Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 20 hour waiting time in my A and E is crazy...

240 replies

Meltinthemiddle · 20/10/2021 09:47

What the hell is happening to our NHS? Is this all down to covid and GP's not seeing patients face to face or people mis using the system. There's been alot of GP bashing recently and I do feel sorry for some of them as no doubt they are working flat out but their appointment system is shocking!

OP posts:
RaininSummer · 20/10/2021 11:44

A relative of mine was on a trolley for 26 hours 2 weeks ago after being ambulanced in after a heart attack. Treated and home now after an op but it was a worrying start. Not true that if you have to wait that long you don't need to be there at all.

SueSaid · 20/10/2021 11:43

'You have no concept. That poster could have died.'

I do have concept thanks.

I'm not suggesting anyone with any symptoms should sit at home and die. There is a system you see, you ring your gp they will see you if needed. If not you ring 111. Or, attend one of the many UTC or minor injury units.

A&Es tend to be in larger towns and cities so these people who use A&E as a gp surgery are able to travel.

Just go the UTC. A&E is for accidents and emergencies.

Equimum · 20/10/2021 11:39

In response to the comments in here saying that people go to A&E too easily, I was actually advised to go to A&E by my GPS reception for a simple infection that just needed antibiotics. She said they had no appointments, 111 was overloaded, the local urgent care was at capacity, so I should go to A&E (I had been told by pharmacist that I needed an urgent GP appointment). I explained this at A&E, and was told it didn't need A&E, but it did need treating urgently. On that evening, they were literally the only place seeing patients that hadn't made an appointment early in the day. They treated me, as they accepted I did need antibiotics ASAP, but we all knew they shouldn't have been the people treating me.

SnottyLottie · 20/10/2021 11:35

I work in a hospital and have access to the A&E waiting list. The other day there were 130 people in A&E at 11am. It was absolutely crazy (for context it’s usually half that amount at that time of day). The waiting time was over 10 hours.

You get ranked 1 to 4, 1 being you’re literally dying, 4 being you would probably be better off going to the walk in centre. Most were 3 or 4s. I would say two people did not need to be there (one report of a snotty nose, one had a nettle sting rash - both rated a 4 so not struggling to breathe or in anaphylactic shock). If an emergency comes in then you obviously get pushed down the list.

The most shocking aspect were the number of people there with mental health problems or who had purposely overdosed. Unfortunately I know from personal experience how difficult it is to get an appointment at the GP for mental health reasons. It caused a loved one to have a mental break down which required hospital admission which fast tracked them to get the GP appointment they desperately needed.

The A&E receptionist told me that they are really understaffed (both clinical and non clinical staff) because people keep going off sick with stress. She said on an average week there will only be two days where everyone who was scheduled to work will be in. It’s gotten worse since Covid.

Xiaoxiong · 20/10/2021 11:35

@StormTreader

We used to have a fantastic walk-in centre that got closed about a year before Covid, I used it for a suddenly worsening tonsilitis that couldn't have waited weeks trying to get a GP appointment but didn't need A&E - was out with antibiotics inside an hour, problem sorted.

Unfortunately, the A&E queues and GP crisis has been worsened by the removal of all these fantastic surrounding services taking some of the load.

We are the same - there was a walk-in centre up the road at a smaller hospital which we always used before, when it was closed, they explicitly told people to go to A&E instead. The statement they made in March 2020 said it was temporary because of covid but that was 18 months ago and no sign of reopening:

Services at XX Walk in Centre are being temporarily suspended on 30 April.
News – 1 May 2020

For health advice visit NHS 111 online. For minor illnesses such as ongoing back pain, contact your GP. For minor injury, such as fractures, visit A&E at XX Hospital.

The minor illness and injury unit at XX Walk in Centre is to be temporarily suspended as part of the national effort to combat Covid-19 (coronavirus).

Many NHS staff have been redeployed into new, temporary roles, to increase the response to Covid-19 and to support those treating the most seriously ill patients.

In order to make the best use of resources, local NHS commissioners have taken the decision to suspend services at the XX Walk in Centre from Thursday 30 April. This will allow clinicians from the unit to be redeployed to where their skills can be put to the best use. This could include additional support to the Out of Hours Service, or home visiting to support GP practices in the management of patients with covid-19 symptoms.

Patients will still be able to access treatment for minor ailments via their GP surgery, which they can access by phone or online. Further information is available on their practice website and help is also available via the NHS111 service, by dialling 111 or visiting: www.111.nhs.uk.

Anybody needing treatment for injuries such as suspected fractures should go to A&E at XX Hospital.

This is a temporary measure aimed at making the best use of valuable clinical expertise and resources during extraordinary times.

PandoraP · 20/10/2021 11:34

I think people do go to a&e too quickly, but I also don’t agree that you practically have to be dead already to go to a&e.

ThatsSoFetch · 20/10/2021 11:31

@Iooselipssinkships

Had to wait hours upon hours and then some more for a dislocated finger. Definitely needed to be there as it was deformed and at a complete right angle. I did look up online if I could put it back into place myself but it wasn't recommended due to potential complications. So yeah, those who are waiting a very long time sometimes do need to be there. It's for accidents as well as emergencies, hence the title. Saying that I did have a look around though and wondered why certain (most) people were there when they seemed absolutely fine, in good health, with no visible injuries or any inclination of being in pain. It felt more like an airport lounge with a delayed flight than a hospital, but then again who am I to judge.
This is like me - googling to see if you could sort it yourself!

I managed to slice open my knuckle with a Stanley knife doing DIY - it was like a flap of skin on the top of my hand and I could see my tendon - I tried to put a plaster on it! Grin As it is - I eventually went to A&E because I couldn’t line the skin back together and it was just steri stripped BUT they said it was right to attend as IF I had nicked my tendon even just a little bit, it would have required surgery. They actually said they had never seen such an injury where the tendon hadn’t actually been damaged!

Fetarabbit · 20/10/2021 11:31

@elbea

They clearly don’t need to be there if they are able to wait 20 hours. The only times I’ve ever been to A&E I’ve been seen immediately because it was life threatening.

111, minors or out of hours all seem like more appropriate places. If it isn’t a life threatening emergency A&E isn’t the right place.

If you still have minor injuries or out of hours appointments available, yes. Here the wild decision was made to increase staffing at the hospital A&E that serves a huge catchment, and close many of the minor units, and limit out of hours apps to few locations and for limited reasons.
REDHERO · 20/10/2021 11:29

My surgery has a huge delay in seeing people. They only see a few things face to face. My asthma review is over the phone - now how does that work, they cannot listen to breathing, check peek flows and BP and chest. Stupid really. I think people get desperate and go to A&E then with things GP could sort.

Why are GP's still doing most over the phone? It makes no sense anymore.

elbea · 20/10/2021 11:28

They clearly don’t need to be there if they are able to wait 20 hours. The only times I’ve ever been to A&E I’ve been seen immediately because it was life threatening.

111, minors or out of hours all seem like more appropriate places. If it isn’t a life threatening emergency A&E isn’t the right place.

SmellyOldOwls · 20/10/2021 11:26

@AlyssasBackRolls

I've got mixed feelings about all this.

Telephone consultations are pretty good when it's a straightforward quick query and they have a place in healthcare going forward, especially given demand, but a relative working in healthcare as a consultant says that Face to Face is important because you can pick up on all sorts of physical cues that you can't over the phone. The way someone sits down or gets up, being able to observe their body and see things the patient themselves hasn't noticed whether it's a tremor, rash, discolouration or whatever.

I think the practices do need to loosen up a bit - I have a dermological condition that needed a face to face and I had to queue up outside to wait for my appointment in the howling rain, alongside people with tiny babies, elderly people with no where to sit and the reception staff literally only open a window a crack to check you in. When I was handed a repeat prescription I swear if she could have stuck it on the end of a stick to increase the distance she would have. I appreciate they're trying to stay safe but social distancing and masks in the waiting room could be a reasonable compromise not least as winter's on the way.

In fairness to my GP I've managed to be seen and treated, as have my children throughout the pandemic, with same day appointments, referals etc all going through pretty smoothly so they're doing an amazing job.

My GP surgery is the same, it does make me laugh but at the same time you know every other idiot who gets a cough will go to the doctors looking for antibiotics or a cough bottle rather than just staying at home so I can't blame the receptionists for wanting to keep away from them Grin

SmellyOldOwls · 20/10/2021 11:22

@User134342134

Severe pain and heavy bleeding can be sepsis. That kind of thing is exactly what A&E is for. Unless you don't trust a woman to know what is abnormal for her? People don't just post on Mumsnet asking if they should go to A&E if they're having a normal period. Of all the examples to pick, you pick the one that could genuinely need attention. Honestly.

You're being deliberately abstruse here to pick on the poster. In the example, it was clear that she was saying how some people write about a common health problem (quote unquote PERIOD pains) and how MN replies whip it into a frenzy.

It was very fortunate that one MN poster did end up with sepsis and was seen but you do not know the specifics of that case. Eg if the bleeding happened in between periods, if it was post-partum, if it was after a miscarriage then all that could obviously point to more serious reasons.

Funny you mention miscarriage. I've seen posters advise other posters to go to A&E for very early miscarriages. Of all the conditions that A&E cannot help with a miscarriage is one of them (I've had 4)
hibbledibble · 20/10/2021 11:22

Thank you for posting. I work for the NHS. I hope highlighting the long waits will help to deter people who don't need urgent care from going to A&E, and accessing suitable alternative services.

I do completely agree the NHS is in a very sad state right now. Sadly that's unlikely to change soon.

Fetarabbit · 20/10/2021 11:20

@BingBongToTheMoon

If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there.
It depends I suppose. My friend broke her ankle, phoned 111, tried to find out if there were any minor injuries open but no, so had to go to A&E to have it x rayed and strapped up. She was in agony but not in immediate danger, and was waiting around 9 hours. That wait could have been a lot longer if it was busier, she could have gone home and tried another day, but probably be the same story, not to mention at risk of doing more damage. Its not just GP apps being hard to get, but a lot of areas have closed their minor injury units so cannot x Ray which is ridiculous.
CrumpleHornedSnowcack · 20/10/2021 11:19

I had to go to A&E recently & only waited around 15-20 mins to be initially triaged by a nurse. Was taken straight to a bed & treatment so I guess it depends how urgent it is deemed to be at triage

Iooselipssinkships · 20/10/2021 11:18

Had to wait hours upon hours and then some more for a dislocated finger. Definitely needed to be there as it was deformed and at a complete right angle. I did look up online if I could put it back into place myself but it wasn't recommended due to potential complications. So yeah, those who are waiting a very long time sometimes do need to be there. It's for accidents as well as emergencies, hence the title. Saying that I did have a look around though and wondered why certain (most) people were there when they seemed absolutely fine, in good health, with no visible injuries or any inclination of being in pain. It felt more like an airport lounge with a delayed flight than a hospital, but then again who am I to judge.

Staryflight445 · 20/10/2021 11:18

A lot of people abuse GP appointments too and even book in and go when it’s not really necessary.

We have pamphlets for everything! Why isn’t there one about things we can ignore and things that need to be taken seriously?
What sort of issues you need to have to need to attend a&e.
All the services available in the area if you need help etc.

It is all helpful.

Ottercave · 20/10/2021 11:16

Where I live people would love to have a telephone consultation with the GP’s but you can’t even get that.
Dr’s surgery opens at 8.30. By 8.40 all appointments are gone and you’re told to ring back the next day.
If you’re lucky to get an appointment it’s usually for about 3-4 weeks time.
No walk in centre anywhere near and a MIU that’s either on short hours or closed due to lack of staff.
Not excusing everybody who turns up at A & E but can kind of understand it if a condition gets worse and you can’t access the first point of call.

sunflowerdaisies · 20/10/2021 11:15

For balance, I had to take my child to A&E recently - we were questioned on the door before even allowed in as they were dealing with illnesses separately from accidents. It was for a broken bone - triaged, X-ray, doctor, cast all within 1.5 hours. It's not so bad as some of these anecdotes everywhere.

Staryflight445 · 20/10/2021 11:13

I think that the staff checking people into the system should be able to refuse access to those who do not need to be there. For example, people who really should be directed to their GP or for fractures redirected to another service (I know that’s not available everywhere).

I recall waiting in the walk in surgery once and someone went to the desk and said that their issue had been going on for 5 days and a&e redirected them there. The staff eye rolled and asked did they even consider to make a gp appointment?

It must be infuriating to see so many people wasting time in already overstretched services.

This just doesn’t happen when the services need to be paid for by the patient. I think that something like a fine needs to be brought in, people will die because of it I’m sure but people need to be able to access the correct services without the risk of not being able to use them correctly due to time wasting people that abuse their free healthcare.

YearsSinceISawYou · 20/10/2021 11:12

@Mybalconyiscracking

Not sure why people are so fixated on face to face GP appointments. I find that telephone consultations at least initially, are much more convenient.
Not everyone can express themselves on the phone clearly-even verbally confident people are not great describing medical problems on the phone.

Not everyone can describe how a lump feels or what consistency a rash or change in colour might be. Photographs taken with a mobile phone are next to useless.

A good GP knows that often patients present with one problem but, as they talk, the real-sometimes more frightening-reason for their visit will improve.

Talking to a GP on the 'phone is no where near good enough to actually seeing a doctor and if doctors are saying they get through more patients on the phone, that that will be because each patient is not getting enough time.

What has actually changed for them pre-pandemic that they can no longer give appointments. I mean, what has ACTUALLY changed?

Mummyoflittledragon · 20/10/2021 11:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

user7667781 · 20/10/2021 11:10

At least half of you voted for this.

The first thing the conservatives did when they took over from (new) labour was to remove the 4-hour waiting time target.

dreamingbohemian · 20/10/2021 11:02

@Tistheseason17 Yes that's so true, people are not at their most rational when they're in pain and scared.

They really should have minor injuries units everywhere, I've used one in London and it was fantastic.

MorrisZapp · 20/10/2021 11:01

My adult niece had agonising pain due to gallbladder inflammation. Five separate GPS refused to believe her, gave her pregnancy tests, then sent her off with painkillers.

Even when my sister got involved and finally got a diagnosis she was told that it wasn't an emergency and that the waiting list for the surgery she needed was over a year.

We were going to go private but then the pandemic shut down the NHS and everyone dashed to get on private lists, making them months long.

One very difficult night my sister could take no more of her daughters distraught agony and took her to A and E, at which point a doctor said 'gosh yes this does need emergency surgery' and my neice was operated on the next day.

So I'm sorry but yes, if all other options fail, a and e can indeed act as the nuclear option to actual treatment.

As an aside, throughout this entire process, NOT ONE hcp has mentioned diet to my niece. Not one. She was given tramadol.

This is where we are.

Swipe left for the next trending thread