Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 20 hour waiting time in my A and E is crazy...

240 replies

Meltinthemiddle · 20/10/2021 09:47

What the hell is happening to our NHS? Is this all down to covid and GP's not seeing patients face to face or people mis using the system. There's been alot of GP bashing recently and I do feel sorry for some of them as no doubt they are working flat out but their appointment system is shocking!

OP posts:
Bagamoyo1 · 20/10/2021 19:32

A&E is busy because demand outstrips supply. Simple as that. It’s the same for GPs too.

Last week someone posted on here that they’d been referred by their GP to an urgent clinic for a breast lump, but the appointment was delayed (by a couple of weeks I believe). People advised A&E. One person even said she could get a scan done if she went to A&E.

That’s your answer OP.

Crispycremedelight · 20/10/2021 19:32

I have been to A&E twice within the last week and both times extremely different experiences. First last Week, I couldn’t even get through to my GP, so I rang our local minor injury unit (it was a minor injury) I was directed to A&E as I would be seen quicker than minor injuries, only myself and one other waiting when I arrived. I was seen within 20mins and had my injury X-rayed (not normal result) got special foot guard and found out today I’ve got a fracture in my foot. DC had chest pains Monday we waited 7hours to be admitted, lots of code blue’s being called so I knew it would be a wait. My child and I spent a lot of time with the nurses (close monitoring) and they were admitting lots of kids were being directed to the wrong places or that pharmacy or GP should see them. There were also lots of seriously Ill babies who GP had refused to see in person citing viral infections-they were clearly seriously unwell and in desperate need of medication; it’s heartbreaking that A&E staff are being bashed and those who are in need of the NHS simply can’t access the right service for them

takemetomars · 20/10/2021 19:32

@YearsSinceISawYou

Gps are working incredibly hard! Ha! Tell us another fairy tale-you've jumped the shark there, *@takemetomars* If only we all lived in the green and pleasant La La land that you do,

It's easier to spot a giant dodo than a GP at their desk seeing a patient.

Almost every man and his dog have a story to tell about how they can't get to see a GP face to face-the government have even had to tell them, tell them, to get back to work.

This didn't happen before the pandemic, so what changed after it? They saw a chance not to have to have face to face appointments and they took it.

If they are all working so so hard, why is the government telling them to get back to work and everyone-apart from those pushing their own agenda-knows you can't get to see one of the buggers.

Anyway, in response to the original question. People are waiting 20 hours in A& E because many of them can't get to see a GP.

It really isn't rocket science.

Bless you and your complete lack of intelligence. You can't reason with stupid so I won't try
fuddleducks · 20/10/2021 19:21

@YearsSinceISawYou

Gps are working incredibly hard! Ha! Tell us another fairy tale-you've jumped the shark there, *@takemetomars* If only we all lived in the green and pleasant La La land that you do,

It's easier to spot a giant dodo than a GP at their desk seeing a patient.

Almost every man and his dog have a story to tell about how they can't get to see a GP face to face-the government have even had to tell them, tell them, to get back to work.

This didn't happen before the pandemic, so what changed after it? They saw a chance not to have to have face to face appointments and they took it.

If they are all working so so hard, why is the government telling them to get back to work and everyone-apart from those pushing their own agenda-knows you can't get to see one of the buggers.

Anyway, in response to the original question. People are waiting 20 hours in A& E because many of them can't get to see a GP.

It really isn't rocket science.

There appears to be a government bot on here.

'If they are all working so so hard, why is the government telling them to get back to work and everyone-apart from those pushing their own agenda-knows you can't get to see one of the buggers'

If not, it is extremely ironic that you are more inclined to believe this government's or the mainstream media's version of events than the GPs/ practice nurses/ reception staff actually doing the job. You talk of agendas.....

I'm a GP and I have been at my desk seeing patients today and every day that I have worked during the pandemic. But I guess you know what I have been doing all day than I do myself.

A little bit of intelligent thought would make you realise that successive governments (Tory ones recently) have led to chronic underfunding of the NHS and a severe staff shortage. Many staff feel undervalued and unsupported. The pandemic has exacerbated staff shortages because of high rates of illness and the need to isolate. General Practice has been very much inadequately funded and there is a now huge lack of GPs and those who are able to leave or reduce hours are doing so. The population has increased significantly, the percentage of elderly and those with chronic conditions has increased, the amount of possible interventions of every type and the rates and fears of litigation (transported from the US). The population has also been positively encouraged to expect to turn up to see a Dr our nurse whenever they feel like it and however minor the complaint.
Lots of reasons we find ourselves in this situation but it's not down to the GPs.

TSSDNCOP · 20/10/2021 19:14

I suppose @AwaAnBileYerHeid that "people" by which you mean "patients"are mystified when entering a completely empty surgery mid-morning why there is a room of empty chairs and it is impossible to get through in the phone for an appointment so one has to have a day i off go in person and cannot get one until 19th November.

I obviously cannot speak for every patient in every GP surgery, but surely you can see that's a head scratcher and likely linked to an influx at A&E.

Additionally I should add the blood test letter was only obtained at all because a GP rang me by mistake, so I seized the moment.

CarrotSticks23 · 20/10/2021 19:07

I think it's many many things. No beds in the hospitals means 2 things 1) a&e bays are full, no space to assess patients and 2) a&e is full of sick patients requiring a lot of attention. Beds have been gradually reduced in many hospitals across the country for years now

You also have I would say a greater awareness of health problems now. And people like to get checked out to be on the safe side. For example an infection means risk of sepsis means A&E. Without actually thinking 'do I have signs of sepsis'

There is also a difficulty accessing primary care. I myself have been directed 3 times in the last year by my GP to A&E for things I know did not need A&E, because I had a temperature or a cough and it maybe covid. You cannot properly assess over the phone anything but the most basic health problem, maybe things like a UTI, but anything that requires looking or examining needs to be seen in person. Sadly I have seen a couple of cancers missed because of Telephone appointments. You risk missing things, patients aren't always the best at describing their symptoms- the problem is your well spoken, well educated patient will probably be okay, but I think this can disadvantage patients who arent in their category. There are also patients who over egg symptoms and many patients who don't want to make a fuss so under egg. You miss so much over the phone.

I think there is now a fear around difficulty accessing a GP as well. I frequently see patients who have been seen by their GP, but they weren't happy with the outcome so go to A&E because they think they won't be able to get back into the GP. In many cases the patients do need to go back to their GP but a lot of this work is now falling back to hospitals

But then we also have an aging population, and a population of elderly people who have had nearly 2 years of reduced contact, often living alone. Loneliness leads to mental health problems which can worsen things like dementia. They haven't been able to stay active, and keep their mind active as well. They've not had the care maybe they would have had without covid, or the family visits to notice when they start to need a but more help. Plus a real social care crisis leads to a melting pot of falls, and ill elderly people that get stuck in hospital

I think you also have to differentiate between 20 hrs to get assessed, and 20 hrs in a&e which may include investigations, wait to see specialities, waits for a beds, waiting for patients to sober up etc.

Bunnycat101 · 20/10/2021 19:03

I think some gps are a problem at the moment but not the only problem.

Eg my practice- the online consultation is brilliant for routine things but it won’t let you put in things for a child around breathing or other issues that are potentially a hospital visit. In the past I’ve been able to call the GP for an urgent issue and they have seen my children within minutes and been able to make the call whether they need to go to paediatrics and have been able to admit straight to the ward. At the moment it is literally impossible to answer the phone so if in doubt, I’d be off to A&E. This benefits no-one.

goose1964 · 20/10/2021 19:00

My husband made an appointment to see his GP on Friday and he was seen today and he made me an appointment whilst he was there for Friday, both in person.

Some people are going to A&E totally inappropriately. I've been to our minor injury centre and never had to wait more than 20 mins.

AwaAnBileYerHeid · 20/10/2021 18:57

@TSSDNCOP

I had cause to go to my GP this morning to collect a blood test referral.

At 11am there was not one single person in the waiting room. It is a big surgery, with probably 6 Gp's. I was there for 20 minutes (much looking for piece of paper that was misfiled). When I left there was not one person waiting and not one person had come out. That appeared very at odds with the items I read that GP's are on their knees.

So, my question is why can I not get an appointment until 19th November to discuss a matter with my GP?

They are just as busy doing phone appointments as they were doing face to face appointments. I'm not sure why people can't understand that they are still doing their jobs, albeit mainly via the phone as opposed to f2f.
AwaAnBileYerHeid · 20/10/2021 18:55

@YearsSinceISawYou

It is wrong to use A&E like a doctor's surgery.

But everyone, A&E staff included, are aware that until GPs go back to work, this will continue.

Before anyone with a skin in the game jumps in, GPs are not working hard.

I don't have any skin in the game, I'm a mental health nurse but nothing to do with GPs. I think many GPs are working extremely hard; my GP has certainly provided an excellent service throughout covid, simply changing to phone appointments which is fine for most stuff and seeing people f2f when necessary. I think it's very easy to say that GPs aren't working hard when you don't have a clue what they are actually doing.
bordersroaming · 20/10/2021 18:50

Yeah I mean why would you think they are working hard, they only have to manage significantly more patients than elsewhere in Europe, but that should be no problem because us brits are just so much more productive than other humans

YearsSinceISawYou · 20/10/2021 18:47

Gps are working incredibly hard! Ha! Tell us another fairy tale-you've jumped the shark there, @takemetomars If only we all lived in the green and pleasant La La land that you do,

It's easier to spot a giant dodo than a GP at their desk seeing a patient.

Almost every man and his dog have a story to tell about how they can't get to see a GP face to face-the government have even had to tell them, tell them, to get back to work.

This didn't happen before the pandemic, so what changed after it? They saw a chance not to have to have face to face appointments and they took it.

If they are all working so so hard, why is the government telling them to get back to work and everyone-apart from those pushing their own agenda-knows you can't get to see one of the buggers.

Anyway, in response to the original question. People are waiting 20 hours in A& E because many of them can't get to see a GP.

It really isn't rocket science.

RaininSummer · 20/10/2021 18:46

I realise discussion has moved on but in answer to the questions re my story, he was picked up in an ambulance after GP identified a likely heart attack , was in ambulance around an hour then moved to a trolley which went from corridor after a few hours into a bay. After 26 hours from the start, he went to an assessment ward. Then 6 or so hours later to cardiac ward. Things sped up after that and a stent and home within two days. I went to emergency that night to drop him food and clothes and was really shocked at the number of people sat outside obviously poorly, having been spoken to and presumably triaged.

cptartapp · 20/10/2021 18:38

Redhero peak flows are contraindicated in general practice currently (national guidelines) as it can induce coughing in a confined space. They can be done at home though and discussed. A routine asthma review doesn't sound your chest. BP's can be done at home too and discussed - more accurate anyway.

SmellyOldOwls · 20/10/2021 18:23

@TSSDNCOP presumably they are doing phone and email appointments, home visits, care home visits, writing prescriptions, doing referral paperwork and that's only the things I can think of and I'm not a GP. Seeing patients isn't their entire job by a long shot.

TSSDNCOP · 20/10/2021 18:07

@LakieLady I wonder if the difference is because you were in the system, thus the dots were able to be connected.

The issue is getting into the system, which should be via GP but issues at that enter point are creating the issues at A&E.

TSSDNCOP · 20/10/2021 18:05

I had cause to go to my GP this morning to collect a blood test referral.

At 11am there was not one single person in the waiting room. It is a big surgery, with probably 6 Gp's. I was there for 20 minutes (much looking for piece of paper that was misfiled). When I left there was not one person waiting and not one person had come out. That appeared very at odds with the items I read that GP's are on their knees.

So, my question is why can I not get an appointment until 19th November to discuss a matter with my GP?

LakieLady · 20/10/2021 17:53

@Fallagain

GPs are the new teachers. Vilified on social media for doing their best with limited resources. No wonder we don’t have enough of either.
Spot on. I wonder which public service employees will be next in line for a slating?

In recent weeks, I have had surgery as an in-patient, been referred to A&E by 111, where I was seen in under an hour, and had an appt with a nurse at the GP surgery. Every one of these interactions has been excellent, I've been seen promptly and things have been resolved swiftly.

While waiting for results at A&E, I had the opportunity to observe the staff and they were really busy, but unfailingly efficient, polite and cheerful. I was in awe of the lot of them.

MoreHairyThanScary · 20/10/2021 17:52

Locally our A&E is stacked up because there are very limited beds within the hospital, ( over the years many have been closed an hospitals rationalised) but in recent weeks it is the lack of carers available in the community to support at home or in care homes adding increased pressure as patients can not be discharged home.

Many many carers locally have not had the vaccine and have instead handed their notice in. It is likely to get worse in the coming weeks once we hit the magic date in November.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 20/10/2021 17:45

Our GP told us to go to A and E because she couldn’t get her head around making a proper referral! Shock

When we got to A and E (another day) they sorted the referral really quickly but they shouldn’t have had to. Dd does have cardiac issues so I can see why they wanted her seen urgently but a quick, planned appointment would surely be better?

HomeSliceKnowsBest · 20/10/2021 17:19

Our GP surgery is directing patients to A&E for minor ailments.

eeyore228 · 20/10/2021 17:19

I work in A&E. The wait all depends on what else is going on. We have people who will be in the department who are waiting on beds but because we haven't got enough people being discharged because they are waiting on care in the community. So the poor patients end up in A&E waiting for a bed and the poor staff are then giving ward-based care alongside emergency care. On top of that the more acute a patient is the more staff they might need to stabilise them, meaning fewer to try and treat the less urgent ones. Additionally we are seeing 30-40 patients turning up every hour at stages during the day. So if all of those people need investigations they all take time to be processed which adds to the wait. People seem to think it's a bit like ‘stars in their eyes’. Walk-in sick and rotate through the door cured in minutes. It's complex and it's a big issue but when you're left with 130 patients at any given time I'm not sure what the public are expecting. I wish their was a magic wand because I have never seen so many staff leave nor look so burnt out.

Abraxan · 20/10/2021 17:08

@Mybalconyiscracking

Not sure why people are so fixated on face to face GP appointments. I find that telephone consultations at least initially, are much more convenient.
I have no issue with telephone appointments.

I do have an issue with the way my surgery is dealing with the telephone appointment system.

It's very easy for those people who have surgeries who are doing them well. But for those who don't it's hard and yes, patients will complain. It isn't necessarily the GP they are complaining about, but the outdated system.

Our surgery turned off the app appointment shame when Covid hit and never turned it back on fully. I can do a repeat prescription through it and that's all now.

To get an appointment you must call same day at 8:30am. If they answer you may or may not be offered a call. This can be at any time of the day. If you don't answer, they don't return the call and you start the system again the next day. Most appointments have gone soon after lines open.

There are no video calls. They is not online system. There is no text system. There is no way to send photographs etc.

If you do speak to a doctor then they will decide if you need to be seen. If you do, you are expected to be able to get there as soon as possible, ideally within 30 minutes or so. This is fine if it is the type of thing you are ill and at home, and can get yourself there. Difficult if at work or have no transport option.

I'd be happy to keep telephone options for most types of doctor visits. I am not happy to return the way my surgery handles them though.

Nothingoriginalhere · 20/10/2021 17:06

@YearsSinceISawYou

It is wrong to use A&E like a doctor's surgery.

But everyone, A&E staff included, are aware that until GPs go back to work, this will continue.

Before anyone with a skin in the game jumps in, GPs are not working hard.

Wow! Do you work in a GP surgery Because I do and everybody is working incredibly hard and have been throughout the pandemic including the GP’s! Jesus no wonder staff are leaving primary care in droves…..
Abraxan · 20/10/2021 16:59

@JaniieJones

It is because people treat A&E like a walk in gp surgery. Look at mn for a snapshot 'I have severe period pain and heavy bleeding should I go A&E?' 'Yes it would be sepsis, or a life threatening hemorrhage, go NOW!'.

All practices offer econsults and phone consults and will then see those who require examining.

If this is based on the post yesterday or day before - that was a genuine a and e case. The op was also told to go to a and e by the doctor she spoke too.

And severe bleeding, even if linked to periods, most definitely can be an a &e case.

A&E doesn't have to mean life or death situations. Yes, a lot of people do misuse it but in some cases it's not the case, as was the case in the above mentioned post.