Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to hate work yearly reviews

87 replies

user789653 · 19/10/2021 19:37

Tomorrow I have my yearly review at work and I'm dreading it. I hate them at the best of times but this one is my first since been back at work after cancer and my confidence is so low.
Feeling so anxious about it. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
february08baby · 31/10/2021 10:26

I have one coming up and I have no idea what to even write so would appreciate ideas. I'm in the third sector in a training and development role.

Kite22 · 20/10/2021 21:10

Sometimes people are ambitious, sometimes they are not, but often there are things they'd like to change or learn but just have never spoken up about it. This is my chance to tease these out. I do work in a fairly small company though, where we have the power to change things and tailor things for our team, so that may be different from a lot of people posting here.

You are right to acknowledge it is different in different organisations. The issue for us is that our Team Manager doesn't have the power to make any significant changes - she is constantly working to try to give us a half decent chance at completing at least a small amount of our job, but we are so short staffed, and having to take up work from other Teams that have been cut through austerity, so just 'doing our job' isn't possible anymore.

The more you prepare and contribute the more benefit are likely to obtain from it.
Grin
Oh, if only life were that simple for all staff in all organisations. It would be lovely if that were the case.

Appraisals are so outdated and as for setting SMART targets, these just don't work if you do the kind of job where what's happening changes daily, especially if these targets are linked to the work of others that you have no control over.
This ^
When you are told you 'have to' have a target about things you have absolutely no control over, the whole situation is then farcical, which is one of the reasons why so many people think it is such a waste of time.

Our appraisals are standard Council Service ones and unsuitable for my work as a peripatetic teacher. I resent being given targets/work challenges that will inevitably have to be done in my own time.

This ^ too. (I'm not a peripatetic teacher, but same principle) - big organisations like Council think they can squeeze into the same box, a person that stands by a barrier in a car park, raising it when people with the right pass arrive to park, and a senior lawyer or accountant or strategic director. It is nonsensical.

I just want to do a good job and go home!

Quite.
In fact, this x 100%.
Some people will want to 'develop' or go off in a new career direction, but, lets be honest, at various points in our lives, all of us want this.

Lunaballoon · 20/10/2021 19:11

I detest these with a passion and so does my line manager. It’s another layer of pointless admin that stresses everyone out.

I get that employees and businesses need to move forward and set targets but this is such a blunt tool. Ours are now called OKRs or objectives and key results with yet most lists and form filling.

CJSmith2019 · 20/10/2021 18:44

@HollaHolla

I hate them.

I did once get told you should never go into one, and get any surprises. Sadly, my boss doesn't seem to believe this, and saves up any minor errors, inaccuracies or perceived slights for the year, and goes through them one-by-one. It's some kind of power play for her. She's the epitome of someone promoted beyond their level of competence.

It's wrong that one person can make this such a negative experience, and have so much bearing over your career. Sad

I had a manager like that. So glad to be gone from her spiteful little universe.
thecatsthecats · 20/10/2021 18:43

I was in the glorious position of being able to cancel annual reviews in my last job.

Everyone knew what their projects and responsibilities were, and I'd have regular 121s or team catch ups with my managees, so we could identify any issues or successes and talk about any training they needed.

Far better than an annual chat with moronic SMART goals.

JustDanceAddict · 20/10/2021 18:41

I had an interview where they told me appraisals were quarterly. Thankfully I didn’t get the job!!

SingingSands · 20/10/2021 18:33

I hate them too. Ours are quarterly Sad I've been doing this job for 19 years, I'm good at it and yet I feel like I have to justify my existence and come up with "objectives" every 3 months.

Helocariad · 20/10/2021 18:29

@HollaHolla

I hate them.

I did once get told you should never go into one, and get any surprises. Sadly, my boss doesn't seem to believe this, and saves up any minor errors, inaccuracies or perceived slights for the year, and goes through them one-by-one. It's some kind of power play for her. She's the epitome of someone promoted beyond their level of competence.

It's wrong that one person can make this such a negative experience, and have so much bearing over your career. Sad

Flowers @HollaHolla

This was me with a previous manager- it was beyond stressful and so unnecessary. Showed what a poor manager she was. I took if up with HR in the end and it turned out I wasn't the first one to complain. Would that be a possibility for you?

I've since changed roles and my current LM couldn't be more different. Annual reviews are a reflection of achievements of that year and a look ahead at the next 12 months. Over in an hr, and that includes chat and a laugh.

JustDanceAddict · 20/10/2021 18:28

I hate them with a passion. Never did so much in previous jobs as I worked v closely w my line managers, but my last lm was much more removed from me and not a fair boss (no-one liked them). Also, the process was just a tick box exercise and I had to make up ‘goals’ when my job was going nowhere.
Im hoping that in my current role it will be a conversation on both sides. I am already looking at how I could take on more responsibility and I haven’t been there long.

hotmeatymilk · 20/10/2021 18:28

It’s a two way process. The more you prepare and contribute the more benefit are likely to obtain from it
This is a lie and I will fight you.

ChrisS36 · 20/10/2021 18:22

It’s a two way process. The more you prepare and contribute the more benefit are likely to obtain from it.

hotmeatymilk · 20/10/2021 18:17

How did yours go, OP? Mine’s first thing tomorrow, and on Zoom. Somehow think it’ll be worse on Zoom

Neveratruerfriend · 20/10/2021 15:32

@imnotacelebritygetmeoutofhere

YANBU to hate them, a lot of people hate having them, a lot of managers hate doing them. An annual review is fairly pointless anyway, problems and praise should be addressed at the time they are required. At my work we ditched them and instead have a fortnightly coaching development programme - meet with line manager every two weeks to focus on skills and development needs continuously. So much better!
That seems to be the problem. When appraisals are ditched, they get replaced with something that appears to be just as onerous - I'm sure I'd hate a fortnightly "coaching development programme" even more!
Pushkinia · 20/10/2021 14:58

They’re pointless and I hate them. Our appraisals are standard Council Service ones and unsuitable for my work as a peripatetic teacher. I resent being given targets/work challenges that will inevitably have to be done in my own time.

Questions such as “What target can we set that will benefit the Service as a whole?” are a nightmare to answer because I’m not given any paid time for extra “activities”!

To be fair, my last 2 appraisals have had “Continue to uphold excellent teaching standards” as a target, because neither my boss nor I could think of anything.

I just want to do a good job and go home!

Sparklingbrook · 20/10/2021 14:09

I had to go on a week’s residential course to learn how to do people’s appraisals in a previous job. Role plays, the works. Urgh. It only took that week for me to realise I didn’t actually want to do them.

imnotacelebritygetmeoutofhere · 20/10/2021 14:00

YANBU to hate them, a lot of people hate having them, a lot of managers hate doing them. An annual review is fairly pointless anyway, problems and praise should be addressed at the time they are required.
At my work we ditched them and instead have a fortnightly coaching development programme - meet with line manager every two weeks to focus on skills and development needs continuously. So much better!

Neveratruerfriend · 20/10/2021 13:55

Yes I hate them too and think they are completely pointless. To save time, I paste & copy the last year's write up into the current year appraisal form and then just alter it (figures, dates etc).

I suggest appraisal by exception only may be a way forward. ie if you are doing okay (and we all know, and our managers know, who is doing fine) then why have one? But if someone has gone the extra mile (or had performance issues) then an appraisal may be needed for fairness. Similarly people could specifically request an appraisal if they felt they wanted / needed one.

TheGoogleMum · 20/10/2021 13:30

I dont like them, but with a nice manager they aren't so bad. Goal setting is hard if you just want to carry on getting by!

Sparklingbrook · 20/10/2021 13:27

For anyone worrying what to say about ‘goals’

to hate work yearly reviews
MayorGundersonsDogRufus · 20/10/2021 13:22

I manage several people and put quite a bit of thought into their annual reviews. As PPs have said, I try and make sure there aren't any surprises and I try and focus on getting them to step back and think about the bigger picture and what they want out of work and their career. Sometimes people are ambitious, sometimes they are not, but often there are things they'd like to change or learn but just have never spoken up about it. This is my chance to tease these out. I do work in a fairly small company though, where we have the power to change things and tailor things for our team, so that may be different from a lot of people posting here.

thetesdybears · 20/10/2021 11:02

In my opinion they are a tick box exercise. I can't imagine many people feel they get anything out of it.

I hate them too and worse still our monthly 1-2-1 is now almost like a mini one. Hate it, I am not interested in goals, I don't have the time for it in my already very busy workload. I do a really gd job and I work out of hours to make deadlines etc. I have colleagues that are a lot less busy, probably half my workload and they have time to do improvements and other stuff. They then get all the praise for it and it pisses me off.

nicknameidea · 20/10/2021 10:41

I used to have a line manager who utterly hated me and tried all sorts of tricks to try and get me sacked or to leave. One of these was through my annual appraisal, we had to get 5 people to give us feedback every year and he would choose his cronies for me so my feedback wasn't great. HR knew and did nothing. He called my appraisal my 'permanent record' like it was some kind of criminal record that would follow me forever. I stuck it out for 3 years then left, funnily enough my record with that company stayed there. Horrible man and a shit manager.

Appraisals are so outdated and as for setting SMART targets, these just don't work if you do the kind of job where what's happening changes daily, especially if these targets are linked to the work of others that you have no control over.

NerdyBird · 20/10/2021 10:05

Where I work we are supposed to do continuous feedback, which means anyone can give feedback to anyone, at any time. You can ask for feedback too. It isn't any better than an annual review. People rarely ask for feedback and most people are too busy to give it all the time.
But this thread has reminded me that our system has stopped sending alerts about objectives being overdue and I'm sure some of mine are! Thankfully line manager and team leader don't care, but department manager probably does...sigh. Might try and update stuff before xmas!

SturminsterNewton · 20/10/2021 09:59

We have to mark ourselves out of 10. The first year I assessed myself honestly and my manager reduced everything by a couple of marks.

The following years I've given myself all 9s and 10s. My manager still reduces, but now that gives me 7s and 8s and we are both happy! Grin

It's a stupid game, both managers and staff hate them. Don't let it get to you OP.

Blankspace4 · 20/10/2021 09:36

The bell curves are awful.

The appraisals are generally used 80% plus of the time in my organisation to justify why someone’s performance rating, pay or bonus isn’t as good as they hoped. Of course there are a minority of people who are happy but it’s a huge consumption of time for very little reward and people hate being put in boxes (quite right too)

Swipe left for the next trending thread