Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Staff absence due to childcare

60 replies

HelpIHaveNoStaff · 20/10/2021 11:02

NC for this .

I'm a manager of a small business. I'm struggling because several employees are off a lot with poorly children. Covid related obviously - wasnt a problem before.

I understand this happens and I'm happy for them to be on paid sick leave. However, they all have spouses who do not do their share of the childcare when children have to be off.

I really, really don't want to be an arse, but I'm letting down clients due to staff shortages, we are hanging by a thread, and I feel it would be avoidable if these employees parental responsibilities were shared more evenly with spouses.

I dont even know how I can possibly raise this with staff. But if the business collapses we'll all lose our jobs.

AIBU to expect parents to go 50/50 on childcare duties where possible in these situations?

How can I communicate this?

OP posts:
8dpwoah · 20/10/2021 12:11

@HelpIHaveNoStaff

I'm realising on this thread that it's made me look like a poor business manager etc to not consider the bottom line. Pre Covid it was so different, we had lots of feedback that these little things were really valued by staff and it was clear that being locally regarded as a decent employer was a valuable plus in terms of recruitment and retention.
There's no reason for that to change if you explain to staff why things are having to be changed a bit. If it makes you feel better I bet most of your staff (leaving aside covid stuff) would have stayed well within the amount of days in a period that you land on, you could even work that out to help reassure them. The ones that are fair with you will appreciate you encouraging the others to do the same too. As I say, do consider a special leave policy too for big things like operations and other hospital admissions, ours went down to whether you'd be paid or unpaid for a funeral depending on whose it was. You'll always upset someone but if it's applied fairly and consistently then everyone benefits in the end and it's not you being the bad guy, it's just what the policy says.
EvilPea · 20/10/2021 12:00

All the tips above.
Id also have an honest and frank conversation with your staff about it.

In a “I understand it’s hard, I understand these are difficult times, however as a result we are struggling to complete X Y and Z for our clients and letting them down, if you can find a better way to manage this it would be appreciated, otherwise we will lose the clients and the business”

JetRocket · 20/10/2021 11:56

I can literally hear the conversations In these women’s houses.

‘I keep calling in can’t you be off with the kids tomorrow?’
‘No, I won’t get paid you do you have to be off’

JetRocket · 20/10/2021 11:55

You need to stop paying them OP and I say this as a mum with 2 under 2 and a job myself. Limit the pay to X days a year and be upfront with your staff about why.

‘Unfortunately as of X date we will only pay absences due to parental sick leave for a maximum of X days every 12 months. Whilst I understand the current circumstances are not ideal, we are facing significant struggles as a business to meet the demand of our clients. We must also request that, wherever possible, employees attempt to share the responsibility of childcare equally with co parents. With this in mind I hope our business strains will soon be resolved and we can all continue safely in our roles’

HelpIHaveNoStaff · 20/10/2021 11:53

I'm realising on this thread that it's made me look like a poor business manager etc to not consider the bottom line. Pre Covid it was so different, we had lots of feedback that these little things were really valued by staff and it was clear that being locally regarded as a decent employer was a valuable plus in terms of recruitment and retention.

OP posts:
Rollercoaster1920 · 20/10/2021 11:50

Be honest with your staff about the affect on the business then formally communicate that you are going to apply the policy. I have someone (male) in my team who has taken the piss right to the limit of my company's (overly generous) policy whilst his partner does big-job things. It has caused increased load on others (me mainly), poor work, and now redundancies.

YANBU - and you need to be a bit firmer with your staff.

HelpIHaveNoStaff · 20/10/2021 11:48

TeenMinusTests

We work with clients who arent available outside business hours (8-6 or so) so that one doesn't really work but it's a nice idea.

OP posts:
WhenISnappedAndFarted · 20/10/2021 11:47

You seem like a nice manager, honestly it's really nice that you let them take paid days off for childcare.

But, look at it this way.

Your business is struggling because of this, what happens to your staff if your business goes under because of this? They have no job. You need to be a lot more stricter to protect your business and their jobs.

TeenMinusTests · 20/10/2021 11:43

This may not work dependent on the business, but can you offer flexible weekend working so the partner can have the child at the weekend and they work then to make up?

So

  • paid leave for ill childcare isn't working, it is getting unsustainable
  • it will have to be unpaid or come out of your holiday allowance
  • BUT you can make up paid hours at the weekends
Megan2018 · 20/10/2021 11:43

Outside of Covid we get 10 paid days per year, otherwise it’s annual leave or unpaid.
I do split it with DH as he gets similar and he works shifts so we can often juggle it so we only need to take a few hours each.
For Covid related absence we have no limit but it’s a big organisation. I think you should cap the paid days @HelpIHaveNoStaff

I think you need

HelpIHaveNoStaff · 20/10/2021 11:42

8dpwoah I like this idea, thanks it's a good option.

So allow a fixed number of days parental/dependents leave paid, then beyond that unpaid. Might go for a day per quarter as that may help spread it through the year, eg if a kid is sick for two days in a row, the first is paid but theres more incentive for other options to be used on second (unpaid day).

Thanks everyone.

OP posts:
BrilliantBetty · 20/10/2021 11:41

I get 5 days per year UNPAID for childcare / dependancy leave.

If you're a small company, can you discuss it with them? Find a way around it.. maybe WFH if looking after a DC. Coming in to make hours up if they don't want it to be unpaid. You're in a tricky situation.

Clymene · 20/10/2021 11:39

@HelpIHaveNoStaff

Paid sick leave for a poorly child sounds odd

I know, it's more that pre-covid it wasnt happening lots, I didnt mind turning a blind eye here and there as it didnt impact on clients as it was infrequent, I know it's a pain when your kid is off school sick so I tried to be decent about it.

I feel like its backfired now, people are constantly off with kids having to be PCR tested, the work isnt being caught up.

Well it's backfired on you. Of course they'll take the time off if you keep paying them! There's bugger all incentive for you to find an alternative solution.

You're running a business. You're not their mate, you're their boss. You need to enforce your own rules.

Apart from the impact on clients, have you worked out how much it's costing you to fund their days off?

Hardbackwriter · 20/10/2021 11:39

@HelpIHaveNoStaff

Tbh though even if I make it unpaid sick it's not going to solve for my reliability issue and letting down clients :(
It will if it drastically reduces how much time your staff take off! As people have said if one parent will get paid if they have the day off and the other won't the vast majority of people would choose that the one that gets paid stays off.

As a compromise you could continue to pay but only for X days per year, as that avoids penalising the people who are already sharing.

2020isnotbehaving · 20/10/2021 11:38

If one employee is offering unlimited fully paid no problem time off for childcare then of course they become the default parent to be off its a no brainier.

You as a business have taken the hit over the last 18m or so now it’s fully acceptable to offer paid for set number of days a year or like most people unpaid unless you are the person who is sick. It’s hard for parents but even harder if your business goes under because you don’t have staff to complete the jobs and bring money in.

8dpwoah · 20/10/2021 11:38

Five days in 12 months, that should say. Obviously bearing in mind that's only really 10 working months with the holidays etc.

userchange987 · 20/10/2021 11:38

YANBU at all. The total disregard for employers when posters on here say "but my husband earns more" well I'm not bloody surprised with that attitude.

8dpwoah · 20/10/2021 11:37

Most places I've worked (schools though) have allowed five days paid for dependents and then any more unpaid, although there is also a special leave policy that covers more exceptional stuff.

Maybe that's the half way approach- the ones that try to split it should be ok with five days, and the ones that don't might be more inclined to consider it? It doesn't work so well for those that have no other option but to do it themselves but I don't know what else you can do about that really.

I also don't know the specifics of including/excluding covid absence from that but at least this might help even things out for the more usual stuff.

Fallagain · 20/10/2021 11:36

@HelpIHaveNoStaff

Tbh though even if I make it unpaid sick it's not going to solve for my reliability issue and letting down clients :(
You can’t make it unpaid sick leave, it’s not sick leave. You need to make it unpaid parental leave.

It may change the culture though especially if their partners get paid parental leave.

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 20/10/2021 11:35

No but it might make them consider some other childcare option sometimes such as the father. They aren't going to consider another option when they can take a paid day off

HelpIHaveNoStaff · 20/10/2021 11:33

Tbh though even if I make it unpaid sick it's not going to solve for my reliability issue and letting down clients :(

OP posts:
HelpIHaveNoStaff · 20/10/2021 11:32

Paid sick leave for a poorly child sounds odd

I know, it's more that pre-covid it wasnt happening lots, I didnt mind turning a blind eye here and there as it didnt impact on clients as it was infrequent, I know it's a pain when your kid is off school sick so I tried to be decent about it.

I feel like its backfired now, people are constantly off with kids having to be PCR tested, the work isnt being caught up.

OP posts:
Twillow · 20/10/2021 11:32

Paid leave for childcare issues? I think that's the issue. It's very good of you but you know it's not mandatory?

I work for a national company where we do not get sick pay until the 4th day of absence. We also have return to work interviews after even 1 day sick/absent. For situations like a sick child leave is unpaid.

I think they're getting a bit too comfortable with the paid sick leave, rather than anything to do with their other halves not pulling their weight. And you would be on very dodgy ground trying to raise it in that way, I suspect.

Rethink your sick policy. Have a straight-up talk/ write a letter to staff setting out how much it is costing the business and what the effects on your ability to survive are. Change your policy to unpaid or annual leave for childcare issues. I suspect you'll see a massive difference.

HelpIHaveNoStaff · 20/10/2021 11:30

How do you know their partners aren't doing their fair share?

We have a chatty and open working environment and lots of comments made, sometimed whinging that their partner is useless and won't help, sometimes apologetic "I wish DH could cover,I know it's a pain, but his boss would go mental" etc.

I feel like if we can't sort it I'll have to actually strictly apply our formal policy which is that days off caring for dependents is unpaid. I hate having to do this as I have some (a minority) of staff who are pretty reasonable in taking turns, and because I would have to apply policy evenly on everyone they would be hurt by the change.

Aaaaaaargh. It's not a job you can do wfh, have to be there in person. I know theres often a dynamic post kids that the DHs job matters more (I'm female and my career took a bit of a backseat too) but DH and I manage to split this stuff even though he's on double the wage I am.

OP posts:
Fetarabbit · 20/10/2021 11:28

Paid sick leave for a poorly child sounds odd, as a PP has said, no wonder their other half's (if they have one) might not be doing their share; there's every chance they won't be paid! You can be a supportive and caring employer whilst looking after your own needs too, I'm not sure how it would work now you've set a precedent but I'd look at your policies- most places have x days a year or to use annual leave. It is hard with children, but similarly you have a business to run. Can any be done from home?