Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there's a difference between being nosey and being inquisitive?

111 replies

winningforhim · 19/10/2021 19:30

Tonight my daughters dad phoned her whilst we were driving. A girl in my daughters class works for my ex so my daughter said that she seen him at school pick up this afternoon. My ex replied saying, 'yeah well it is usually him that collects his DD'. At that point I said, 'yeah I've noticed that, what does her mum do for work?' Ex replied 'I don't know, your mums awful nosey isn't she DD?'

Now I do ask people questions, 'did you have a nice break?' 'What do you do for work?' 'Do you enjoy it?' 'How old are your kids etc'. I like to show an interest because...well I'm interested.

I will ask questions about people, for instance DD is going to a wedding in December with ex and so the guy who is getting married I knew through ex so I asked, 'how is M doing these days?' 'Where is he working?' 'How long have they been together?' 'Where are they getting married?'

This obviously strikes my ex as me being nosey, however, I'm not asking these questions with any malicious intent or to spread information about. I'm not asking how much they earn or about there sex life.

It offended me that ex called me nosey in front of DD. I would say my personality is more inquisitive. When I said this to ex he said there's no such thing.

AIBU thinking that asking this question does not make me Nosey?

OP posts:
NiceGerbil · 20/10/2021 02:29

I had this conversation with my parents.

We've been wondering about neighbours where they get their money from what they do for work. They never seem to go out!

Ok... Well I dunno. Why are you interested?

Well they never go to work! She's got a job in HR and he's an accountant. It seems peculiar. We googled them and that was all we found.

You googled them? That's a bit. Strange. Why are you so interested?

Well obviously we googled them! Everyone googles neighbours etc. Don't tell us you don't!!!! Hahaha.

I don't. Why?

Yes you do.

No... Etc etc.

They were baffled as was I.

Anyway then they said well she's head of this for X. Just hr.

It was a massive well known group with thousands of employees multinational etc...

I mean FGS!

NiceGerbil · 20/10/2021 02:23

Only read OP.

There's a lot of difference in this. And the you types seem to find it impossible to understand the other type.

Surely noting that parent a or b usually does pick up is in itself a bit.. that way.

I mean at primary even with parents I chatted with it didn't drop into my mind oh parent a picks up. If someone had said which parent usually gets c (assuming two involved etc). Then if I'd have to stop and think ah child c. how often do I see a Vs b. And I didn't always do school run so still couldn't have said for sure!

Your question yes nosey. why do you want to know? Is it information you will do something with? Don't think so. You wanted to know just because.

I mean she could be Ill, at work, volunteering, in the pub, looking after other children, visiting her mum, doing a course...

I mean. So what?

Him saying you're nosey in front of DC is out of line though. Does he often make disparaging comments in front of them? It's really not on.

EmeraldShamrock · 20/10/2021 01:50

I agree with him. Inquisitive people never think they're nosey.
I'm neither.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 20/10/2021 01:35

Yes! You’re nosey!! A right wee Isa

But people need tae knooooowwww!!!!!!

I'd fall into the 'nosey' camp on this one - but definitely the 'nosey with genuine interest' rather than the 'nosey looking for malicious gossip' side of the Nosey Fence.

rainraim · 20/10/2021 01:25

I get what you mean, your not nosey but ex is choosing to interpret as that. My dh i find asks a lot of questions like you, god forbid he speaks to a stranger outside with an accent preee the questions! He's not nosey, he just loves to talk and finds somethings really interesting, I always joke that he can get a wall to talk back to
Him! I do get Annoyed sometimes as I feel others might feel he's being intrusive but maybe that's me projecting myself on to them because everyone seems to IOve engaging in conversation with him

SpookyPumpkinPants · 20/10/2021 00:43

@pumpkinpie01

So do I but a lot of people don't , they just talk about themselves . I read once ' when you talk about yourself you are repeating what you already know when you 're asking questions and listening you are learning ' and it's true . I call taking an interest being a people person , not nosy .
Exactly!!

@winningforhim. You asked in the wrong place! Showing an interest in people, being interested is a crime around these parts...asking people their favourite Wimbledon us highly personal 🙄🙄

He was very rude to you in front of DD, but at least he's your ex!!

You be you!

StoneofDestiny · 20/10/2021 00:33

Strikes me as nosey - anything you don’t really need to know, is someone else’s business or they haven’t offered to tell you themselves is nosey.
I’d not wanted to be asked lots og questions - so I give others the same latitude.

sammylady37 · 20/10/2021 00:13

[quote winningforhim]**@ChubbyK* well @sammylady37* said she would hate someone quizzing someone about her life like I'm doing. For Christ sake, I asked one question about the woman - hardly quizzing 😂. And her answer was rude - 'back off!' - she does so sound angry or rude and unable to articulate herself politely at the very least. [/quote]
I’d call the 4 questions you asked about the person getting married to be ‘quizzing’ someone about them. And wrt to the one question episode, from your account you butted in on a conversation others were having to ask this info that was absolutely nothing to do with you and which you didn’t need to know. I find that strange, to say the least.

And her answer was rude - 'back off!' - she does so sound angry or rude and unable to articulate herself politely at the very least

Btw, when you make a comment like the above on someone’s posting style, you should make sure you haven’t already lost the moral high ground by starting your preceding sentence with “For Christ sake”, because you know, that makes you sound angry, rude and unable to articulate yourself politely at the very least.

sammylady37 · 20/10/2021 00:08

Oh dear, you sound awfully angry. Are you okay?

I’m not in the least bit angry, I’ve merely given you an answer you don’t like and pointed out how some others may perceive your behaviour, which is after all what your op was asking. Perhaps you need to reevaluate your understanding of what ‘angry’ means as well as ‘nosey’.

Namechangedforthethousandthtim · 20/10/2021 00:06

I'm the same, I am genuinely interested in people. I assume your ex was joking when he said you were nosey.

sillysmiles · 20/10/2021 00:06

To me, that just sounds like conversation!

shampooing · 19/10/2021 23:58

@IWouldLikeToKnow

My mother in law is like this. Always asking questions. She swears that she's not nosey, that she's just interested, but it really comes across to me like she is. Drives me mad.
My MIL is exactly like this, always asking questions about my family that are none of her business. Also telling me stuff about other people that is personal to them and I have no desire to know (about her friends' marriages or financial situations). She spends a lot of time what she would call 'musing' and I call being nosey. "I wonder how Elizabeth can afford that new car" and when I say I don't know or care she can't understand that I'm being truthful, I don't give a fuck how Elizabeth affords the car because it's not my business.

@winningforhim you do sound pretty nosey, some people I know are nosey and admit it, and I just tell them to stop being nosey, but you describe being nosey but are then offended when your ex says you are nosey. Is that because it's him who said it? If a friend said you were nosey would you consider it more objectively?
I have some very nosey relatives, we all know they're nosey and they don't deny it. We can call them out on it and have a laugh.

As a general rule I don't ask people about their jobs or whether they have children, for conversation starters or people I don't know I stick to safer topics, food, the weather, what they like to do. If we become friends more personal information will follow, and if we don't then I don't need to know.

IgiveupallthenamesIwantedareg0 · 19/10/2021 23:55

I'm not in the least bit nosy, I just want to know everything!

PixieLaLa · 19/10/2021 23:52

I think the big difference is asking questions
to someone in conversation but it sounds like what your doing is asking questions about other people which does sound nosey, I can see why your ex would find it a bit annoying.

eisforemma · 19/10/2021 23:45

@FrenchBoule

Everything what *@IWouldLikeToKnow* said. I have MIL like that. She drives me bonkers asking for an info she doesn’t need. To be fair she offers the same information in return (which I neither want or need). It’s mentally exhausting
See people like you sound very unpleasant. Your MIL asks questions - drives you bonkers. Your MIL shares things about herself - you don't want or need to hear it. She can't really win then can she? She may as well sit quietly and not speak to avoid upsetting you.

It sounds like very hard work being around you if both asking questions or sharing makes you unhappy. People can't talk about politics, history, culture and the bloody telly constantly.

FrenchBoule · 19/10/2021 23:39

Everything what @IWouldLikeToKnow said.
I have MIL like that. She drives me bonkers asking for an info she doesn’t need.
To be fair she offers the same information in return (which I neither want or need).
It’s mentally exhausting

pumpkinpie01 · 19/10/2021 23:32

So do I but a lot of people don't , they just talk about themselves . I read once ' when you talk about yourself you are repeating what you already know when you 're asking questions and listening you are learning ' and it's true . I call taking an interest being a people person , not nosy .

PeriChristmas · 19/10/2021 22:27

Well I find it weird when people don't ask questions about anyone else!

Thatsplentyjack · 19/10/2021 21:40

Tonight my daughters dad phoned her whilst we were driving. A girl in my daughters class works for my ex so my daughter said that she seen him at school pick up this afternoon. My ex replied saying, 'yeah well it is usually him that collects his DD'

This confused me for so long! So the girls dad works for your ex.

Yeah you di sound a bit nosey OP.

BurntO · 19/10/2021 21:30

As I said, I think it’s nosey. But perhaps just change your perspective of nosey Grin I can admit I can be nosey. I am fine with that considering I don’t gossip to others and despite my nosiness I am genuinely rarely judgemental. I just find people interesting.

Chasingsquirrels · 19/10/2021 20:59

I don't think there is much difference, you are inferring a negative connotation to nosey that you don't to inquisitive. Not everyone would make that sake judgement.

To think there's a difference between being nosey and being inquisitive?
To think there's a difference between being nosey and being inquisitive?
3scape · 19/10/2021 20:58

It's quite 1950s/ Tory to be so "inquisitive" about people's jobs in that way. You're ex thinks you're nosey because you are.

Kite22 · 19/10/2021 20:54

tbf - In your OP, which one would reasonably expect a poster to put "their side" you sound very nosey.
If I've understood it right, you weren't even in this conversation - it was your dd and her Dad, and you were ear wigging (understandable if it was on speakerphone), but in that scenario, it isn't your place to butt in with questions (unless it was to do with some practical arrangement about getting dd somewhere).
Nor is it your place to ask your dd's Dad about other people's lives. If you are friends with this people (or people you just meet for the first time), then perfectly legit to bring up in a conversation with them what job they do, but asking someone about other people is nosey.

TractorAndHeadphones · 19/10/2021 20:53

Also OP - the main thing here is that you're upset your ex called you nosey.
Even if you are he should not have said that to you in front of your child

CaptainThe95thRifles · 19/10/2021 20:51

Whilst I think you'd learn more about someone by asking their thoughts on Brexit than what they happen to do as a job, there are also less controversial political topics for the faint hearted polite introductory conversation.