Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there's a difference between being nosey and being inquisitive?

111 replies

winningforhim · 19/10/2021 19:30

Tonight my daughters dad phoned her whilst we were driving. A girl in my daughters class works for my ex so my daughter said that she seen him at school pick up this afternoon. My ex replied saying, 'yeah well it is usually him that collects his DD'. At that point I said, 'yeah I've noticed that, what does her mum do for work?' Ex replied 'I don't know, your mums awful nosey isn't she DD?'

Now I do ask people questions, 'did you have a nice break?' 'What do you do for work?' 'Do you enjoy it?' 'How old are your kids etc'. I like to show an interest because...well I'm interested.

I will ask questions about people, for instance DD is going to a wedding in December with ex and so the guy who is getting married I knew through ex so I asked, 'how is M doing these days?' 'Where is he working?' 'How long have they been together?' 'Where are they getting married?'

This obviously strikes my ex as me being nosey, however, I'm not asking these questions with any malicious intent or to spread information about. I'm not asking how much they earn or about there sex life.

It offended me that ex called me nosey in front of DD. I would say my personality is more inquisitive. When I said this to ex he said there's no such thing.

AIBU thinking that asking this question does not make me Nosey?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NiceGerbil · 21/10/2021 22:02

I hate nosy types. Gossipy types.

When anyone asks me about anyone else and I just think. You don't need to know that you're being nosey. I just say. Dunno/ never noticed/ hadn't thought about it.

The woman down the road is terrible. What's going on at 26? Have you seen X not seen them a while think they may have split. That young bloke at 17 I reckon he's a drug dealer. Blah blah blah who gives a fuck. Leave them alone! You sound boring and sad. Get your own life.

Volhhg · 21/10/2021 18:18

I love a nosey Parker!

Volhhg · 21/10/2021 18:16

Yes I was asked numerous times.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 21/10/2021 16:50

TBF if you google the dictionary definitions of inquisitive it pretty much comes back as nosey unless it's to do with learning so I think you're just splitting hairs over terminology and do come across as nosey.

Rewis · 21/10/2021 16:21

I think it's more about how it's done. You should sense if the person is happy to respond and chat. I'd they give vague answers or cuts it short. Stop asking. If they provide extra info and ask you back, then go ahead and ask more.

LettertoHermoine · 21/10/2021 16:17

Nobody likes a nosey parker.

Palavah · 21/10/2021 16:12

@Volhhg

Yes it's unacceptable here in the UK but it is an acceptable question in some cultures and I thought it was great
Were you on the receiving end?
Volhhg · 21/10/2021 10:05

Yes it's unacceptable here in the UK but it is an acceptable question in some cultures and I thought it was great

greenlynx · 21/10/2021 09:13

I don’t think this question was so intrusive however it’s your DD’s phone conversation with her Dad not yours and the topic wasn’t affected you in the slightest, in those circumstances your question was too much. And I think that’s why your ex reacted like this, you were nosy because you interfered into their private conversation not because of question itself.

CounsellorTroi · 21/10/2021 09:07

@Volhhg

OP you are being inquisitive and open to the world and that is an excellent quality. Here in the UK people can be a bit stiff but after visiting and spending time in other countries this kind of thing is more relaxed and acceptable. I've been to places where I have been regularly asked things like "What does your father do" "why don't you have children" "how much do you earn", I absolute love it it's great! Much better than small talk about the weather. It would be considered very rude to do that here. I think being accused of being nosey is a relic of the Victorians in our culture here
Asking someone if they have children is one thing, asking why they don’t have children is totally unacceptable.
KrispyKale · 21/10/2021 08:49

I'd be more likely to ask a third party which I guess makes me nosy. (I thought I was an amateur student of economics!)

KrispyKale · 21/10/2021 08:47

The problem asking about work you may be touching a sore point about unemployment, illness, SAHP, carer or something else. Or someone simply hates talking about their job. It's not neutral and I avoid asking.

M4J4 · 21/10/2021 05:52

@winningforhim

I think asking what someone does for work is a perfectly reasonable question. Asking how someone's marriage is on the other hand is not reasonable.
Now I do ask people questions, 'did you have a nice break?' 'What do you do for work?' 'Do you enjoy it?' 'How old are your kids etc'.

I would have hated you asking what my family members ‘do for work’ (what an awful phrase).

Don’t do it, it’s rude and unnecessary.

You’re doing it out of idle curiosity, you have no business being ‘interested’ in the lives of people who don’t concern you.

readingismycardio · 21/10/2021 05:15

@IWouldLikeToKnow

My mother in law is like this. Always asking questions. She swears that she's not nosey, that she's just interested, but it really comes across to me like she is. Drives me mad.
MIL does that too 🤣 She once asked me how much my father makes. But she does it so casually that it shocks me 🤣
FrenchBoule · 20/10/2021 23:57

@eisforemma

The information I give MIL (all names changed)

Emma (DD) was playing with Lily after school in the playground.

MIL’s questions following my statement:

who is Emma
how old is she
what class she’s in
what’s her teacher’s name
where does she stay
does she have any siblings
how old they are
parents age,marital status and occupation

To me it’s all irrelevant and she doesn’t NEED to know half of that

The information is that Emma and Lily had a nice time together after school in the playground.

MIL’s offering: I went to co-op today to buy a chicken in the bag but they didn’t have any. I was looking for them on the shelf,I noticed Betty,you know Betty two doors down from Louise who had her dog put to sleep 2 years ago. Poor thing had a cancer,she spent a fortune at the vets,Betty told me.

Anyway,they didn’t have any so I went to Morrisons. I had to get one as FIL really wanted a chicken, he said he was fed up with eating beef all the time.
I went inside and there was Malcolm and Irene,she really should lose some weight. Malcolm was telling me about his brother Richard. Apparently his wife’s Marie’s second cousin twice removed had slipped on the spilled milk in the supermarket and broke his leg so they are very careful going round the shops now. So ah yes,milk. I got a bottle and was looking for yoghurts,they didn’t have the ones FIL likes on the offer so I grabbed the chicken and went home.

🙄🙄🙄

There is only so much of that I can take.

I love meaningful conversations and interacting with sensible adults.

I don’t have to get on with everybody and that’s fine. I don’t have TIME for everybody. Life’s busy with work,kids,ilnesses and appointments.
I DO make time for people important in my life and for crisis situations.
Sadly I have to prioritise sometimes.

Oh and we help PIL with several issues despite having a lot on our plate. Because that’s what families do.
I don’t have time for MIL’s blabbing. She would easily take an hour daily given a chance.

Marvellousmadness · 20/10/2021 23:47

Sounds nosey to me ..

StoneofDestiny · 20/10/2021 23:43

The dictionary lists both forms of spelling. Either 'nosy' or 'nosey' is acceptable

PixieLaLa · 20/10/2021 22:50

It is a completely different scenario asking someone who you are chatting to something about themselves from butting into a conversation between your dd and her Dad to start asking him details about a 3rd person It is odd that people can't see that

Couldn’t agree more!

Volhhg · 20/10/2021 22:20

OP if people call you nosey so be it. Just ignore it and enjoy questioning

Kite22 · 20/10/2021 21:44

It is a completely different scenario, asking someone who you are chatting to something about themselves, from butting into a conversation between your dd and her Dad, to start asking him details about a 3rd person.
It is odd that people can't see that.

I love talking to people and listening to people and getting to know people. I ask people about themselves - I like to think in a 'drawing out' way rather than a 20 questions way - because I find people's lives interesting, but that is when you are talking to that person, not asking someone else for information about their lives. Completely different.

Volhhg · 20/10/2021 21:26

OP you are being inquisitive and open to the world and that is an excellent quality. Here in the UK people can be a bit stiff but after visiting and spending time in other countries this kind of thing is more relaxed and acceptable. I've been to places where I have been regularly asked things like "What does your father do" "why don't you have children" "how much do you earn", I absolute love it it's great! Much better than small talk about the weather. It would be considered very rude to do that here. I think being accused of being nosey is a relic of the Victorians in our culture here

EmeraldShamrock · 20/10/2021 20:47

I think I've heard it all now. If you are nosy OP then I definitely am. The previous posters obviously haven't been to rural Ireland
I've visited rural Ireland I couldn't be arsed knowing anything about anyone third hand.
I detest nosy people born in the city, unless you're business concerned me or made me happy for you, I don't wanna know.
Again inquisitive nosy people are my sore point.

TractorAndHeadphones · 20/10/2021 19:27

@FinallyHere 'handle' describes it so well - your mother's a wise one ;)

@Stoppochoco exactly!
Also you can always get to know people by asking open ended questions, or creative questions and letting them take it from there, rather than something they have to answer accurately.

Stoppochoco · 20/10/2021 11:14

@sillysmiles

How do you get to know people if you don't ask them about themselves?

Don't say they'll tell you, because why would you tell anyone things about yourself if they didn't seem interested?

If no one asks and no one tells they you don't get to know people. And getting to know people shouldn't stop at a certain age.

Asking someone 'how they are' allows peoples to tell you want they are comfortable with and shows that you are interested in them. For some it might be a 'a short answer, for others you might wish you never asked. The point being is that they are disclosing what they want to and the conversation doesn't feel like an interview with MI6. All the ' 20 question' people that I've met are all doing it to create a profile in their heads about someone to form a judgment on them, whether that's coming from a place of anxiety, or its because they are malicious gossips. It isn't because they are interested in those people.
FinallyHere · 20/10/2021 10:59

You draw it out of people in the course of conversation.

Wot @TractorAndHeadphones said ^

I am interested in people and love to get to know them better.

Nowadays, I am more careful and avoid asking questions about specific things, incase they do not want to tell me about those things.

Instead, I aim to give them space to talk about whatever they are interested in. For me, it's the best way of getting to know people better. Turns out what they are interested in is often more interesting any answers to the simple 'specific' questions.

Some people just do no want to open up and prefer to stick to small talk. Fair enough, they won't ever be my favourite people.

Most people, though, I've found, given the right situation, can become comfortable enough to talk about interesting things about themselves. It's about finding the right opening fir them. My mother called it finding their 'handle' , the way a handle lets you pick up saucepan.

Swipe left for the next trending thread