Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ear piercing without consent at Meadowhall in Sheffield (might be triggering)

335 replies

PoetryLaser · 20/10/2021 09:53

I'm amazed that I can't find another thread on this – and I know I'm not being unreasonable to find this video incredibly upsetting. Poor child, perhaps six or seven being pinned to the floor while having her ears pierced in a jewellery store at the Meadowhall in Sheffield, screaming her head off saying "no no no".
Should ear piercing be banned for say under 12s, until they're old enough to consent?
Warning - the video is very distressing to watch: twitter.com/mrscjos/status/1450020437744885761?s=10

OP posts:
UnaLength · 20/10/2021 12:04

This is a mother completely devoid of any moral compass or care for her child. That clip is harrowing abs the mother deserves to be shamed every day for that.

SickAndTiredAgain · 20/10/2021 12:03

This is awful, and I just don’t get it. I do not underhand having any strong feelings at all that your child must have their ears pierced. Why would that be something that you felt so strongly must happen, that you’d hold a screaming, crying child down? The thought process is just beyond me.

TuftyMarmoset · 20/10/2021 11:57

Awful. Children should absolutely not get piercings until they are old enough to consent.

However I disagree with some PPs comments that guns are always bad and should be banned. I have 2x holes in each ear done by gun and I was quite glad that I had them done by gun, especially for the first ones, as it’s less daunting than a needle. Never had any issues with them.

EgonSpengler2020 · 20/10/2021 11:56

I'm a HCP and the only time I've pinned I screaming, resisting child down in that manner and stabbed them with needles was because they were at imminent risk of dying from anaphylaxis. This was years ago and it still haunts me.

I don't understand how anyone other than a sadist could do what is shown in that video to a child for purely cosmetic reasons.

Spidey66 · 20/10/2021 11:52

That's disgusting.

It maybe ok for e.g. vaccinations but not ear piercing. Staff and parents should be ashamed of themselves.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 20/10/2021 11:51

@notso

That's absolutely disgusting. I lost my first job in a hairdressers as a teen for refusing to hold down a screaming six month old baby for ear piercing.

And that is why there needs to be a law change, so that low paid retail staff aren't put in this position.

It is all very well saying the staff should have refused but if you will be sacked for refusing and need that job to pay the rent and feed your kids it is a very difficult position.

I'd remove ear piercing from high street shops and classify it with tattoos, body piercing etc. It should be done only on people who can give genuine informed consent by technicians who are licenced and inspected and who understand consent.

I would add an age limit to help protect the staff and children against the effects of coercive parents. At say 13 it should be fairly easy to confirm consent and be confident that the child understands the effects etc.

Mulhollandmagoo · 20/10/2021 11:51

That poor little girl Sad I'm dumbfounded that four adults allowed that situation to escalate!

HermioneKipper · 20/10/2021 11:50

@Clocktopus

That poor kid.

I got DDs ears done when she was 6, almost 7. She asked for it done and had been asking for ages as a few in her class had them and her cousin did too. I chose a piercing parlour that had been recommended by several of the other mums. The guy doing her piercing told me that he doesn't pierce screaming children, he doesn't allow any child to be held down, and that at the first sign if no or don't he wouldn't go ahead. I even had to sign a form saying I accepted this and that I understood if it happened after the sterile packs had been opened then I'd still have to pay. He asked DD if it was okay to go ahead at every stage of the process and had a second person in so that both ears could be done at the same time with minimal fuss. DD didn't even realise it was all finished until he said she could get off the table and there were no tears.

There should be laws around piercing distressed children, piercing the under 5s, and a ban on high steet stores such as Claires doing them.

This sounds a much better way of doing it but why on Earth is there any need to pierce a 6 year olds ears.

Just too young. Shouldn’t be allowed

sbhydrogen · 20/10/2021 11:48

I don't think ear piercings should be banned for under 12s, but if the kid doesn't want it, or if the kid doesn't want the second one done because the first hurt, then there's no need to go through with it!

GlomOfNit · 20/10/2021 11:48

While this video is an appalling watch and I'm horrified, I'm wondering what we're seeing here, really. I couldn't see a piercing gun in the staff member's hands, and the poor girl is clearly screaming 'get off my ears! get off them! ow ow ow' as the woman bends over and seems to fiddle with something.

Could there not be a possibility that the piercings have already happened by that stage and that this recording is the aftermath, where the butterfly backs are adjusted or fitted to the stud? (of course if that's the case, we still don't know if the girl gave her consent to the actual piercing.)

I had mine done at 19 at a booth in Debenhams Hmm (didn't know about needle piercing at that stage and wish I had, they got my holes mismatched for one thing). They used a gun, it was fairly painful and then they adjusted the back and that really HURT.

Having said that, I certainly don't want to let anyone off the hook here. I think piercing young children is an appalling practice, I think using guns is dangerous, I think doing it out in the open like this is bad practice, and if that poor girl had consented at one point, she was clearly unprepared for how sore it would feel afterwards (if that's what this video records).

REDHERO · 20/10/2021 11:47

I just watched the video. Disgusting.

The mother, grandmother and store staff should be arrested for abuse.

The store should be prevented from carrying out any further piercings.

sbhydrogen · 20/10/2021 11:46

I'm not easily shocked but this is appalling. That poor little girl.

Summersnake · 20/10/2021 11:46

Hopefully this is one thread that will get picked up by a newspaper

JollyAndBright · 20/10/2021 11:44

I wish this was unusual for these kind of places but it’s not.

I used to work as a body piercer and I heard of this happening so many times.
The argument is that “they really want it they are just scared, they will be happy that we forced them afterwards because the really Want it”

It’s such BS.

I had a friend who worked in Claire’s accessories as a teenager and she was told never to listen to the child, do exactly what the parent wants.
They even had them trained in how to get the parents to hold the child tightly against their body and hold their head so that the couldn’t move (usually used for the second piercing after they refused because the first one hurt)

I won’t start a rant about piercing guns but they are unnecessarily painful and traumatic to the skin. And to children.

It should 100% be banned.

Sirzy · 20/10/2021 11:42

@CovidCorvid

The only circumstance that this could possibly be Ok was if (depending on the age) the girl said before the proceedure that she really wanted it done, understood the risks, was scared of needles and knew she would shout/cry/scream get off during it but told the piercer to ignore her? Possibly.

I saw that happen with a friend having a tattoo once. Yes she was older at 18yo but I suppose it comes down to capacity. A 13yo can have capacity.

You'd still think most piercers for an under 18yo would say no.

That’s an awful road to go down for anyone. Especially for something that is entirely voluntary.

No means no. No it’s, buts or maybes. That should be the basic of bodily autonomy for anyone.

MrsRobbieHart · 20/10/2021 11:39

The only circumstance that this could possibly be Ok was if (depending on the age) the girl said before the proceedure that she really wanted it done, understood the risks, was scared of needles and knew she would shout/cry/scream get off during it but told the piercer to ignore her? Possibly.

No. That should still be a hard “no” from the piercer or tattoo artist.

Derbee · 20/10/2021 11:39

@CovidCorvid

The only circumstance that this could possibly be Ok was if (depending on the age) the girl said before the proceedure that she really wanted it done, understood the risks, was scared of needles and knew she would shout/cry/scream get off during it but told the piercer to ignore her? Possibly.

I saw that happen with a friend having a tattoo once. Yes she was older at 18yo but I suppose it comes down to capacity. A 13yo can have capacity.

You'd still think most piercers for an under 18yo would say no.

So possibly ok if a young girl tells her boyfriend that she wants to have sex, but might feel nervous and sound like she’s changed her mind. It hurts, so she starts shouting “no, stop” but he carries on because it’s for the best in the bigger scheme?

Absolutely fucking not ok. Neither is this piercing.

ancientgran · 20/10/2021 11:37

I don't think there is anyway this is OK.

WaterAndRichTea · 20/10/2021 11:37

A child actually recorded the footage

Derbee · 20/10/2021 11:37

This absolutely disgusting. I hope people boycott these stores.

How the fuck do we teach our children about bodily autonomy and consent when their own mother is the instigator of the abuse and mutilation? So so sad.

Glad the police are involved, but I assume they will say no crime has actually taken place. I hope lots of people recognise this fucker and shame her to her face

amusedtodeath1 · 20/10/2021 11:36

I should add that my DD is more upset I took her to a place that used guns. I had no idea tbh, I had mine done with guns, I had no clue how much safer needle piercing is.

CovidCorvid · 20/10/2021 11:36

The only circumstance that this could possibly be Ok was if (depending on the age) the girl said before the proceedure that she really wanted it done, understood the risks, was scared of needles and knew she would shout/cry/scream get off during it but told the piercer to ignore her? Possibly.

I saw that happen with a friend having a tattoo once. Yes she was older at 18yo but I suppose it comes down to capacity. A 13yo can have capacity.

You'd still think most piercers for an under 18yo would say no.

REDHERO · 20/10/2021 11:34

@Bagelsandbrie

I’ve seen this. It’s absolutely disgusting and heartbreaking.

Staff should be sacked and staff and those involved investigated for child cruelty.

Shop should be shut down.

This should never happen. Ear piercing should only happen when a child is old enough to give valid consent and take care of their ears themselves - I think about 12/13 as a minimum.

As a side not piercing with a gun should be banned anyway. Needle is always better, less scarring and less risk of infection.

Staff should be sacked and parents - where are they. Some pierce babies ears.

I wish there was a minimum age it's quite cruel but fashion and religious and cultural practices seem to be the way.

ancientgran · 20/10/2021 11:34

@MrsRobbieHart

I said this but all the girls in my daughters primary in year 6 had been done I made her wait until 12 but she really wanted it done

My son was the same. All the boys in his class went through a stage of having an ear pierced. He begged and pleaded with me. I said no. Repeatedly. He really wanted it done. I still said no. I’m the parent.

My son desperately wanted it done when he was about 13. I said no. Funnily enough he's in his 40s now and never got his ears pierced.
LittleMissGlum · 20/10/2021 11:34

'I wonder how long it will be before the mother/grandmother pops up somewhere to say that, actually, the little girl "really, REALLY wanted" earrings and was just "being naughty"?'

My thoughts exactly, won't be long before we hear how she's been asking for years to have this done and it was the right choice 🙄

It's awful, no one should be forced any sort of cosmetic procedure, let alone a child. I'm from a culture where getting ears pierced when you were very little was common, I must have been 3. I cried and cried, it was scary as can be. I have a family member who has pierced their very young daughters ears, I hate it, makes me very angry. Leave well alone, there isn't a 'time frame' to piece ears, let people make their choices. Sorry going off on a rant, really hope the girl is doing ok. Good to see police involved (still trying to work out how mum and grandma thought it was a great idea 🤷‍♀️)