a start up, IT headhunting firm. I'm pretty tough by nature, (I've since successfully worked in sales in investment banking for 20 years), but sometimes I'd sit in my car and cry at lunchtime.

I covered NW London, living in SE London. I was expected to get up around 5.30am, drive to NW London to conduct the breakfast candidate meetings, then drive back to the SE London office, do a full day of cold calling and receiving threatening calls from candidates employers threating to break my legs, then drive back to NW London after work to conduct the after work candidate interviews. Candidates want to talk to you outside their own working hours i.e. evenings and weekends and if you can't/won't, they will soon find another recruiter who will.

There was so much back stabbing in the office about which candidate 'belonged' to which recruiter, I had to tell so many lies, both to find potential candidates and then to candidates about how good the job was to get them to apply. I made good money, certainly compared to friends of similar ages, but I wouldn't return for £1m a year. Investment banking has far more integrity than recruitment in my own experience.

LadyJaye · 20/10/2021 16:26

One of my best friends owns and runs a very successful niche (blue-chip, City-based) recruitment agency, and it is HARSH: he's the first to admit it was one of the deciding factors in the breakdown of his marriage.

As PPs have said, it is sales on steroids and really, REALLY not for the faint of heart. Definitely not a nice 'let's find nice people nice jobs' kind of a career.

BulliedNoMore · 20/10/2021 16:25

@heymammy - do you mean like people leaving / getting poached by other firms and / or getting fired all the time?

OP posts:
heymammy · 20/10/2021 16:20

@Blahdyblahbla

It's a work hard play hard culture. You'll be expected to work 8-6 as a minimum, and be available on Friday nights for drinks etc. From your user name, if you are being bullied at work, you'd probably HATE recruitment. It's dog eat dog, and you can be sacked or managed out on a whim. Most successful recruitment consultants are arseholes in my experience.
I agree with this in spades, worked in recruitment industry for years and it's a revolving door of staff
BulliedNoMore · 20/10/2021 16:07

@tealandteal

When I worked in recruitment I didn’t see a lot of people working there with kids, one of the reasons I left was that it was not family friendly and I wanted to start a family. Working hours 8-6, you were expected to meet 5 clients and 5 candidates a week I think, as well as making 20+ calls a day. All very target driven, everything you do is recorded. You would be expected to call new clients to try and get them to work with you, call existing clients to check for any vacancies, sell one of your candidates to start with them. A temp desk is very fast paced, if a client calls with a vacancy you were expected to tell them all about your candidates and get them to agree for one to start then and there. If you go on holiday this has an impact on your earnings for the month. The base was around 22k and some months you could earn and extra 1k, the higher ups would obviously earn more. It’s very cut throat, people leaving suddenly, other agencies trying to take your roles, even other consultants at the same company claiming part of your fees.
Thank you very much, this is really helpful to know. Telling that not many of your colleagues had kids 😬
OP posts:
BulliedNoMore · 20/10/2021 16:05

@caketiger

You sound very naive about this kinda role. It's brutal and not for you if you haven't done sales. How about looking for other social services roles you will have a ton of transferable skills.
Fair enough! I wanted to make more money but maybe this isn't the right move for me 😕
OP posts:
BulliedNoMore · 20/10/2021 16:04

People often mistakenly think that recruitment is about helping people, sadly this isn't true. It's all about sales, targets and how much someone is worth to you - this was kind of what I was worried about... As I said it was always kind of a pipe dream of mine but definitely from a 'helping people' perspective not a sale perspective

OP posts:
Watchingyou2sleezes · 20/10/2021 15:02

Sorry OP but you just don't 'sound' the type..,

Read what pp have said.

caketiger · 20/10/2021 14:55

You sound very naive about this kinda role. It's brutal and not for you if you haven't done sales. How about looking for other social services roles you will have a ton of transferable skills.

ErickBroch · 20/10/2021 14:26

The majority of the job is cold-calling all day long to people who will tell you to fuck off Grin

ErickBroch · 20/10/2021 14:25

The 'sales' part is securing new business with clients, which is hard, and then harassing people daily to try and get them to interview for jobs they don't really want. You will be monitored on how many calls you make a day, how long they last, how many emails you send, how many CVs you sent, if you've secured new business, have you got any interviews? If not, good luck! Most people I worked with were fired within 3 months.

JessicaFletcherxx · 20/10/2021 13:22

Yes, the sales aspects is trying to win new clients/companies. Once you've won the business it's a case of matching the best candidates and arranging interviews but you will be up against other agencies as very few companies will work with just one agency. Candidates can be very flaky and will let you down frequently.

People often mistakenly think that recruitment is about helping people, sadly this isn't true. It's all about sales, targets and how much someone is worth to you.

Agree with PP, the industry has a very high turnover and you will be let go of you don't hit your targets.

If you like the idea of the industry maybe get a job in an agency in a support role to start with so you can observe. The money won't be as good at all but you can suss it out. Alternatively try looking for an internal account manager role. These roles are still recruiting but you are based in a company purely resourcing to fill their vacancies.

NoYOUbekind · 20/10/2021 13:20

It's super-target driven. I lasted a year and hated every minute.

Essentially working on a perm desk, I would only interview shit-hot candidates that either fitted a role I already had sourced or that I thought would be sellable. I would then ring round all the companies I had in my books whom I thought might like to hire this person. Now, the chances of me finding an exact role for the exact person on my books was slim, in reality what I was really doing was trying to drum up more vacancies, which the client would give to me because I'd just demonstrated that I had a really good 'fix' on the kind of people they liked. It was back breaking.

I did have a UK-wide contract with a particular firm who liked young people for sales roles and made a lot of money off them - essentially cherry picking the wide-eyed grads and funnelling them into that role whether they'd like it or not.

I'd like to hope that with today's focus on diversity this kind of recruiting is frowned upon, but I doubt it. The reality of recruitment (for me) was selling square pegs into round holes.

tealandteal · 20/10/2021 13:13

When I worked in recruitment I didn’t see a lot of people working there with kids, one of the reasons I left was that it was not family friendly and I wanted to start a family. Working hours 8-6, you were expected to meet 5 clients and 5 candidates a week I think, as well as making 20+ calls a day. All very target driven, everything you do is recorded. You would be expected to call new clients to try and get them to work with you, call existing clients to check for any vacancies, sell one of your candidates to start with them. A temp desk is very fast paced, if a client calls with a vacancy you were expected to tell them all about your candidates and get them to agree for one to start then and there. If you go on holiday this has an impact on your earnings for the month. The base was around 22k and some months you could earn and extra 1k, the higher ups would obviously earn more. It’s very cut throat, people leaving suddenly, other agencies trying to take your roles, even other consultants at the same company claiming part of your fees.

Hobbesmanc · 20/10/2021 13:00

There's a huge range of opportunities depending on the sector. The high volume, hard partying high-street culture is still around in some companies where everything is KPI sales driven and burn-out is high.

But you have a current background in Social Care and the Health and Social Care sector might be an option. Compared to areas like IT, Scientific, Trade and Labour, it's much more female dominated and flexible around family life. It's also highly regulated so much more quality driven- sales targets still exit but are much less cold calling and there are more opportunities to service existing accounts- such as the NHS or big care home groups for example.

The downside is that whilst basics are usually ok- commission structures are a lot less generous except for Perm desks. Also if you are working for example a Home Care recruiter- you might need to share an on call.

Good luck

BulliedNoMore · 20/10/2021 12:53

Should have namechanged before posting - I am not being bullied at work DC is at school

Hate idea of being frowned upon if child is off sick... Confused like the idea of drinks after work as my work never goes out, ever (even at Christmas!)

Forgive my ignorance but what does the "sales role" mean? When I was temping (20 + years ago) you would go to the "temp agency" and they'd take your details and match you to a job. I thought that seemed really nice Smile Is the sales part getting the contract with the NHS (or whoever) in the first place? Do you have to do a lot of cold calling.

Thank you so much for the responses.

OP posts:
ErickBroch · 20/10/2021 12:46

Hated it. People would get fired every single day with no warning. I made good money my first-year thanks to commission - the basic salary was 18k, I made around 33k in my first year. I left to become an unpaid intern! A handful of people made significant money, but it depends on what area you are working in. You can get lucky with an amazing niche, but they are usually reserved to longstanding employees. Not friendly for people with kids/childcare, tough sales environment, the salaries advertised online are a load of shit.

MaverickDanger · 20/10/2021 12:42

I worked for a “nice” recruitment company a few years ago & the whole ethos was to not be like the dog eat dog, sell me this pen type companies that you hear.

I think the secret is to go into an existing warm desk, rather than have to build your own client base.

I really enjoyed it. Probably worked 40-45 hour weeks, earned 35k salary and averaged about 25-30k commission each year. I did it for about 3 years and then moved into what I do now, which isn’t sales-based.

Tal45 · 20/10/2021 12:39

OH works in recruitment (but support rather than sales) there is the constant stress in sales of having to meet targets and the targets go up and up the minute you hit one. It definitely takes a while (years) to be earning good money, getting on the trips etc and tends to be the same people every year, people who have built themselves up and are very good at what they do. It's definitely not an easy option and not something my OH would ever consider. The sales side seems very male dominated, pushy and aggressive to me - assholes often - that make a lot of money, drink a lot and think they are important. There is the opportunity to make an awful lot of money though if you are very good at it.

Hoppinggreen · 20/10/2021 12:34

I have been in Sales for many years and in have always avoided Recruitment as it’s too hard core for me.
It’s very target driven ad the turn over can be high - you perform you stay, you don’t you leave.
I dint think it’s especially family friendly either

Roselilly36 · 20/10/2021 12:32

I agree with the above, most people I know who have worked in this sector are pretty thick skinned, hard working, very long hours, pushy and excellent salespeople. Often coming from other sales roles. It certainly would be a total career change from social care.

Swipe left for the next trending thread