Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Architects error

85 replies

Greenleaves20 · 19/10/2021 20:40

We’re in the middle of a kitchen diner extension to our house. We’ve discovered that the kitchen part is 20cm smaller than the architects drawings. This means our kitchen and island have to be reduced in size and also means the back wall is uneven. There is a post dividing the two sections so it probably won’t be too noticeable but it’s frustrating as we’d have gone out further into the garden if we’d known this. The shell of the building is finished and the roof is on. The project is costing well over £100K (utility and downstairs loo and hall all being done too). The architect has emailed to say it was an error due to an assumption they made but hasn’t really apologised. Having looked online etc I think I’m some ways we would like some compensation for this error, especially as we’ve paid over £10K in architects fees and their survey and it’s meaning we have to change our designs and end up with a smaller space. So should we (and anyone who knows are we able to) ask for some money back for this error?

YABU - it’s a mistake, just leave it and enjoy your extension

YANBU - ask for some money back

OP posts:
kirinm · 20/10/2021 15:20

I agree, the post / pillar will become a major irritant. I'd definitely try and get it rectified. Maybe try and establish the cost from your builder so you can approach the architect with a figure in mind. I wouldn't look for a reduction of fees.

minipie · 20/10/2021 15:19

Yes I was going to ask that. What’s the gap between island and pillar, if island stays the same size? And is there a garden door somewhere on that wall? If it’s a squeeze to get past the island and especially to get to the garden that will drive you mad.

billy1966 · 20/10/2021 15:12

Not having enough space for ease of movement around the island will be a long term annoyance, especially as your family grows up.

Will people be able to pass comfortably or will someone standing at that much narrowed width, actually block entry into the kitchen?

minipie · 20/10/2021 15:07

Ohh tricky. I absolutely see the issue from your drawing OP.

What ought to be done is to recess that post 20cm into the wall it’s on. However to do this means taking out the steel in the ceiling and swapping for a longer one. This is pretty major work especially with the roof on now. It can still be done however and tbh that is what I would push for as a first ask.

The wall that the post is against, it is a party wall shared with neighbours l, or not?

kirinm · 20/10/2021 14:44

[quote WizardOfAus]@kirinm

It's not about the builder having done what he's been asked to do. It's about the contractual responsibility for design. Certain contracts pass all design responsibilities to the main contractor regardless of whether they had any input into the design.

As someone working in the construction industry, I have never encountered a contract which passes all design responsibilities to a builder. Nor would I ever sign one.

The builder is not at fault here. The architect is.

Speak to the architect and ask them to compensate for any changes which need to be made, OP.[/quote]
As a solicitor who deals with disputes in the construction industry, I have. JCT Design and Build contracts are not named that for no reason.

I'm not suggesting the builder has done anything wrong at all. What I am saying is that subject to the wording of any contract agreed, the architect may well say the builder has taken on design responsibilities.

It's pretty straightforward to find out.

WizardOfAus · 20/10/2021 14:35

@kirinm

It's not about the builder having done what he's been asked to do. It's about the contractual responsibility for design. Certain contracts pass all design responsibilities to the main contractor regardless of whether they had any input into the design.

As someone working in the construction industry, I have never encountered a contract which passes all design responsibilities to a builder. Nor would I ever sign one.

The builder is not at fault here. The architect is.

Speak to the architect and ask them to compensate for any changes which need to be made, OP.

Hope478 · 20/10/2021 14:18

Instead of an island, why don't you attach it to that wall to hide the post?

Whinginadeville · 20/10/2021 14:12

Do you still have adequate room around the island?

Oblomov21 · 20/10/2021 14:12

Draw us another picture of how it should be / what you were expecting.

billy1966 · 20/10/2021 14:06

@minipie

By the way I would be focusing on asking them to bear the costs of fixing the error. (As a pp said they should have insurance to cover). Not asking for a fee reduction. A fee reduction will be tiny in comparison with the costs of fixing the error.
Excellent point.
Greenleaves20 · 20/10/2021 13:58

Posted pic twice in error, sorry!

OP posts:
Greenleaves20 · 20/10/2021 13:57

@minipie here’s a very rough and totally off scale drawing. Basically because the back wall (in purple) isn’t in the position we thought it pushes the 30cm post (yellow) forward by 20cm, meaning that the length of the wall in blue plus the post is 50cm now.

Architects error
Architects error
OP posts:
minipie · 20/10/2021 13:17

By the way I would be focusing on asking them to bear the costs of fixing the error. (As a pp said they should have insurance to cover). Not asking for a fee reduction. A fee reduction will be tiny in comparison with the costs of fixing the error.

minipie · 20/10/2021 13:16

Can you draw a diagram OP? (Or post the architects plans, lol). Is the post at the centre of the room or at the side?

I’m trying to understand how two walls not being in line affects the size of the post. As depending on the answer there may be different solutions possible.

billy1966 · 20/10/2021 13:08

OP,

Years ago we were having work done, including a new shower fitted, and the shower itself was put in the wrong spot and it was a hassle to redo it.

I didn't care and refused to be made feel bad.
The shower was put in an easier spot for them BUT it would bug the hell out of me every day.

Do NOT underestimate how much that post is going to bug YOU.

You need to really reflect on that annoyance.

100k spent and you will bugged EVERY day.

I would not be letting this go.

IMO this is a really HUGE fxxk up, and I would be making it crystal clear that it is up to the architects to fix THEIR mess, but you are not accepting this.

Sending off an email is a good idea, but do not let this go.

Be brave now, because you will bitterly regret not standing your ground and having to live with it.

Be prepared for them to minimise and just want this to go away.

Their lack of apology is outrageous in the circumstances.

Flowers
DancingQueen85 · 20/10/2021 12:25

We had exactly the same thing happen to us. The architect completely mis- measured the size of current building and this meant our extension needed to be larger than what the builders had quoted for.
We didn't pursue any compensation but I still feel annoyed about it. Surely one of the key aspects of an architects role is being precise with measurements.

kirinm · 20/10/2021 12:21

@Greenleaves20

Thanks for all the replies. Loads of good points and ideas about how to approach it; keeping calm and having a list of questions ready and taking it from there. I think we’ve decided that the post being 50cm rather than 30cm is actually the biggest issue now as it will really affect the main walkway into the kitchen and divide the rooms in a much more noticeable way. I think I’ll be a bit fed up every time I see it which will be a lot! The other main issue is the size of the room not being as we expected and having to alter our designs for this. So we’ve asked for an online meeting with the architect to discuss this and the next steps. Our ideal outcome is to at least have the post at the intended size. We can’t face starting again to get the room there right size - we’re currently living miles away from home with the in-laws as we have a 5 month old baby and a toddler and the house is extremely dusty. I feel really disappointed more than anything now - we’d been planning, saving up for and looking forward to this extension for a long time and it’s just not going to be as we wanted or expected it to be.

With regard to the measurements etc and is checking them I wouldn’t have expected to have to do this - the architects survey is a professional service and accuracy is what we’ve paid them for. I think we probably will ask for at least some of the fees back as I they’ve not done a good job. I accept that of course everyone makes mistakes and this is part of what their insurance is for I guess!

The builder isn’t at fault here - we have a 3 way contract with him, us and the architect and he has followed these (incorrect) plans to the letter as far as we can see.

It's not about the builder having done what he's been asked to do. It's about the contractual responsibility for design. Certain contracts pass all design responsibilities to the main contractor regardless of whether they had any input into the design.
Oblomov21 · 20/10/2021 12:14

Well. I'd definitely put it in writing. Possibly an email to solicitor, with builder cc'd in.
For traceability, so nothing that's 'said' could later be disputed.
List everything. Say you are not happy and this has to be resolved.

Do it today. Even if the email isn't perfect, Your'll have started, And the weight lifted off your shoulders will be very pleasurable I can assure you.

Greenleaves20 · 20/10/2021 11:40

Thanks for all the replies. Loads of good points and ideas about how to approach it; keeping calm and having a list of questions ready and taking it from there. I think we’ve decided that the post being 50cm rather than 30cm is actually the biggest issue now as it will really affect the main walkway into the kitchen and divide the rooms in a much more noticeable way. I think I’ll be a bit fed up every time I see it which will be a lot! The other main issue is the size of the room not being as we expected and having to alter our designs for this. So we’ve asked for an online meeting with the architect to discuss this and the next steps. Our ideal outcome is to at least have the post at the intended size. We can’t face starting again to get the room there right size - we’re currently living miles away from home with the in-laws as we have a 5 month old baby and a toddler and the house is extremely dusty. I feel really disappointed more than anything now - we’d been planning, saving up for and looking forward to this extension for a long time and it’s just not going to be as we wanted or expected it to be.

With regard to the measurements etc and is checking them I wouldn’t have expected to have to do this - the architects survey is a professional service and accuracy is what we’ve paid them for. I think we probably will ask for at least some of the fees back as I they’ve not done a good job. I accept that of course everyone makes mistakes and this is part of what their insurance is for I guess!

The builder isn’t at fault here - we have a 3 way contract with him, us and the architect and he has followed these (incorrect) plans to the letter as far as we can see.

OP posts:
kirinm · 20/10/2021 10:06

@Welshiefluff

But didn't you get a copy of the final drawings? He might have drawn then but you could have checked the measurements.
What do you think a qualified professional is? The OP is paying for them to get it right and it's not for her to review the drawings.

OP do you have a design and build contract with the contractors? If so, you might find the design responsibility now rests with them rather than the architect.

billy1966 · 20/10/2021 09:36

I can't get my head around the minimising either.

This is a big fxck up and really sloppy work.

Any compensation is meaningless in the context of a 100k job.

I would be very very upset, and they would definitely know it.

OP, I think you need to list out EXACTLY how their sloppiness has impacted the project and the end result.

I certainly wouldn't just leave it go.

Very annoying.Flowers

A1b2c3d4e5f6g7 · 20/10/2021 08:11

Different circumstances as we hadn't started the work yet, but our architect plans were incorrect also (based on the survey measurements from their surveyor). It meant it was rejected by building control. The architect was avoiding our calls and not being helpful. We ended up emailing the directors and they reviewed the case and gave us a refund on fees.

20 cm in a kitchen is a lot, and much bigger pillars are also. I'd definitely want a partial refund of fees

Tomatalillo · 20/10/2021 07:59

10k is a huge sum to pay for incompetence. I would only be cutting the architect any slack if they are falling over themselves to put this right; change the design, change materials, pay the difference etc.

If they just can’t be arsed, I’d put your needs and rectifications across coolly and calmly and see what they come up with but would absolutely be planning to make a complaint.

If you have lost confidence in their project management, do they have a colleague who could take over? Or can they pay for another professional to do the job.

Welshiefluff · 20/10/2021 07:40

But didn't you get a copy of the final drawings? He might have drawn then but you could have checked the measurements.

JayAlfredPrufrock · 20/10/2021 06:51

You ask how we got them to rectify their mistakes.

The rsj was too big so had to be redone to fit.

And the incorrect footings for the garage were so screamingly obvious they had no choice but to start again.