Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ear piercing without consent at Meadowhall in Sheffield (might be triggering)

335 replies

PoetryLaser · 20/10/2021 09:53

I'm amazed that I can't find another thread on this – and I know I'm not being unreasonable to find this video incredibly upsetting. Poor child, perhaps six or seven being pinned to the floor while having her ears pierced in a jewellery store at the Meadowhall in Sheffield, screaming her head off saying "no no no".
Should ear piercing be banned for say under 12s, until they're old enough to consent?
Warning - the video is very distressing to watch: twitter.com/mrscjos/status/1450020437744885761?s=10

OP posts:
Jenufer · 20/10/2021 12:42

[quote EllieQ]It has been reported to the police, according to the BBC

www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-south-yorkshire-58971560[/quote]
Good. I have watched the video and I hope everyone involved is prosecuted.

I would in fact like all the adult to be locked up for a very, very long time and never to be allowed anywhere near a child again, but I do know that this WBU!

diddl · 20/10/2021 12:41

@nanbread

Agree *@Kanaloa* I imagine the staff really didn't want to do it
So then they shouldn't have done.

The people who restrained are clearly in the wrong but then surely piercing without consent is worse?

skodadoda · 20/10/2021 12:39

@Bagelsandbrie

I actually wanted to complain openly on the stores Facebook page but there’s nowhere to do that.

I have complained about Claire’s before after witnessing something similar.

They do have a Twitter page.
shouldistop · 20/10/2021 12:37

This video is horrible but what about religious male circumcision ? If your talking about long term psychical effects there is no comparison will that be banned as well?

It has been discussed time and again on Mumsnet and the vast majority of posters are completely against it.

MrsRobbieHart · 20/10/2021 12:35

No one cares unless a video comes out.

Well that’s not true, is it? People have been discussing genital mutilation of boys for a long time. It’s a much debated topic. Ear piercing in babies has been discussed on MN for as long as I’ve been here (13 years).

Mommabear20 · 20/10/2021 12:33

Absolutely disgusting!! And that's coming from someone with over 30 piercings in her life time!! I love them! My daughter however will not have hers done until she is over 10 AND comes to us asking for them to be done! It's abuse! Plain and simple!

Warsawa31 · 20/10/2021 12:31

Children don't have their autonomy respected in general.

This video is horrible but what about religious male circumcision ? If your talking about long term psychical effects there is no comparison will that be banned as well?

No one cares unless a video comes out.

shouldistop · 20/10/2021 12:30

That's disgusting and so upsetting.

I had my ears pierced at 8 and was very keen, sat still and took good care of them but actually I do think 12 would be a good cut off.

MrsRobbieHart · 20/10/2021 12:30

Of course 5 year olds can’t consent. You could offer a 5 year old a tiny tattoo of beautiful flower or a smiley face on their earlobe and they’d love the idea. Tell them it would hurt just like ear piercing and they’d still want the pretty thing on their ear. But we don’t do it just because they really want it.

sashh · 20/10/2021 12:26

@Peraltiago

That is just awful. Not quite the same scenario but when I was six I was pinned down for a medical procedure - I needed stitches on my face and was terrified. They sent my parents out of the room, two nurses held me down and the doctor stitched my face with no anaesthetic. I can honestly say it's caused me no end of issues with medical procedures. The feeling of powerlessness is just horrendous. The fact that this is an unnecessary cosmetic procedure and it's the girls own family holding her down... just wow. I hope she won't have any lasting issues from it.
I totally get this.

I had my face stitched as a child of about 4 maybe 5. No parent allowed and I was perfectly behaved, then a nurse came along ripped my knickers down and gave me a tetanus jab.

I walked back in to the waiting area crying that, 'they took my knickers down'.

I still cannot get an injection in my bum, I've had tetanus jabs since and depo but not in my bum. I'm 55 in a couple of weeks.

However I disagree with some PPs comments that guns are always bad and should be banned. I have 2x holes in each ear done by gun and I was quite glad that I had them done by gun, especially for the first ones, as it’s less daunting than a needle. Never had any issues with them.

Me too.

There is a lot of talk about sterilising and guns v needles, but guns were designed for this, needles are not and I have yet to see a needle piercer keep a sterile field.

I have had piercings done with both gun and needle.

Coffeeonmytoffee · 20/10/2021 12:25

I think they should ban ear piercing on children until they are at least 11

Sirzy · 20/10/2021 12:24

[quote k1233]@Sirzy yes, I think children can comprehend what piercing entails. I was 5yo too. My sister got hers done the same day, so I fully knew what was going to happen.

I do not agree with the video and restraining a child. However not all children behave like that.[/quote]
We will have to agree to disagree, I don’t believe any 5 year old can fully consent to the procedure itself and the aftercare involved.

They may think they want it but that’s not the same as informed consent

k1233 · 20/10/2021 12:23

@Sirzy yes, I think children can comprehend what piercing entails. I was 5yo too. My sister got hers done the same day, so I fully knew what was going to happen.

I do not agree with the video and restraining a child. However not all children behave like that.

heathspeedwell · 20/10/2021 12:21

What message are parents sending their daughters by saying they have to feel pain in order to look more attractive?

listsandbudgets · 20/10/2021 12:18

I dont know if this is ABH or GBH but would be very surprised if it was not classified as one of them.

The company shouldn't allow it. The staff member shouldn't have done it and the parents should be utterly and completely ashamed with themselves. They should all be prosecuted IMHO.

Poor little girl Angry

steff13 · 20/10/2021 12:17

That's terrible. My daughter got her ears pierced last year, for her 10th birthday. She'd been asking for years, but we waited until we thought she was old enough. I took her to a professional piercer at a tattoo shop, and he made it very clear when I scheduled the appointment that if she struggled or got upset he wouldn't do it.

SweetPetrichor · 20/10/2021 12:16

Personally I think piercings should be treated the same as tattoos. I assume in this case, the kid got scared and changed her mind...mum didn't want to pay for the procedure only for it to be 'wasted' by not going ahead...so went for the restrain approach. The shop should have stopped, but I guess they get given hell by parents who don't want to pay cause their kid changes their mind. It's a disaster start from finish.
I was 30 before I got my ears pierced because I was too scared when I was young and then never really wanted it done until I shaved my hair off and found that ear rings offset the baldy look a little.

Sirzy · 20/10/2021 12:14

@mam0918

As for OPs question on age, I willfully consented at 5 year old.

I think children (NOT babies) can consent but it's the child unforced consent that matters not the parents wants.

However, a side issue is if you have them pierced young as you grow the hole migrates into the wrong alignment, it's not a huge issue but something to consider.

Do you genuinely think that a 5 year old can provided informed consent though?

Saying “I want it” isn’t the same as understanding what your actually agreeing to.

AnnieLobeseder · 20/10/2021 12:14

@MrsRobbieHart

If I had been in the shop in the video while that poor child was being restrained and assaulted while verbally denying consent, I would have started kicking over the displays and shelves to get the staff's attention on me instead of assaulting that child.

Really? Instead of just telling them you were filming it and calling the police?

Okay, to be fair, I left out the bit where I would have spoken to them first, but would fully expect to be told to piss off and mind my own business, as happened in Claire's.

And I will concede that threatening to call the police might also be a better strategy, but apparently that's not the natural direction my brain goes.

QueenofKattegat · 20/10/2021 12:12

If I had been in the shop in the video while that poor child was being restrained and assaulted while verbally denying consent, I would have started kicking over the displays and shelves to get the staff's attention on me instead of assaulting that child

Now that would be worth filming.

mam0918 · 20/10/2021 12:11

As for OPs question on age, I willfully consented at 5 year old.

I think children (NOT babies) can consent but it's the child unforced consent that matters not the parents wants.

However, a side issue is if you have them pierced young as you grow the hole migrates into the wrong alignment, it's not a huge issue but something to consider.

MrsRobbieHart · 20/10/2021 12:10

If I had been in the shop in the video while that poor child was being restrained and assaulted while verbally denying consent, I would have started kicking over the displays and shelves to get the staff's attention on me instead of assaulting that child.

Really? Instead of just telling them you were filming it and calling the police?

DueyCheatemAndHow · 20/10/2021 12:08

2bf by videoing we have evidence so at least something has come from that...

AnnieLobeseder · 20/10/2021 12:08

I have had an extensive argument in Claire's before with a mother who was getting her screaming baby's ears pierced. I have no shame in telling parents that I think it's assault and abusive to disregard their child's bodily autonomy and modify the child's body before the child can give any kind of meaningful content. And I'm someone with a lot of piercings and tattoos, so it's not that I don't agree with piercings in general.

If I had been in the shop in the video while that poor child was being restrained and assaulted while verbally denying consent, I would have started kicking over the displays and shelves to get the staff's attention on me instead of assaulting that child.

It should be absolutely illegal to perform a piercing on a child who cannot verbally express that they want it done (special needs aside), and definitely illegal to continue if the child is distressed and denies consent!

I'm also examining why, in the instance I saw in Claire's, I just expressed my view and didn't physically intervene, but feel sure I would have physically intervened in this case. The only real difference is that the baby in Claire's didn't know what was happening and couldn't actually say 'no'. Perhaps it's because the baby probably won't remember the event, no long-term emotional damage done. Whereas a fully aware little girl will carry emotional and mental scars for a long time. The physical assault is the same, but the mental damage is greater in an older child. But don't mind me, just thinking out loud.

mam0918 · 20/10/2021 12:07

I studied crime and criminology for a semester but don't know the answer to this one so if anyone has a law degree I would be interested to know if a bystander intervened by forcibly removing those restraining and assaulting the child who would be responsible for assault?

The parents/shop workers for abusing the child or the bystanders who laid hands on adults to protect the child?

I don't think I could just stand and video that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread