Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to hate work yearly reviews

87 replies

user789653 · 19/10/2021 19:37

Tomorrow I have my yearly review at work and I'm dreading it. I hate them at the best of times but this one is my first since been back at work after cancer and my confidence is so low.
Feeling so anxious about it. AIBU?

OP posts:
DeepaBeesKit · 19/10/2021 21:12

Yanbu, I honestly think they achieve nothing too. Its actually quite a hard process to use a poor performance review to manage someone out or even implement changes without running the risk of being in some way unfair/biased/discriminatory in some way.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 19/10/2021 21:12

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

wigglerose · 19/10/2021 21:11

I haaaaaaaate them but then I have two (2! TWO!) line managers and both are crap managers in different ways. Together, they makes them more stressful by doing things like

  • talking about what other team members will be doing (I don't care???)
  • talking about the next big project, then when I ask what my role in it will be, will tell me that I won't be involved because it's fully staffed (thanks for wasting our time, then)
  • being impervious to the concept of SMART objectives or setting objectives at all (I'm to understand my job is to do whatever shit lands on my desk as soon as practicable, I think???)
  • asked me if I'd like to be classed as my job role, or the one above (my job role, you numpty, particularly if I'm exceeding expectations for my job role but simply meeting expectations for the job role above me??)
  • not engaging when asked about development/progression - I'm not sure how they find "I'd like to discuss what the next 3-5 years look like for me. I'd like to work toward leading a project within a reasonable timescale and set up a personal development plan for me to achieve this" confusing and impossible to respond to, but there you are. Everyone is supposed to have a personal development plan. They looked baffled until I said, "You know, with milestones to meet and a timeline," and they said we'd discuss it next appraisal (ok, I get the hint)
  • the only feedback I get is "your internal clients think you're good and respond quickly to them, which relieves the pressure on them". OK, thanks. Praise is nice but feedback on how to improve would be good, particularly since you took two projects off me for arbitrary reasons.

I return to work from mat leave in two weeks and I'm dreading another fucking ineffectual appraisal. I'm dreading what a waste of time my return to work meeting will be.

I'm interviewing elsewhere specifically because I'm fed up of how I'm managed.

SuddenArborealStop · 19/10/2021 21:06

@Thiswontendwell

Oh my goodness! Just want to put another view... I line manage a number of people (NHS-mental health) and the annual appraisals are a space to think about learning from the past twelve months (so people are invited to highlight good experiences and think about how they have developed) and then we look at the next twelve months and make SMART objectives - what do they want to achieve and how can they be supported to do it. It isn't perfect at all but it's supposed to be a supportive thing... There is another way!!! (Poor performance and disciplinary issues are addressed other ways in case people are worried about that)
You wrote this like you expect people to want to set pointless goals . I'm not given to introspection and find this sort of thing excruciating and if management have an issue they should tell me at the time not once a year.
elizabethdraper · 19/10/2021 21:03

I hate Smartgoals vs

I don't want to manage people so no more progression for me.

I want to do my job and go home

My company go on about development yet turn down all requests for additional trains train I g or career developme

echt · 19/10/2021 20:59

I teach in Australia, and annual reviews are tied to progression up the pay scale.It's government-led.

Every year I have to find four ways of being better. That fit the school's agenda, not mine. That's 70 different ways since I've been here. I am not opposed to getting better at my job, far from it, just pissed off that some things I do don't count.

This year is my last one, as I'm retiring. Yay.

Epic mic drop.

MondeoFan · 19/10/2021 20:55

I hate it too, I have to have it twice a year.
They normally ask about my work/life balance but I never get told if I'm doing anything wrong or how I could improve. Then each time they ask me what courses I want to go on and I always say none as the courses are on evenings or weekends when I'm already spreading myself thin with working hours and 2 DC at home.
Hardly any praise either. So I take it I must be doing ok if no praise or ways to improve

Nearlytheretrees · 19/10/2021 20:55

We have monthly meetings so the end of year is completely pointless but we still have to tick the boxes to say we've done it

Blindleadingtheblind · 19/10/2021 20:51

Fucking hate them. Was supposed to do mine about errrrmmmm, two months ago. Not even wrote the fucker out yet but honestly I'm too busy at work to be bothered doing a paper exercise. Line manager also keeps saying I dont need to worry about it yet so I'm taking my sweet time.

stakhanovite · 19/10/2021 20:50

Ugh, yes. Mine was a bloodbath last year. Not looking forward to this one.

MadeItOut21 · 19/10/2021 20:50

I used to hate them but now I work in a place where they don't do them at all. It's a fairly large sized organisation, I have no idea if people think I'm doing well and I have no formal way to discuss my career, performance or raise issues. At all. It's all informal, I'm supposed to go through my middle manager who 1) is on mat leave and 2) has no say in anything anyway, they ignore her entirely. It's actually a great way for management to ignore issues of more junior members of staff because there is no way for us to raise them.

Oneforthemoneytwo · 19/10/2021 20:50

I hate them. I came out of my last one with absolutely no idea if it was good or bad. My line manager simply listed things I had done and needed to do

PrincessPaws · 19/10/2021 20:48

I work in HR and while I can see the value I also hate them on a personal level.

I just find talking about myself very uncomfortable and hearing people say nice things about me makes me cringe.

maddening · 19/10/2021 20:47

There should be nothing in there that you don't expect, if the first you hear of how badly you have done is qt your annual review then the manager has totally failed and I would be raising it to their manager.

It should be a case of, this is what you do well, this is stuff you should aim to stop doing and this is what you should start doing.

FangsForTheMemory · 19/10/2021 20:46

@ftw163532

Anybody who surprises you with stuff or saves up examples of mistakes from 12 months ago for an annual review is a shit manager.
True, but good luck if you decide to tell them that.
Flufferty · 19/10/2021 20:45

I hate them. Just console yourself with the thought that your line manager probably hates them just as much as you do

ftw163532 · 19/10/2021 20:44

@Dibble135

YANBU. Thankfully my last one was in 2019. My company then dumped them in favour of “career conversions” with the emphasis on you to ask for one as and when. I never have and never will!
Living the dream.
Ilikewinter · 19/10/2021 20:43

Yep i hate them to, as does my manager. I havent looked at mine since i wrote it 12 months ago and yet ive ecxeeded my contract! Guess actions speak louder than words.

ftw163532 · 19/10/2021 20:43

Anybody who surprises you with stuff or saves up examples of mistakes from 12 months ago for an annual review is a shit manager.

Kite22 · 19/10/2021 20:42

I don't 'dread them', but I am just annoyed that I have to waste my time sitting through them. I am more annoyed on behalf of my Manager who has to not only sit through her own, but half the Team she manages too!

In our Team they are a complete waste of time - we all raise things as we go through the year if we need or want to, and our Managers would raise things with us if they want to. It is just a complete box ticking waste of time exercise.

Dibble135 · 19/10/2021 20:41

YANBU. Thankfully my last one was in 2019. My company then dumped them in favour of “career conversions” with the emphasis on you to ask for one as and when. I never have and never will!

ftw163532 · 19/10/2021 20:40

Setting completely pointless SMART goals is the absolute highlight of my year.

DrManhattan · 19/10/2021 20:37

Does anyone read them? I've cut and paste a couple over the years...

TerribleZebra · 19/10/2021 20:33

I manage quite a few people and I enjoy the ones I do with them, but I loathe my one with my line manager. The difference is I have 30 min 1:1s with my staff every week so the 6 monthly reviews are just an extension of these and so nothing is a suprise. My team is fab so I really enjoy helping them reach their potential. I also prepare for them so I have notes and a structure to follow. On the other hand my line manager frequently cancels my 1:1s and never prepares for any meetings so he just gables and makes stuff up. He's now in formal performance management with HR due to this.

MagentaRocks · 19/10/2021 20:27

I don’t mind them, but it is time consuming doing them for my staff. I have regular meetings with them, so nothing in the yearly review is a surprise to them. I update the record regularly with good work etc and I ask them to go their own personal copy, so if they have received a direct thank you or something. Then at the review time I marry it all up and we have a chat through it.