Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he can't just leave his job?

39 replies

Oneeata · 19/10/2021 16:22

DS starts a new job 1st November. He only has to give a weeks notice in his current job but has said he might just hand his notice in and not go back after that.
He absolutely hates the place he's in at the moment and to be fair to him they really have messed him about over the last 2/3 months or so, telling him no work on so would have to use lieu days to cover as not enough holiday entitlement accrued, going in to start a back shift and being sent home to come back and do a nightshift and other issues (still not good enough reason to just jack in)
I know he's a grown ass man and can make his own decisions (mostly mistakes imho) but surely he can't expect to not go back without any ramifications? I'm thinking it could come back and bite him should he need a reference from them at any point in the future. Plus I know it'll cause ructions between him and DH. I'm trying to get him to see sense and that he has commitments that he needs to keep to but he's like a dog with a bloody bone insisting "it'll be alright!" and that he owes them no loyalty.
I just think he's being stupid and stubborn.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TerribleCustomerCervix · 19/10/2021 22:47

I did similar with a call centre job- just walked out and didn’t go back. Best decision I ever made and it felt amazing.

Luckily it was company policy to only provide dates of employment and reference requests are made to straight to HR as opposed to the line manager I cleared my desk in front of and walked past on my way to the bus stop. I’ve changed jobs a few times since then and never had any issues.

I’m in HR now and if asked for a reference I’ll only provide dates- it’s not worth the hassle of getting into extra details.

Dixiechickonhols · 19/10/2021 22:28

I’d encourage him to give notice and work it it’s only a week. He could ask if he could be leave without notice they may release him. If they are shitty with him then call in sick. It’s a small world and you never know if you need a ref or come across someone from there. It’s a shame to mess up a reference for sake of a week if he’s been there 19m.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 19/10/2021 22:11

@sirfredfredgeorge

his approach makes me wince but the employers behave badly so the workers respond in kind

And so many here are validating the employers behaviour by not penalising them for it, indeed encouraging their kids to reward the bad employers, if there's no penalty, there's no motivation to change.

Of course it is sometimes possible that you have to do something that is not in your best interest or risk getting another job - but given he's already got another job the risk is very low.

Exactly - I am sick of the race to the bottom mentality of a lot of people - it stinks.

As for the “no gaps” stuff - gaps are generally fine if explained and one so short probably wouldn’t even be noticed - mostly the “no gaps” rules are looking for people who have been in prison.

Oneeata · 19/10/2021 22:03

He isn't on zero hours. He is contracted 39 hours a week. There had been a hold up with shipping of some of the materials they use a firstly in the first week in August. He went into work on a Monday and got told at the end of his shift there was not enough work for his line for the rest of the week. He had the choice to take unpaid leave, holiday or in lieu. Because he had only become a permanent employee in April he had not accrued sufficient holidays to take paid, he chose to work it back in lieu rather than having only one days pay. Then the same situation occurred second week in September and again last week. He went in one day to start work on a back shift at 4.30pm and got told they were changing the shift to a night shift that week and to go home and come back in for 11pm. He's gone in a few separate occasions and found he was the only one in and had to run the line alone when there's usually six of them. He's just pissed off with it all and I understand his reasons but like I said before don't want him to burn his bridges as you never know🤷.

OP posts:
Sittingonabench · 19/10/2021 21:39

Try to distill what he ‘owes’ in terms of loyalty and what he committed to in his employment contract. Going back on terms of employment can damage his reputation and even if it is ‘ok’ in terms of repercussions it doesn’t set a good precedent

DysmalRadius · 19/10/2021 21:05

But why isn't it wise? There's no comeback on his current employers from his potential new job, no matter what they have done!

Strangevipers · 19/10/2021 20:58

@DysmalRadius

As above

writing a factual negative reference after the companies behaviour isn't wise and wouldn't be worth their time . That is my point

Strangevipers · 19/10/2021 20:57

@NavigatingAdolescence

Whatever the company have or haven’t done doesn’t prevent them from writing a factual reference.
Correct.

But writing a factual negative reference after the companies behaviour isn't wise and wouldn't be worth their time . That is my point

DysmalRadius · 19/10/2021 19:29

[quote Strangevipers]@NavigatingAdolescence

only if they genuinely believe it to be true and accurate and have reasonable grounds for that belief.
Which according to OP they don't they have messed him around

Plus the consequence of lying for the company is getting sued and in the is circumstance they have nothing to gain

[/quote]
Them messing him around doesn't mean that a reference saying he failed to complete his contractual notice period would be untrue.

sirfredfredgeorge · 19/10/2021 19:19

his approach makes me wince but the employers behave badly so the workers respond in kind

And so many here are validating the employers behaviour by not penalising them for it, indeed encouraging their kids to reward the bad employers, if there's no penalty, there's no motivation to change.

Of course it is sometimes possible that you have to do something that is not in your best interest or risk getting another job - but given he's already got another job the risk is very low.

devildeepbluesea · 19/10/2021 19:16

Hang on, it sounds like he's on a zero hours contract, if they're not providing him with regular work?

If so there's no mutuality of obligation. He can simply refuse any shifts they offer him.

NavigatingAdolescence · 19/10/2021 19:13

Whatever the company have or haven’t done doesn’t prevent them from writing a factual reference.

Strangevipers · 19/10/2021 19:06

[quote CAMHShelp]@Strangevipers that’s a myth. They can give negative references and the chance of an individual seeing the reference and being able to sue a company is very slim.[/quote]
only if they (company) genuinely believe it to be true ( to give a negative ref) and accurate and have reasonable grounds for that belief.

Which OP said the company has messed him around

QueenBee52 · 19/10/2021 18:26

He's 23... let him decide

CAMHShelp · 19/10/2021 18:24

@Strangevipers that’s a myth. They can give negative references and the chance of an individual seeing the reference and being able to sue a company is very slim.

Motnight · 19/10/2021 18:22

My dd aged 21 faced a similar dilemma last year. She called in sick for the last week of her notice. She had been treated awfully and couldn't face another 5 days of it.

Rachie20 · 19/10/2021 18:17

I think most of these jobs are easy come, easy go and very rarely check references. My brother does similar work and his approach makes me wince but the employers behave badly so the workers respond in kind. There’s loads of this kind of work in my area and dbro has never been out of work for more than 2 days. He’s on 35k for a job that requires no skills or training but few can do because it needs brute strength.

MiloAndEddie · 19/10/2021 18:10

My friend did this and they didn’t pay her at the end of the month because she hadn’t worked her notice. She lost about 3 weeks pay

Strangevipers · 19/10/2021 18:03

@NavigatingAdolescence

only if they genuinely believe it to be true and accurate and have reasonable grounds for that belief.
Which according to OP they don't they have messed him around

Plus the consequence of lying for the company is getting sued and in the is circumstance they have nothing to gain

Jessieabs · 19/10/2021 17:45

He should definitely do his weeks notice. It’s only a week and could effect any of his jobs moving forward. Never leave on a bad note! Who knows who his old boss could be friends with at future jobs?

It’s just 1 week! And to those saying you can’t give a bad reference, yes you can as long as it is truthful. His reference could say ‘left without serving notice’ which would be entirely true if he did.

What they can’t say is ‘x was a bad employee’ it’s too subjective but saying he did not complete his notice period would be entirely fair game and stand him in bad stead for future roles.

NavigatingAdolescence · 19/10/2021 17:44

[quote Strangevipers]@Fallagain
@NavigatingAdolescence

They wouldn't give a bad reference if they have messed him around [/quote]
20 years in HR says otherwise.

znaika · 19/10/2021 17:40

Seriously, he sounds like a good kidas he's ridden out the shit and got somewhere lined up. Him walking out is fine. I say this as a business owner. They deserve yo be fucked over if they screw their yoyng staff around. Many 23 yr olds don't have references. He'll walk out without a backwards glance. Good for him.

Couldhavebeenme3 · 19/10/2021 17:32

Has he got set hours or is it zero hours contract?

If its zero hours then can't he just refuse the hours they ask him to work? It works both ways...

Oneeata · 19/10/2021 17:11

@Eeiliethya

How long has he worked there? I think this would make a difference.

If he's been there a month or two then it would make less of a difference than if he's been there a few years because in the case of a few years a reference would be required in which case it's not going to be great is it.

If it's up to 2 month then he could get away with leaving as a gap on his CV but this wouldn't wash with companies that require a full 5 year background check (as does mine due to security clearance reasons).

On a side note, when I was younger I started a new job, found out 3 weeks in that I was pregnant. Old employer offered to reinstate my old contract providing I could restart immediately thus getting the maternity benefits that I wouldn't be entitled to at new job.

Resigned, manager at new job insisted I work an eight week notice period. I asked if we could reach a compromise, they flat out refused. I handed in my access ID and just said I wouldn't be coming back tomorrow.
Nothing ever came from it.

I think the legality of it is if the company can prove they lose money due to your refusal to work notice (such as hire agency staff) then they are within their rights to pursue you for costs incurred, so I would consider this.

He's been at the factory for 19 months but started with an agency and then got offered a permanent contract with the company in April. So in effect only with the company 6 months.
OP posts:
Oneeata · 19/10/2021 17:05

@namechange30455

How old is he?
He's 23.
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread