Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Architects error

85 replies

Greenleaves20 · 19/10/2021 20:40

We’re in the middle of a kitchen diner extension to our house. We’ve discovered that the kitchen part is 20cm smaller than the architects drawings. This means our kitchen and island have to be reduced in size and also means the back wall is uneven. There is a post dividing the two sections so it probably won’t be too noticeable but it’s frustrating as we’d have gone out further into the garden if we’d known this. The shell of the building is finished and the roof is on. The project is costing well over £100K (utility and downstairs loo and hall all being done too). The architect has emailed to say it was an error due to an assumption they made but hasn’t really apologised. Having looked online etc I think I’m some ways we would like some compensation for this error, especially as we’ve paid over £10K in architects fees and their survey and it’s meaning we have to change our designs and end up with a smaller space. So should we (and anyone who knows are we able to) ask for some money back for this error?

YABU - it’s a mistake, just leave it and enjoy your extension

YANBU - ask for some money back

OP posts:
Oblomov21 · 20/10/2021 05:45

20cm is f**king huge. It's nearly a ruler. Losing a small cabinet at the end of your kitchen. This is absolutely a massive issue.

Oblomov21 · 20/10/2021 05:43

I can't believe these replies either. It's not even the £10k spent on the architect that's the problem. They've made a massive mistake. You might get a refund. £2k max. But what that doesn't in any way compensate for is the damage done to your £100k extension. Your dreams.

Your kitchen units. Which IS the most important part of this extension. Dreaming about and installing the very kitchen unit that you wanted and using it for years to come and being happy with it, in a room that's the right size - what you expected, what you ordered, what you asked for. How can you compensate for that?
Get £2k back. Meaningless. major damage has been done here.

Architect and builder sound negligent. I don't know if they are actually in legal terms! but it feels like you've had a really rough ride here and no amount of money is going to compensate.

SisforSoppy · 20/10/2021 05:24

Our architect got the back of our extension wrong by 3 feet! It was only once the digger started that I realised. we had to stop the whole project and go to planning again. They paid the additional fees but we didn’t get any compensation

cloudtree · 20/10/2021 04:48

I thought the other thread said it was 14cm. Did you confirm whether your measurements were external or internal?

But as I understand it the reality is you haven’t lost any space. Your extension goes out to where it always would have, its just that part of your back wall wasn’t in line with the rest and so your space is slightly smaller there?

LetHimHaveIt · 20/10/2021 04:41

Ah, well, I stand corrected. I still can't see that it's a lot, but posters who've actually had work done seem to think it is, so I'll accept that. Hope you can resolve it to your satisfaction.

Hope478 · 20/10/2021 02:44

20cm is a lot. I don't have much to add to the conversation, only that I'm a bit Confused at people saying it's no big deal!

kirinm · 19/10/2021 23:58

That should be 'negligent error that'

kirinm · 19/10/2021 23:54

Can you calculate what your loss is? Because you could really only claim for whatever quantifiable loss they've caused you. That's a genuine question rather than me suggesting you're somehow out of order for being pissed off with your architect.

I find it so odd that people shrug this sort of stuff off as 'building works'. If a professional has made a negligent Jody she that has caused you financial loss then absolutely you skipped pursue it.

I'm not sure you'll get a reduction on fees unless you make a compliant and a bit of noise.

Kneesaregood · 19/10/2021 23:07

20cm isn't a large amount if you were talking about a room being 20cm shorter or longer than you'd hoped for X reason.

20cm is a large amount if you're talking about architects measurements which if they're wrong, impact on the design in multiple ways (ie because multiple other elements have to change size to fit)

Architects measure in mm not cm because their measurements and drawings are meant to be accurate, with very small margins of error. That's one of the reasons you're paying for an architect (as opposed to say, a builder project manager) I'd definitely raise it with them and think ahead about what outcome you'd be happier with.

hotmeatymilk · 19/10/2021 22:46

WoolyMammoth55 has good advice. I think I said this on your other thread but think about what you want the outcome to be ideally, and what you’d be prepared to settle for. Make lots of notes and come up with some bullet points to email the architect, so:

Question how and why it happened
Detail how many sq m of space you’ve lost and what the impact of this is, eg squeezing round chairs, losing a unit, smaller island, giant post
What compensation you expect (monetary - he’s failed to properly project manage, and did a bad design? Base it on a % of the fee or lost sq m or something that compensates for the specific problem, not a random “feel better” amount)
What practical solutions you want (him finding a way for you not to have the giant post, anything else?)

and go from there. Stay calm and reasonable even if you’re spitting feathers.

minipie · 19/10/2021 22:45

Confused BoredZelda our kitchen had to be designed and ordered long before there was a finished shell to measure. So it had to be done off the architects plans. Architect was fully aware of this and expected it. Yes there was a site survey right at the end before fitting to check the built dimensions matched the plans but by then it would have been too late to make any major changes to the kitchen design.

I suppose if you are ordering a kitchen that is available within a week or teo then you can wait till the shell is built and order it off those real life measurements but surely most kitchens have to be designed off the plans.

BoredZelda · 19/10/2021 22:23

A lot of drawings will have notes such as 'please check all dimensions on site before xyz'

Not “a lot” ALL drawings say this. It is a well known fact in the industry that you never order or plan from drawings, it is always done from a site survey. Whoever planned the kitchen would have warned that a site survey was required too.

The architect hasn’t been negligent, making a complaint to the RIBA is ridiculous.

Builders do and do expect to rely on architects’ plans

Nope. Not if they are reputable.

WoolyMammoth55 · 19/10/2021 22:12

Hi OP, I went through the move-out for extension experience last year so I am with you on the stress, anxiety and weeping of it all...

FWIW we love our house now it's done and the hideous stress feels like a bad dream.

I think if I were you I would sleep on it for now, and in the morning call your architect and calmly and clearly state your position - ask how it went wrong, say you feel that you've paid a lot for something not as expected, etc.

Find out what his position is, what advice he can give you regarding additional time needed to rectify, etc. See if he makes an offer of compensation.

While you're within your rights to be disappointed - extremely so - you do in fact want the project completed, and since he's your project manager too you want to work with him to resolve this amicably if at all possible!

In the worst case scenario going nuclear in full indignant fury might lose you a project manager and leave you with an unliveable house and a court case to get stuff sorted, which would be sub-optimal :)

Best of luck!

Greenleaves20 · 19/10/2021 22:09

I also don’t think 20cm is a small amount. It’s affecting the post and is half one of the pull out larder cupboards which is a lot. It also means space is tighter getting around chairs etc. And for the money we’ve paid I’d expect things to be accurate!

OP posts:
Greenleaves20 · 19/10/2021 22:08

@Winniemarysarah yes I am pretty annoyed now actually, now we’ve realised what this means for the post and the kitchen design in general!

@JayAlfredPrufrock how did you go about asking them to rectify the mistake? I assume this was all paid for my them?

@minipie sorry I don’t think I explained that very well. The architect has admitted in an email that they made an assumption about two walls being in line with each other when there’s actually 20cm between them. This then meant the survey drawings were incorrect.

OP posts:
HunkyPunk · 19/10/2021 22:03

PP insisting it isn't a small amount is being absurd. It is a small amount.

20cm might sound like a small amount, but it’s not a small amount taken over the entire kitchen.

Greenleaves20 · 19/10/2021 22:02

We’ve just been looking at things again and have realised that this error also means that we now have a 50cm post between the kitchen and the sofa area rather than a 30cm one because it sits on the wall that is further forward than they thought. I feel 50cm is quite a big post and means we will have to walk round it to get into the kitchen area. This is altering how I think about it all now and I don’t want a massive post. We’ve paid extra to reduce posts and move them away as much as possible so my feeling now is that I want this change to be rectified.

OP posts:
JayAlfredPrufrock · 19/10/2021 21:44

Not if you’ve designed your kitchen units for the larger space.

LetHimHaveIt · 19/10/2021 21:42

I'm reading this on an iPhone 12 mini that I'm informed is 5.5 inches. So the space you've lost is one roughly one and a half times the length of my smartphone. Or the length of a banana. It'd make a difference on the space shuttle, sure, but not in a frigging kitchen extension. I'm not saying he hasn't cocked up a bit but PP insisting it isn't a small amount is being absurd. It is a small amount.

JayAlfredPrufrock · 19/10/2021 21:41

20cm is a lot.

We had a similar issue bug it was for the RSJ so they had to start again.

And the builders doing the garage built the wrong side of the string. Had to start again.

As my old dad used to say ‘measure twice, cut once’.

DiscoGlitterBall · 19/10/2021 21:37

Is it actually an architect? If so they will be RIBA, should have professional insurance and if you so wished you can make a complaint via RIBA.

I’d expect them to come up with a solution first though

minipie · 19/10/2021 21:33

I think it all depends on why the error was made which he hasn’t explained. Perhaps there is some reasonable excuse. Although I must admit I can’t think of one.

Builders do and do expect to rely on architects’ plans- not on the tiny details (eg architect plans will show a chimneybreast as completely straight when in RL it’s probably a bit wonky) but certainly to the tune of 20cm, that’s not a small amount.

Has it cost you extra to have the kitchen adjusted?

unluckyinlife · 19/10/2021 21:30

I'd definitely read the drawing notes and things to know where you stand. The fact they are project managing would change things for me, I'd ask them to confirm the builders have built to the specification on the drawings and if not show you where. This will then allow you to decide whether the architect or the builder would be liable for any costs incurred. Both the builder and architect should have insurance to cover these things but as long as there are no 'get-out' clauses you should be able to resolve this through a conversation without having to formally pursue costs. But I'd try and get any agreement in writing. (I work for an architectural practise so and oversee larger construction projects so just going off of experience) Hope you get things resolved x

Winniemarysarah · 19/10/2021 21:25

I actually can’t believe these replies. You paid a professional a huge sum of money to design part of your house, and he fucked it up! And 20cm CAN make a big difference, as you’ve discovered now you’ve had to have various things changed/redesigned to fit the wrong sized kitchen. I hate the ‘compensation culture’ but I’d be livid over this, he’d be lucky to not have someone go after him for the costs to rebuild it, let alone a partial refund!

Greenleaves20 · 19/10/2021 21:20

@RavingAnnie yes you’re right, we have paid for a service and it isn’t up to the standard we were expecting. It’s annoying and it means the space will be tighter than we expected which is such a shame given the money we’re spending and the inconvenience with having to move out due to all the dust.

OP posts: