Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there's a difference between being nosey and being inquisitive?

111 replies

winningforhim · 19/10/2021 19:30

Tonight my daughters dad phoned her whilst we were driving. A girl in my daughters class works for my ex so my daughter said that she seen him at school pick up this afternoon. My ex replied saying, 'yeah well it is usually him that collects his DD'. At that point I said, 'yeah I've noticed that, what does her mum do for work?' Ex replied 'I don't know, your mums awful nosey isn't she DD?'

Now I do ask people questions, 'did you have a nice break?' 'What do you do for work?' 'Do you enjoy it?' 'How old are your kids etc'. I like to show an interest because...well I'm interested.

I will ask questions about people, for instance DD is going to a wedding in December with ex and so the guy who is getting married I knew through ex so I asked, 'how is M doing these days?' 'Where is he working?' 'How long have they been together?' 'Where are they getting married?'

This obviously strikes my ex as me being nosey, however, I'm not asking these questions with any malicious intent or to spread information about. I'm not asking how much they earn or about there sex life.

It offended me that ex called me nosey in front of DD. I would say my personality is more inquisitive. When I said this to ex he said there's no such thing.

AIBU thinking that asking this question does not make me Nosey?

OP posts:
KrispyKale · 20/10/2021 10:51

It's easy to read judgement where there isn't any.
Half my family are on the inquisitive side and to be fair they are not judgemental in that way and for that reason it never crossed my mind that this sort of small talk was often deemed judgemental. And yes they'd be asking about what dads did too.

Peoniesandpeaches · 20/10/2021 10:45

@echt

Inquisitive and nosey mean the same thing: undue interest in another's business.

This isn't mere pedantry; the OP sees a difference between her actions and what her ex says. He's a stirrer for making the comment passively aggressively to the child.

I'd go for interested (positive) v. nosy/inquisitive (out of order).

I would go with out of order given that she came from a judgemental place - ie why doesn’t the other mum do pick ups. I mean I doubt she asks why other fathers aren’t doing more pick ups. It comes across as trying to work out whether this woman’s job really warrants not picking up her daughter and she was already sticking her beak into a conversation that wasn’t directed towards her. I think this was a timely reminder by her ex that this is a bad habit to have got into and isn’t something they want to instill in their daughter.
longwayoff · 20/10/2021 10:22

"Don't make personal remarks" was my mother's mantra. That is, mind your own business about other people's lives unless you've been invited to comment. It's quite difficult to live up to!

sillysmiles · 20/10/2021 10:14

How do you get to know people if you don't ask them about themselves?

Don't say they'll tell you, because why would you tell anyone things about yourself if they didn't seem interested?

If no one asks and no one tells they you don't get to know people. And getting to know people shouldn't stop at a certain age.

FangsForTheMemory · 20/10/2021 09:31

@sammylady37

Oh dear, you sound awfully angry. Are you okay?

I’m not in the least bit angry, I’ve merely given you an answer you don’t like and pointed out how some others may perceive your behaviour, which is after all what your op was asking. Perhaps you need to reevaluate your understanding of what ‘angry’ means as well as ‘nosey’.

Exactly, @sammylady37. I thought that was an outrageous reply from the OP. She doesn't sound very nice at all.
KrispyKale · 20/10/2021 09:24

I have stopped asking questions of some people for this reason op and the same ones now think I'm awfully closed off and uninterested.
Some people are simply not on your side and will take every opportunity to have a nip at you.

TractorAndHeadphones · 20/10/2021 09:20

@eisforemma but if you’re a skilled conversationalist you don’t have to ask questions. You draw it out of people in the course of conversation.
Lots of people like the pp you replied to quite happily talk to me and tell me everything about themselves although they hate being quizzed. Because I don’t quiz them.

Asking questions one after another which are either too narrow or too broad is a low effort conversational technique.

Flumpyfish · 20/10/2021 07:25

I think the only difference is the intention behind it.

I guess the nosy side is more selfish, wanting to know more to satisfy your own curiosity, where as the not nosy side is wanting to know more about the person out of a genuine interest. Since others don't know your intent, then it could be picked up either way.

Alexand23 · 20/10/2021 07:06

My partner has autism and asks people a lot of questions. He does realise sometimes that he is doing it and trys to rein it in but sometimes he can't stop himself. Obviously because he is relaxed with me I get the full 20 questions.
If I meet someone during the day while he is at work he will either ask nothing about them when I get home (if he isn't interested in that person) or it will be every question he can think of however random (if they have siblings, their job, their children, how many they have etc) It can be embarrassing when he does it to people as the questions he might ask can be seen as very nosy, like if someone mentions their house he might ask when they bought it, how many bedrooms it is etc. Obviously people don't know he has autism.
I do try be patient but it can be very annoying! Although after writing that out and thinking about it, I feel bad for getting annoyed. I must try be nicer.

Feckingirritated · 20/10/2021 06:50

I ’d say nosy, it’d be inquisitive if you were talking directly to the person in question, or if you were already acquainted with them. Jobs can also be a relatively awkward question. I’ve had people respond poorly when I’ve told them what I do (retail)- varying from acting like I’m a layabout, to someone recoiling and then ignoring me. It’s demoralising, and even more so when there’s other factors they’re likely to be judged on, like being a mum who doesn’t do the school run. There could be loads of reasons why her dad does the school run, and not always ones that people want to talk about.

RantyAunty · 20/10/2021 06:46

It's nosy as it wasn't your call to be listening in on and these people your ex knows has nothing to do with you.

I've found nobody truly is interested in what I do for work other than trying to size me up as to how much money I make so they can decide if I'm worth talking to or to look down their noses at me.
Sounds harsh but it's true.

sammylady37 · 20/10/2021 06:46

@Whatwillbetheendofus

I think I've heard it all now. If you are nosy OP then I definitely am. The previous posters obviously haven't been to rural Ireland 😂
I’m Irish, and I detest nosy people, as do plenty others. There’s a reason the phrase “a guard wouldn’t ask me that!” is popular here.
IMarchToADifferentDrummer · 20/10/2021 06:20

If you don't ask questions you don't get to know anything!
We tell our children to ask questions at school, encourage them to ask at home so what's the difference?
If my children were off to a wedding, or elsewhere, with an ex partner I'd be asking questions, too! Do people not want to know where their children are going or what time they'll be back, if there'll be lots of people there, will they be safe etc, etc?
I'd rather openly ask questions than hide behind my curtains, twitching away!

CardiganAddict · 20/10/2021 06:17

In the UK people are generally more reserved and there's more of a focus on privacy. I'm also like you, very interested in people - because I care and I used to use it as a way of showing that I care.
Whether you are nosey or not depends on your intent and it sounds like your are not... But....
What's more important is whether the person does or doesn't want to disclose the information.

A private topic for one person might not be for others. As a PP said, you need to fish out of they wish to talk about it or not. I do also think there's an onus on the other person to communicate this. A lot of people seem to think that everyone has the same boundaries when they don't.

Whatwillbetheendofus · 20/10/2021 06:11

I think I've heard it all now. If you are nosy OP then I definitely am. The previous posters obviously haven't been to rural Ireland 😂

junebirthdaygirl · 20/10/2021 06:09

If l am talking to my dc in their 20s about their friends l ask: Oh where is Tom these days? What did he do in college or where does he work? I am not remotely interested in Tom's social status but liked Tom when he used call around and like to hear how he is getting on. Is that nosy?
My friends ds is getting married and l ask her how the preparations are going. I am just showing an interest in her life surely although her ds is not there and l barely know the women he is marrying..nosy?
I am not going to be talking about either of these situations to anyone else. I just see it as chat.
I love to hear about people's lives, travels, children etc.

lottiegarbanzo · 20/10/2021 06:07

You lost me at the girl in your dd's class who works for your ex, yet is young enough to need collecting from school.

It all seems very much like the contents of your head spilling directly onto the page, or out from your mouth when talking, without much thought being given to how you come across to others, or whether they enjoy conversations with you and feel they're getting something out of them too.

CounsellorTroi · 20/10/2021 06:04

@SarahBellam

I’d consider that nosey - prying into other people’s lives, especially when it’s about people you don’t know. I’d see inquisitive and being interested in the world around you - so reading, visiting interesting places, appreciating art or music - that sort of thing, not whether the cat’s vet’s aunt got new curtains.
Now I would see that as curious.

Seems like that Yes Prime Minister thing. I am curious, you are inquisitive, she is a nosy parker.

CounsellorTroi · 20/10/2021 06:00

@Stoppochoco

Asking people what they do for a living, is a way of sniffing out income and social status. Why do you need to know that ?
True - I believe in some cultures it’s considered quite rude to ask someone you’ve just met what they do.
Pemmican · 20/10/2021 05:54

The most interesting thing about this thread is that most people can't spell nosy.

SarahBellam · 20/10/2021 05:49

I’d consider that nosey - prying into other people’s lives, especially when it’s about people you don’t know. I’d see inquisitive and being interested in the world around you - so reading, visiting interesting places, appreciating art or music - that sort of thing, not whether the cat’s vet’s aunt got new curtains.

WholeHog · 20/10/2021 05:42

I think nosy and inquisitive are two words for the same thing, one judgemental, one not.
I was brought up with "Small minds discuss people, average minds discuss events, great minds discuss ideas", my family don't ask or enjoy personal questions.
However I've grown to realise it has value. For example many nurses seem to have this kind of mind, they constantly accumulate and remember information about people so when answering an unexpected phonecall about a patient or dealing with a readmission they have the relevant info in their heads already without needing to refer to notes or repeat previous questions. I quite admire it as my brain doesn't do it. I psychotherapist colleague once observed that I was "not interested in people". Which seemed a little harsh but I see their point.

UnsuitableHat · 20/10/2021 04:42

Whether or not you like to know stuff about other people (hardly uncommon), you don’t need to accept labels from your ex. Maybe try to shrug it off rather than worrying about semantics.

echt · 20/10/2021 04:17

Inquisitive and nosey mean the same thing: undue interest in another's business.

This isn't mere pedantry; the OP sees a difference between her actions and what her ex says. He's a stirrer for making the comment passively aggressively to the child.

I'd go for interested (positive) v. nosy/inquisitive (out of order).

RicherThanYew · 20/10/2021 02:33

I see where you're coming from Op. I think it depends on the question. For example;

Q1) Oh you work in the city, which sector are you in? Is inquisitive.

Whereas

Q2) I heard your husband was arrested, was it sheep bothering or petty theft? Is nosy.