Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 20 hour waiting time in my A and E is crazy...

240 replies

Meltinthemiddle · 20/10/2021 09:47

What the hell is happening to our NHS? Is this all down to covid and GP's not seeing patients face to face or people mis using the system. There's been alot of GP bashing recently and I do feel sorry for some of them as no doubt they are working flat out but their appointment system is shocking!

OP posts:
BarryTheKestrel · 20/10/2021 10:37

My Nan was experiencing chest pains and shortness of breath the other week. To avoid clogging things up we sat on hold to 111 for 45 mins, she got worse so hung up and called 999, 4 hours later a crew turned up. She has existing heart problems and we and the paramedics concluded likely heart attack so off to hospital she finally went.

My grandad is blind and I don't drive, they live over 10 miles from a hospital in an area where taxis are non existent on a Sunday afternoon.

The care she received once they arrived was second to none, but the wait could have killed her if things had gone south. It is terrifying.

Tistheseason17 · 20/10/2021 10:36

The latest rescue offer to GP surgeries from Boris says thst GPS need to see more people face to face.
Then it goes on to say the govt are aware there are not enough GPs so the govt will fund remote digital GP apptmts...
Can everyone not see this for what it is ?
Even the govt knows there are not enough GPs - they failed to deliver the extra trained GPs . They alow the right wing press to demonise GP services whilst govt is promoting payments to digital online GP providers (NOT F2F). The Govt is choosing not to invest in the NHS and we all need to understand this instead of getting divisive. Complain to your MP, not your GP.
Use your vote wisely next time or your GP service will be all digital and very profitable for friends of the govt - who prob have shares in the business.

P.s. hospital wait times are massive due to Covid backlogs and not caused by GPs!

AlyssasBackRolls · 20/10/2021 10:34

I've got mixed feelings about all this.

Telephone consultations are pretty good when it's a straightforward quick query and they have a place in healthcare going forward, especially given demand, but a relative working in healthcare as a consultant says that Face to Face is important because you can pick up on all sorts of physical cues that you can't over the phone. The way someone sits down or gets up, being able to observe their body and see things the patient themselves hasn't noticed whether it's a tremor, rash, discolouration or whatever.

I think the practices do need to loosen up a bit - I have a dermological condition that needed a face to face and I had to queue up outside to wait for my appointment in the howling rain, alongside people with tiny babies, elderly people with no where to sit and the reception staff literally only open a window a crack to check you in. When I was handed a repeat prescription I swear if she could have stuck it on the end of a stick to increase the distance she would have. I appreciate they're trying to stay safe but social distancing and masks in the waiting room could be a reasonable compromise not least as winter's on the way.

In fairness to my GP I've managed to be seen and treated, as have my children throughout the pandemic, with same day appointments, referals etc all going through pretty smoothly so they're doing an amazing job.

WeCalledTheDogIndiana · 20/10/2021 10:34

This If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there is just not true.

15 years ago waiting times were far lower; we haven't turned into a nation of hypochondriac time wasters in half a generation

Recent examples from my family/friends of things that were not immediately life threatening, could be waited for for some hours if had to, but did nonetheless need A&E:

  • adult with sudden loss of hearing in one ear. Saw GP, GP spoke to hospital consultant, consultant said send to A&E so he could take a look, because a referral to ENT any other way would take months. Waited 10 hours, got seen, immediate treatment given and fast tracked into follow up services
  • child who had a seizure (first ever). Ambulance called, gave oxygen, took her to A&E for observation. Would have been fine without A&E but doctors wanted her to be there in case she deteriorated quickly or had another seizure. Was there 8 hours
  • child with laboured breathing and a few other symptoms. Saw GP, sent to A&E, stayed in an A&E bay for 16 hours, checked every half hour to see if he was deteriorating further. Didn't need further treatment but again doctors wanted him there for quick treatment if he got worse
  • elderly adult fell, trouble moving freely, spoke to GP on phone who was worried and sent to A&E.

None of these were immediately life threatening and could (and did!) wait a long time, but all needed more medical intervention than a GP could provide and the GPs followed the system by sending to A&E.

Basically it's underfunded and understaffed and while there will always be some people going when they don't strictly need to, it is not the fault of people attending that there aren't enough staff or beds or equipment. Posts that blame people going to A&E can (a) put people off going when they really should and (b) shifts the focus away from the government underfunding services

user7667781 · 20/10/2021 10:34

Why it's happening: ambulances no longer able to unload patients onto trolley in corridor to wait to be seen due to Covid restrictions meaning each person needs their own little bay. Ambulances stuck outside ED for hours and hours waiting to unload patients. People can't get an ambulance due to this.
Same with patients walking into ED.
Add in people not happy with GP service so using ED as the GP (instead of e.g. going to pharmacy or out-of-hours GP service).
Add in not enough ED staff because the working conditions are horrendous and nursing as a profession involving a degree and often a masters is grossly underpaid.

Can you remember the days of new labour when the government implemented a 4 hour waiting time limit and the vast majority of the time this was met?!!! I wonder if the conservative government will ever achieve this, even after Covid is under control. No they won't. I say this to those that voted conservative: big mistake

StormTreader · 20/10/2021 10:33

We used to have a fantastic walk-in centre that got closed about a year before Covid, I used it for a suddenly worsening tonsilitis that couldn't have waited weeks trying to get a GP appointment but didn't need A&E - was out with antibiotics inside an hour, problem sorted.

Unfortunately, the A&E queues and GP crisis has been worsened by the removal of all these fantastic surrounding services taking some of the load.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 20/10/2021 10:33

My very good gp is sticking with the phone call/video consult where they do thar first, then book an appt themselves if needed. Exceptions made for any that can't use tech. Their view is that it is more efficient, and what many people prefer.

sillysmiles · 20/10/2021 10:33

Surely the people responsible for the A&E crisis is the government for underfunding and understaffing it? And for underfunding the GP service?

Couldhavebeenme3 · 20/10/2021 10:32

@BingBongToTheMoon

If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there.
Precisely this.

I was 8 hours in A&E (via 111 and ambulance with sepsis), and some of the idiocy I saw and overheard was incredible. Literally basic first aid and home medicine stuff, never mind pharmacist, GP, or MIU.

Frankly if you're well enough to be asking where the canteen is, or where you can nip out for a fag, your situation is not urgent. GPS are not refusing to treat patients, though it might seem more complicated, but bunging up A&E and preventing medical professionals from being able to deal with real life or death situations is abominable.

Enb76 · 20/10/2021 10:27

In 2008 the BMA voted to restrict the number of places at medical school and for a complete ban on opening any new medical schools. "allowing too many new doctors into the market would risk devaluing the profession"

I'm not sure what the votes have been since then or whether they have had any on this subject.

www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a748.full

Heidi1976 · 20/10/2021 10:25

I took my daughter recently as she broke her wrist. It was OOO but the amount of people in there for stuff that the GP or even the chemist could have sorted a few hours later was unbelievable. A dressing needed changing on a finger, chickenpox, a cough and cold. I was like what is going on.....there was a young boy in there who had sepsis symptoms and it was a 10 hour wait. It was awful.

BarbedButterfly · 20/10/2021 10:25

I had severe chest pains a few weeks ago and had to wait 2 hours to even see the triage nurse. There were people there with head injuries and one woman whose ankle was clearly broken. People were crying and begging to see someone. We were all still there 18 hours later. I had my blood tests and ecg after 3 hours in the end. They are crippled at the moment with lack of staff and a number of people attending due to problems that have become an emergency over lockdown

Second part of the problem of course was there were no beds for anyone that needed them.

Tigerwhocameforsupper · 20/10/2021 10:24

I needed a GP appointment yesterday, phoned at 8am and was asked whether I needed a face to face appointment or if a phone call would do. I got a call back at 9:30. Issue could be dealt over the phone so we were sorted.

We don’t have an A&E, just an urgent care centre. But the wait here is always 3-4 hours and has been for years.

User134342134 · 20/10/2021 10:22

Severe pain and heavy bleeding can be sepsis. That kind of thing is exactly what A&E is for. Unless you don't trust a woman to know what is abnormal for her? People don't just post on Mumsnet asking if they should go to A&E if they're having a normal period. Of all the examples to pick, you pick the one that could genuinely need attention. Honestly.

You're being deliberately abstruse here to pick on the poster. In the example, it was clear that she was saying how some people write about a common health problem (quote unquote PERIOD pains) and how MN replies whip it into a frenzy.

It was very fortunate that one MN poster did end up with sepsis and was seen but you do not know the specifics of that case. Eg if the bleeding happened in between periods, if it was post-partum, if it was after a miscarriage then all that could obviously point to more serious reasons.

Skysblue · 20/10/2021 10:21

My friend in Australia took her kid to their emergency department last week with shoulder pain. The wait to be seen was 5 minutes.

In Britain some children with suspected cancer wait a year to be seen by a consultant after the referral.

Britain is not a ‘good’ country anymore. Decades of mismanagement by morons.

I don’t want to leave my family and friends but I’m scared for my health in old age if I stay in UK and conscious that I have the option to emigrate now but won’t have that chance in later life.

clockover · 20/10/2021 10:20

@Lovelymincepies

Not very appointment needs to be F2F, unless you need physically examining why does it need to be F2F.

There is telemedicine, photo's some of it is actually much better than F2F because what you see is larger and clearer.

There are lots of reasons to by F2F is better for some. It's wrong to assume we are all the same and don't need that F2F. I'm autistic and I can't process a phone consultation the same as a F2F. I would imagine a lot of people with mental health issues would also benefit from being in the room with the doctor. It's not always just about the 'of it needs to be examined' aspect.

I haven't bothered calling my GP since covid began because I can't deal with the process or the phone appointment. Some would say that means I don't really need a doctor but the truth is I'm actually awful at taking care of myself and very much do need to see my doctor.

Simonjt · 20/10/2021 10:19

People use A&E irresponsibly, I have a colleague who goes every 2-3 weeks for various bizarre reasons, the latest being dry skin on her scalp. She then posts rants on social media about waiting for a long time and not being given the treatment she has demanded for her pretend illnesses.

I’ve been to A&E a few times, sometimes for me, sometimes for my son, we’ve always been triaged within the hour and either treated or admitted within 1-3 hours of that. When I had an appendicitis I was admitted within the hour and operated on that evening.

PheasantsNest · 20/10/2021 10:18

The whole system needs to change. They can't admit anyone from A&E as there are no beds free on the wards. Too many people go to A&E when they don't need to. You only have to read threads on here where people are advised to go to A&E for all sorts of things that aren't Accidents or Emergencies.

Mybalconyiscracking · 20/10/2021 10:17

Not sure why people are so fixated on face to face GP appointments. I find that telephone consultations at least initially, are much more convenient.

SmellyOldOwls · 20/10/2021 10:17

@BingBongToTheMoon

If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there.
Exactly. And even if the GP won't see you there are other options - a minor injuries unit, see a pharmacist. And there's the out of hours doctor for nights and weekends too.

Truth is lots of people are waiting long times for first consultant appointments and think they can bypass the wait by turning up at A&E because they know they might get a scan or if they're admitted they may get to see a specialist. That's not the GPs fault, that's a failure of the government who have been underfunding the health service and closing down hospitals for years.

YearsSinceISawYou · 20/10/2021 10:14

It is wrong to use A&E like a doctor's surgery.

But everyone, A&E staff included, are aware that until GPs go back to work, this will continue.

Before anyone with a skin in the game jumps in, GPs are not working hard.

Glitterybug · 20/10/2021 10:13

It is because people treat A&E like a walk in gp surgery. Look at mn for a snapshot 'I have severe period pain and heavy bleeding should I go A&E?' 'Yes it would be sepsis, or a life threatening hemorrhage, go NOW!'.

Severe pain and heavy bleeding can be sepsis. That kind of thing is exactly what A&E is for. Unless you don't trust a woman to know what is abnormal for her? People don't just post on Mumsnet asking if they should go to A&E if they're having a normal period. Of all the examples to pick, you pick the one that could genuinely need attention. Honestly.

A woman once posted on that subject and she did turn out to have sepsis. Her life was saved because MNers urged her to go to hospital. It's in classics somewhere.

blissfulllife · 20/10/2021 10:13

I've recently had to go through a and e that had an 8 hour wait. I was triaged and seen within an hour luckily. Waiting room was full with a queue to book in going right out the door. I was in a lot of pain and two ladies also waiting were talking to me to keep my mind off it. Both were there due to ongoing issues that would usually have been kept on top of with outpatient appointments with their consultants. But the pandemic stopped clinics. This meant their conditions worsened. GP can't help much. Complications then arise and they've had to present at A and E.

Same thing happened with my youngest. Seen by dermatologist since birth for a rare skin condition. She's a teen now and with dermatologist help and immune suppressants prescribed by him she was living a relatively pain free life. Then pandemic hits, no clinic, no meds review or blood tests to check on her liver, she gets sick very quickly and ends up in hospital 4 times that year. All could of been avoided with continuation of clinics even remotely.

User134342134 · 20/10/2021 10:12

Friend of mine worked as a doctor on A&E and 90% of cases were not true emergencies. They were usually long-standing health problems that escalated to the point where people panic and go to A&E. There is also the mistaken belief that going at crazy time (eg 1am) helps you escape the faff of making appointments and waiting and you skip the queue to see a doctor. A&E are not equipped to provide treatments or diagnosis for many things, they can only offer pain relief/antibiotics and make sure you're not dying at that point in time.

This is an unpopular opinion but I feel the NHS is broken to the point that people need to go private if they're truly worried about their health. Why put your own life on the line just to prove a point that healthcare should and needs to be free? In the vast majority of other countries, healthcare is not free and people accept that. The "free" version of healthcare for uninsured patients is so poor that it's normal for people in many countries to pay for doctors.

There's a bizarre entitlement in the UK that medical care NEEDS to be free which is very strange for people who have lived in other countries. Paying for healthcare is seen as a perversion but if your car or washing machine breaks then you obviously need to pay for that too. A private consultation is about the same as car repairs, one night's hotel or other unexpected expenses that should be budgeted for in an average household. I know friends who doggedly wait months for their NHS appointments whilst in ever worsening health but refusing to contemplate spending that £100 to get an answer immediately.

As the title suggests, if more people went private they would be doing their own health a favour as well as relieving the collective burden on GPs and A&E. The problem is obviously not enough doctors to begin with so the free services are stretched to the limit. This is common across many countries, including highly taxed German and Scandinavian countries. In many European countries it's perfectly normal to use insurance covered doctors if you can but also pay for private care if you need it. You don't need private insurance either. If it's just 1-2 appointments per year then it's cheaper to pay out entirely out of pocket. The major advantage is that you get your health seen at a point where hasn't escalated into something more serious and you also helped relieved pressure on the system for other patients.

Meltinthemiddle · 20/10/2021 10:12

I actually feel sorry for GPs. Alot of people are blaming them for a and e crisis l.

OP posts: