Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 20 hour waiting time in my A and E is crazy...

240 replies

Meltinthemiddle · 20/10/2021 09:47

What the hell is happening to our NHS? Is this all down to covid and GP's not seeing patients face to face or people mis using the system. There's been alot of GP bashing recently and I do feel sorry for some of them as no doubt they are working flat out but their appointment system is shocking!

OP posts:
TheReluctantPhoenix · 20/10/2021 16:54

@Fallagain,

There are GPs and GPs. Some are great, too many have realised how little they can get away with.

It was the same with teachers in the lockdowns. Some worked themselves to the bone to support the children, others took advantage of the lack of oversight to do very little.

And GPs get paid an awful lot more than teachers.

Fallagain · 20/10/2021 16:46

GPs are the new teachers. Vilified on social media for doing their best with limited resources. No wonder we don’t have enough of either.

takemetomars · 20/10/2021 16:36

[quote YearsSinceISawYou]@takemetomars

An urgent care clinic is not a routine GP appointment.

Are we supposed to stand up and applaud because a GP saw 15 out of 60 patients?

That's his/her/their job! Anyway, only 1 GP-where were the rest of them?[/quote]
Funnily enough, all the other GPS had clinics too, seeing 'routine stuff' as you call it. Have you any idea how long it takes to see an average patient with complex care needs? The GP in question worked from 8 until 1.30 to see those 15 patient. She then grabbed some lunch - hope that is ok with you- then drove to the branch Sugery where she did an afternoon F2F clinic, paperwork etc. This is typical of most GPs. Bet you don't work that hard. See how annoying it is when people make assumptions about your working life even though they don't know you? Yes

YearsSinceISawYou · 20/10/2021 14:17

@takemetomars

An urgent care clinic is not a routine GP appointment.

Are we supposed to stand up and applaud because a GP saw 15 out of 60 patients?

That's his/her/their job! Anyway, only 1 GP-where were the rest of them?

MalteserGeezee · 20/10/2021 14:16

The NHS is no longer fit for purpose and it's high time that we as a nation have a sensible discussion about how to reform it. I'm sick of being made to feel constantly "grateful" for the crumbs off the table that is healthcare in this country, a system I pay a significant amount of tax for. There needs to be another way.

PumpkinPie2016 · 20/10/2021 13:34

I think the system is overwhelmed and there are a number of reasons for that.

My GP surgery is extremely difficult to get an appointment with, emergency, telephone, in advance or any other version! There simply aren't enough GPs for the numbers of patients.

The town had a walk in centre which was well used but that closed last year and isn't reopening.

I do feel though that some people could take a bit more responsibility for themselves and use self care/pharmacy/out of hours but they choose to rock up at A&E instead. This then increases wait times in A&E and so the cycle continues. Obviously, many people attending genuinely need A&E.

Mental health services again are over stretched. I know someone who is on a waiting list for mental health support. I can't give details but it's a very genuine need and they have times when they don't feel safe/are distressed. But the waiting list is 6+ months. They are not someone who would go to A&E when distressed so they suffer with whatever support family/friends provide Sad

The issue is underfunding causing shortages of staff and then remaining staff are overworked and become sick etc.

Ethelswith · 20/10/2021 13:34

The ambulance crisis isn't helping.

All the ambulances are queuing outside A&E (they can't just offload patients and go to the next one, as there's nowhere to put the patients)

Patients who need to be admitted can't be, because wards are full. Covid really hasn't helped on that. But neither has the social care crisis - there are patients who don't need to be in hospital, but end up stuck there because they cannot be discharged safely as the support provision they need can't be provided (in many cases, backlog means they can't be assessed)

So with A&E doctors trying to make sure there aren't tragedies in those waiting ambulances, there is precious little to tackle those who can wait.

Having a drop in GP collocated with A&E can help - but tends to get clogged OOH by patients who need painkillers following their A&E discharge (eg broken limbs) because A&E can't provide them, and the hospital pharmacy (where they'd get them in working hours is skeleton staff overnight, and urgent dispensing means others don't get a look in)

All that said, some pathways do work faster than others. If you rock up with a possible fracture, you might be lucky and be sent straight to X-ray (especially if you are able to walk) and then it's pretty quick to stabilise and sort a fracture clinic referral. But a PITA to also have to go to the hospital GP for a green script to take to an all-night pharmacy

TableFlowerss · 20/10/2021 13:27

@User134342134

Friend of mine worked as a doctor on A&E and 90% of cases were not true emergencies. They were usually long-standing health problems that escalated to the point where people panic and go to A&E. There is also the mistaken belief that going at crazy time (eg 1am) helps you escape the faff of making appointments and waiting and you skip the queue to see a doctor. A&E are not equipped to provide treatments or diagnosis for many things, they can only offer pain relief/antibiotics and make sure you're not dying at that point in time.

This is an unpopular opinion but I feel the NHS is broken to the point that people need to go private if they're truly worried about their health. Why put your own life on the line just to prove a point that healthcare should and needs to be free? In the vast majority of other countries, healthcare is not free and people accept that. The "free" version of healthcare for uninsured patients is so poor that it's normal for people in many countries to pay for doctors.

There's a bizarre entitlement in the UK that medical care NEEDS to be free which is very strange for people who have lived in other countries. Paying for healthcare is seen as a perversion but if your car or washing machine breaks then you obviously need to pay for that too. A private consultation is about the same as car repairs, one night's hotel or other unexpected expenses that should be budgeted for in an average household. I know friends who doggedly wait months for their NHS appointments whilst in ever worsening health but refusing to contemplate spending that £100 to get an answer immediately.

As the title suggests, if more people went private they would be doing their own health a favour as well as relieving the collective burden on GPs and A&E. The problem is obviously not enough doctors to begin with so the free services are stretched to the limit. This is common across many countries, including highly taxed German and Scandinavian countries. In many European countries it's perfectly normal to use insurance covered doctors if you can but also pay for private care if you need it. You don't need private insurance either. If it's just 1-2 appointments per year then it's cheaper to pay out entirely out of pocket. The major advantage is that you get your health seen at a point where hasn't escalated into something more serious and you also helped relieved pressure on the system for other patients.

You talk as if there’s 10,000 GP’s, A&E doctors waiting twiddling their thumbs in the empty private hospitals next door. That’s not true is it?

I’m sure if someone had to pay £50 to see a GP if they felt it was urgent, I’m sure they would, but the set up the way it is now, that’s not really an option.

The issue is there isn’t enough doctors full stop.

I agree paying to see doctors might be something for the future and it would make money available to train more GP’s etc…. But in the short term it’s not the solution

Eskarina1 · 20/10/2021 13:27

Just wanted to say severe period pain and bleeding can 100% be an ED issue (in response to comment on p1). Ectopic pregnancy, burst cyst, ovarian torsion etc. I've been blue lighted in by my GP more than once because of the impact of pain and bleeding (Endo related) on my pulse and blood pressure and they wanted me on morphine to bring it down.

There's an important balance here - no don't go to ED with a minor infection but don't wait until you're actually dying of sepsis.

ScaredOfDinosaurs · 20/10/2021 13:23

I was at my local A&E the other week, my GP told me to go urgently due to heart/breathing issues and needed to get urgent scans. I was seen immediately for triage, had the tests/scans, given meds and advice and sent on my way within 3 hours.

Listening to some of the conversations of people around me, I honestly was shocked at the complete pointlessness of their visits, stuff that you wouldn't even bother a GP with - one man started kicking off because I was seen first. Yes mate, your bruised ankle is more important than my inability to breathe properly.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 20/10/2021 13:23

@JaniieJones

'She didn’t say they were in a corridor - she said on a trolley. A cubicle wait of 26 hours for a bed is pretty appalling.'

It really isn't. She implied the ambulance had dropped them off and they then waited 26hrs.

If they were seen, examined, treatment initiated, they were fed and monitored then no it isn't 'appalling'. It is not ideal but depending when this allegedly happened I would expect the hospital probably had significant bed pressures anyway due to covid.

Waiting for a bed is not the same as waiting to be seen and treated is it?

It’s far, far away from the 4 hour target which has been forgotten, and means that people are backed up in ambulances. Those ambulances are not then available to go to emergencies. This is the consequence of bed pressures caused by mismanagement of Covid and lack of investment in the health service since 2010.

It is appalling.

TableFlowerss · 20/10/2021 13:18

@BingBongToTheMoon

If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there.
Can’t say I disagree
RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 20/10/2021 13:14

Sons partner waited in A&E for 7 hours a fee evenings ago

No food or drink, felt so sorry for him

Oneeata · 20/10/2021 13:12

Worked in A&E for many years, the amount of people coming through the doors who would come and wait 4 plus hours to be sent home with paracetamol that would cost them 49p was unreal.
Doctor - "When was the last time you took pain relief?"
Patient - "Oh! I haven't taken anything yet, I don't want to mask the pain..."
Seriously, you would not believe the shit people would turn up with. I will write a book one day, I swear. Had a young girl turn up with a broken acrylic nail, screaming the place down when she was told to go back to her technician to have it soaked off but refusing to as it would cost her £15. There was no injury to her nail bed it hadn't broken in the middle, it was literally the tip. Then at the opposite end you've got a little old lady coming in on the bus after falling 3 days before hand with an arm shaped like a blackened banana but she didn't like to bother anybody or the man who thought he just had a little bit of chest pain with indigestion who didn't want to ring for an ambulance so his friends brought him in a taxi, stood and waited in a 20 minute queue to get booked in while pissed/drugged up arseholes shout and scream at the reception staff, proceeds to get booked in and then collapses with a cardiac arrest hitting his head also in the middle of a packed out waiting room less than 10 minutes later.
He died and I still see him every day nearly 10 years later.

takemetomars · 20/10/2021 13:10

@YearsSinceISawYou

It is wrong to use A&E like a doctor's surgery.

But everyone, A&E staff included, are aware that until GPs go back to work, this will continue.

Before anyone with a skin in the game jumps in, GPs are not working hard.

Blimey! I must have imagined the 60 patients seen in our urgent care clinic yesterday then! 15 of which were seen by the GP on duty. Seen. With their eyes. Face to face
Timeforwinterclothes · 20/10/2021 12:52

Long waits in A&E are nothing new. Twenty years ago my DH broke his elbow. I drove him to our nearest hospital. Triaged, X rayed and then a long wait. We arrived at 7pm. At 3am we were exhausted and went home for a few hours sleep. We went back in the morning. Nobody had noticed and the teenager with a broken ankle who had arrived the night before just ahead of DH, was still waiting. About half an hour later my DH was treated. Sorry for the wait they said. We laughed to ourselves as we had had four hours in bed asleep.

ChevreChase · 20/10/2021 12:49

I've been to A&E twice in my adult life, both were hand injuries: a broken finger, and a suspected wrist fracture, and I was sent there after going to MIUs first and being told to go to A&E for x-ray. Both times I got there by bus, as was in little pain, but there were no other services that could get the hand looked at. It does feel like another service should exist, so that things that can't wait as such can be dealt with, but aren't exactly crisis.

Until I had cause to use them, I thought MIUs filled that space, but the ones I went to were staffed by nurses with no doctors, and said suspected fractures were beyond what they could deal with. Anyway, the Minor Injuries Units in our area close in winter - they have done for the last few years, so that staff can be re-deployed to the hospitals, so people have to go to A&E for anything that a GP or pharmacist can't help you with.

Whammyyammy · 20/10/2021 12:38

My oh has private care through his work, I have axa insurance, its about £90pm, its brilliant. Only thing they don't do is a and e , otherwise great. 24hr doctor available, plenty of private hospitals if you need them, included diagnostics as they call it (mri, ct scans etc) and you can still use nhs if you chose.
Highly recommend private insurance , as you never have to wait to be seen or treated for anything. Also saves burdening the nhs which is on its knees

Whammyyammy · 20/10/2021 12:34

@BingBongToTheMoon

If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there.
Yep. I took my friend in with a burst appendix, she was taken straight away. Whilst waiting i got chatting to a young lad approx 20 ish, he was complaining about waiting for 7 to 8 hours, he had a 1cm cut on his finger, wasn't bleeding and the plaster his mum applied at home had done its job.
MCMelon · 20/10/2021 12:34

I often read threads like this and this has honestly not been my experience with the GP or A and E, both of which I've unfortunately had to access recently. If any of you work for Gateshead NHS- thank you. My GP has been fully accessible throughout Covid and just yesterday I had an appointment and antibiotics for my child an hour after calling. I honestly don't know how they've done it but they are doing an amazing job.

Shitfuckcommaetc · 20/10/2021 12:32

Alot of these posts are missing the bigger picture.

My A&E department has 29 adult beds, plus 6 resus.
So if you need to be admitted you first need to get one of these A&E beds.

Yesterday we had over 120 patients in the department. Alot of those were minor who would need a bed. But a significant figure do

Now these beds only become free when people are admitted up to a ward.
The wards have no beds free as they cannot discharge patients, the lack of resources of physio, OT, home help, care packages etc.

It's not just an A&E problem, it's a government problem. Lack of funding, shit pay, lack of training opportunities leads to no retention of staff and no one to do the vital work at both ends!!

stop voting Conservative

TheReluctantPhoenix · 20/10/2021 12:30

What are people meant to do who literally cannot get access to a GP or afford a private one?

It is all v well saying A&E is for accidents and emergencies, but are we going back to the early 20th century where medical care was only available to the rich or dying?

FleetwoodRaincoat · 20/10/2021 12:24

The NHS has been chronically underfunded for the past several years. It's the Conservatives' way of running down the system so that they can justify privatisation. Simples.

Don't blame people going to A and E unnecessarily, don't blame Covid or GPs. It's the government, pure and simple.

NoDecentHandlesLeft · 20/10/2021 12:23

It's all well and good saying that A+E is not appropriate.
But my local (well, fairly local) MIU closed down in 2019. They have recently built upwards of 70,000 new homes/apartment buildings in my area, with more to come, and not increased the GP services in any meaningful way.
And people don't have medical degrees. They do not realise what is and what is not urgent, only what is abnormal for them.
(obviously not talking about someone with things like a paper cut here, for clarity)

blubberee · 20/10/2021 12:21

@User134342134 that would be fair enough if we didn't also have to contribute so much tax to this broken system. I pay for private and contribute. It's not good is it. I can't really afford to pay but I've had to because my GP wouldn't see me face to face and my health was deteriorating. I agree we should pay something but it should be a better system like France or Germany has. Not 'free' healthcare vs pay a ton of money for anything!

I also had to wait 6 hours in a&e with my dc with her broken arm before she was seen last year so it really isn't working. My dd was 6 it was really unpleasant.