Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How is Jim Davidson not cancelled?

305 replies

donemeover · 20/10/2021 02:27

If you've watched the documentary black and white by Ashley Banjo you will see what I mean.

This man is the most racist man I've seen on TV in recent years.

He's a disgrace.

OP posts:
Aquafizzle · 20/10/2021 08:12

@MrsRobbieHart

Cancelled in what way? You can’t cancel people. They’re allowed to exist. Even the vile ones.
You know that the term is used to describe removing attention and a public platform from people right?

It doesn't mean they cease to exist.

Are you really that confused about a simple concept?

JurgensCakeBaby · 20/10/2021 08:10

My white very working class father from the east end of London said 'if that fucking idiot (JD) walked into the local pub name, he'd get knocked out saying that', I was young so it must've been eighties, and I remember it clearly because whilst I'm sure his language was colourful with his friends, my dad never swore in front of us.
I also live in a seaside town with a theatre with a popular panto, friends and older colleagues who were dancers in their youth have all described him as lecherous, one said to me she's very very surprised yewtree haven't been after him yet.

StoneofDestiny · 20/10/2021 08:09

I wish people wouldn't say it was acceptable in the eighties or whatever because it really wasn't. Not in our house it wasn't. I was well aware from the 70s onwards about JD and others like him, Benny Hill for instance. My mum didn't approve of 'racialism' or 'chauvinism' as called then. There was nothing exceptional about her - she was from a white northern working class background. So how did she manage to work it out? She can't have been the only one

She wasn't. These objectionable people were recognised as vile in our home too. Unfunny offensive men with pea brained followers.

I watched the Ashley Banjo programme - an impressive man! Jim Davidson presented himself as the racist Neanderthal that he is. Davidson was no match for Banjo, so much so he stormed out of the interview. Banjo has oceans more moral and professional courage than the Davidsons of the world could ever have.

blissfulllife · 20/10/2021 08:03

He's not very popular here in the Midlands. Cancelled in Wolverhampton hurrah

Ponoka7 · 20/10/2021 08:03

Well he's a freemason and has an OBE, so no doubt friends in high places. I found it shocking that he won big brother in 2014. He was vile while in the house, but women and girls were his target then, so ignored. He admitted to having a blow job from a Transwoman, so that'll make him popular.

rrhuth · 20/10/2021 08:02

No one is cancelling anyone.

This is made up phrase designed to provoke outrage amongst idiots.

stalkersaga · 20/10/2021 07:59

Also, Chubby Brown hasn't been prevented from performing. He's absolutely free to perform at any privately owned venue in Sheffield, of which there will be many. The council has just declined to have racist and sexist views expounded on its publicly funded turf. If he can't find a private venue, well, then evidently none of them think he's a profitable risk.

ScreamingMeMesaur · 20/10/2021 07:57

@Tal45

I look back on the 80's now (when I was young) and think god there were so many vile men on tv.
The 90s too. We have a ways to go, but we've come a long way in some respects.
stalkersaga · 20/10/2021 07:56

What pp said about "cancel culture". Not being interested in paying people is not the same thing as "cancelling" them. Jim Davidson still has access to all the usual free platforms to expound his repellent views and absolutely nobody is arresting him. It's frankly offensive for right-wing dickbags to try and claim the martyrdom mantle of e.g. dissidents in China who are genuinely being oppressed for their views.

MrsRobbieHart · 20/10/2021 07:56

Cancelled in what way? You can’t cancel people. They’re allowed to exist. Even the vile ones.

Pottedpalm · 20/10/2021 07:54

@RicherThanYow

He is an absolutely vile individual, of that there’s no doubt. But you cannot “cancel” a human being. It’s a simplistic, misguided notion which doesn’t actually lead to any positive change. That kind of insidious social censorship feels very uncomfortable and I just don’t think it’s the right way to deal with things. Even nasty old Jim.
I agree; succinctly put.
Tal45 · 20/10/2021 07:53

I look back on the 80's now (when I was young) and think god there were so many vile men on tv.

Technosaurus · 20/10/2021 07:53

I can't stand Roy Chubby Brown but I signed the petition - it's ridiculous that they cancelled his gigs. I don't like his patter so I don't go to his shows, but that doesn't mean others should be banned from doing so.

By the same logic I can't stand jazz music so I don't go to jazz gigs either, but I wouldn't ban them for the small minority who do like it.

Same with Jim Davidson really. Awful man, wouldn't get the steam off my piss, but if others want to give him £25 of their hard earned money for 2 hours of his "act", that's totally up to them

ScreamingMeMesaur · 20/10/2021 07:46

@PerseverancePays

He came to my daughter’s high school in the nineties when she was part of a show. She said in the photographs where they had line up to pose with him , he always had his arms at the back and groping them while grinning at the camera. They were 14. Disgusting man.
He always did give me the creeps, so this doesn't surprise me. I bet he wouldn't be allowed in schools now!
Samcro · 20/10/2021 07:45

whilst we are cancelling him, can we do the disablist twunt Frankie Boil?

CSJobseeker · 20/10/2021 07:43

@rrhuth

I also think the type of government we have now is not overtly racist but is pro-racism, they need a group visibly/audibly more racist than them in order to not look so extreme.

It is a government talking about deliberately taking actions that will cause fellow humans to drown. This government needs a) overt racists and b) arguments about peripheral issues.

This is a valid point.

Regarding Sheffield council, I think they can make whatever decisions they want about the use of their venues. It's not cancellation because there are other venues out there, and councils actually have a responsibility to tackle racism, not give it a platform.

CSJobseeker · 20/10/2021 07:38

@AdelindSchade

I wish people wouldn't say it was acceptable in the eighties or whatever because it really wasn't. Not in our house it wasn't. I was well aware from the 70s onwards about JD and others like him, Benny Hill for instance. My mum didn't aporove of 'racialism' or 'chauvinism' as called then. There was nothing exceptional anout her - she was from a white northern working class background. So how did she manage to work it out? She can't have been the only one.

Is disgraceful that Davidson was on tv for so long.

Same here, I come from a white working class background and my parents were open about their views on this type of 'comedian' in the 80s. The TV would be turned off if the likes of Jim Davidson came on.
rrhuth · 20/10/2021 07:37

I also think the type of government we have now is not overtly racist but is pro-racism, they need a group visibly/audibly more racist than them in order to not look so extreme.

It is a government talking about deliberately taking actions that will cause fellow humans to drown. This government needs a) overt racists and b) arguments about peripheral issues.

CaptainCallisto · 20/10/2021 07:36

Jim Davidson was banned from our local (seaside so good box office) theatre in the late 90's/early 00's due to his behaviour backstage. I don't think there was a female member of backstage crew or bar staff that he hadn't felt up or insulted, and the dancers who did a cabaret spot as his warm up (of whom I was one) had a really rough time of it. His second half was delayed by fifteen minutes during one of his summer shows after he stuck his hand down the front of my dress during the interval and I elbowed him in the ribs and winded him. I was 15.

Fiercestcalm · 20/10/2021 07:35

I don’t get the adoration that surrounded Bruce Forsyth, he was incredibly misogynistic/ outright leery and of the same ilk as Jim Davison IMO.

FlipFlops4Me · 20/10/2021 07:34

@rrhuth

You can't cancel someone, 'cancel culture' has been invented by the right as part of their bullshit culture wars.

People can be de-platformed, which IMO is fine - if I have control of an organisation, I can organise it in three ways:

  • to suit myself
  • to suit the members
  • to suit the users/customers/clients

Organisations where members say 'we don't want this person' are not doing anything wrong.

Those who do want a particular event can organise anything they like in line with the law, and publish on YouTube, Facebook, Twitter.

Free speech exists in this country just fine. As evidenced by the amount of shit posted everyday on every platform.

It is just that racists etc. are upset their views are now minority/unwanted.

This is a really good post!
CSJobseeker · 20/10/2021 07:33

@Nat6999

Chubby Brown has been banned from Council venues in Sheffield, there is a 40,000+ names petition to have his gig reinstated. The majority of people want the council to back down.
40,000 people is not a majority of Sheffield! And the petition will have been signed by plenty of twats who don't live in Sheffield too.
logsonlogsoff · 20/10/2021 07:33

Does he have a prime tv show that I’m missing???
Even as a teenager I could see that he was horrible - racist,
Homophobic,
Sexist etc …
Absolute tool.
s

knittingaddict · 20/10/2021 07:32

@rrhuth

You can't cancel someone, 'cancel culture' has been invented by the right as part of their bullshit culture wars.

People can be de-platformed, which IMO is fine - if I have control of an organisation, I can organise it in three ways:

  • to suit myself
  • to suit the members
  • to suit the users/customers/clients

Organisations where members say 'we don't want this person' are not doing anything wrong.

Those who do want a particular event can organise anything they like in line with the law, and publish on YouTube, Facebook, Twitter.

Free speech exists in this country just fine. As evidenced by the amount of shit posted everyday on every platform.

It is just that racists etc. are upset their views are now minority/unwanted.

Great post.
gogohm · 20/10/2021 07:31

He was "cancelled" long before that term was used in that way! He's barely been seen on anything in years