Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Architects error

85 replies

Greenleaves20 · 19/10/2021 20:40

We’re in the middle of a kitchen diner extension to our house. We’ve discovered that the kitchen part is 20cm smaller than the architects drawings. This means our kitchen and island have to be reduced in size and also means the back wall is uneven. There is a post dividing the two sections so it probably won’t be too noticeable but it’s frustrating as we’d have gone out further into the garden if we’d known this. The shell of the building is finished and the roof is on. The project is costing well over £100K (utility and downstairs loo and hall all being done too). The architect has emailed to say it was an error due to an assumption they made but hasn’t really apologised. Having looked online etc I think I’m some ways we would like some compensation for this error, especially as we’ve paid over £10K in architects fees and their survey and it’s meaning we have to change our designs and end up with a smaller space. So should we (and anyone who knows are we able to) ask for some money back for this error?

YABU - it’s a mistake, just leave it and enjoy your extension

YANBU - ask for some money back

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Greenleaves20 · 21/10/2021 21:54

@minipie I think we’d probably have gone out further into the garden and extended the utility room so the back wall was in line if that makes sense.

OP posts:
Marelle · 21/10/2021 20:51

You would probably have to demonstrate a financial loss in order to claim compensation. If your kitchen supplier has charged you more for adjusting your kitchen, or if the kitchen has cost you more, you could sue for that amount.

minipie · 21/10/2021 20:48

What would you have done differently if you’d known that wall actually stuck out 20cm further? (ie if his drawings had been accurate)

Greenleaves20 · 21/10/2021 20:37

He’s acknowledged in an email that it was their survey that was incorrect but there was no mention of this and no apology which I was surprised about I have to say….

OP posts:
billy1966 · 21/10/2021 20:12

Did he take responsibility for HIS fxxk up?

Greenleaves20 · 21/10/2021 19:17

Sorry that should read shelving to disguise the post

OP posts:
Greenleaves20 · 21/10/2021 19:16

Meeting today and initially the architect suggested shelving and reducing the island to disguise the large post. We said we weren’t happy with that and asked what the options were…. He said they’d actually explored the option of a steel post instead of brick to make it smaller but this would be very expensive. The screed has also just been completed on the floor. We left it with him to look into options and meeting again tomorrow but it doesn’t look like there is a simple solution.

OP posts:
minipie · 21/10/2021 10:30

Oh is the window for above the sink already in place? Yes I can see it might be odd to have no units there in that case. Any chance it could be changed into a full height picture window?

Assuming it’s not too late to change the plumbing…

justasking111 · 20/10/2021 23:20

I have an architect in the family he says builders will pickup on some things but this isn't one of them. It's down to the architect who is insured I hope. This may delay the job if he can make amendments

Greenleaves20 · 20/10/2021 23:15

Thanks @billy1966, we will try to layout the kitchen plan with newspapers! That’s a great idea. We can then put the post in too and see what that might look like.

@minipie that is a good idea and would definitely hide the post but there are a couple of reasons that it might not work. We have a kitchen window above the sink and looking out into the garden on the long wall where the sliding doors are. The opposite wall doesn’t have a window so moving it would probably look a bit odd. Secondly all the plumbing is being done this week which may be difficult to alter…

OP posts:
minipie · 20/10/2021 22:49

Would it be possible for you to swap the L shape to the other wall? So you have units along the pillar wall and behind the island ? That way the pillar is encompassed within kitchen units (fitter will need to cut into units to fit round it and obvs restricts what you can have there). You lose some wall cabinet but don’t have to shrink the island.

Doesn’t work if the plumbing is all in place and can’t be moved though.

billy1966 · 20/10/2021 22:37

Well without a doubt if you have to, resize the island.

Because the pleasure of it will be immeasurably diminished by constantly having to squeeze by.

It will go from being a useful work space to being something that feels in the way and its usefulness will also be diminished if two people can't stand back to back, or pass by each other comfortably.

I don't even know if 1500 is still a bit narrow for that.

A very useful tip is to lay out your kitchen with old newspapers to the exact measurements of the kitchen, with work tops and islands clearly laid out.

As a visual tool it is powerful.Flowers

Greenleaves20 · 20/10/2021 21:46

I think looking at solutions is probably the first step from what people have said. If none are possible I think we may be taking further steps.

@billy1966, yeah it’ll have to go down to 1000mm on one side and 1100 on the dishwasher side, or reduce the island size is the other option. Useful to know what works and what doesn’t as it’s hard to visualise it. Very disappointing as we wanted a big island and it’s one of the reasons we chose the kitchen size we did.

OP posts:
Welshiefluff · 20/10/2021 21:25

What do you think a qualified professional is? The OP is paying for them to get it right and it's not for her to review the drawings

Have you never heard of a qualified professional make a fuck up? It happens all around the country all the time.

I would be checking the final drawings on any project.

billy1966 · 20/10/2021 21:24

So OP, am I reading correctly thst the width will go from 1200, or 1100 down to 900 or 1000mm?...around the island?

If so I think that is very tight and will bug you.

I have one side of mine with a width of 1,000 and it's tight and bloody annoying.

Less than 1,500 is tight.

Two people cannot stand back to back on that width, well they could, but they won't, because it's tight.

I didn't notice it so much until we spend lockdown and I had endless snacking going on 18 hours a day, often all at the one time.

Hope478 · 20/10/2021 20:46

Unless you're attaching the island to that wall, I personally wouldn't have an island I had to squeeze around. It is just dead space.

Georgie8 · 20/10/2021 20:27

Agree with @Appleseesaw RIBA is a voluntary organisation, but for some reason people think it’s the gold standard. However, all architectural firms should have professional indemnity insurance cover.

For those who say it doesn’t really matter well, it does. You sought and paid handsomely for professional advice -it’s not as if you’d drawn plans out out on the back of an envelope for a builder to interpret.

Having said that, these disputes are hideous and expensive, especially if your household insurance doesn’t cover it. (Btw did you let your insurer know about the building work? If not, your insurance may be invalid.)

Ultimately you’ll need to look at solutions (unless you or your insurers have very deep pockets), which isn’t right, or fair, but otherwise you’ll never be able to move on. This is especially important if you borrowed money to do this work, as you have to continue to repay the loan whether or not you’re happy and, I assume, there won’t be spare cash for a legal fight.

Greenleaves20 · 20/10/2021 19:50

We asked for a meeting to discuss options with the architect and have one tomorrow. In his reply he said that the options are a reduction in island length and back wall unit length we don’t have back wall units. He also said ‘Working with existing buildings often brings about these situations, and its why no kitchen order should be placed without taking site dimensions’. We haven’t ordered a kitchen though so that’s not really the problem. I’m sort of getting the impression he doesn’t think it’s an issue and isn’t concerned so tomorrow should be interesting as we really do think it’s an issue!

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 20/10/2021 19:48

I’m not sure a peninsula style would work to disguise the post as it would be in the way of the main entry to the kitchen area and would mean walking all the way round to get/put away things

Doing so through a too tight space will be equally annoying.

Appleseesaw · 20/10/2021 19:47

@DiscoGlitterBall

Is it actually an architect? If so they will be RIBA, should have professional insurance and if you so wished you can make a complaint via RIBA.

I’d expect them to come up with a solution first though

Architects don’t have to be registered with RIBA to practice. They do have to be registered with the ARB. You can search the ARB’s website to check to see if someone is an architect.
Greenleaves20 · 20/10/2021 19:41

Pic attached now!

Architects error
OP posts:
Greenleaves20 · 20/10/2021 19:39

The gap between the island and pillar was supposed to be 1100mm and it was 1200mm between the other end and surface there to match the space all the way around. We also have planned a dishwasher on the units opposite the post so need a bigger space there really.

Expected design attached below with some of the rest of the house (utility room and understairs cupboard for coats) included. That short corridor leads to the hallway and front door. So we will we bringing shopping etc in through that brown door into the kitchen. I’m not sure a peninsula style would work to disguise the post as it would be in the way of the main entry to the kitchen area and would mean walking all the way round to get/put away things .The green bits indicate sliding doors into the garden.

OP posts:
LadyTiredWinterBottom2 · 20/10/2021 19:06

They aren't going to apologise as that would mean admitting they are at fault. But that is irrelevant as what you want is some money off.

If the layout is pretty much unchanged l would leave it. This isn't a massive loss or a significant change from your description.

BoredZelda · 20/10/2021 18:58

Possibly an email to solicitor, with builder cc'd in.
🙄 Don’t do this unless you want to look like a complete tool.

As someone working in the construction industry, I have never encountered a contract which passes all design responsibilities to a builder. Nor would I ever sign one.

Are you sure you work in the Construction industry? Design and build projects are one of the most common types of contracts. I’m working on 5 of them at the moment. In fact, I can’t remember the last time I didn’t do a D&B.

Instead of an island, why don't you attach it to that wall to hide the post?

Seems like the simplest solution to me.

BoredZelda · 20/10/2021 18:51

confused BoredZelda our kitchen had to be designed and ordered long before there was a finished shell to measure. So it had to be done off the architects plans. Architect was fully aware of this and expected it. Yes there was a site survey right at the end before fitting to check the built dimensions matched the plans but by then it would have been too late to make any major changes to the kitchen design.

An entirely difference scenario to fitting a kitchen in an existing space, and far less risky. But even with that, sounds like there was a fuck up with programming because having worked on hundreds of construction projects over 30 years, no contractor would order a finalised kitchen off an architect’s plan. Any change that came from that error would be yours, not the architect’s.

Swipe left for the next trending thread