Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 20 hour waiting time in my A and E is crazy...

240 replies

Meltinthemiddle · 20/10/2021 09:47

What the hell is happening to our NHS? Is this all down to covid and GP's not seeing patients face to face or people mis using the system. There's been alot of GP bashing recently and I do feel sorry for some of them as no doubt they are working flat out but their appointment system is shocking!

OP posts:
ThatsSoFetch · 20/10/2021 11:00

They are all just so overrun at the moment!

I know people who have gone to A&E with minor problems - ear infections etc - and been clearly told that their GP could have dealt with it but it’s been that they simply can’t get in

But then I know others who haven’t gone because of the wait and actually needed to go - for example eventually finding out their child had indeed fractured their arm and needed a cast.

I think GPs need to get ‘back to normal’ before A&E will. TBH though I really don’t mind a telephone appointment with the GP if it’s something that can be discussed over the phone - for example knowing you need a particular medicine or requesting a referral. It does save a lot of time for the patient! And in fact if they do need to see you after that telephone appointment they are normally quite quick at getting you in.

NoDecentHandlesLeft · 20/10/2021 10:59

If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there

In some cases this is true, but for example, imagine an elderly person (no family support) fell at home. No injuries, but couldn't get up so called an ambulance. Ambulance took them into hospital as they were clearly not coping at home safely.
The person is not ill and does not need medical attention as such. However, they can not discharge them as their home is unsafe. There are no community services. The person probably needs to go into a care home.
They are safe to wait for many hours over emergencies. They probably shouldn't be in A+E, but there is nowhere else for them to go.

Or someone who is suffering from a mental health crisis, but in no immediate medical need. They can sit in A+E for hours and hours waiting to see a MH professional. They probably shouldn't be in A+E either, but MH services have been cut to the bone.

neededafart · 20/10/2021 10:58

@BingBongToTheMoon

If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there.
THIS !

A real accident or emergency is seen very quickly.

Saoirse82 · 20/10/2021 10:58

@BingBongToTheMoon

If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there.
Of course you would Hmm. What if you have a broken limb?
Seasonschange · 20/10/2021 10:57

@WeCalledTheDogIndiana

This If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there is just not true.

15 years ago waiting times were far lower; we haven't turned into a nation of hypochondriac time wasters in half a generation

Recent examples from my family/friends of things that were not immediately life threatening, could be waited for for some hours if had to, but did nonetheless need A&E:

  • adult with sudden loss of hearing in one ear. Saw GP, GP spoke to hospital consultant, consultant said send to A&E so he could take a look, because a referral to ENT any other way would take months. Waited 10 hours, got seen, immediate treatment given and fast tracked into follow up services
  • child who had a seizure (first ever). Ambulance called, gave oxygen, took her to A&E for observation. Would have been fine without A&E but doctors wanted her to be there in case she deteriorated quickly or had another seizure. Was there 8 hours
  • child with laboured breathing and a few other symptoms. Saw GP, sent to A&E, stayed in an A&E bay for 16 hours, checked every half hour to see if he was deteriorating further. Didn't need further treatment but again doctors wanted him there for quick treatment if he got worse
  • elderly adult fell, trouble moving freely, spoke to GP on phone who was worried and sent to A&E.

None of these were immediately life threatening and could (and did!) wait a long time, but all needed more medical intervention than a GP could provide and the GPs followed the system by sending to A&E.

Basically it's underfunded and understaffed and while there will always be some people going when they don't strictly need to, it is not the fault of people attending that there aren't enough staff or beds or equipment. Posts that blame people going to A&E can (a) put people off going when they really should and (b) shifts the focus away from the government underfunding services

Add on broken bones and cuts that need stitches… a&e isn’t just for those on deaths door.
TheReluctantPhoenix · 20/10/2021 10:56

You were sold an illusion.

The NHS has always been pretty bad, with some (although far from all) heroic individuals working in a terrible system.

There is a reason that most who can afford it but medical insurance.

It never had any contingency built into it and, under a little stress, it has cracked wide open.

It is underfunded, managed by ex nurses and overpaid management consultants, and a recipe for any additional funding to feed mainly into inflation and only a small percentage into better medical outcomes.

It needs a combination of a major uplift in funding and root-and-branch reform. Not going to happen , though.

Good religion for some, though.

HeadNorth · 20/10/2021 10:56

Another issue is not being able to register with a GP. My youngest is at University and cannot get a GP in her University city, so has no choice but to go through 111, who then may send her to A&E. The system is broken, don't blame the poor victims (by which I mean the staff and the worried patients) blame the system.

Glitterybug · 20/10/2021 10:54

You're being deliberately abstruse here to pick on the poster. In the example, it was clear that she was saying how some people write about a common health problem (quote unquote PERIOD pains) and how MN replies whip it into a frenzy.

The word is obtuse. Most women with heavy bleeding and abdominal pain would describe that as a period and period pains because that is their frame of reference. It doesn't mean it is "just" a period.

Pottedpalm · 20/10/2021 10:54

@blissfulllife

I've recently had to go through a and e that had an 8 hour wait. I was triaged and seen within an hour luckily. Waiting room was full with a queue to book in going right out the door. I was in a lot of pain and two ladies also waiting were talking to me to keep my mind off it. Both were there due to ongoing issues that would usually have been kept on top of with outpatient appointments with their consultants. But the pandemic stopped clinics. This meant their conditions worsened. GP can't help much. Complications then arise and they've had to present at A and E.

Same thing happened with my youngest. Seen by dermatologist since birth for a rare skin condition. She's a teen now and with dermatologist help and immune suppressants prescribed by him she was living a relatively pain free life. Then pandemic hits, no clinic, no meds review or blood tests to check on her liver, she gets sick very quickly and ends up in hospital 4 times that year. All could of been avoided with continuation of clinics even remotely.

The cessation of clinics was a disgrace, in my opinion. DH has been attending regularly for reviews of an eye condition which can result in loss of vision. During lockdown he received a letter cancelling his scheduled appointment and stating that as his condition was considered ‘stable he was being removed from the consultant’s list. Madness! Strangely, some nine months later, he received a new appointment as it was considered ‘important that he attend for his condition to be monitored and treatment adjusted as necessary’. One can only assume this was some sort of fudging of statistis.
Tistheseason17 · 20/10/2021 10:54

[quote dreamingbohemian]@Tistheseason17 I'm talking about A&E triage.

Where I come from if you showed up in A&E with dry skin or something really minor, they would tell you to go home, you wouldn't even be put in the system.[/quote]
Thank goodness it's working somewhere 😅 you've got to wonder what goes thru the mind of some people - although I suspect it us heightened anxiety. Our mental health services need more resource! Best wishes

Lovelymincepies · 20/10/2021 10:54

True and ever increasing population. Lots of elderly people with conditions and lots of younger unhealthy people with chronic conditions.

I worked in A and E for many, many years before I jumped ship because I was fed up of the abuse and how unsafe it was. There were indeed some people who loved hanging out in A and E for many hours Grin

dreamingbohemian · 20/10/2021 10:54

I agree with you @User134342134 but I understand it's a very emotional attachment to 'free' healthcare in the UK

Personally I think the French system is best as it's means tested, so a huge number of people do have free healthcare, many more pay something very small, and people with resources pay more.

You can buy private top-up care for things like vision and dental and prescriptions.

But I can't see any UK government trying to change the whole system, instead they will just let it get more and more dysfunctional so people are driven into private and then the government can wash its hands of them completely.

starrynight87 · 20/10/2021 10:52

You need to hire an old school matron to go around A&E going 'no, go home...pharmacy for you...wait for GP'

NoDecentHandlesLeft · 20/10/2021 10:51

@PheasantsNest

The whole system needs to change. They can't admit anyone from A&E as there are no beds free on the wards. Too many people go to A&E when they don't need to. You only have to read threads on here where people are advised to go to A&E for all sorts of things that aren't Accidents or Emergencies.
The thing is, nobody on here can tell someone if they need immediate medical attention or not. It's dangerous to say that the poster will be fine and does not need A+E.
Mrbob · 20/10/2021 10:50

I work in an A&E with wait times regularly over 12 hours. Sometimes people die in the waiting room which would suggest they probably did need to be there. Although its possible they died of old age having waited so long. Don't blame the people. There will be a small number who shouldn't be there but most people attend because they have no other option either because no one else will help them or because they are in pain or unwell

sillysmiles · 20/10/2021 10:50

@MissyB1

Because we now have a third world healthcare system thanks to years of underfunding. This was the Tory plan, break it then say it’s needs selling off. Seems to be going to plan so far….
^

This.

It is a strategic plan.

dreamingbohemian · 20/10/2021 10:49

@Tistheseason17 I'm talking about A&E triage.

Where I come from if you showed up in A&E with dry skin or something really minor, they would tell you to go home, you wouldn't even be put in the system.

Couldhavebeenme3 · 20/10/2021 10:48

@WeCalledTheDogIndiana

This If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there is just not true.

15 years ago waiting times were far lower; we haven't turned into a nation of hypochondriac time wasters in half a generation

Recent examples from my family/friends of things that were not immediately life threatening, could be waited for for some hours if had to, but did nonetheless need A&E:

  • adult with sudden loss of hearing in one ear. Saw GP, GP spoke to hospital consultant, consultant said send to A&E so he could take a look, because a referral to ENT any other way would take months. Waited 10 hours, got seen, immediate treatment given and fast tracked into follow up services
  • child who had a seizure (first ever). Ambulance called, gave oxygen, took her to A&E for observation. Would have been fine without A&E but doctors wanted her to be there in case she deteriorated quickly or had another seizure. Was there 8 hours
  • child with laboured breathing and a few other symptoms. Saw GP, sent to A&E, stayed in an A&E bay for 16 hours, checked every half hour to see if he was deteriorating further. Didn't need further treatment but again doctors wanted him there for quick treatment if he got worse
  • elderly adult fell, trouble moving freely, spoke to GP on phone who was worried and sent to A&E.

None of these were immediately life threatening and could (and did!) wait a long time, but all needed more medical intervention than a GP could provide and the GPs followed the system by sending to A&E.

Basically it's underfunded and understaffed and while there will always be some people going when they don't strictly need to, it is not the fault of people attending that there aren't enough staff or beds or equipment. Posts that blame people going to A&E can (a) put people off going when they really should and (b) shifts the focus away from the government underfunding services

All these examples were sent to A&E after seeking advice from gp/other healthcare professionals, so absolutely the right place for them to be. The extended wait times are what op is talking about - if folk all took the line of self-care/gp/pharmacist/miu etc before heading straight to A&E then a huge number of them would be dealt with in the community rather than blocking A&E for people with a critical need for care.

Absolutely go to A&E if you need urgent and emergency care, but I've seen folk walk out with paracetamol and elastoplast.

MissyB1 · 20/10/2021 10:46

Because we now have a third world healthcare system thanks to years of underfunding. This was the Tory plan, break it then say it’s needs selling off.
Seems to be going to plan so far….

bunnybuggs · 20/10/2021 10:46

@Lovelymincepies People want instant fixes rather than just letting there bodies get over minor illness and viruses, you only have to look on here to know that! The amount of people that tell people to go to A and E for self limiting reasons or reasons that a pharmacist could sort you out for.
Exactly this but that is not ALL the fault of the government although I agree they are spending our tax contributions unwisely as regards the NHS.
It is the entitled attitude of so many of the rapidly increasing population who think because it is 'free' it must be available for them all the time.
There needs to be more minor injury units with medical staff either present or on call if required and x-rays to deal with minor bone breaks.

Most people if they have had attention and 'been seen' by a medical professional feel reassured.

Seriously no-one really wants to spend 8+ hours in an a and e waiting room. Hmm

Seasonschange · 20/10/2021 10:44

@BingBongToTheMoon

If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there.
Well this is bollocks. I waited 16 hours to go to a&e with a broken shoulder. I still needed a&e!
Tistheseason17 · 20/10/2021 10:43

@dreamingbohemian

If the problem is time wasters then why not fix the triage system?

Why aren't people showing up with 'dry skin' sent home right away?

Because the Govt has told the general public they have a right to choice to see their GP for whatever issue they have.
Couldhavebeenme3 · 20/10/2021 10:40

I remember in my gp surgery there was a poster showing how many appointments were missed in the last month. Maybe there should be a campaign for similar in A&E departments - 30% of patients could have taken paracetamol and self-care, 20% could have visited the GP, 10% could have bout otc medicines from the pharmacist...

dreamingbohemian · 20/10/2021 10:40

If the problem is time wasters then why not fix the triage system?

Why aren't people showing up with 'dry skin' sent home right away?

user7667781 · 20/10/2021 10:37

[quote Enb76]In 2008 the BMA voted to restrict the number of places at medical school and for a complete ban on opening any new medical schools. "allowing too many new doctors into the market would risk devaluing the profession"

I'm not sure what the votes have been since then or whether they have had any on this subject.

www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a748.full[/quote]
God, they are still of this opinion.

They are not worried about the profession being devalued, they are worried about their salaries being lowered.

Supply and demand. If they restrict supply, the price goes up.

In other countries, they train far more doctors, GPs only have MScs not full doctorates so there are far more of them and primary care is not the shitshow it is in the UK. If your job is to refer people to secondary care, you don't need to be the same level of training as an eye surgeon.

Swipe left for the next trending thread