Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How will vaccine passports help?

34 replies

Dancerinthedark01 · 20/10/2021 10:33

How will they help the spread of Covid?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Geamhradh · 20/10/2021 20:37

@millymolls

It’s depressing most people dont seem concerned about the handover of liberties that ha e just happened. I fear for our children
I've been re-given the liberty of travel, restaurants, museums, theatres, school, university, parties, nightclubs, cinemas, football matches etc. And I'm thankful each and every day.
LeggyLinda · 20/10/2021 20:34

@Dancerinthedark01

How will they help the spread of Covid?
I don’t think they will. On the contrary, they will hinder the spread. Which is kind of the point unless I’m missing something obvious 🤷‍♂️
EileenGC · 20/10/2021 20:28

Handover of liberties? Which liberties am I handing over?

Eating in a restaurant or attending a football match aren't liberties. They're privileges.

millymolls · 20/10/2021 20:11

It’s depressing most people dont seem concerned about the handover of liberties that ha e just happened.
I fear for our children

underneaththeash · 20/10/2021 20:01

Well they obviously will help as if you're fully vaccinated many people have (approx) 67% less chance of catching Covid. But it varies.

We have the option of just ploughing through - my preference, but it could backfire.
Or not ploughing through and then everyone has a crap time....

wombwithawiew · 20/10/2021 19:54

Testing everyone before entering all indoor places is not feasible.

Having a vaccine passport OR a test to get into somewhere IS feasible. As demonstrated by many countries.

Is your argument that if it's not 100% effective we shouldn't bother? If so, how do you live your life because virtually nothing in life is 100% certain.

XenoBitch · 20/10/2021 18:51

@Changer123

Passports wont help to reduce transmission at all, a negative test result would be much more helpful as a vaccinated person can be infected & infect others. I'm double vaccinated but the idea of medical domestic passports concerns me alot
Yep, this. With the passports, there is the assumption that vaccinated people can not possibly have and spread Covid. Testing everyone is a better thing to do.
Ontopofthesunset · 20/10/2021 18:34

I was in Italy recently and it worked very smoothly. Mask compliance on public transport and in museums etc was almost universal and the Green Pass scanning was quick and easy. Cases are much lower there. Over 12s have also been eligible for both vaccinations for a while and masks are still obligatory in schools.

Geamhradh · 20/10/2021 18:28

Italian poll just on news:
66% happy with Covid passes
22% no view one way or the other
18% not happy.

EileenGC · 20/10/2021 18:13

I’ll give you that one!

My point still stands, how is the government preparing to control you via ID cards? What information could they contain that they don’t already have? We all have phones and social media and location and Bluetooth on and what not, but it’s a card with your date of birth on it that’s going to give them information? Even the police have software to basically put your name in and find out anything they want within seconds.

jgw1 · 20/10/2021 17:47

@EileenGC

When the government then introduce digital ID cards

Most of Europe has ID cards, now turning digital. Has had for decades. I was issued my first ID card over 20 years ago, when I was born. We’re not controlled by some bizarre force in the government, it’s just a card like your driving licence, with your address and fingerprints on it, which once every 5 years the police ask for when they stop you on the highway. Really not a big deal.

Most of the Europe doesn't have Boris Johnson and his gang as Prime Minister...
EileenGC · 20/10/2021 16:57

When the government then introduce digital ID cards

Most of Europe has ID cards, now turning digital. Has had for decades. I was issued my first ID card over 20 years ago, when I was born. We’re not controlled by some bizarre force in the government, it’s just a card like your driving licence, with your address and fingerprints on it, which once every 5 years the police ask for when they stop you on the highway. Really not a big deal.

wombwithawiew · 20/10/2021 16:51

[quote EileenGC]Where I live we’ve had them since March and they do work. Cases are low, the third wave never got bad, Delta hasn’t really affected the numbers much. Transmission is now mostly identified in small social situation such as family or friends gatherings only.

They don’t cause faff or queues. I’m yet to stand in a queue for longer than a minute whilst they check Covid passes. Same amount of standing I would’ve done beforehand when queuing for a restaurant or a concert.

It’s not just vaccine passports though, a

KrisAkabusi · 20/10/2021 13:34

[quote Dochas121]@DayKay but unvaccinated are far more likely to get seriously ill with covid. Vaccine has around a 95% effectiveness at preventing hospitalisation so your scenario about those in 50’s is statistically very unlikely.

Whereas in Ireland where I am 65% of ICU patients are unvaccinated so keeping the unvaccinated out of enclosed spaces and spaces where they are likely to catch covid is just sensible and will hopefully keep pressure off the health system.

Showing vaccine certs works very well here and is easy and quick to implement.[/quote]
Well said.

Dochas121 · 20/10/2021 13:11

@DayKay but unvaccinated are far more likely to get seriously ill with covid. Vaccine has around a 95% effectiveness at preventing hospitalisation so your scenario about those in 50’s is statistically very unlikely.

Whereas in Ireland where I am 65% of ICU patients are unvaccinated so keeping the unvaccinated out of enclosed spaces and spaces where they are likely to catch covid is just sensible and will hopefully keep pressure off the health system.

Showing vaccine certs works very well here and is easy and quick to implement.

SapereAude · 20/10/2021 13:04

@Toty

Because if you've been vaccinated you're less likely to have Covid and transmit it. It's not 100% effective. The odds are, if you're in a museum/restaurant with all vaccinated/holding current negative test results, you're less likely to catch it because the company you're in is less likely to have it.

Yes but for how long? When is someone no longer considered fully vaccinated? 6 months it would seem. So unless everyone is getting a booster 6 months after their 2nd vacc they're as good as unvaccinated, particularly where spread is concerned.
Unless the scientists can establish how long vaccines are actually effective for passports are completely pointless.
In fact I read today that those infected with delta have the same protection as someone double vaccinated. If they're going to carry on with passports then infection acquired immunity also needs to be considered.

Covid passes in the countries that have them have a validity. As far as I know those countries are rolling out boosters now, so the pass validity becomes automatically extended as the system is centrally managed.
DayKay · 20/10/2021 12:58

@Dochas121

You are less likely to get severely ill if vaccinated and less likely to catch covid or be severely ill.

Hypothetical example: Vaccine passports in place - 4 friends all vaccinated go to pub. 2 catch covid - none need to be hospitalised. 2 don’t catch it.

No vaccine passport - 4 friends all unvaccinated for to pub. All catch covid - 2 are fine, 2 require hospitalisation and 1 of those needs an ICU bed - increased pressure on NHS and ICU.

Makes perfect sense to me.

But another hypothetical scenario is, sane as yours but all the unvaccinated group are healthy mid 20’s and none of them get covid and all the vaccinated group are in their 50’s and not in the best of health and they all get covid and 3 need hospital treatment. Who’s to say what could happen? I don’t think vaccine passports make much difference.
jgw1 · 20/10/2021 12:53

If they make no difference to anything why did we have 40,000 cases and over 200 deaths yesterday and France have 5,000 cases and 49 deaths?

Which just goes to show how well we are doing in the UK.
The French have 1 death for every 100 cases, whereas here in mighty Boris lead Britain we have 200 cases for every death.

jgw1 · 20/10/2021 12:52

@Dancerinthedark01

How will they help the spread of Covid?
That is not the point of them. Covid passports serve two purposes. The government can say that it was doing something and blame people if it doesn't work. When the government then introduce digital ID cards they will say, but its not much different from a covid passport and you were happy using those.
Dochas121 · 20/10/2021 12:50

You are less likely to get severely ill if vaccinated and less likely to catch covid or be severely ill.

Hypothetical example: Vaccine passports in place - 4 friends all vaccinated go to pub. 2 catch covid - none need to be hospitalised. 2 don’t catch it.

No vaccine passport - 4 friends all unvaccinated for to pub. All catch covid - 2 are fine, 2 require hospitalisation and 1 of those needs an ICU bed - increased pressure on NHS and ICU.

Makes perfect sense to me.

Changer123 · 20/10/2021 12:49

Passports wont help to reduce transmission at all, a negative test result would be much more helpful as a vaccinated person can be infected & infect others. I'm double vaccinated but the idea of medical domestic passports concerns me alot

Tal45 · 20/10/2021 12:48

@hamstersarse

They won't help

And they are fundamentally a revolting non democratic idea

There has been rioting every week for some time in France - I'd imagine we'd be the same. It is so so so so wrong to give away our freedoms in such a way

www.express.co.uk/news/world/1507289/france-vaccine-passport-health-pass-protests-coronavirus-latest-news-vn

I have been to France since vaccine passports introduced and to be fair they are quite easily done. But they literally make no difference to anything - I could still have had Covid.

If they make no difference to anything why did we have 40,000 cases and over 200 deaths yesterday and France have 5,000 cases and 49 deaths?
EileenGC · 20/10/2021 12:47

Where I live we’ve had them since March and they do work. Cases are low, the third wave never got bad, Delta hasn’t really affected the numbers much. Transmission is now mostly identified in small social situation such as family or friends gatherings only.

They don’t cause faff or queues. I’m yet to stand in a queue for longer than a minute whilst they check Covid passes. Same amount of standing I would’ve done beforehand when queuing for a restaurant or a concert.

It’s not just vaccine passports though, a

Toty · 20/10/2021 12:45

Because if you've been vaccinated you're less likely to have Covid and transmit it.
It's not 100% effective.
The odds are, if you're in a museum/restaurant with all vaccinated/holding current negative test results, you're less likely to catch it because the company you're in is less likely to have it.

Yes but for how long? When is someone no longer considered fully vaccinated? 6 months it would seem. So unless everyone is getting a booster 6 months after their 2nd vacc they're as good as unvaccinated, particularly where spread is concerned.
Unless the scientists can establish how long vaccines are actually effective for passports are completely pointless.
In fact I read today that those infected with delta have the same protection as someone double vaccinated. If they're going to carry on with passports then infection acquired immunity also needs to be considered.

hamstersarse · 20/10/2021 12:42

They won't help

And they are fundamentally a revolting non democratic idea

There has been rioting every week for some time in France - I'd imagine we'd be the same. It is so so so so wrong to give away our freedoms in such a way

www.express.co.uk/news/world/1507289/france-vaccine-passport-health-pass-protests-coronavirus-latest-news-vn

I have been to France since vaccine passports introduced and to be fair they are quite easily done. But they literally make no difference to anything - I could still have had Covid.