Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 20 hour waiting time in my A and E is crazy...

240 replies

Meltinthemiddle · 20/10/2021 09:47

What the hell is happening to our NHS? Is this all down to covid and GP's not seeing patients face to face or people mis using the system. There's been alot of GP bashing recently and I do feel sorry for some of them as no doubt they are working flat out but their appointment system is shocking!

OP posts:
StarCourt · 21/10/2021 01:13

It's all very well people extolling the virtues of going private and how worth it it's been for them. And 'only' £90 per month. Aside from the many many people who could never afford that, what would happen with pre-existing conditions?

MountainDweller · 20/10/2021 23:57

If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there

What is an acceptable time limit within which you are considered 'ill enough' to be at A&E?

My mum waited 16 hours several years ago with a severe infection after heart bypass surgery. (She waited 12 hours after her original heart attack, after which she was admitted for 3 weeks to be stabilised before surgery). On both occasions she had called her GP first who told her to hang up and call 999. She subsequently had 6 further surgeries under GA for the (hospital-acquired) infection and was in and out of hospital for six months. She'd have died if she hadn't got treatment. Yet she was borderline-not-sick-enough for A&E?

So can you only go to A&E if you might die within 12 hours, not 24?

The NHS was not fit for purpose 15 years ago when it fobbed off my friend's relative. She sought treatment after a year when visiting her daughter abroad and was diagnosed with late-stage ovarian cancer. She received treatment but died a year later in her 60s.

Thé NHS was not fit for purpose 20 years ago when they first fobbed me off for a condition that affects 1 in 10 women. I moved abroad and had 3 surgeries between 2006 and 2010. I have permanent damage due to the late diagnosis. I never attended A&E.

I am under no illusion that it is fit for purpose now. I have remained abroad and pay a lot for private health insurance, but get my money's worth.

Graphista · 20/10/2021 23:53

You want a simple answer?

Tory govt

They never wanted an nhs and always undermine it when they're in power

With a&e there are always those patients there who don't need to be but that's always been the case.

Longer answer

Austerity so lack of funding all round
Poor handling of COVID generally by this govt

Lack of morale meaning staff leaving in droves
Lack of equipment and supplies (like the recent issue with blood vials for tests) meaning it's harder to assess and treat patients in a correct and timely manner

This is an unpopular opinion but I feel the NHS is broken to the point that people need to go private if they're truly worried about their health.

That would be because it's a callous and ill thought out opinion that shows you're thinking exactly what this govt wants you to

The most ill in society are usually the poorest too (either cos they can't work at all or can't maintain employment) like me - how are they supposed to pay for private treatment?

The nhs ISN'T free it's free at point of use

And even if the GP won't see you there are other options - a minor injuries unit, see a pharmacist. And there's the out of hours doctor for nights and weekends too.

Not everywhere has minor injuries or out of hours cover. We don't here. Our supposed ooh place is 90 mins away now!

I am a great advocate of pharmacists where they can be useful but they can't cover everything

As for "just have mh issues"

Odfod!

Lost me there op!

Mental illnesses can be just as much of an emergency as physical

Sleeplessem · 20/10/2021 23:36

@Meltinthemiddle

Half the people in A and E probably just have mental health issues and they want someone to talk to or other support. When I did a placement there a women tried to kill herself and they said she comes in every weekend. She even said see you next weekend 😯 My friend was up there a few days ago and she said it was mental one women pretended to have a fit so she alerted the receptionist as people were just stepping over her. She said she does it all the time. Another lady wee 'd in the middle of the department and got seen straight away after that. Maybe they need a A and E for mental health department and separate one for medical emergencies.
‘Just have mental health issues’ jeeeez
Meltinthemiddle · 20/10/2021 23:33

Half the people in A and E probably just have mental health issues and they want someone to talk to or other support. When I did a placement there a women tried to kill herself and they said she comes in every weekend. She even said see you next weekend 😯 My friend was up there a few days ago and she said it was mental one women pretended to have a fit so she alerted the receptionist as people were just stepping over her. She said she does it all the time. Another lady wee 'd in the middle of the department and got seen straight away after that. Maybe they need a A and E for mental health department and separate one for medical emergencies.

OP posts:
JustLyra · 20/10/2021 23:29

You can't expect to be seen at A&E for a minor injury because you can't be arsed driving to minor injuries

No-one seriously expects people to do a two hour round trip to minor injuries…

Motorina · 20/10/2021 23:25

There isn't a minor injuries unit in my county.

Nearest one is a round trip of over 100 miles.

I think minor injuries are great, but not every area has one.

SmellyOldOwls · 20/10/2021 23:12

@Roystonv

Posters talk about minor injury units but our main hospital doesn't have one (nearest one maybe an hour away) which means you really fall between a and e and your gp. One should not be bothered and one no longer deals with. Does anyone know how it is decided where they sited?
You can't expect to be seen at A&E for a minor injury because you can't be arsed driving to minor injuries Confused
blackheartsgirl · 20/10/2021 22:43

Econsult has been suspended in my area, its very difficult to get an appointment and even 111 there is a long wait.
I was lucky I got seen straight away but many don't. We also have no minor injuries unit either.
I don't blame people for going to a and e. The nurse triaging me blamed the GPS and the system..they were absolutely rushed off thier feet. I admired them. So many people were there whoobviously really needed medical treatment and weren't seen for hours. Yes you always get some time wasters but how can you say one person needs treatment and another doesn't just by observing them in the waiting room

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 20/10/2021 22:39

@JustLyra

The number of adults who can’t, or won’t, grasp that what happens and what is available in their area isn’t universally what happens and is available everywhere is always quite baffling.
Yep
JustLyra · 20/10/2021 22:31

The number of adults who can’t, or won’t, grasp that what happens and what is available in their area isn’t universally what happens and is available everywhere is always quite baffling.

orangeautumnleaves · 20/10/2021 22:30

I have not read through the whole thread but I do have 18 years experience of working in A&E. This is the worst I have ever seen it. It's by far the most unsafe environment I have ever worked in.

The reasons are so complex, it's not just GPs so please stop blaming them! There is a massive shortage of GPs which does not help as their role as gatekeeper is vital, they are a very overstretched and under resourced service just like the rest of the NHS.

So yes some people land in A&E as they are struggling to access a GP. Not the GPs fault, it's a broken system!

Yep 111 send a load of patients to A&E who could be seen by a GP or often don't actually need to be seen by anyone!

Yep people rock up to A&E with no real emergency. It's frustrating but tbh understandable right now. They just want to see someone!

Patient flow through A&E is shit as I think has been mentioned by pp. But this happens every winter, not usually as early as October though! Lots of patients in beds waiting for social care etc lots of early unsafe discharges been made as the medical team are under pressure to create beds... usually 24 hours later these patients come back to A&E etc. Consequently people are literally waiting hours upon hours in A&E for a hospital bed. Now in my department as well as running an A&E we are simultaneously running a ward as we have lots of partings bedded down every night.

The biggest difference i am seeing now is how unwell and complex so many patients are. It's the sheer volume of very complicated, very unwell patients that is incredibly overwhelming to A&E and the wards and probably meaning much longer stays in hospital. Why is this? To me this is the collateral damage of the pandemic. People with complex chronic illnesses have often not seen their specialists face to face since before the pandemic, many have missed routine bloods, investigations over such a prolonged time. This is secondary care, not GP and again who is to blame? The whole of the NHS apart from the acute sector pretty much became so much less accessible for months on end. Covid became the focus. What about everyone else?
Yes some of these patients have not been to their GP or have had phone consults only. And the difficulty is accessing primary care is certainly part of the problem but it's not the only cause by any stretch and tbh I have only touched on a few other reasons for the bottle neck that is now A&E. but I really do believe that this lack of access to many aspects of health care has created this crisis to what was an already seriously over stretched system. The pandemic has simply broken it.

When an enquiry is made about how the government handled this pandemic I seriously hope that they look at how health care did not remain accessible to those who did not have Covid and how if it happens again how can we keep the NHS FULLY functioning.

Arbitan · 20/10/2021 22:27

Like everyone has stated above, it’s a perfect storm with many causes. It’s also not going to get sorted any time soon as one of the main issues is a lack of staff - you can chuck as much money as you like at it, you can’t train staff overnight. Quite honestly, it seems totally beyond fixing.

Vbree · 20/10/2021 22:27

Also phone consultations with my GP have always been great. It's rare I've had to go in person even before Covid.

Vbree · 20/10/2021 22:26

I would think if something was life threatening it wouldn't be a 20 hour wait. I don't understand why people go to A&E when they can't get hold of their GP. I've called 111 twice in the last month and I've managed to get an in person appointment with my son, with only a 10 minute wait on the phone.

Sleeplessem · 20/10/2021 22:24

It’s a whole mess of things, lack of GP appointments, irresponsible usage, systematic underfunding meaning there aren’t enough nurses and doctors to get through patients ‘quickly’ (I went to a and e for an appendicitis and I was waiting 6 hours, there were 2 Doctors and 2 nurses covering a&e) and an ineffective 111 and out of hours service.

I disagree with the comment that said if you have to wait 20 hours you don’t need to be in a&e, sometimes you bloody well do. May bank holiday weekend Bham children’s hospital had a 15 hr wait. We were directed there by 111 for a 40degree fever on our 18 months old that we couldn’t get down. There was a 4 week old baby that wasn’t feeding, passing urine and had rapid breathing- the baby had been there 6 hours and hadn’t been triaged. That child needed to be seen, the only option was to wait. Out of hours and 111 seem to just direct all children under 5 to a&e.

blackheartsgirl · 20/10/2021 22:06

**13Glitterybug

'It is because people treat A&E like a walk in gp surgery. Look at mn for a snapshot 'I have severe period pain and heavy bleeding should I go A&E?' 'Yes it would be sepsis, or a life threatening hemorrhage, go NOW'

Actually I went to hospital with severe vaginally bleeding 2 weeks ago AFTER ringing my gp (couldn't get through) AND 111 who advised me to go straight to a and e.
I collapsed in the waiting room, went straight in and was admitted. Turns out I had an unusual reaction to sertraline and it was a good job I went.

What a stupid Post.

Chipsinthewoods · 20/10/2021 22:02

@User134342134

Funny you mention miscarriage. I've seen posters advise other posters to go to A&E for very early miscarriages. Of all the conditions that A&E cannot help with a miscarriage is one of them (I've had 4)

Yes I was in the early stages of a natural MC and my (private) consultant actually told me to go to A&E if the bleeding becomes too heavy. DH used to work as a paramedic and he remembers one ambulance callout for a woman miscarrying. Sadly that's one situation which has a tiny chance of being very serious (ectopic, infection) but in the vast majority of cases turn out fine even if the bleeding is horrendous.

However unlike a twisted ankle, miscarriages are very emotionally charged so people are more likely to want "help" of some kind or are generally in far more distress.

I went to a&e with a miscarriage following the advice on the sheet from the epac. I haemorrhaged at a weekend pending a d&c, soaking through maternity towels in 5 minutes and passing out. This was precovid but I was seen quickly, treated with tranexamic acid, fluids and transferred to gynae. They said I definitely needed to be there as I apologised for taking up their time, making a mess and having no veins.

These are the things that the nhs exist to treat, we have to be really careful not to make patients feel so guilty for using services that they stay away. This was certainly a concern during the first lockdown… elderly people avoiding hospital with signs of stroke or dysuria for example.

BoredZelda · 20/10/2021 22:01

It really isn't rocket science.

Ot may not be rocket science but it is far more complex than your 2+2=5 calculation. As @TheShadoutCrepes has noted the problem is flow. Partly because of the lack of social care, but also because wards that might have been available for people to be admitted to have been repurposed for treating all the Covid patients we have. People need to understand when they say we “just have to live with” Covid and “only a small percentage of people get really ill with it” that means that health services will be stretched and your hugely important F2F appointment tomorrow might not be possible. That’s what isn’t rocket science.

Upsky · 20/10/2021 22:00

If you have to wait 20 hours to be seen in an A&E then you don’t need to be there
I suspect this refers to people waiting on a trolley for a bed. I was taken to A&E in August and needed admitting. I was on a trolley 11 hours until a bed was available. I was seen by doctors and treated while waiting though it was uncomfortable and I was pretty ill.
I don't know what the answer is. So many people going to hospital who really just need a GP or practice nurse.
111 doesn't help, run on algorithms rather than medical expertise so many people again get directed to A&E who don't need it.

Roystonv · 20/10/2021 21:46

Posters talk about minor injury units but our main hospital doesn't have one (nearest one maybe an hour away) which means you really fall between a and e and your gp. One should not be bothered and one no longer deals with. Does anyone know how it is decided where they sited?

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 20/10/2021 21:28

If that man so worried about his skin, why didn't he pay to see a dermatologist?

Dreadful thing to say

JustLyra · 20/10/2021 21:11

@JaniieJones

It is because people treat A&E like a walk in gp surgery. Look at mn for a snapshot 'I have severe period pain and heavy bleeding should I go A&E?' 'Yes it would be sepsis, or a life threatening hemorrhage, go NOW!'.

All practices offer econsults and phone consults and will then see those who require examining.

It’s simply not true to say that all practices offer that.

Here you have to have to get through on the phone at a certain time to get a phone consult appointment and they don’t do econsults.

I had to resort recently to going into the surgery and making a very embarrassing demand to speak to someone after trying daily for 6 weeks to speak to a Dr about a breast lump with other symptoms.

And that was despite explaining to the receptionists numerous times why I wanted an appointment and being told simply to try the next day. Emails to the practice manager also didn’t get anywhere as she’s off sick and no-one was picking them up.

Had I not managed to embarrass them into shoving me into a room to see someone just to shut me up my next step was going to have to be A&E as I had no other way of getting seen (and it turns out I very much did need to be seen - luckily the delay hasn’t caused significant impact to prognosis).

Yes, there are a lot of people who misuse services, but there are a lot of areas where services are failing patients and that leads to necessary misuse

mbosnz · 20/10/2021 21:10

I work in a practice that serves 23,000---we have 11 GPs. Do the maths. Start emailing your MP rather than moaning on Mumsnet,

WTAF? How does that work? Okay, I suck at maths, but I simply cannot compute in such a way that this works out!

SmellyOldOwls · 20/10/2021 21:10

Ok @thebestnamesweregone sorry you ended up being so unwell but it's not clear, did you actually tell the receptionist what the issue was?