Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How is Jim Davidson not cancelled?

305 replies

donemeover · 20/10/2021 02:27

If you've watched the documentary black and white by Ashley Banjo you will see what I mean.

This man is the most racist man I've seen on TV in recent years.

He's a disgrace.

OP posts:
mustlovegin · 23/10/2021 11:31

Prejudice exists. Power structures exist. Therefore the combination of prejudice + power exists. That is what is defined as 'racism'

No, the law does not support this view which focuses on oppression and imbalance. Please see case below and many others

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/white-heterosexual-male-police-recruit-matthew-furlong-discrimination-employment-tribunal-a8794521.html

Academics and theorists are (unfortunately) paid (sometimes using public funds) to concoct ideas. These are only opinions that can be challenged, they are not dogma and certainly don't always reflect science or what happens in the real world.

NotBadConsidering · 23/10/2021 11:24

Yes, you've really misunderstood me. That's partly why I don't bother to explain - because those screaming about 'cancel culture' seem to be the most keen on not actually listening to anyone else. They have one view and if you don't get on board they attack. No better than the people they claim to oppose.

I’m not screaming Hmm. You made a claim that was easily refutable. Kathleen Stock has been subject to harassment by those actively partaking in cancel culture.

I would also argue that those who deny it exists are just as guilty of those who partake in it.

“We’re not trying to cancel anyone, what a ridiculous suggestion! We’re just threatening her and subjecting her to harassment and demanding for her resignation from her post, that’s all. It’s not cancel culture.”

Why does it even matter? Because it makes the Overton Window extremely precarious. While it’s easy for everyone to agree that Jim Davidson is horrible, righteous indignation only leads to a path of total intolerance in which the lines become blurred and if you’re not screaming along with the mob all of a sudden you’re on the outside for perfectly reasonable views and will be subjected to the same abuse. It’s bizarre to deny such culture exists and it’s been invented and to continue to do so even in the face of evidence.

rrhuth · 23/10/2021 11:07

@NotBadConsidering

You have already decided what I think anyway

I haven’t decided off my own bat. You stated cancel culture doesn’t exist, so you told everyone including me, what you think. You said it’s been invented by “the right” despite multiple examples of it happening right now. The denial of these examples does lead me to infer a few things though.

I just find it sad really. Women are victims of this disproportionately and to dismiss it is beyond my comprehension of how people can’t stand it solidarity of those being bullied.

Yes, you've really misunderstood me. That's partly why I don't bother to explain - because those screaming about 'cancel culture' seem to be the most keen on not actually listening to anyone else. They have one view and if you don't get on board they attack. No better than the people they claim to oppose.

Kathleen Stock has been subject to harassment. I understood her University had backed her.

NotBadConsidering · 23/10/2021 11:00

You have already decided what I think anyway

I haven’t decided off my own bat. You stated cancel culture doesn’t exist, so you told everyone including me, what you think. You said it’s been invented by “the right” despite multiple examples of it happening right now. The denial of these examples does lead me to infer a few things though.

I just find it sad really. Women are victims of this disproportionately and to dismiss it is beyond my comprehension of how people can’t stand it solidarity of those being bullied.

rrhuth · 23/10/2021 10:56

@NotBadConsidering

I have said nothing about Kathleen Stock confused

Yes. I noticed.

You have already decided what I think anyway Hmm
NotBadConsidering · 23/10/2021 10:54

I have said nothing about Kathleen Stock confused

Yes. I noticed.

rrhuth · 23/10/2021 10:53

It could have been filmed down the pub, it's just two people talking This does pretty much sum up GB News Grin

rrhuth · 23/10/2021 10:50

@NotBadConsidering

So you don’t believe the screenshots? The visual evidence of his name being removed?

And Kathleen Stock? You don’t believe multiple news sites telling you students are currently actively trying to have a philosophy professor removed because of her views?

I have said nothing about Kathleen Stock Confused
antsinyourpanta · 23/10/2021 10:47

Jim Davidson had issue with Ashley Banjo making a statement on a "tea time light entertainment show"
I couldn't believe the hypocrisy of it when he's probably told hundreds of sexist, misogynist, racist (and probably ageist and able-ist) "jokes" in the name of light entertainment.

NotBadConsidering · 23/10/2021 10:45

@longwayoff

GB News, too right wing for Andrew Neil and made him cry. Dear me. That suggests, disregarding Dreyfus, that overall it's an unreliable news source. Maybe ask Mr Neil, one of its founders, how he feels about its current credibility.
But in this context, on discussing whether cancel culture exists or not, you’re not being asked to appraise GB News And its reliability. You have an interview with a person who is telling you his personal experience of cancel culture. It could have been filmed down the pub, it's just two people talking.
DILevil · 23/10/2021 10:45

Felt uncomfortable as a kid watching Jim Davidson, but there are enough people like my in laws still around that would be queueing up to go and see him and others like him live.

longwayoff · 23/10/2021 10:41

GB News, too right wing for Andrew Neil and made him cry. Dear me. That suggests, disregarding Dreyfus, that overall it's an unreliable news source. Maybe ask Mr Neil, one of its founders, how he feels about its current credibility.

NotBadConsidering · 23/10/2021 10:38

So you don’t believe the screenshots? The visual evidence of his name being removed?

And Kathleen Stock? You don’t believe multiple news sites telling you students are currently actively trying to have a philosophy professor removed because of her views?

rrhuth · 23/10/2021 10:34

He himself is there telling you what happened I was always taught there are three sides to every story, your side, my side and the truth.

That interview was one side only, so we have plenty missing.

Unless you know James Dreyfus personally, how do you know you've picked the right side?

Isn't the whole point that we shouldn't be jumping into either side?

NotBadConsidering · 23/10/2021 10:33

I have my view and am at liberty to state it. It was the other person who referred to others as a 'mob' so no, I reject that.

But I didn’t. I didn’t refer to people other than me as The Mob. I pointed out that a Mob exists, a group of like-minded people who will bay for blood, metaphorically and in some cases literally, of women who express different opinions. They will gather and protest outside libraries:

www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/megan-murphy-toronto-library-protest-1.5339909

They will protest other professors:

www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-essex-57170095

Cancel culture is the existence of a culture that believes this form of action is reasonable for those guilty of Wrongthink. To deny its existence is ludicrous.

mustlovegin · 23/10/2021 10:26

Why is it unreliable? He himself is there telling you what happened

The Guardian, Channel 4, ITV and Netflix are the only 'reliable' sources according to some Hmm

rrhuth · 23/10/2021 10:25

@mustlovegin

You clearly have a very strong view that other people are a mob, whereas you are a well-informed person

You seem to think this too rrhuth, don't you?

I have my view and am at liberty to state it. It was the other person who referred to others as a 'mob' so no, I reject that.
mustlovegin · 23/10/2021 10:23

You clearly have a very strong view that other people are a mob, whereas you are a well-informed person

You seem to think this too rrhuth, don't you?

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 23/10/2021 09:56

When I worked as a theatre tech when I was around 18, another female crew member was ‘accidentally’ locked into Dressing Room 1 by Davidson so she was trapped against the door by him.

Put it this way, If I ever saw that piece of shite in person again I’d rip his ducking head off.

Vile man. The venue turned down his tours after that. According to our theatre manager, his promotors said we weren’t the only ones to do so after a visit from him.

NotBadConsidering · 23/10/2021 09:54

@rrhuth

FYI I consider 'abuse on social media' to be entirely distinct from 'cancelling' - clearly the former happens all the time, to all sorts of people across the spectrum, and it absolutely should not.
Kathleen Stock was abused on Twitter, then they stepped it up a notch and physically abused her on campus. Why are they trying to do this, if cancel culture doesn’t exist?
NotBadConsidering · 23/10/2021 09:53

Yes, I watched it, but it didn't include anything from the people who took the actions against him and GB News is an unreliable information source

Why is it unreliable? He himself is there telling you what happened. Are you saying you can’t believe him because of the place the interview took place?! How blinkered. It’s not someone else providing hearsay. And the link I provided has screenshots and links to the evidence. Did you see the evidence for yourself?

You clearly have a very strong view that other people are a mob, whereas you are a well-informed person. But you're just reading/watching stuff online yourself

No, not that other people are the mob compared to me, just that a mob exists, that you seek to deny. A cancel culture mob.

At Sussex University, a culture exists among its students that allows them to believe that verbally and physically threatening Professor Kathleen Stock is acceptable and protesting to the university to try and get her fired is a worthy course of action, just because she believes in the incontrovertible fact that humans can’t change sex. This has led to her living in fear at home and the police advising her to consider personal security. Do you think this has been fabricated by “the right”?

www.spiked-online.com/2021/10/12/kathleen-stock-is-the-real-victim-of-hate-here/

www.theguardian.com/education/2021/oct/12/professor-says-career-effectively-ended-by-unions-transphobia-claims

It doesn’t matter if they’re successful in having her fired. Cancel culture doesn’t mean they’re always successful. It means they try their very best to ruin people for having the wrong opinions.

rrhuth · 23/10/2021 09:48

FYI I consider 'abuse on social media' to be entirely distinct from 'cancelling' - clearly the former happens all the time, to all sorts of people across the spectrum, and it absolutely should not.

rrhuth · 23/10/2021 09:41

@NotBadConsidering

I don't know James Dreyfus, so I can't say anything about him. I thought you made the point we shouldnt automatically believe things said by strangers online - so I can't take his side simply because you do?

He’s an actor, well known in the UK. Did you actually watch it? Then you can make your own mind up. It’s also been well documented on Twitter what abuse he’s had for saying he agreed with JK Rowling. If you want a timeline:

grahamlinehan.substack.com/p/the-dreyfus-affair

No you don’t have to believe me. But if you’re not willing to accept the possibility that people are being punished for views deemed unacceptable, because of some need to prove the idea that you don’t have to believe and I am wrong, you’re no better than The Mob who is doing the cancelling. How many examples of people suffering do you need? Kathleen Stock has been physically intimidated by people at her workplace. To suggest this type of action is an invention of the political right is a denial of the reality of what’s happening.

Yes, I watched it, but it didn't include anything from the people who took the actions against him and GB News is an unreliable information source.

I know who James Dreyfus is, but I don't know him - there is a difference.

You clearly have a very strong view that other people are a mob, whereas you are a well-informed person. But you're just reading/watching stuff online yourself.

tttigress · 23/10/2021 09:39

The thing is, he is not on TV, but you can just build up a following on the internet, so "cancelling" is a bit meaningless now.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 23/10/2021 09:38

@mustlovegin

Racism requires power imbalance. Prejudice against people from specific races isn't the same thing as racism

These are all theories (in some people's minds prejudice=racism). And, in any case, it very much depends on the context, so it's not as clear cut as X doesn't exist

Not really. Prejudice exists. Power structures exist. Therefore the combination of prejudice + power exists. That is what is defined as 'racism'. Some people may understand any racial prejudice to be racism but they have misunderstood the definition of racism.
Swipe left for the next trending thread